Another Great Day For Media Freedom
When they are not forging weapons deals and scheming to create a Russo-Latin American space program, the allied governments of Vladimir Putin and Hugo Chavez are cracking down on free speech in their respective authoritarian countries. First, in Russia's "managed democracy," police today seized 100,000 copies of an anti-Putin book written by opposition politicians Boris Nemtsov and Vladimir Milov (available for download here, in Russian only). Details on this latest spasm of non-communist media Sovietization via The Telegraph:
Copies of "Putin. The Results. 10 Years on", written by opposition politicians Boris Nemtsov and Vladimir Milov were "intended for participants of the [Saint Petersburg International Economic Forum]", starting Thursday, according to Olga Kurnosova, head of the city's branch of the opposition United Civic Front, said.
The reasons for the seizure "are not very clear", she said.
The book, which has a total print-run of one million copies, aims to "tell the truth about the real results of the leadership of Putin and the tandem", Mr Nemtsov, a former deputy prime minister, wrote in his blog on Monday.
Mr Putin served two terms as president from 2000 onwards before being elected as prime minister. He is still viewed as Russia's strongest political figure in a power tandem with his ally President Dmitry Medvedev.
After Hugo Chavez twice shuttered Venezuela's oldest television station, RCTV—first on the terrestrial band, then on cable—only one opposition television station remains. But now the head of Globovision, Guillermo Zuloaga, has fled Venezuela after being accused of financial irregularities relating to a used car business. Or some such nonsense. Last year, Zuloaga was arrested for making "offensive and disrespectful" statements about the Bolivarian revolution; now he's accused of fraud. Curious. The Wall Street Journal has details:
Guillermo Zuloaga, the owner of the last major television station in Venezuela critical of President Hugo Chavez, has fled the country after a warrant was issued for his arrest, a station representative confirmed Wednesday.
"He's no longer in Venezuela," said Edith Ruiz, director of institutional relations at Zuloaga's Globovision television station. She said his exact whereabouts outside of Venezuela are unknown.
Observers are now wondering how much longer the government may allow Caracas-based Globovision to remain on the air, given its owner is an international fugitive. Government critics say shutting down the anti-Chavez station, if only temporarily, might work well for the ruling socialist party ahead of September legislative elections, which promise to see tight races.
Authorities on Friday ordered Zuloaga arrested so he could answer to a year-old accusation of irregularities related to a car dealership owned by him and his family. Zuloaga denies the allegation, and calls it another example of "judicial terrorism" by the Chavez government.
For the past several days, Chavez has publicly urged Zuloaga, one of the country's most influential people, to turn himself in, and said that the businessman would be considered innocent until proven guilty.
But Monday night, Zuloaga spoke on Globovision by telephone from an unidentified location, and said he has no plans to hand himself over to Chavez.
"I've reached the conclusion that with my surrender I won't be doing any favor to Globovision, to the country or to my family," he said.
Zuloaga added the government's accusation against him was trumped up for the sole purpose of shutting down Globovision, which is effectively the only local channel where criticism of Chavez is heard.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
To quote the long departed joe on Hugo Chavez and totalitarianism -
"Trust democracy".
I remember joe once getting huffy when I called Hugo a caudillo. I think he said something like, "caudillos don't overwhelmingly win elections".
I'm really glad joe is gone.
I'm too lazy to do the site search but long ago I predicted that Chavez would never leave office voluntarily. It will take his death, a revolution or a military coup to get him out of office.
In Putin's Russia, oil spills you!
In Putin's Russia, oil spills you!
Repeatedly!
I knew someone would bring up joe in this thread. I didn't know it would be the very first comment. Of course if he were still commenting here, he would find a way to blame everything Chavez has done on a coup that took places years ago, which he continuously insisted, despite no evidence at all, was led by the United States.
Man he is such a cowardly piece of shit that he quit commenting here the moment it became obvious Obama was an incompetent clown, which was on or around January 20th.
He's doing God's work.
We're doing God's work, he's doing Jesus' work.
And we are doing Satan's bidding. Too bad Government is monotheistic.
I'm certain an outraged Sean Penn will denounce Chavez in no time...
**crickets**
I dig the Russian dating ad. Add to cart.
Me likee.
I took a look... yeah, the Russian lady ad is great, but the ads for deformed children kind of ruin it for me.
The folks at No Mas Chavez protested him at the last UN General Assembly meeting. I expect them to be back in September for more protesting.
So why are we giving Russia 1 billion in federal aid each year?
RUSSIAN WOMEN. WE'RE BUYING THEM BY THE SHIPLOAD.
