What Are California Cities Hiding?
While the story has moved along and the Pulitzer has been duly awarded, the scandal of hidden compensation of government employees in California goes on.
The L.A. Times digs up more dirt on the Robert Rizzo, the former Bell city manager with the million-dollar salary. It turns out Rizzo also stashed $4.5 million into a secret retirement fund containing two pension plans: One for 40 employees and another just for Rizzo and former assistant manager Angela Spaccia.
Meanwhile in eastern L.A. County: Montebello, that sparkling city on the banks of the mighty Rio Hondo, is headed for bankruptcy on the bullet train. Interim city administrator Peter Cosentini, who was just brought in last August, announced last week that he is resigning after being unable to come to terms with the city council over financial disclosure and fiscal management. California Controller John Chiang has ordered an audit of the city, which is sitting on $126 million of outstanding bond debt with no visible means of servicing it. Excellent coverage by Randall Jensen at The Bond Buyer.
And away up north, the Bay Area News Group has filed 510 information requests in an effort to to get local governments to cough up compensation records on benefits, pensions, deferred compensation and insurance costs. While some governments have come through, the Contra Costa Times reports that some of the most prominent communities in the Bay Area are still playing hard to get:
Prominent among those that have not yet made data public include the Mt. Diablo Unified School District, where Superintendent Steven Lawrence has not responded to a request for data sent to him in January.
In Alameda County, the Berkeley Unified and Oakland Unified school districts have yet to comply with multiple requests. In San Mateo County, the cities of Daly City, East Palo Alto and Menlo Park and the towns of Atherton and Woodside didn't respond to requests for data.
In Marin County, the Kentfield and San Rafael school districts and cities of Sausalito, Fairfax and Corte Madera did not respond.
Other government entities have released only partial data, including Oakland, Berkeley, San Francisco, San Ramon, Walnut Creek, Fairfield and Palo Alto.
"It's insane, absolutely asinine" that some governments continue to balk at making compensation data readily public, said Tom Newton, executive director of the California Newspaper Publishers Association.
"The Supreme Court said that public pay is the public's business. That's everything. The public should get to see every single penny of what public employees get paid," Newton said.
As a former San Franciscan, I can attest that in terms of good government, transparency and general ethics, the Bay Area is a veritable Sweden compared to the counties of Southern California. If the same kind of public-comp shenanigans are going on up there, all I can say is: Good times, good times!
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Did anyone catch last week's Law & Order: LA? Ok, since I was the only one watching, they did another straight-from-the-headlines story about the Bell crimes. They filmed in what is obviously South Pasadena and it's the fictional city of "East Pasadena" that served as Bell's standing (even though previous episodes used real city's names).
The story was confusing and it involved a murder. It was a pretty bad episode.
Re: Apologetic California,
I stopped caring about the series when Michael Moriarty left.
^^THIS^^
Michael Moriarty's ex-wife bought my house a few years ago. True story.
Wow, you're goin' way back. I thought the series held together well after Sam Waterston took over. I thought the series went downhill after they started caring about the personal lives of the characters. I mean, who cares? I want to see points of law, police evidence and legal wrangling.
Dong Dong
I saw the episode so that makes two of us.
I thought it was confusing too. They were fining people for violating a non existent ordinance? Seems so easy to catch that no one, even muni government types, would try that.
I actually saw that episode too. I was traveling so in a hotel and had nothing else to do. It would have been a much better episode if they'd simply did away with the tacky murder storyline (murder of a patriotic American Soldiergirl) and focused on the unholy corruption.
NBC probably doesn't want to push too much. They do live there afterall.
... and that ain't saying much, when it comes to the "Let's not work Mondays and Fridays" Sweden...
Europe hurr durr!
Re: dbcooper,
Exteriorizing, dbcooper?
Would that 4.5 million they found stashed buy enough tar and feathers to coat that Rizzo fuck?
I think you'd have to commandeer the feather-output of every chicken processor in the country for a month or two to accomplish that job.
We need a law to incentivize these people to respond to FOIA and similar requests. Don't respond within 30 days? We take 25% of your pay and the pay of everyone in your department. Don't respond within 60 days? We take 50%. And on and on.
(SLD applies)
90 days? The department gets permanently eliminated.
