Dubbed the "anti-joking law", the relic of Brazil's 1964-1985 dictatorship prohibits ridiculing candidates in the three months before elections.
Critics say the ban threatens free speech and is a blight on the reputation of Latin America's largest nation.
"Do you know of any other democracy in the world with rules like this?" asked Marcelo Tas, the acerbic host of a weekly TV comedy show that skewers politicians and celebrities alike.
"If you want to find a bigger joke, you would have to look to Monty Python."
Proponents say the restrictions keep candidates from being portrayed unfairly, help ensure a level playing field and encourage candour by those seeking to replace centre-Left President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva.
Making fun of candidates on air ahead of elections is punishable by fines up to £72,000 and a broadcast licence suspension.
Print and the Internet are not covered by the ban. The article doesn't say what happens if a candidate simply makes an ass of himself.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com
posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary
period.
Subscribe
here to preserve your ability to comment. Your
Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the
digital
edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do
not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments
do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and
ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
"Do you know of any other democracy in the world with rules like this?" asked Marcelo Tas, the acerbic host of a weekly TV comedy show that skewers politicians and celebrities alike.
SRSLY. What kind of authoritarian shithole tries to regulate the content of speech for a certain period surrounding elections? Surely if such a far-fetched made-up nation had a functioning free press, the political leadership would be roundly shouted down and run out of town on a rail for even suggesting such a thing.
I wonder if they could film his show earlier in the summer and show reruns of it in the 3 months prior to the election and get away with it. Based on the way the law is written, that should satisfy the jackass lawmakers and federales.
What satisfies the jackass lawmakers and federales is to not be mocked for the three months prior to the election, so I'm sure they'd interpret it in whatever way serves their interests.
Boy, this sure isn't the way I remember it, and I lived in Brazil right after the military dictatorship left power. There were some brutally funny political comedians - Jo Soares and Chico Anisio come immediately to mind - that absolutely devastated crooked and clownish pols like Paulo Maluf, Janio Quadros and Orestes Quercia. If the law was on the books back then, it was definitely ignored.
Thread jack (I think):
Headline:
"Brain-Dead Has No Concept of What She Supports"
"Yes, I collaborated with the MRTA. I was never a leader or a militant. I never participated in violent or bloody acts. I never killed anybody," she told a panel of judges. "If my participation contributed to societal violence, I am very sorry for this," she said at the hearing."
http://www.aolnews.com/world/a.....?icid=main|main|dl1|link3|http://www.aolnews.com/world/article/peru-court-orders-american-lori-berenson-back-to-jail/19599140
I do not support the death penalty, but this really tests my decision.
What a joke! lol
So, it only applies to TV ads?
Anyways, if you want a 'serious' business financing option, check our my merchant cash advance site.
"Do you know of any other democracy in the world with rules like this?"
We wish!
Payne is funny on Friday Funnies this time. Good one with Michelle Antoinette and her Spain vacation.
Caption Contest!
"AAAAAAAAAAAND WHO'S THE GAYEST!"
"Omigod, Omigod, Omigod!!!! There's a sale at Mervyn's!!!!"
+1
Brazil is such a crazy place. I truly love it there.
Lou
http://www.total-privacy.cz.tc
H&R can thwart stupid HTML pranks, but not annoying bots? This is depressing.
Stupid? I'll have you know that the Libertarian Party funded the whole business!
I like Anon-Bot.
AB is not as fun as TofuSushi was.
Anon-bot is an institution around here. It would be like banning LoneWh...oh. NVM
And here I was thinking it was the real Justin Bieber. AnonBot sure fooled me!
sometimes anon-bot makes the most perceptive or funny or hilariously inappropriate comments on the thread.
it is welcome here, far as i'm concerned.
getting rid of anon-bot would be like reason instituting it's own "anti-joking" law, which would be full of irony.
So that is where McCain and Feingold get their 'brilliant' ideas.
Stop thinking like me.
Use your real name.
No.
I like my pseudonym.
"Do you know of any other democracy in the world with rules like this?" asked Marcelo Tas, the acerbic host of a weekly TV comedy show that skewers politicians and celebrities alike.
SRSLY. What kind of authoritarian shithole tries to regulate the content of speech for a certain period surrounding elections? Surely if such a far-fetched made-up nation had a functioning free press, the political leadership would be roundly shouted down and run out of town on a rail for even suggesting such a thing.
Indeed. Still smoking those dollar-sign cigs, Hugh?
And making the best hamburger sandwich you've ever tasted.
Make mine medium rare, with blue cheese and Obama sauce.
I wonder if they could film his show earlier in the summer and show reruns of it in the 3 months prior to the election and get away with it. Based on the way the law is written, that should satisfy the jackass lawmakers and federales.
What satisfies the jackass lawmakers and federales is to not be mocked for the three months prior to the election, so I'm sure they'd interpret it in whatever way serves their interests.
C'mon people. Doesn't anyone else here get the racist comment that was sorta snuck into the title of the article here?
I only opened the comments to see what was said about it, but no dice. I thought this would get my afternoon started off with a laugh.
For shame, Reason. For shame.
Ha! "Nigger Toes"!
Hang on, Sloopy!
somebody got it. Here's a little McCoy's for ya gettin my name as well.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DO2Y2sGZ1dk
Feynman in Brazil
Metal in Brazil
Completely unrelated to Brazil, but it's always a good time for some kraut:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pvamU4v1rjk
You NutraSweet'ed the link, jackass.
Ah crap.
Here ya go:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pvamU4v1rjk
+25 for Sepultura.
That was @ Warty.
programmes cannot "use trickery, montages or other features of audio or video in any way to degrade or ridicule a candidate, party or coalition"
I know ridicule when I see it.
prohibits ridiculing candidates in the three months before elections
Crap, why didn't I think of that?
Boy, this sure isn't the way I remember it, and I lived in Brazil right after the military dictatorship left power. There were some brutally funny political comedians - Jo Soares and Chico Anisio come immediately to mind - that absolutely devastated crooked and clownish pols like Paulo Maluf, Janio Quadros and Orestes Quercia. If the law was on the books back then, it was definitely ignored.
Thread jack (I think):
Headline:
"Brain-Dead Has No Concept of What She Supports"
"Yes, I collaborated with the MRTA. I was never a leader or a militant. I never participated in violent or bloody acts. I never killed anybody," she told a panel of judges. "If my participation contributed to societal violence, I am very sorry for this," she said at the hearing."
http://www.aolnews.com/world/a.....?icid=main|main|dl1|link3|http://www.aolnews.com/world/article/peru-court-orders-american-lori-berenson-back-to-jail/19599140
I do not support the death penalty, but this really tests my decision.
*contemplates the effect of a law which prohibited candidates from making asses of themselves*
I think I could support that.
We'd have anarchism in two days.
Supra Shoes
Supra Footwear
Supra Cuban
Supra Bandit
Supra Bullet