Here's a report that, if the story behind it is true, is both totally unsurprising and worthy of our notice and contempt:
In his new book, the first Homeland Security chief, Tom Ridge, accuses top aides to President George W. Bush of pressing him to raise the terror alert level to influence the 2004 presidential election.
Ridge, a former Republican governor of Pennsylvania, says that he refused the entreaty just before the election from Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld and Attorney General John Ashcroft, according to a summary of the book from publisher Thomas Dunne Books.
"After that episode, I knew I had to follow through with my plans to leave the federal government for the private sector," Ridge, who resigned soon after the election where Bush defeated Democrat John F. Kerry, writes in "The Test of Our Times: America Under Siege … And How We Can Be Safe Again."
You're a true patriot, Tom Ridge. When faced with senior administration officials deliberately trying to scare the crap out of the American people to win an election–a tar-and-featherable offense, at minimum–not only did you decide to eventually quit some day, you rushed out and told citizens about their duplicitous leaders in just five short years! For profit!
A banal point to remember, but foundational: Government is materially incentivized to frighten you, about everything. Power–surprise!–corrupts, no matter which set of angels happens to be exercising it this year. Which is why some of us don't gladly give the stuff over to Washington, D.C.
For more on the eternal politics of scaremongering, see Nick Gillespie's classic, "You know, this used to be a helluva good country." And for a fat archive criticizing the Department of Homeland Security back when the respectable consensus assured us of its necessity, start here.
UPDATE: The artist formerly known as Lonewacko points out in the comments that (as LW blogged at the time), Ridge was telling a similar story to USA Today back in May 2005.
Start your day with Reason. Get a daily brief of the most important stories and trends every weekday morning when you subscribe to Reason Roundup.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com
posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary
period.
Subscribe
here to preserve your ability to comment. Your
Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the
digital
edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do
not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments
do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and
ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
You're a true patriot, Tom Ridge. When faced with senior administration officials deliberately trying to scare the crap out of the American people to win an election-a tar-and-featherable offense, at minimum-not only did you decide to eventually quit some day, you rushed out and told citizens about their duplicitous leaders in just five short years! For profit!
Next in series: Former DEA Agent Criticizes Drug War
You're a true patriot, Tom Ridge. When faced with senior administration officials deliberately trying to scare the crap out of the American people to win an election-a tar-and-featherable offense, at minimum-not only did you decide to eventually quit some day, you rushed out and told citizens about their duplicitous leaders in just five short years! For profit!
"You're a true patriot, Tom Ridge. When faced with senior administration officials deliberately trying to scare the crap out of the American people to win an election-a tar-and-featherable offense, at minimum-not only did you decide to eventually quit some day, you rushed out and told citizens about their duplicitous leaders in just five short years! For profit!"
Better late than never. I have no problem with someone making a profit.
I like how Welch declines to use L-Dub's current handle. No matter how he *ahem* handles himself, he'll always be our LoneWacko. [insert 80's sitcom end credits]
Did any sane American really believe those terror alerts? Cry wolf enough times and you lose your edge. I doubt they were having much impact by the time of the '04 election.
Did any sane American really believe those terror alerts?
I'd say that shit was ignored within a month after it was thought up and implemented. If you sit at DEFCON 3 all the time, it sort of loses its meaning.
It's worth noting that the allegation in the latest report is materially different than what USA Today reported on in May 2005.
"Sometimes attempting to raise the terror alert level on flimsy evidence" does not equal "Specifically trying to influence an election by raising the terror alert level".
Not that this diminishes LW's vital contribution in any way... 😉
The big point in his favor was that he had the balls to say "no". It would have been really fucking nice if some of the unnamed Jack Ryan wannabes over at the CIA had had the guts to do that about WMD thing in 2003, rather than keep their jobs by promulgating bullshit info that got us into a fucking war.
