The IRS Abuse Scandal Keeps Growing

An audit of the agency’s behavior unearths disturbing new information.

Reading the highly critical report by the Internal Revenue Service’s auditor, you get the sense that rogue, lower-level agents ran amok, writing up watch lists, targeting conservative agencies, and stalling their applications for tax-exempt status.

At least IRS management has painted a picture of misguided underlings who acted “inappropriately,” finally offering a mea culpa a couple years after claims that Tea Party groups being hung up, even harassed, by tax agents began filtering in.

Lois Lerner, director of the IRS’ exempt organizations unit, apologized a week ago for front-line employees who inappropriately flagged for further review organizations with the descriptors, “tea party” or “patriot.”

“We had a shortcut in the process. It wasn’t appropriate.  We learned about it and we fixed it,” Lerner said, emphatically denying that the segregation of applications and the lengthy delays in processing them merely based on conservative-sounding names had absolutely nothing to do with partisan politics.

But a report released late Tuesday by the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration, the independent overseer of the IRS, points to lax management and at least ignorance of federal code governing tax-exemption review. And while TIGTA may not employ the term “targeted” in its scathing review, the auditor blasts the IRS for singling out conservative groups, asking them a host of unnecessary questions and, in many cases, grinding the application process to a halt.

More than anything, the IRS’ “inappropriate” measures threaten public confidence, the report notes.

“The mission of the IRS is to provide America’s taxpayers top quality service by helping them understand and meet their tax responsibilities and by applying the tax law with integrity and fairness to all.  According to IRS Policy Statement 1-1, IRS employees accomplish this mission by being impartial and handling tax matters in a manner that will promote public confidence,” the audit states.

“However, the criteria developed by the (IRS) Determinations Unit gives the appearance that the IRS is not impartial in conducting its mission.  The criteria focused narrowly on the names and policy positions of organizations instead of tax-exempt laws and Treasury Regulations.”

BOLO List

The audit depicts agents in 2010, earlier than IRS brass previously had stated, pulling out 501(c)(4) applications with “Tea Party, Patriots, or 9/12 in the organizations name,” as well as “political-sounding names.” In May 2010, the Determinations Unit began developing a spreadsheet that would become known as the “Be On the Look Out” list, according to the audit. By August, the unit began distributing the first formal BOLO list.

A 501(c)(4) is designated for the promotion of social welfare and cannot include direct or indirect participation or intervention in political campaigns on behalf of, or in opposition to, any candidate for public office.

“However, a section 501(c)(4) social welfare organization may engage in some political activities, so long as that is not its primary activity. However, any expenditure it makes for political activities may be subject to tax under section 527(f),” according to the IRS.

It is the IRS’ tax-exempt division’s job to sort all of that out.

The “look out” criteria were expanded over time, including:

  • Issues include government spending, government debt or taxes.

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  • West Texas||

    The problem isn't whether a bunch of rogue agents or partisan hacks played favorites. The problem is with the premise of income tax itself because there is no such thing as "privacy" and therefore EVERYTHING is taxable unless or until our benevolent tax collectors declare that it's not.

    It's not that they abused their power, it's that they have that power in the first place.

  • JimmyJohn||

    Agreed! Absolute power corrupts absolutely.

  • ron650||

    Start working at home with Google! It's by-far the best job Ive had. Last Wednesday I got a brand new BMW since getting a check for $6474 this - 4 weeks past. I began this 8-months ago and immediately was bringin home at least $77 per hour. I work through this link, www.Mojo50.com

  • sam the man||

    This can't be true, Cenk Uygur on the Young Turks told me this was not that big of a deal!

  • darkflame||

    I went and watched the Young Turks video just cause of your comment. Excuse me while I go throw up now

  • Killazontherun||

    They were just this close to saving us from the onslaught of Cher and the Kardashians. Some how, they knew.

  • sam the man||

    The Armenian Genocide?

  • ||

    I remember when he said that Obamacare was going to reduce healthcare costs by limiting health insurance profits. I'm not holding my breath waiting for a retraction from that stupid jackass.

  • sam the man||

    he also propagated the whole weinergate denial thing for two weeks, then when weiner admitted he had a replacement host.

  • Fist of Etiquette||

    It's interesting that the Benghazi scandal and the AP wiretap scandals both have to deal with, at least in part, free speech issues, however it is singularly the wiretaps that got journalists to start looking at all three administration scandals this past week. It hit home for the news media and brought the other two in.

    But I think the IRS scandal is going to be the one that resonates most with people in general. While the targeting seems to be advocacy groups, which most people don't pay attention to, the IRS is a feared and hated organization that everyone has to deal with at least once a year. To see it used so openly as a club to beat political opponents with, most will recognize as truly disgusting and pretty frightening. It's third world dictatorship thuggery crap.