FOR THEIR WOMEN. WE'RE BUYING THEM BY THE SHIPLOAD.
How much per pound? I'll take, let's see... 130 pounds worth.
I thought we were subsidizing Russian scientists who would instantly become Bond villains if they were allowed to become capitalists. I never quite followed the logic, but that was back when we were pretending that former Red Army intelligence officers were fonts of civic democratic virtue, so obviously the drugs were better then.
Can we have some hot female scientists?
Given the pervasiveness of corruption in Latin America, it by no means certain that the allegations against Zuloaga are meritless. On the other hand, it is also normal that the only big players that face charges are the ones that lose the protection of the patronage network for some reason. Even if he did do something underhanded, Zuloaga would not be facing charges now if he was a Chevez supporter.
"..it by no means certain that the allegations against Zuloaga are meritless."
Orwell would condemn such phrasing.
So why are we giving Russia 1 billion in federal aid each year?
They have politicians there.
If you include off-budget sinkholes like the IMF, who doesn't get any? I'm drawing a blank.
The reasons for the seizure "are not very clear", she said.
Oh, I think they're pretty clear.
I hope the Globovision guy has enough sense not to seek asylum in the US. Obama and Holder would turn him over in a hearbeat.
Agreed. But of course The O'Auntie got asylum.
Obama and Holder would turn him over in a hearbeat.
Only if we tell him to.
It's for deficit reduction.
RC, that's just silly. You're better than that.
http://online.wsj.com/article/.....02170.html
Are you so sure about that?
Apples and oranges. But you knew that.
Mosab is tangled up with our stupid immigration and anti-terror laws, Zulaoga is not. If an when Zulaoga becomes tangled up with our stupid immigration laws and our extradition treaty with Venezuela, it will still be a reach to compare the two.
Try harder.
What does this beast from the sea represent?Mmslim Barack Hussein Obama Antichrist! But Antichrist as a world government, a political power, the likes of which this world has never seen. The origin of this beast is the sea, which represents the restless nations and peoples of the earth. "The wicked are like the troubled sea, when it cannot rest, whose water cast up mire and dirt."That the beast has power and a throne and great authority. ,GOD OPEN YOUR EYES.///For us there are only two possiblities: either we remain american or we come under the thumb of the ANTICHRIST Mmslim Barack Hussein OBAMA. This latter must not occur.REPOST THIS IF YOU AGREE. ,THE COMMANDER.
Can I get fries with that?
I though the beast from the sea represented an oil-soaked pelican?
It's always a sad day when you see pelican that's oil soaked for reasons other than being deep fried.
Wow. That's some industrial-strength crazy, right there.
The blowout valve failed! There's crazy going everywhere! Get off the rig! Get off!
Winner.
You sound like the Time Cube guy:
http://www.timecube.com/
beast from the sea
We call out to the beasts of the sea to come forth and join us, this night is yours
Because, one day we will all be with you in the black and deep
One day we will all go into the water
Damn you.
I saw Beast From the Sea open up for Steppenwolf in, um, '73 I believe. Right here in the 'Burgh at old Three Rivers Stadium.
At 6:30pm I took 6 hits of that purple jesus acid...7:30pm 'Beast' hits the motherfucking stage and ripped my goddamn skull apart.
You a fan, COMMANDER? I got some old bootlegs I could trade for. Maybe you have some rare Antichrist tapes, you seem to be a fan.
GIS for beast from the sea
Yep, that's about right.
Oh, good!! He's back. Meds must have worn off.
I think it's safe to say that Moynihan will never get a role in an Oliver Stone film.
Oh wow, that makes a lot of sense dude.
Lou
http://www.ip-spoofing.net.tc
You would think Australia would be a safe place to cuss. It has begun.
http://www.goldcoast.com.au/ar.....-news.html
Premptive Tony predictionon the Zuloaga situation.
Free speech is great, but let's break this down. This guy made it pretty explicit that armed overthrow of the Chavez government (i.e., treason) would be necessary, you know, in case nobody could build a strong enough case for impeachment (it certainly wasn't made here).
Chavez said he hopes he's arrested and put in jail.
If this makes Chavez an enemy of free speech, then this douchebag an enemy to the sovereign Venezuela. Guess who the libertarians defend.
Spot-on.
Apparently, if a left-wing president in any country is elected, they have to be worshiped and should also rule for life with no interference - let alone criticism - from the simpleton populace.
Freedom, morality, respecting and serving others; it sort of all goes hand in hand.
The best governmental system ever conceived by man will not be able to guarantee civic liberty (free speech) if a nation is stacked with self serving vain politicians, and populated with a weak divided citizenry.
'eternal vigilance...'