John McCain

Straight Talk!


Is John McCain flip-flopping on immigration? Now? Why?

Republican presidential hopeful John McCain on Thursday backed a scaled-down proposal that imposes strict rules to end illegal immigration but doesn't include a path to citizenship.

The move away from a comprehensive measure is an about-face for the Arizona senator, who had been a leading GOP champion of a bill that included a guest worker program and would have legalized many of the estimated 12 million illegal immigrants living in the U.S. It failed earlier this year.

Among other things, the bill makes being in the country illegally a criminal misdemeanor and toughens penalties for re-entering after being deported. It mandates an electronic system for employers to check workers' citizenship status and requires illegal immigrants who commit a crime to be held in jail until they are deported.

The press release is here: Lindsay Graham and John Kyl, buffetted by the base during the immigration fight, are co-sponsors.

Here's what McCain was saying about immigrants and citizenship in 2006:

These people have come for the same reason immigrants have always come to America. They came to grasp the lowest rung of the ladder, and they intend to rise. Let them rise. Let them rise. We will be better for it. For America, blessed, bountiful, beautiful America - is still the land of hope and opportunity - the land of the immigrant's dreams. Long may she remain so.

By the way, the title of McCain's upcoming book is Hard Call: Great Decisions and the Extraordinary People Who Made Them.

NEXT: John Dean on Rudy (and Hillary?)

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  1. Schadenfreude (help?info) is a German word meaning ‘pleasure taken from someone else’s misfortune’.

    straight-up schadenfreude, homey.

  2. Schadenfreude (help?info) is a German word meaning ‘pleasure taken from someone else’s misfortune’.

    In other words, “lol@McCain”.

  3. I’m iN yER P0litiX, fLip-Fl0ppinG 0n IshooZ…

  4. A sad old man desperately clinging to a lost dream will say or do anything.

  5. It’s worth noting that he still supports “reform”, he’s trying to get it another way.

    As for why he’d try another way, I really have absolutely no clue. After all, don’t those ever reliable polls tell us that the public supports “reform”? Could… Mort… Kondracke……. be wrong???????????

    P.S. to Weigel: please bring back a couple jars full of smug from the conference.

  6. Scooped by Ezra?

    BTW, it would seem there were many opportunities for mischief of other kinds at YK. Did no one engage in such things as, say, passing out copies of the SocialistWorker, or leaving them around and taking pictures, or passing out flyers denouncing Kos as a corporate shill or something? Young people nowadays, I tell you.

  7. I feel like I’m guest blogging here or something.

    Anywho, if Weigel wants to try asking one of tomorrow’s speakers a real question, try one of these.

  8. “A sad old man…”

    I personally disagree with McCain on a whole host of issues but his lifetime of service, including a very painful stint in Vietnam, is worthy of respect, not derision.

Please to post comments

Comments are closed.