A Robert Altman Veterans' Day
Robert Altman's first movies were the industrial shorts he made for the Calvin Company in Kansas City in the 1950s. It was an unpretentious film school for the man who would become one of America's most revered directors in the 1970s: a way to learn the nuts and bolts of quick and effective low-budget filmmaking, and also an opportunity to experiment in the margins, nurturing Altman's art as well as his craft. "All of this, it must be emphasized, was in the service of some of the most deadly, routinized film subjects imaginable," biographer Patrick McGilligan wrote in Robert Altman: Jumping Off the Cliff. "Yet there were touches. This is what distinguished Altman at Calvin—his touches, his moments of lightness, his imaginative digressions."
And that's how you got The Magic Bond, a 1955 documentary sponsored by the Veterans of Foreign Wars. The bulk of the film is bland stuff steeped in the language of countersubversion; the narrator pivots from describing the wartime soldier's "feeling of belonging to a team" to stressing the need to maintain that unity when battling domestic foes, which are "doubly dangerous because they are subtle, intangible, and hard to identify." The enemy at home turns out to be the quadruple scourge of juvenile delinquency, neglect of veterans, the "smugness which lets our national defenses dwindle away," and "apathy toward our political problems, leaving the door open for the grafter, the subversive, the traitor, the tool of pressure groups, the crook, the incompetent." And the patriotic entity taking them on is, of course, the VFW. The details of its efforts then follow, starting with a National Marble Tournament that undermines delinquency by giving kids something more wholesome to do.
But before the official script starts, there is something else: five minutes of a gritty war sequence that feels like it was dropped in from another movie. In theory it's there to illustrate the aforementioned "feeling of belonging to a team," but the tone and style are at odds with everything else in the picture. In terms of Altman's career, you can see it as a dry run for Combat!, the TV series he helped create in 1962, and you might even see some early traces of Altman's movie M*A*S*H. If it's a little rough around the edges, well, it is journeyman work. But it's good journeyman work. Altman was a veteran of the Second World War, and it's likely that many of the actors were vets as well, so their semi-improvised scene has an air of truth to it. And since it's November 11, I'll post it here today.
Watch the first 14 minutes of the picture here…
…and the rest here:
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
And the patriotic entity taking them on is, of course, the VFW.
I have a hard time thinking of the VFW as anything other than that place near my high school where we would have spaghetti dinner fundraisers for the football team.
Also, glad to see you back, Jesse.
Spaghetti dinners? Man, I wish my local VFW made itself useful like that. All it does is host bingo nights.
We have one near us. Lots of spaghetti dinners advertised.
I’ve had a spaghetti luncheon at a VFW. Good stuff.
The VFW in my town was the coolest – because the soda machine in the basement was stocked with beer.
The VFW one town over was way more bitchin’.
Were you raped by Jerry Sandusky at these “dinners”, by any chance?
Altman is no Jam Handy.
Altman humanizes his subjects and doesn’t glamorize at all in that first scene. There’s definitely something to it.
Altman’s McCabe & Mrs. Miller is a mess of a movie. But I still like the little gunfight scene at the end.
A mess? It’s Altman’s best and one of the greatest movies of the 1970s!
Altman was a liberal and therefore all of his work and everything he ever said is of no value.
Altman was so erratic. For one movie he’d be brilliant, and then for another, totally insipid. But when he was on, man, he was on.
Just happened to watch A Wedding again, last week. Still funny.
Also, Carol Burnett is a master comedic actor.
“…leaving the door open for the grafter, the subversive, the traitor, the tool of pressure groups, the crook, the incompetent.”
Wow, that’s being pretty harsh on the Republican and Democratic parties.
That’s a pretty nasty (but accurate) burn there, Coyote.
Ron Paul money bomb today: Support the Troops — Bring them home!
Ron Paul 2012 dot com
Just think if Altman had directed Atlas Shrugged instead of those no-talent hacks who fucked it up so badly. It must have physically hurt for Reason’s editors to pimp that turkey.
Well, if Altman had directed Atlas Shrugged, the long speeches would have been even more annoying with all the overlapping dialog.