I think there definitely needs to be a mechanism for daily fines.
Assuming that these municipalities don't intend to simply try to evade the request, they're probably delaying because:
1. They figure that the last guy to get an expose done on their pay practices will fare better than the first - because the public will grow bored of constant new disclosures;
2. They figure that if they can just make it into the next fiscal year, maybe times will improve economically by next year and they can evade public desire for current cuts.
Either way, it's very underhanded and has to be reined in somehow.
I have no idea how these entities get away with playing hidsies with FOIA. I've had to respond to FOIAs and the thought never crossed my mind to delay responding. And if the thought did cross my mind the local command's FOIA rep would have quickly disabused me of the notion.
How is it that dumb ol' Soldiers can learn that screwing with a FOIA request doesn't make like easier, but the brilliant people who are elected to lead us cannot?
Simple, Soldier. You are a servant of the law. I wrote the law, and so you are my servant.
Now go shred these documents for me.
Check out Carl De Maio, candidate for San Diego Mayor. He wants to create bonus pools, with appropriate penalties and incentives for exceptional and poor (respectively) service from public officials. That would make six-figured, city clerks much more palatable
That Rizzo douche looks like the fat, floaty guy from Dune...what was that name...Emperor Zurg? No that's not it...little help here!
No clue. Dumbo?
Baron Harkonnen
You're doing it wrong.
Sky Captain?
That guy reminds me of something...
Mmm, this is more what he reminds me of.
I remember taking a personal finance class in college. The textbook said that Municipal bonds were much safer then Corporate bonds because they are guaranteed to be paid.
Re: omg,
One can almost smell the bullshit coming out of those textbooks...
It's not "insane" or "asinine". It's perfectly logical. If municipalities started showing what the real compensation of public employees is, the whole house of cards comes tumbling down. It's real hard to pull a "Wisconsin" style sit-in when the sit-in-ers are making more than the people they serve.
Only a ratbagging teafucker would think it makes a difference how public money is spent.
SPEND BABY SPEND, dammit!
This kind of corruption is tailor-made for the Libertarian Party to ferret out and expose....much more productive than worrying which non-entity to run for President.
Illegal immigrants probably
That Rizzo douche looks like the fat, floaty guy from Dune
Hypnotoad?
See? P Brooks understands.
"What Are California Cities Hiding?"
I would guess illegal immigrants and probably a fair amount of drugs.
"... headed for bankruptcy on the bullet train"
So there IS some benefit to high speed rail after all!
Who woulda thunk it.
64K pop, 75% hispanic.
It also has $5 million of outstanding COPs tied to its golf course.
Just thought that paired oddly w/ the demographics.
"64K pop, 75% hispanic.
It also has $5 million of outstanding COPs tied to its golf course.
Just thought that paired oddly w/ the demographics."
Well those golf courses aren't gonna maintain themselves, Missy.
Man, that dude has the biggest face I've ever seen. It's like, when he turns his head, there's just ... more face.
I used to make faces like that with Silly Putty? and the Sunday comix.
These officials have done no wrong.
Think about the great bargain we got from these Bell officials. They are extremely dedicated to serving the public. Where else could you get such a great return on your tax dollar?
There should be a state law that all cities need to post public employee compensation data on their website (at least for all employees making over $100,000). This should be a precondition to get any funding from the state. Same for all school districts.
I can attest that in terms of good government, transparency and general ethics, the Bay Area is a veritable Sweden compared to the counties of Southern California.
Well, yeah, you don't want too much of the truth running around in the open like that. Otherwise this might happen.
I don't get what the big deal is, guys. A man's gotta eat, especially this one. Regular public servant wages won't cut it.
Rizzo's fat body is shaped like a bell.
I call him "the Man Who Ate Bell."
This guy needs to be thrown in jail and stay there. He's already working off a DUI w/community service.
http://sunshinereview.org/inde.....California
Here's someone worse than Rizzo, read it and pass it on to everyone you know: http://texsquixtarblog.blogspo.....-rich.html
No mention of the City of Graft and Stealing AKA Upland? They've got an extorting, money laundering, embezzling mayor and a city manager with an anger issue and an annual pension of about 285,000$. Spending close to a million bucks on city officials currently on leave. I think that merits a mention right?