Poor old John Ashcroft said "no" to warrantless wiretapping when Torquemada Gonzales pushed him to sign off on it while in a hospital bed after his gallbladderectomy, yet he gets no love around these parts for some reason too.
Sounds like everything went as it should: Political leaders attempted to maintain their power, but Ridge did his job and refused. Turns out it didn't matter to the election and it never would have anyway since nobody cared what the threat level was, (do you know what it is now?).
I expect this stuff to happen. It's minor and would have had no effect. They only asked him to raise it, they did not force or threaten him. They may have honestly thought it should be higher. If for political advantage, then it was wrong, but mildly. Like a married man watching porn. Wish it didn't happen, but everyone knows it does.
What has happened with Inspector Generals under Obama is the real thing. Fire, discredit, and slander when one of your appointees maintains his integrity and you don't like it. That's real corruption.
If he were a real patriot, he would've spoken out before the election -- not before his book is released.
Frankly, I don't blame him... coming out about it then would have just resulted in him getting fired, villainized by the Republican Party, and then someone who would have been Bush's total bitch would have taken his place.
And Kerry probably still would have lost.
Average Voter, 2004: "Look! Even Tom Ridge is a terrorist! See how far the terrorists have infiltrated our government! We need Bush now more than EVER!"
Yeah, what convincing confirmation. This confirms "it" about as convincingly as Anita Hill confirmed her sexual harassment a fucking decade after the fact.
I'll wait until the book comes out. Did Rumsfeld and Ashcroft specifically tell him to raise the threat level before the election to sway it? Did they tell him to raise the threat level because they legitimately thought that our national election would be an opportunity for terrorists to strike? (remember Spain, anyone?) Or, did they just sometimes disagree on what the threat level should be, as the USA Today article makes it? Unless Ridge says, "Rumsfeld and Ashcroft told me to raise the threat level so that Bush could win the election", I don't see this as news.
PS: yes, I agree that the colors are silly. If you're always on high alert, than the levels don't mean anything.
Can someone please tell these pricks the story of the Boy Who Cried Wolf?
(Bashir tells the story of the boy who cried "Wolf")
Bashir: If you lie all the time, no one is going to believe you, even when you're telling the truth.
Garak: Are you sure that's the point, Doctor?
Bashir: Of course. What else would it be?
Garak: That you should never tell the same lie twice.
I'm really surprised that people were still taking that "terror alert level" thing seriously back in 2004.
Like people would see on the news that the government RAISED THE ALERT LEVEL TO ORANGE and start shitting their pants. OMG! We're at orange! Make sure the doors are locked! Seal up our windows in Saran Wrap and make sure the Cipro is still in date!
"terror alert level" in 2002 & 2004 worked well enough on enough stupid cowards to get a few more votes, so Republicans didn't need to game as many voting machines.
"You're a true patriot, Tom Ridge. When faced with senior administration officials deliberately trying to scare the crap out of the American people to win an election-a tar-and-featherable offense, at minimum-not only did you decide to eventually quit some day, you rushed out and told citizens about their duplicitous leaders in just five short years! For profit!"
Unfortunately, these days, that IS the measure of a true patriot, and I feel compelled to thank Mr. Ridge for his service. We are royally screwed.
Thanks! Great! Now I'm contractually sucked into listening to Death Cab / Postal Service for the next hour or so. Sorrow drips into my heart thru a pinhole.
According to this article, "Ridge says that despite the urgings of former Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld and then-Attorney General John Ashcroft he objected to raising the security level, according to a publicity release from the book's publisher.
I'm amazed how little story there is here. Bin Laden issued a threatening tape. Two of the people on the committee that sets threat levels (Ashcroft, Rumsfeld) thought we should up the threat level and at least three (Townsend, Powell, Ridge) thought we shouldn't. Bush accepted the recommendation of the committee and didn't raise the threat level. The scandal, such as it is, seems to be that people dared to disagree with Tom Ridge, even if the President ultimately agreed with him.
