Barrio Battles
Street vendors in New York are fighting back against official harassment.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
"A street vendor isn't offering a sit-down meal out of the weather like Wendy's." True enough, Tim. Maybe a better example would be flower vendors vs. florists, or tables with radios vs. electronics stores.
Lord knows I'm not exactly comfortable defending big corporations vs. independent vendors, but the guys in the stores (or their landlords) are paying taxes to maintain the sidewalks that their competition is setting up on.
I'm somewhat sympathetic to the vendors, and some of what goes on is pretty vile - "The police always confiscate the merchandise and throw it out, and they take the vendors' money." Any bets on whether that money goes straight into cops' pockets? If the cops found Bouley in violation of some law, you think they'd trash the kitchen?
But the self-righteousness of the vendors gets under my skin, too. "The authorities don't understand our culture, our way of life." Excuse me? You came to our country; maybe you should have found out something about it before you tried your hand at breaking the law. (It reminds me of the old joke about the British colonial authorities hanging a native who'd committed some act only the British found reprehensible: "You don't understand! It is part of our ancient and traditional way!" "Yes, and our ancient and traditional way is to hang people who do it.")
Ah well...there are no angels in our worldly disputes, I suppose. As a libertarian, I'm all in favor of the freedom to move and work where you please, but I don't think that just ignoring current law by ignoring people's immigration status is really the way to go.
As far as bringing people into the mainstream, I'm in the middle of "The Mystery of Capital" by Hernando de Soto, which has as one of its main thrusts the need to integrate the marginalized into a larger system of laws and rights, and I'd recommend it to anyone.
I can understand why something has to be done. The Wendy's, for example, has to pay property taxes, meet health codes, etc. Forcing them to comply with the law, while allowing another class of businesses to exist outside of it, is neither moral nor smart.
But in this case, the cure is worse than the disease. There needs to be a way to bring these micro-businesses into the mainstream economy. Just as there needs to be a way to decriminalize the immigration of Mexican guest labor. Neither cracking down nor anarchic openning of the flood gates is wise or politically viable. We need a third way.
There is a way to bring these businesses into the "mainstream." Make the price of the permits negligible. That way money can be spent on equipment instead.
Where exactly does property tax enter into the picture? A street vendor isn't offering a sit-down meal out of the weather like Wendy's.
Some locations of some pizza chains have take-out only service, and have nothing more than a bench where you wait for your pizza. Despite that, they still pay property taxes.
But, that's immaterial compared to the human issues involved here. Whether these people are "legal" or not, they're human beings. Simply by arriving in the U.S., they're entitled to everything that a "legal" citizen is. Why, many of them even have had children here, and, by that fact alone, everyone in their entire extended family should be immediately declared a citizen. This country is made up of immigrants just like them. Sure, those other immigrants came here legally through Ellis Island and other portals, and the governments of Italy and Poland weren't constantly trying to meddle in our internal affairs, but, let's ignore that issue entirely.
Hotels 1 Hotels 2 Hotels 3 Hotels 4 Hotels 5 Hotels 6 hotels 6 hotels 7 hotels 8 Orient Bizimkent Porselen Sar Ottoman Asia Europe Asia 2 Europe 2 Barcelona Madrid Athens Istanbul Cannes Paris Rome Milan Munich Moscow Budapest Santorini Singapore Singapore 2 Singapore 3 Singapore 4 Singapore 5 Singapore 6 Singapore 7 Singapore 8 Thailand Thailand 2 Thailand 3 Thailand 4 Thailand 5 Thailand 6 Thailand 7 Thailand 8 Thailand 9 Thailand 10 Thailand 11 Thailand 12 Malaysia Malaysia 2 Kuala Lumpur Penang Taiwan Taiwan 2 Taipei Greece Athens Santorini Thessaloniki Greece 2
bad breath
tonsil stones
broadband internet
car rental
car rental
cell phone plans
cell phone plans
colleges universities
contact lenses
singlesw dating
singles dating
dentist directory
dental directory
dental insurance
fucus vesiculosus
weight loss patch
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
directv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
directv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv / dish network
direct tv / dish network
direct tv / dish network
direcway internet
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network receivers
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
strivectin
flowers
headache
ellipticals home gyms
exercise equipment
treadmills
hotels
laser dentistry
home loans
medical insurance
discount shopping
online dating
pennes enlargement pills
pennes enlargement pills
security cams
security cams
security cams
security cams
security cams
security cams
strivectin
strivectin sd
strivectin-sd
strivectin-sd
strivectin sd
tan towels
teeth whitening
teeth whitening
teeth whitening
vacation packages
vacations
vacations
vacations
vacations
vacations
weight loss
weight loss patch
weight loss patch
weight loss
weight loss programs
zantrex-3
==================================================
bad breath
tonsil stones
broadband internet
car rental
car rental
cell phone plans
cell phone plans
colleges universities
contact lenses
singlesw dating
singles dating
dentist directory
dental directory
dental insurance
fucus vesiculosus
weight loss patch
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
directv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
directv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv
direct tv / dish network
direct tv / dish network
direct tv / dish network
direcway internet
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network receivers
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
dish network
strivectin
flowers
headache
ellipticals home gyms
exercise equipment
treadmills
hotels
laser dentistry
home loans
medical insurance
discount shopping
online dating
pennes enlargement pills
pennes enlargement pills
pennes enlargement pills
security cams
security cams
security cams
security cams
security cams
security cams
strivectin
strivectin sd
strivectin-sd
strivectin-sd
strivectin sd
tan towels
teeth whitening
teeth whitening
teeth whitening
vacation packages
vacations
vacations
vacations
vacations
vacations
weight loss
weight loss patch
weight loss patch
weight loss
weight loss programs
zantrex-3
===================
I have used Strivectin-SD.
I have used Fucus Vesiculosus.
I have used Direct TV. I have used Direct TV vs Dish Network. I have used Male Potency Patch. I have used TestroGel Testosterone Cream. I have used Dish Network. I have used Dish Network Dish. I have used Satellite TV. I have used Dish Network Special. I have used Compare Home Equity Loans. I have used Home Security Systems. I have used x10 Wireless Security Cameras. I have used Nordic Track Treadmills. I have used Proform Treadmills. I have used Florists Flower Delivery. I have used Best Cell Phone Plans. I have used Compare Cell Phone Plans. I have used Contact Lenses. I have used Weight Loss Programs. I have used Singles Dating. I have used Dating Online. I have used Dish Network & Direct TV. I have used Weight Loss Patch. I have used Great Vacation Spots. I have used Great Vacations. I have used StriVectin-SD. I have used Dish Network Dish TV. I have used Dish Network. I have used Dish Network. I have used Dish Network. I have used Dish Network. I have used Dish Network. I have used Dish Network. I have used Dish Network. I have used Dish Network. I have used Dish Network. I have used Dish Network. I have used Dish Network. I have used Tan Towel Tan Towels Tanning. I have used Tan Towel. I have used Tan Towel Tan Towels Tanning. I have used Exercise Equipment & Treadmills. I have used Dish Network. I have used Dish Network. I have used StriVectin-SD. I have used Dish Network. I have used Satellite TV. I have used Dish Network. I have used College Search. I have used StriVectin-SD. I have used StriVectin-SD. I have used StriVectin-SD. I have used StriVectin-SD. I have used StriVectin-SD. I have used StriVectin-SD. I have used Zantrex-3. I have used Zantrex-3.
I have used Strivectin-SD.
I have also used Dish Network.
I have used Dish Network Receivers.
I have used Dish Network.
I have used Dish Network.
I have used Dish Network.
I have used Dish Network.
I have used Dish Network.
I have used Dish Network.
I have used Dish Network.
I have used Dish Network.
I have used Direct TV.
I have used Direct TV.
I have used Direct TV.
I have used Direct TV.
I have used Directv.
I have used Direct TV - Directv.
I have used Directv.
I have used StriVectin-SD.
I have used Dish Network.
I have used Directv.
I have used Tonsil Stones.
I have used Strivectin SD.
=======================
My name is Luke Dish
Network, and I am the son of Anakin Dish
Network and Padme Dish
Network. Anakin Dish
Network had three brothers, and their names were Moe Dish
Network, Larry Dish
Network and Curly Dish
Network. They all lived in the Dish
Network household at 1010 Dish
Network Road. The Dish
Network family lived in troubled times as the rebels were battling against
the empire, who were under Anakin Dish
Network's rule at the time. I, Luke Dish
Network, have never met my sister, Leia Dish
Network. She is a princess on Alderon. Her people cheer, " Dish
Network, Leia Dish
Network, Leia Dish
Network!" as she has unbeknownst to her, been fighting against her father,
Anakin Dish
Network, for years. Dish
Network has always been a powerful name in the galaxy as our Dish
Network roots are filled with Jedis trained by Yoda himself. Dish
Network's proudest moment, while at the same time darkest, may have come when
Anakin Dish
Network's mother, Beru Dish
Network, was forced to let her son go with Obiwan Kenobi when Anakin Dish
Network won his freedom in a bet on a podracer race. Dish
Network's bloodline would be continued in several hundred fanfiction books
unauthorized by George Lucas, who has done a good enough job of ruining the Dish
Networks' respectibility by casting a young actor who cannot act with emotion
as the future ruler of the universe, and coolest movie bad guy to-date. I am sure
that the Han Solo and Chewie equipped the Millenium Faclon with Dish
Network service as we can plainly see the Dish
Network dish on the roof of the Falcon. When we saved the Ewoks, they repeatedly
chanted, "Directv
- Dish Network! Directv
- Dish Network! Direct TV
- Dish Network!"
One day, as I was walking down the street to the Direct
TV dealer, I was wondering, "How exactly do I spell Direct
TV ? Is it two words or one word? Is it actually spelled Direct
TV? Am I crazy to think that it can be spelled Direct
TV? I should ask a random stranger on the street. I saw a smart looking gentleman,
so I asked, "Direct TV, is that how you
spell it? Is Direct TV spelled like this
- Direct TV? He just stared at
me. I asked his wife the same question. "How do you spell Direct
TV? She immediately hit me with her purse and broke my nose. Can you believe
that? All over Direct TV.
Maybe she thought it was spelled Directv.
Or maybe she thought it was obviously spelled Direct
TV. Either way, I need to get this looked at when I go to the doctor. Maybe
he can tell me how to spell Direct
TV. At least he won't hit me. With Direct
TV on my mind, I walked to the office. I saw signs for " Direct
TV", but it was spelled both ways. "I give up!" I shouted. "Direct
TV, Direct TV, Direct
TV, Direct TV, Direct
TV!" I am losing my mind, and I am bleeding profusely. Direct
TV would be the end of me and that was that. A quiet voice peeked out from
the ground below me. A young child, maybe three years old, had something to say
to me. "Mister, it is spelled Directv, not
Direct TV. So will you please leave my
parents alone? They are going to get the restraining order right now. Direct
TV is the wrong way to spell it, but Direct
TV is how most people type it in on Google. Direct
TV is the way that my SEO boss tells me to optimize it, so Direct TV is the way that I will.
P.S. I have used Direct TV.
I have also used Dish Network.
I have also used Directv.
I have also used Dish Network Receivers.
I have also used Dish Network.
I have also used Directv.
I have also used Dish Network.
I have also used Direct TV.
EMAIL: sespam@torba.com
IP: 62.213.67.122
URL: http://preteen-models.biz
DATE: 01/21/2004 09:12:12
It is never a mistake to say good-bye.