Show Tourists a Good Time By Taxing Them Upon Entry. Majority Leader Harry Reid Really Is That Stupid.
Over at National Review's The Corner, Reason columnist Veronique de Rugy takes note of a new and immensely retarded bit of legislation being pushed by Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.). It's called the Travel Promotion Act of 2009 and is designed to give foreign visitors a positive impression of the good ol' U.S. of A the minute they hit Customs. From de Rugy's gloss:
[Reid's] Travel Promotion Act of 2009 would create a private company to advertise the United States as a tourist destination to foreigners. For instance, one of the objectives of the bill is, literally, to create a welcoming first impression upon arrival into the U.S….
Should that really be a priority of the U.S. right now? Obviously, Congress thinks so, since this is the first bill that it will consider once senators come back from their summer recess.
But here is the best part: The primary funding source for the bill is a $10 fee (tax) on foreign visitors that use the Visa Waiver Program (primarily European countries). It's a horrible policy that makes for a horrible bill.
Got that? Make a good first impression on tourists by picking their pockets for an extra sawbuck. Caution in the Senate: Genius at work. More here.
The great site Washington Watch, which tracks federal spending, estimates this idiotic bill costs only about $22 per family, making it a relative bargain. And if it keeps the Senate from passing cap and trade, health care "reform, or a slew of pernicious financial regs for a couple of weeks, hell, maybe it's a net benefit.
Update: Reason's Matt Welch was on the case back in June!
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Is anyone shocked by any idiotic thing Harry Reid does? Seriously?
I think Harry still thinks we are in the days of the super-weak dollar when Europeans were coming here in droves to buy stuff; a time when walking down the street in SoHo in NYC I heard more people speaking French, German, and Spanish than I heard English.
Or he's just a fucking idiot.
God forbid foreigners come her and spend money, we have to tax them to prevent that.
Since the good "people" in Nevada seem to enjoy pulling the lever so much for this ignorant twat, perhaps now's the time to accidently nuke the major population centers of the state; they could claim it was an esoteric UFO weapon mishandled at Area 51 or something.... Can't be any more foolish than anything this gasbag has ever belched forth.
Hell, why don't we get them coming and going?
That way we will make $20 per head and be able to fund Obama care!
As a reward for getting a cheap visa that the US spends virtually no money to check or issue, we'll charge you $10!
Call it a value-added tax. The Euros will feel right at home.
Since the good "people" in Nevada seem to enjoy pulling the lever so much for this ignorant twat
That latest polling out of NV shows Reid in trouble with the voters of his home state. (His son is running 3rd in his election)
It seems Nevada may have just had enough of Mr Reid. Let's hope so.
"[Reid's] Travel Promotion Act of 2009 would create a private company staffed with Reid's chronies and assorted idiot sons who can't find productive work elswhere to advertise the United States as a tourist destination to foreigners"
And he gets to tax foreigners (nonvoters) to do it. By congress critter logic, this is brilliant.
Never attribute to incompetence to what can easily be explained by mendacity.
U.S. charges admission. Great.
But, but...national health care, ChicagoTom! What, do you hate the poor and the sick or something?
We tax things we want to discourage.
Exclusionary clause for Mexicans?
I think someone put it best when this was first under consideration. Paraphrasing: "We want to charge them to encourage them to come here after we were taxed to increase the security which made it a pain in the ass to come here in the first place."
Australia charges $A20 to leave. They collect it in cash, no credit cards, travellers checks or foreign currency. Or at least that's how it was in 1994.
What's more I would not have known if someone in the know had not told me. It wasn't advertized anywhere that I saw. I wondered how many people found themselves having to go the money changer because they had spent all their Aussie dollars preparing to go home.
Though they've changed it since you still had to apply for a tourist visa at the Australian Consulate. I've forgotten if they charged for that or not.
You know... back in the open borders days at Ellis Island, for 50 cents you could stay in the US forever.
[Reid's] Travel Promotion Act of 2009 would create a private company...
Note to Tony, Chad, ChicagoTom, and other whiny liberals: When the government creates a 'private' company with no competition and imbues it with special powers that no other corporation has, then it's not actually private. Although capitalism always gets the blame, this is called corporatism. Liberals seem to have the biggest problem comprehending this. For further research, see Halliburton, Blackwater, Wackenhut, Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac, etc.
Reid is one stupid fuck. You can tell just by looking at the fucker's face that he is stupid.
What is Reid's skull made of? It's amazing that it doesn't collapse into its interior vacuum like that.
Seriously, given that you need to be a special sort of powermad jerk who has little consideration for the effects of what you do on other people to be a legislator, what kind of metajerk does it take to be elected leader of a body of such jerks?
As dislocated from reality run-of-the-mill federal legislators are, their leadership must be doubly so.
Hey when I walked into Mexico years ago it only cost .25 cents to get in but they charged me .50 cents to come back. I guess they figured you would be willing to pay double to not stay in Mexico, they were right.
This douche bag (my apologies to douche bags) needs to be sent packing come election day. To think he and Pelosi are the cream of the crop of Dems? That is not a high bar to overcome now is it?