IIRC, the color-coded warning system was the kind of dumb idea that you could expect if you held a bunch of bureaucrats liable for not stopping 9/11 even when they knew about an increase in "chatter". Ok, thought the bureaucrats, if people want to be warned every time we feel nervous, we can do that . . .
It's a great marketing ploy, though. Like Scott McClellan, he's just enticing 50% of the market that would otherwise have no interest in anything he wrote.
This might not have been a one time request.
The terror alert was raised in August when Bush was campaigning in Ohio.
"""Did they tell him to raise the threat level because they legitimately thought that our national election would be an opportunity for terrorists to strike? """
I don't think that would have compelled Ridge to resign.
What's 24 * (the number of days since 12/1/05)?
I ask because almost four years ago I posted about Tom Ridge complaining about the terror level being raised on flimsy evidence.
Good job and keep it up, LoneWacko.
Is it too late to impeach?
What's 24 * (the number of days since 12/1/05)?
I got 69.
Hey, shouldn't John be here to tell how Democrats politicized terror too?
Thanks, LW, updated.
Jesus, Matt, don't encourage him. Then again, nothing discourages him, so I guess it doesn't matter.
Mark this day in the history books, folks: LoneBoner got one right.
You can't be *wrong* all the time, either.
*rubs eyes*
What? LoneWacko . . . contributing something besides retardedness? Whoa!
I eagerly await Colin Powell's memoirs. I want to be regaled with the gripping saga of his struggle to find the truth.
Next in series: Former DEA Agent Criticizes Drug War
24 is the Highest Number.
Can someone please tell these pricks the story of the Boy Who Cried Wolf?
Elliot Richardson was an outlier.
News of an upcoming election is a terror alert.
"You're a true patriot, Tom Ridge. When faced with senior administration officials deliberately trying to scare the crap out of the American people to win an election-a tar-and-featherable offense, at minimum-not only did you decide to eventually quit some day, you rushed out and told citizens about their duplicitous leaders in just five short years! For profit!"
Better late than never. I have no problem with someone making a profit.
poor kerry got terrorboated.
I like how Welch declines to use L-Dub's current handle. No matter how he *ahem* handles himself, he'll always be our LoneWacko. [insert 80's sitcom end credits]
ransom, nah, he just wasn't up to playing in the Bush league.
I like how Welch declines to use L-Dub's current handle.
Orange Line Special didn't stick, and neither will 24AheadDotCom. He's the one who named himself LoneFuckwad first, anyway.
He still calls himself Lonewacko, it's the "team" that contributes to his website and larger movement that's called 24ahead.com.
As you can tell, I've read his blog a few times. For porpoises of entertainment only.
Wait, LonelyWhacker got something right?
I must go to an east-facing window and watch the sun set. The pigs flying by will enliven the scene.
brotherben | August 20, 2009, 7:40pm | #
hahahaha
i have no answer...
strike through16 years agoDid any sane American really believe those terror alerts? Cry wolf enough times and you lose your edge. I doubt they were having much impact by the time of the '04 election.
Did any sane American really believe those terror alerts?
I'd say that shit was ignored within a month after it was thought up and implemented. If you sit at DEFCON 3 all the time, it sort of loses its meaning.
Orange Line Special didn't stick, and neither will 24AheadDotCom.
Sigh. I still remember Chris as "Click 'n' Learn".
strike through16 years agoEpisiarch | August 20, 2009, 8:16pm | #
If you sit at DEFCON 3 all the time, it sort of loses its meaning.
Precisely. Not that it's stopping Keith Olbermann from ranting about it as I type.
Oh boy, it's John Dean!
I say this ranks as an orange.
It's worth noting that the allegation in the latest report is materially different than what USA Today reported on in May 2005.
"Sometimes attempting to raise the terror alert level on flimsy evidence" does not equal "Specifically trying to influence an election by raising the terror alert level".
