How Much Will Legal Pot Cost in Washington?

Washington State Liquor Control BoardWashington State Liquor Control BoardWhen I interviewed UCLA drug policy expert Mark Kleiman about marijuana legalization in Washington a couple of months ago, he worried that the state-licensed stores will have trouble competing with black-market dealers and medical marijuana dispensaries. He called the projected price advantage for those alternative sources "a big problem," adding, "The legal market is going to have a hard time competing with the illegal market, but a particularly hard time competing with the untaxed, unregulated sort-of-legal market." Kleiman, whose consulting firm, BOTEC, was hired to advise Washington's marijuana regulators, now says he is more optimistic, partly because of the Justice Department's August 29 memo suggesting that federal prosecutors will refrain from interfering with legalization as long as regulations are strict enough, which Deputy Attorney General James Cole issued a few days after I talked to Kleiman. "I think the DoJ announcement makes a big difference," Kleiman says in an email message. "Of course things could change. But if they don't, we're going to see prices drop like stone."

Kleiman adds that BOTEC's June 28 projections suggesting that marijuana in state-licensed stores will cost two to three times what it costs in the black market were based on the assumption that legal pot would be grown indoors, which imposes additional regulatory and logistical burdens. But the Washington State Liquor Control Board later decided, perhaps partly in response to BOTEC's projections, to allow outdoor growing as well. "Marijuana as a dirt-farmed licit product will be dirt-cheap," Kleiman says. 

Commenting on my recent Forbes column about marijuana taxes, Russ Belville, a longtime marijuana activist and writer, notes that BOTEC's projections also depend on assumptions about markups:

Those BOTEC analyses of $2 and $3 / gram production costs also included 100% markups at all three levels. What retailer is going to survive selling $482 ounces when, as noted, Seattle prices are currently less than half that? If production costs can't decrease, markup must decrease.

When BOTEC plugged in a reasonable markup found at a liquor store (31%) or other equivalent industries, the retail price of marijuana came down to something more like the current retail prices.

What about the liquor control board's goal of capturing just 25 percent of marijuana sales, which reinforces the impression that the black and gray markets will not only persist but dominate? Kleiman sees that goal as reasonable:

The I-502 system will have to compete with the untaxed and unregulated medical system as well as the illegal system. Under those circumstances, and given the start-up issues, capturing a quarter of the market initially seems like a prudent target. If the medical system is reined in, and if local law enforcement does its bit in shutting down illegal production, I'd expect a 90% market share for the I-502 stores within a couple of years. 

I hope Kleiman and Belville are right that legal pot will not end up costing more than black-market pot, which strikes me as a perverse result suggesting something has gone terribly wrong with regulation and taxation. As Kleiman says on his blog, "legal cannabis will naturally be much, much cheaper than illegal cannabis." Making it more expensive therefore requires a real effort by government to screw thing up. But can anyone confidently predict that won't happen?

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  • Jquip||

    With the State putting a price floor in, it seems more likely that the price of street weed will skyrocket. There will still be a risk discount involved; but current potheads will be able to use their existing dealers regardless. Bonus, no concerns about being on a State list of pot smokers to get late night compliance visits from the Swat team.

    The corollary is that the bull run on street weed will increase importation into the State. And so it makes a great DEA honeypot. Should be fun and dead puppies for everyone.

  • Rich||

    "legal cannabis will naturally be much, much cheaper than illegal cannabis." Making it more expensive therefore requires a real effort by government to screw thing up.

    Well, to be fair, we're talking so-called "legal" here.

  • Swiss Servator, Zurichmania!||

    This why the decriminalization should be first goal and just let the market sort the situation out - the smothering embrace of the State in the name of "legalization" just means taxes, regulations, compliance costs, lawyers, insurance, bonds, licenses, etc.

  • Rich||

    Everyone wants a piece of the brownie.

  • The Late P Brooks||

    the Justice Department's August 29 memo suggesting that federal prosecutors will refrain from interfering with legalization as long as regulations are strict enough, which Deputy Attorney General James Cole issued a few days after I talked to Kleiman. "I think the DoJ announcement makes a big difference," Kleiman says in an email message.

    Good luck with that.

    Sucker.

  • libertard||

    I will be impressed if too many people are willing to take the substantial risks involved in producing medicinal grade marijuana and selling it on the black market in Washington. The profits are already going to be enormous with legalization, and for many people (who can afford it, and its still cheaper than getting drunk) once you have a taste of the medical stuff you aren't going to be smoking shitty weed grown in some dude's basement anymore.

  • verlighsoncno1975||

    Hello to all, how is the whole thing, I think every one is getting more from this site, and your views are pleasant in support of new visitors.

    http://farrdesign.com/jerseys/?id=536

GET REASON MAGAZINE

Get Reason's print or digital edition before it’s posted online

  • Video Game Nation: How gaming is making America freer – and more fun.
  • Matt Welch: How the left turned against free speech.
  • Nothing Left to Cut? Congress can’t live within their means.
  • And much more.

SUBSCRIBE

advertisement