I have pretty much come to the conclusion that if we do not see mass incumbent firings during the next election we are as fucked as fucked can get and nothing is ever going to change. At that point I will no longer care to even stay informed as it is of no use to continue knowing your being fucked like a porn star in a gangbang movie.
Life is short and unless everyone is ready to take up arms and literally take the country back should we not do it via the voting booth then fuck it, I am done even caring.
Actually the bill was created and is being pushed by Disney and a number of the online travel agencies, Travelocity, Priceline and Orbitz as well as Vegas.com who will stand the benfit the most from the $200 million a year advertising budget.
Damn, this almost makes a national sales tax seem reasonable
dave b, good point. I get blue in the face trying to explain that to some people.
"Australia charges $A20 to leave. They collect it in cash, no credit cards, travellers checks or foreign currency. Or at least that's how it was in 1994."
You can't leave NJ without paying a toll. But there is one bridge...
You know what, Harry Reid is a big jerk, but if it comes down between these goofs taxing me or the French, it's a no-brainer: I vote for the French.
Western Europeans have enjoyed life under our defense umbrella for decades now, the whole Marshall Plan thing... I've got no problem with them kicking in a few extra sheckels to help balance our budget.
This is a good example of how our government get so messed up. The right wing gets in charge, implements worthless security procedures that make it a hassle for people to travel to the US and tourism suffers.
Then the left wing takes over, and instead of getting rid of the worthless laws passed by the right, they create crap like this.
Repeat ad nauseam.
The worthless security procedures were bipartisan. The creation of the TSA itself was a Democratic idea (the Republicans wanted to keep security private, but got scared of post 9/11 polls.)
Worthless security procedures were a great (politically speaking) way for the left wing to show that it was "tough on terrorism" without having to support war. Did you see the bipartisan grilling the TSA head got when he was summoned before the Senate to explain why the TSA was no longer going to care about tweezers?
Remember when Harry Reid said taxation was voluntary? Oh... He IS this stupid.
Senator Reid, did your mother have any children that lived?
I took a shit in Nevada once.
I propose a 10% tax on money spent on casino style gambling in the U.S. Not winnings, but ten cents of every dollar gambled. Lotteries and Indian casinos will be exempt.
When I lived in San Diego the Coranado Bay Bridge cost $1.50 to enter Coronado and nothing to leave. I called it a cover charge.
In New Poll, Harry Reid Trails Danny Tarkanian, Sue Lowden, Ham Sandwich
Daily Kos has Research2000 poll on possible Nevada Senate matchups, and finds Harry Reid trailing Republican Danny Tarkanian, 40 percent to 45 percent; Reid also trails GOP state party chair Sue Lowden, 41 percent to 44 percent.
Also interesting? Reid's favorable/unfavorable split is 36/52.
Obama's approval rating in Nevada is at 48 percent; 41 percent disapprove.
http://www.dailykos.com/statepoll/2009/9/2/NV/357
I've never looked so forward to a mid-term election as I do to 2010. I just want to see the carnage. But if this fucking moron gets beat in the primary and then has to finish out his term as majority leader as the embarrassment who got beat in his own primary, all the better. Talk about taking any influence anyone thought he had and tossing it out the window.
Among the many things I love about Reason is that their writers would feel able to say screw the PC police and use the phrase "immensely retarded" (and not in its technical, medical sense as in "TAO is not a moron, he is actually immensely retarded")
Yeah John Thacker, the TSA which was created under a GOP controlled House and Senate and President is the fucking Democrats fault. I mean, if you look at the vote all the Democrats voted for it and all the GOP voted against it and the GOP President vetoed it but it passed because of Mr. Mytzlplyk's magic.
What are you, immensely retarded?
MNG, I believe he said the security procedures were bipartisan. Translation: their implementation was the fault of BOTH sides. Which doesn't mean the Democrats didn't think it up in the first place. Once can say both and not be inconsistent, contra your mendacity.
Or perhaps, just perhaps, YOU'RE immensely retarded for not being able to pick that up.
"...the TSA which was created under a GOP controlled House and Senate..."
No, by that time Jeffords had switched parties, the Dems had a bare majority under Leader Daschle, another tool.
I'm convinced that Nevadans elected Harry Reid to get the asshole out of Vegas. Who would want him around?
-jcr
I'm convinced that Nevadans elected Harry Reid to get the asshole out of Vegas. Who would want him around?
They shoulda just buried him in the desert with all the other crooks.
Hell, why don't we get them coming and going?
That way we will make $20 per head and be able to fund Obama care!
What a great idea! Since every great idea can be improved upon, I suggest we have no entry tax, but instead put on a $100 exit tax. You wanna go home Frenchy, it's gonna cost ya.
Nevadans electing Harry Reid puzzles me. Nevada seems to be a rugged individualist kind of place. I guess all of the NY and CA transplants have brought their utopias with them.
I stopped going anywhere further than about a 800 mile radius (about 2 taks of gas) from where I live because I can't carry a small amount of cannabis and a pocket knife on commercial aircraft without being treated like a terrorist.