Not that this diminishes LW's vital contribution in any way... 😉
strike through16 years agoMaybe there should be socialism alert levels.
Are we at "red" yet?
The big point in his favor was that he had the balls to say "no". It would have been really fucking nice if some of the unnamed Jack Ryan wannabes over at the CIA had had the guts to do that about WMD thing in 2003, rather than keep their jobs by promulgating bullshit info that got us into a fucking war.
Penguin,
Poor old John Ashcroft said "no" to warrantless wiretapping when Torquemada Gonzales pushed him to sign off on it while in a hospital bed after his gallbladderectomy, yet he gets no love around these parts for some reason too.
Lonewacko is Keith Olbermann?
BakedPenguin,
At least none of the the Jack Ryan wannabes didn't try to fake a WMD "discovery" in Iraq.
The executive branch folks were so convinced by their own bullshit that they were too self-deluded to bring along a throw-down piece.
Confession: I was shocked that they at least didn't try to fake it.
Theory: Somebody at CIA has some major dirt on the Bush team or else we'd hear a better argument than "They were secretly shipped to Syria, dude."
Wait, LonelyWhacker got something right?
It makes me doubt my use of incif.
Oh, wait, no it doesnt.
Wait, LonelyWhacker got something right?
I only like cognitive dissonance when it isn't my own.
Wait, LonelyWhacker got something right?
I always thought libertarianism was that "big tent" people keep talking about. So there's your proof.
Sounds like everything went as it should: Political leaders attempted to maintain their power, but Ridge did his job and refused. Turns out it didn't matter to the election and it never would have anyway since nobody cared what the threat level was, (do you know what it is now?).
I expect this stuff to happen. It's minor and would have had no effect. They only asked him to raise it, they did not force or threaten him. They may have honestly thought it should be higher. If for political advantage, then it was wrong, but mildly. Like a married man watching porn. Wish it didn't happen, but everyone knows it does.
What has happened with Inspector Generals under Obama is the real thing. Fire, discredit, and slander when one of your appointees maintains his integrity and you don't like it. That's real corruption.
" Like a married man watching porn. Wish it didn't happen, but everyone knows it does."
so when she turns it i gotta leave the room?
If he were a real patriot, he would've spoken out before the election -- not before his book is released.
If he were a real patriot, he would've spoken out before the election -- not before his book is released.
Frankly, I don't blame him... coming out about it then would have just resulted in him getting fired, villainized by the Republican Party, and then someone who would have been Bush's total bitch would have taken his place.
And Kerry probably still would have lost.
Average Voter, 2004: "Look! Even Tom Ridge is a terrorist! See how far the terrorists have infiltrated our government! We need Bush now more than EVER!"
Come to think of it, why DIDN'T Bush n' Pals fake some evidence?
Yeah, what convincing confirmation. This confirms "it" about as convincingly as Anita Hill confirmed her sexual harassment a fucking decade after the fact.
Come to think of it, why DIDN'T Bush n' Pals fake some evidence?
Because they would have fucked it up if they'd tried?
Come to think of it, why DIDN'T Bush n' Pals fake some evidence?
Because it came about under Clinton and they didn't need to?
We don't even have to worry about the wars and war protesters Cindy Sheehan anymore. At least that's what Charlie Gibson from ABC says.
Cats getting out of bags after an administration change. Who woulda thunk it. Not surprised, about any of it.
I remember Lonewacko getting something else right in the last couple of weeks. Or at least made a good point. So I think this is twice in a month
I'll wait until the book comes out. Did Rumsfeld and Ashcroft specifically tell him to raise the threat level before the election to sway it? Did they tell him to raise the threat level because they legitimately thought that our national election would be an opportunity for terrorists to strike? (remember Spain, anyone?) Or, did they just sometimes disagree on what the threat level should be, as the USA Today article makes it? Unless Ridge says, "Rumsfeld and Ashcroft told me to raise the threat level so that Bush could win the election", I don't see this as news.
