Nanny State

Costs of "Vision Zero" New York City Traffic Plan


Raidarmax \ Wikimedia

New York City's newly minted mayor, Bill de Blasio, unveiled the details of Vision Zero, a broad, swedish-inspired effort to reduce "traffic violence" to nil. A whole slew of technologies – speed cameras, laser guns, anti-speeding tax meters, black boxes – will be deployed if approved by the state legislature.

286 fatalities were linked to vehicles last year in New York City. That is tragically close to the murder rate of 333. The deaths are mostly attributed to "dangerous driver choices," hence the mayor's focus on reducing speed and targeting less cautious drivers. 

Vision Zero would probably reduce traffic fatalities (although not to nothing Sweden has reduced traffic-related deaths by about 50%). But the plan has consequences.

Timothy P. Carney goes eyeball to eyeball with data-gathering enabled by Vision Zero's taxi black boxes in a Washington Examiner op-ed, "How long before every car registered in, say, New York State or Maryland is required to come with a black box, whose data the state can access upon suspicion of a crime?"

We can imagine these black box devices used for bulk data collection similar to National Security Agency metadata harvesting. Reason's J.D. Tuccille describes America's splintered, Panopticon apparatus that includes traffic cameras repurposed for surveillance in Ohio.

De Blasio singles out speedy taxi drivers and apportions an enforcement squad to deal with them. But Bhairavi Desai, director of the Taxi Workers Alliance, said, "Statistics show that taxi drivers are the safest motorists on NYC streets." Officials estimate the total program would cost some tens of millions.

New York mayors have an affinity for nanny state reforms geared toward enhanced health and safety. De Blasio already plans to ban Central Park horse carriages and advance predecessor Michael Bloomberg's war on soda. New York City pioneered the ban on trans-fats and Bloomberg's last act was to ban e-cigs in public areas.

Anyway, what applies to New York City's citizens does not apply to the rule maker. The mayor's caravan was caught speeding last night. 

NEXT: FCC Tapped Company Specializing in Health for Newsroom Review

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  1. The deaths are mostly attributed to “dangerous driver choices,”

    It’s free will that’s the problem.

  2. Vision Zero would probably reduce those traffic fatalities…

    I suggest taking away everyone’s motor vehicle.

  3. Well, given DeBlasios work with MTA, I’m sure this whole ‘using technology to save lives!’ thing should be a stunning success!


    “The project is taking too long, costing too much, and there is no end in sight.”
    The authority has only $59 million in capital funding for the electronic security program, which has ballooned in cost to $833 million from $591 million, the report said.

    Oh, btw? that was 4 years ago. yes, its not any better. but don’t worry = that ~billion dollars? (who’s counting!) It went to good people. Somewhere.

    1. I have no love for De Blasio, but what did he have to do with the MTA? Are you confusing him with Lhota?

  4. Pedestrians and bikers have as much right as car drivers to navigate the city. The issue seems to me to be the lack of holding drivers responsible for crashes they cause. There really aren’t very many circumstances where crashes are really accidents. If tracking devices are the answer then lack of accountability is the reason.

  5. In a few years there will be ZERO horse carriage related deaths in NYC.

  6. I’m stunned that they already have fewer traffic fatalities than murders. Isn’t traffic a bigger killer by far in most places? How low does he think the number can go?

    Oh, right. Zero.

  7. Slightly OT: Why doesn’t someone make an e-cig that looks like an asthma inhaler?

  8. You search for doing funny things completes after visiting this portal iiii which includes all those information by which you can entertain yourself and can also play funny games. Try out for once.

  9. If you are required to play free hearts online so you may move to this portal and can enjoy these games. Also here you will not only entertain yourself but will also help you to improve your skills. Play for once.

Please to post comments

Comments are closed.