Health Insurance and the Commerce Clause
Writing in today's Wall Street Journal, Judge Andrew Napolitano argues that Congress should use its authority under the Commerce Clause for a legitimate purpose and allow the interstate sale of health insurance:
The same Congress that wants to tell family farmers what to grow in their backyards has declined "to keep regular" the commercial sale of insurance policies. It has permitted all 50 states to erect the type of barriers that the Commerce Clause was written precisely to tear down. Insurers are barred from selling policies to people in another state.
That's right: Congress refuses to keep commerce regular when the commercial activity is the sale of insurance, but claims it can regulate the removal of a person's appendix because that constitutes interstate commerce.
Show Comments (80)