PS: yes, I agree that the colors are silly. If you're always on high alert, than the levels don't mean anything.
Lonewacko, you're still under standing orders to shut the fuck up. Shut the fuck up, Lonewacko.
Can someone please tell these pricks the story of the Boy Who Cried Wolf?
(Bashir tells the story of the boy who cried "Wolf")
Bashir: If you lie all the time, no one is going to believe you, even when you're telling the truth.
Garak: Are you sure that's the point, Doctor?
Bashir: Of course. What else would it be?
Garak: That you should never tell the same lie twice.
If only the Bushies could have applied their ruthlessness to the pursuit of competence.
I'm really surprised that people were still taking that "terror alert level" thing seriously back in 2004.
Like people would see on the news that the government RAISED THE ALERT LEVEL TO ORANGE and start shitting their pants. OMG! We're at orange! Make sure the doors are locked! Seal up our windows in Saran Wrap and make sure the Cipro is still in date!
"terror alert level" in 2002 & 2004 worked well enough on enough stupid cowards to get a few more votes, so Republicans didn't need to game as many voting machines.
It should be noted that Ridge tried, unsuccessfully, to modernize Pa's state run liquor distribution monopoly.
Lonewacko, in a rare moment of lucidity, for the win.
"You're a true patriot, Tom Ridge. When faced with senior administration officials deliberately trying to scare the crap out of the American people to win an election-a tar-and-featherable offense, at minimum-not only did you decide to eventually quit some day, you rushed out and told citizens about their duplicitous leaders in just five short years! For profit!"
Unfortunately, these days, that IS the measure of a true patriot, and I feel compelled to thank Mr. Ridge for his service. We are royally screwed.
Hopefully, Sec. Ridge got his name on an official-looking plaque in the lobby of some DHS building.
Then, all the Bush toady-ing will have been worth it: Immortality is achieved! (Until they tear the building down.)
Washington is Hollywood for ugly people.
Again, at what point, exactly, in a political career does the soul leave the body?
Again, at what point, exactly, in a political career does the soul leave the body?
Is this some kind of super easy reverse challenge?
Thanks! Great! Now I'm contractually sucked into listening to Death Cab / Postal Service for the next hour or so. Sorrow drips into my heart thru a pinhole.
According to this article, "Ridge says that despite the urgings of former Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld and then-Attorney General John Ashcroft he objected to raising the security level, according to a publicity release from the book's publisher.
In the end the alert level was not changed."
I'm amazed how little story there is here. Bin Laden issued a threatening tape. Two of the people on the committee that sets threat levels (Ashcroft, Rumsfeld) thought we should up the threat level and at least three (Townsend, Powell, Ridge) thought we shouldn't. Bush accepted the recommendation of the committee and didn't raise the threat level. The scandal, such as it is, seems to be that people dared to disagree with Tom Ridge, even if the President ultimately agreed with him.
IIRC, the color-coded warning system was the kind of dumb idea that you could expect if you held a bunch of bureaucrats liable for not stopping 9/11 even when they knew about an increase in "chatter". Ok, thought the bureaucrats, if people want to be warned every time we feel nervous, we can do that . . .
Solitary Krazee Kracker probably got it from reading "What A Guy" Dienstag's blog...
(he's on /. dontcha know!)
That little phrase already sounds quaint.
J Mann sums it up nicely.
It's a great marketing ploy, though. Like Scott McClellan, he's just enticing 50% of the market that would otherwise have no interest in anything he wrote.
This might not have been a one time request.
The terror alert was raised in August when Bush was campaigning in Ohio.
"""Did they tell him to raise the threat level because they legitimately thought that our national election would be an opportunity for terrorists to strike? """
I don't think that would have compelled Ridge to resign.
It is upsetting because terror alerts scare the public. This should have never been used to promote a political agenda.