Cash-Strapped States and Localities Concentrate on Lobbying the Federal Government
Peter Suderman wrote earlier today about how the prospect of a government overhaul of health care is ginning up more and more health-care lobbyists.
Similarly, despite their being legendarily struggling with crushing budget problems (largely caused by their own improvidence--see this May Reason magazine feature), states and localities are finding they can dredge up the cash they need to lobby the federal government for more cash. See from the Wall Street Journal:
Towns, cities, counties and states across the country spent a total of $21.4 million on lobbyists between April and June, up 2.7% from the first quarter of the year and in line with spending levels through 2008, according to data provided by the nonpartisan Center for Responsive Politics. Almost 1,000 different governments reported paying representatives to pursue their agenda. About a quarter reported lobbying specifically about the stimulus package.
In one of those great paradoxes of the deadweight loss caused via all the rent-seeking that government actions engender, they are managing to keep up with 2008 spending levels despite non-2008 revenues:
The National League of Cities has said its members face their worst fiscal problems since 1985. State revenue dropped more sharply in the first quarter of this year than any time since 1952, according to the Rockefeller Institute of Government in Albany, N.Y.
But think of all the stimulus created by companies and governments spending cash to capture more stimulus money! It's like a magical machine of bullshit economic "growth."
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Government lobbying government, we've truly reached the apex of the governmental space-time-continuum.
The United States Government has become so large, so powerful that it lobbies itself for cash. It's turned into a bunch of men in a burlap sack trading hats for a living.
This also, of course, makes the local governments even more dependent on the federal government, continuing the destruction of federalism and making it even harder for states to buck the feds on something like, oh, marijuana legalization.
It's amazing how, since probably 2000 or so, the concept of actually shrinking government has become something that isn't even really considered any more. First thoughts are always raise taxes and fees, lobby the feds, etc.
The United States Government has become so large, so powerful that it lobbies itself for cash.
Even without invoking "so powerful", this sort of thing goes on constantly among agencies looking for "customer funding". Think it beats central planning?
The First Rule of Panhandling is:
One must have a majic marker and cardboard.
so, i'm not crazy? government really is one giant pyramid scheme?
i have a shitty job and make shitty money doing it. this is no fault of the government. i'm a lazy stoner and would rather have a low paying job with no stress than a high paying job with tons of it.
i'd say there are at least a hundred million other wasteless fucks out there with the same or similar outlook on life. we don't need any government help and we don't ask for it either. we're poor because we're douchebags, not because you didn't do enough. my mom is as disappointed with me as you all should be.
the economy sucks because of me and my kind. i'd say flog us in public, but that's just not cool.
It's like a magical machine of bullshit economic "growth."
How do you really feel? I'm a little bummed there was no mention of magical creatures like unicorns.
I see it as more of a government teat daisy chain.
nipplemancer, folks like you that are content where they're at aren't the problem. It's the folks that go through life like Terrell Owens. Playin league minimum salary football and screaming that they oughtta be payed 10mil a year plus perks.
Reminds me of what I wrote in the 3rd para. here.
Dear President Obama-
My State is out of money. Maria says I should just print some, but I had to study the Constitution before becoming a citizen, and I remember that it won't let States do that. I don't think I'll get away with handing out IOUs, either, but I have already done some of that and need to clean up that mess before too many people get wise. On the other hand you can print as much money as you want, so I am writing to ask you to please print up some and let us have it here in Col-i-FOR-nyah. A little more inflation is a small price to pay, and in exchange for pumping us up, we'll do whatever you say. Such a deal, right?
You know it and I know it, Mr. President: Col-i-FOR-nyah is simply too big to fail. So please electronically deposit the funds into our account, which I have specified by number at the end of this note.
Thank you for your time and trouble.
Yours ever; Arnie
How can you people talk about money when Obama is
How can you people talk about money when Obama is practically being lynched?
You have nothing to be ashamed of as far as I'm concerned, Nipplemancer, but this is probably the most awesome thing I've ever read on the internet.
wingnutx,
Thanks for the Godwin's Law-related hyperbole 🙂
Strike through16 years agoSure, it's fun now, but it's going to be super-deluxe fun when there are more Americans in the public "sector" than the private. The long-held fear that the servants will one day become the masters is nearing reality. We might just pawn ourselves into bankruptcy and oblivion, ending not with a bang, but an IOU to a slave generation.
Apr?s Moi le Deluge.
I dunno what that means. It was something Axelrod, Ayres and the teleprompter came up with, I guess. Whatever.
In RI the state is closing businesses, I guess the only real money is in government.
http://www.projo.com/news/content/BUSINESS_TAX_PROBLEM_07-30-09_HSF7JHN_v29.3c1d325.html
Of course that's when they are not extracting money out of burn victims.
http://www2.turnto10.com/jar/news/local/article/station_fire_victims_may_have_to_reimburse_fund/21014/
And just who do we think is going to have to pay for all these handouts??
RT
http://www.anon-web-tools.us.tc
And just who do we think is going to have to pay for all these handouts??
Yes we can!
The states are just applying the Willie Sutton principle here. They ask for money from the feds because that's where the money is.
-jcr
The long-held fear that the servants will one day become the masters is nearing reality.
Oh, I think we crossed that Rubicon long ago.
brotherben, when did Terrell Owens become a league minimum valued player? The guy is nutso, for sure, but he gets the job done on the field.
It's the folks that go through life like Terrell Owens. Playin league minimum salary football and screaming that they oughtta be payed 10mil a year plus perks.
Actually the problem is the people who pay him $10M...