Raw Milk Provider in the Dock in Wisconsin: Who Decides What You Can Eat?

The Fractured Paradigm blog reports on a forthcoming "food liberty" case involving sale of unapproved dairy products out of Wisconsin, where dairy is a very big deal indeed:

Raw milk drinkers are outraged that Wisconsin DATCP [Department of Agricultural Trade and Consumer Protection ] is bringing criminal charges against a farmer who serves a private buying club. Do citizens have a right to contract with a producer and grow food to their own standards? .....

Cream DropPhoto credit: Kyle May / Foter.com / CC BY

Food rights activists from around North America will meet at the Sauk County Courthouse in this tiny town on May 20 to support Wisconsin dairy farmer Vernon Hershberger and food sovereignty. Hershberger, whose trial begins that day, is charged with four criminal misdemeanors that could land this husband and father in county jail for up to 30 months with fines of over $10,000…

DATCP has charged Hershberger with, among other things, operating a retail food establishment without a license. Hershberger repeatedly rejects this, citing that he provides foods only to paid members in a private buying club and is not subject to state food regulations.

Hershberger says:

There is more at stake here than just a farmer and his few customers — this is about the fundamental right of farmers and consumers to engage in peaceful, private, mutually consenting agreements for food, without additional oversight.

......Hershberger, and other farmers around the country, are facing state or federal charges against them for providing fresh foods to wanting individuals. In recent months the FDA has conducted several long undercover sting operations and raids against peaceful farmers and buying clubs....

Vernon has faced a lot of pre-hearings and postponements already. Legal concerns are mounting. Printable flyers and an account from his May 7th hearing appear here.

I was talking to a reporter from a big national magazine about the Pauls just yesterday and I was asked why "raw milk" is such a big deal to the Pauls and many of their fans. Well, you know, it's hard to explain--some people just are regrettably lacking that bureacratic-managerial outlook on life that says, well, pasteurization and legal restaurant inspectations certainly are conducive to greater public health and are very scientific and rational and thus what sane person could argue with enforcing rules regarding them with men with guns who have the ultimate power to kill you if you decide at any point that you don't want to cooperate and should be able to manage your own life your own way and make trades with willing customers.

Some people just believe you should have more control over your life than that. Who knows why, it's just the wild attitude that some people have.

Reason on raw milk.

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  • sarcasmic||

    How can society function without everyone asking permission and taking orders?!?
    The alternative is chaos!

  • WTF||

    "Whe Decides What You Can Eat?

    Top. Men.

  • WTF||

    Who Decides, even.

  • Scarecrow Repair||

    Top. Ra. Men.

  • ||

    this is about the fundamental right of farmers and consumers to engage in peaceful, private, mutually consenting agreements for food, without additional oversight

    I thought it was already pretty clearly established that neither farmer nor consumers nor anyone else has the right to engage in peaceful private transactions without oversight. Silly cheeseheads!

  • Pro Libertate||

    I just drove by a raw milk provider out in the country a bit from my house. I was wondering how that was regulated.

  • anarch||

    In some places it's legal to sell it "at the farm gate."

    In some places you can buy a share of the cow, and then it's the (partial) cow rather than the milk that is sold.

  • Pro Libertate||

    Must be something like that. Since they make cheese from raw milk in Europe, I suppose the countryside is littered with corpses and that the living envy the dead?

  • Raston Bot||

    I don't know about envy but if the eurail taught me anything, the living certainly smell like the dead.

  • Brett L||

    I see it on Craigslist near me marketed "not for internal use". Apparently, it is legal to sell as a soap ingredient.

  • EDG reppin' LBC||

    I was talking to a reporter from a big national magazine about the Pauls just yesterday and I was asked why "raw mill" is such a big deal to the Pauls and many of their fans. Well, you know, it's hard to explain--some people just are regrettably lacking that bureacratic-managerial outlook on life that says, well, pasteurization and legal restaurant inspectations certainly are conducive to greater public health and are very scientific and rational and thus what sane person could argue with enforcing rules regarding them with men with guns who have the ultimate power to kill you if you decide at any point that you don't want to cooperate and should be able to manage your own life your own way and make trades with willing customers.

    That paragraph is a hot mess.

  • johnl||

    93 words in second sentence.

  • ||

    Watch yourself Doherty, Lucy got fired for far less.

    Although not knowing who Elie Wiesel is was pretty amazing.

  • EDG reppin' LBC||

    My guess is that this farmer sells his milk directly to customers, so the price is fairly negotiated between the counter-parties. This, of course, has pissed off the Wisconsin Milk Marketing Board, which has a vested interest in using monopoly control to keep milk prices artificially high. So the directors of the WMMB call their colleagues at the Wisconsin DATCP and say, "Squash him."

    Using the force of government to obtain economic rent.

  • WomSom||

    Sometimes man you jsut have to roll with it dude.

    www.Proxy-Anon.tk

  • BiMonSciFiCon||

    Walker has done some nice things but this is embarrassing. I don't know how much control he has over the DATCP but if he has any at all, he should be ashamed that they're bringing this suit.

  • Adam.||

    Wisconsin DATCP complaint form

    I plan on submitting a complaint against the DATCP for being total assholes. A private transaction between willing participants is not in your purview fuckers.

GET REASON MAGAZINE

Get Reason's print or digital edition before it’s posted online

  • Video Game Nation: How gaming is making America freer – and more fun.
  • Matt Welch: How the left turned against free speech.
  • Nothing Left to Cut? Congress can’t live within their means.
  • And much more.

SUBSCRIBE

advertisement