Columbia U. President: We Need an NPR-Beeb-Jazeera in the U.S.!


Lee Bollinger is author of a new book entitled Uninhibited, Robust, and Wide-Open: A Free Press for a New Century. He is also president of Columbia University, home of arguably the most prestigious journalism school in the United States. Given what we've come to expect from people with his general professional profile, Bollinger's op-ed in today's Wall Street Journal should come as no surprise. But that makes it no less stinky:

The institutions of the press we have inherited are the result of a mixed system of public and private cooperation. Trusting the market alone to provide all the news coverage we need would mean venturing into the unknown—a risky proposition with a vital public institution hanging in the balance.

Ironically, we already depend to some extent on publicly funded foreign news media for much of our international news—especially through broadcasts of the BBC and BBC World Service on PBS and NPR. Such news comes to us courtesy of British citizens who pay a TV license fee to support the BBC and taxes to support the World Service. The reliable public funding structure, as well as a set of professional norms that protect editorial freedom, has yielded a highly respected and globally powerful journalistic institution.

There are examples of other institutions in the U.S. where state support does not translate into official control. The most compelling are our public universities and our federal programs for dispensing billions of dollars annually for research. Those of us in public and private research universities care every bit as much about academic freedom as journalists care about a free press. […]

To me a key priority is to strengthen our public broadcasting role in the global arena. In today's rapidly globalizing and interconnected world, other countries are developing a strong media presence. In addition to the BBC, there is China's CCTV and Xinhua news, as well as Qatar's Al Jazeera. The U.S. government's international broadcasters, like Voice of America and Radio Free Europe, were developed during the Cold War as tools of our anticommunist foreign policy. In a sign of how anachronistic our system is in a digital age, these broadcasters are legally forbidden from airing within the U.S.

This system needs to be revised and its resources consolidated and augmented with those of NPR and PBS to create an American World Service that can compete with the BBC and other global broadcasters. The goal would be an American broadcasting system with full journalistic independence that can provide the news we need. Let's demonstrate great journalism's essential role in a free and dynamic society.

Bollinger's idea was greeted with the derision it deserves from Jeff Jarvis, Nick Schulz, Michelle Malkin, Mark Tapscott, Steve Bartin, and Cassy Fiano.

Reason on journalism bailouts here, including "All the President's Newsmen," below: