Get notifications of new releases from the Reason-Rupe Poll.

80% of Americans Would Consider Voting for a 3rd Party/Independent Presidential Candidate

The recent Reason-Rupe poll finds that 80% of Americans say they would or might consider voting for an Independent or third-party presidential candidate in the 2012 election. Specifically, 60% said they would consider voting for an independent or third-party candidate, 20% said they might consider, 17% said they would not consider, and 3% said they did not know whether they would consider voting for an Independent or third-party presidential candidate.

To be clear, considering and voting are two separate things. Nevertheless, the high percentage tells us something about the current political climate. It means that individuals are willing to at least consider candidates who do not necessarily fit the cookie-cutter molds of Democrats and Republicans and suggests that the electorate is receptive to unconventional candidates.

Across partisan identification, 89% of Independents (including partisan leaners), 86% of Republicans, and 71% of Democrats said they would or might consider candidates outside of the two major political parties.

Note: Partisan identification is based on Q42 in the questionnaire. Independents include both Democratic and Republican leaners as well as pure independents.

Beyond receptiveness to unconventional partisan candidates, Americans report having little trust in the two major political parties. When asked which party they trust to govern more responsibly, the leading answer was “neither” at 35%, followed by Democrats at 31%, and Republicans at 23%.

These answers varied by political views. 83% of pure independents (non-leaners), 35% of non-Tea Party Republicans, 30% of Tea Party supporters, and 25% of Democrats answered that “neither” party could be trusted to govern responsibly. Taking into consideration margin of error, Tea Party supporters and non-Tea Party Republicans are statistically the same and Democrats are only somewhat less likely to state “neither”. This reveals that there is considerable discontent toward the major political parties even among members of both parties. 

Note: Tea Party supporters reported they were “very favorable” to the Tea Party movement. Republicans (not Tea Party) self-identified as Republican and are not Tea Party supporters. Independents only include Independents who did not lean Republican or Democratic. Democrats self-identified as such.

Democrats appear to be more favorable toward the Democratic Party than are Republicans toward the Republican Party with 66% of Democrats trusting the Democratic Party to govern most responsibly. In contrast, 46% of Tea Partiers, and 55% of non-Tea Party Republicans trust the Republican Party to govern most responsibly.

Trust in the two primary political parties remained fairly constant across most demographics. However distrust in the parties does change across income and education. The groups least trusting of the two dominant parties include households making $50,000-$99,999 a year (39%/40%) and high school and college graduates (37%/40%).

Those making less than $25,000 a year and those making over $200,000 a year were least likely to choose “neither” and thus more trusting of one of the dominant parties. Those making less than $25,000 a year were most likely to say the Democratic Party (40%) and 17% said the Republican Party. Of those making over $200,000 a year the group was split between trusting Democrats and Republicans, with 33% choosing Republicans and 28% choosing Democrats. Those without a high school degree and those with a post-graduate degree were also more trusting of one of the political parties. Of high school graduates, 49% chose Democrats and 12% chose Republicans. Of those with post-graduate degrees 38% chose Democrats and 22% choose Republicans.

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  • Monk||


    No one comments in this part of the world.
    I win.

  • ||

    Having only two parties is the condition that causes polarization - making it difficult for the elected to voice in opposition to their own party. Now, I don't believe in term limits on an individual per se. But think about this: Somehow, in a way I have not diligently explored yet, the limitation on an office is not on the person but on the party. That is, a 2-term limit placed upon an office held by a Republican simply executed means that a Republican cannot hold that office for the next term. Would a Democrat immediately hold de facto this office? There would immediately be a vacuum wherein another party, either currently established or new, would have to fill. I think this would bring balance. Unfortunately, under current law & perhaps constitionally, this might not be feasible. However, laws can be changed. While right or left of center might continue to be applicable, there might also be a greater likelihood for at least a triangle of primary colors. Or four, or five, etc. I would, of course, not want to see 80-some-odd parties as can occur (take a look at Israel), but I do believe party "sides" would give way to sides of reason.

  • ||

    Sounds like a good idea on the surface, but it's roadmap to corruption worse than what we allready have. If said outgoing party has no repercussions in their actions they will do as they please. I believe in outlawing parties to begin with. People should stand on their own morals and issues and not compromise for party affiliation.

  • coachs handbags||

    I LOVE: .
    Take a look!!! come on

  • Buy Cheap Franklin & Marshall ||

    This season, Buy Cheap Franklin & Marshall Marshall bring a host of new looks in casual collegiate tees. Vivid dyes, great color combinations and no shortage of that distressed look that's so popular these days, this design label no doubt has the winning formula. We like the gold graphics on the deep blue tees.

  • John||

    I think a third party could emerge if structured properly.

  • sam||

    Your post is really good
    White spots on skin Stomach gas

  • sam||

    Your post is really good .
    Home remedies for cough Ear wax removal

  • sam||

    Your post is really good .
    Home remedies for cough Ear wax removal

  • sam||

    Your post is really good .
    Home remedies for cough Ear wax removal

  • Abercrombie deutschland ||

    Many thanks finding the time to discuss this, I am strongly concerning this and love learning more about this topic. If at all possible, as you gain expertise, can you mind updating your site with extra information? It is extremely great for me..