  • ||

    The IRS is bad, I find the AP scandal to be most offensive. The 4th amendment may as well not even exist.

  • KPres||

    I think you're a little naive about the IRS. 47% pays no income tax, meaning they're almost certainly getting a return. They fill out a 1040EZ and the IRS sends them a check. They love it!

  • Concerned Citizen||

    Return, refund, what's the difference?

  • Irish||

    47% pays no income tax, meaning they're almost certainly getting a return. They fill out a 1040EZ and the IRS sends them a check. They love it!

    I'm willing to bet that a large percentage of that 47% that pays no income tax also doesn't vote. Wealthier people are much more likely to vote.

    It therefore doesn't really matter if 47% of people like the IRS. The vast majority of people who pay attention to politics and choose to vote despise it. Probably 65-70% of actual voters can't stand the IRS.

  • Peej||

    I think the outcome of the last election is pretty strong evidence that you're belief is no longer correct.

  • Peej||

    Ugh.... grammar snob makes you're your error.

  • Finrod||

    Fraudulent votes/voters don't care about the IRS.

  • Boisfeuras||

    I guess it's nice that the media are now at least paying lip-service to their purported responsibilities, but it makes me despise them even more. The only reason any of this is getting any coverage is because of the AP scandal, which directly affected them. How many other outrages are still unknown because of our derelict press corps?

  • JimmyJohn||

    TAX COURT is the only branch of the law wherein you are GUILTY UNTIL PROVEN INNOCENT. It would seem with that amount of power that the IRS should be held to a commensurate level of discretion. We as Americans are letting a bunch of hacks wield a scalpel.

  • Intn'l House of Badass||

    You've obviously never been to family court.

  • ||

    Yes, imagine if the IRS could take your kids for evading taxes.

  • ||

    Or to criminal court....

  • kingice||

    Maybe if you had the money that had been stolen from you in tax court, you could afford a decent attorney for criminal court or family court.

  • Enjoy Every Sandwich||

    The Obama answer to all of these scandals is "Hey, we're not evil; we're just incompetent! We don't know what goes on in the executive branch departments. Oh well!"

    And I'm supposed to be happy with that answer, to indeed be grateful. And then drop the subject.

    I'm certainly never supposed to entertain the notion that perhaps incompetent people shouldn't be trusted with important jobs. Why, that would be extremist!

  • Archduke Pantsfan||

    "It's the other team that's evil"

  • Mizchief||

    Sounds like an apt slogan for the democrats: "We may be stupid but at least we're not evil like the republicans!"

  • A Serious Man||

    "Don't blame me I voted for Kodos!"

  • ΘJΘʃ de águila||

    Obama: "I compiled my enemies list so I could go after the bad guys."

  • Definately Not Ron Swanson||

    I start my job at the IRS this Monday . . . on the plus side, it looks like there'll be ample opportunity for rapid advancement!

  • kingice||

    Well listen Ron,why don't you start Monday by inserting a worm virus into their data banks and wipe out everybodys balances and contact data.Just a thought

  • Archduke Pantsfan||

    Who’s willing to fight for Stockton?” asked Mayor Anthony Silva.
    After his almost hour-long speech, Silva pulled out armor with a helmet and mace while asking the crowd to go to war for the broke and crime-ridden city.
  • Mike M.||

    +1 plate mail.

  • A Serious Man||

    Aye, stay, and you'll be bankrupt. Run, and your credit will live, at least for a while. And tell me, as you lay dying on your bed years from now would you be willing to trade all of it, from this day to that, for one chance to tell the creditors that they may liquidate our assets, but they may never take our Stockton?!

  • VG Zaytsev||

    “Who’s willing to fight for Stockton?"

    No one.

  • ||

    Stockton /=/ Stockton's government.

  • Mike M.||

    Ken Shultz nailed it dead on in the earlier thread: government bureaucrats do absolutely nothing unless they're ordered to do it by the person above them on the org chart. The idea that someone in the Cincinnati field office did this on their own initiative is utterly laughable.

  • Irish||

    Yeah, the only thing IRS workers are less capable of than competence is initiative.

  • Hyperion||

    The mission of the IRS is to provide America’s taxpayers top quality service a good screwing over by helping them understand and meet their tax responsibilities bend over and take it.

    Had to fix that, it was such a pathetically lame statement.

  • Ted S.||

    If this is the weekend links thread, how about

    Romania's entry to the 2013 Eurovision Song Contest

  • Archduke Pantsfan||

    needz moar epic sax

  • Ted S.||

  • Ted S.||

    And since I accidentally forgot to close the a tag in the last comment, here's the fun entry from last year, a bunch of Russian grannies singing a song called Party for Everybody.

  • kingice||

    How about Bigger sax

  • Drave Robber||

    The song that almost* became Estonia's entry.

    * well, it finished third but was a local sensation over two countries for a week or so :)

    Meiecundimees üks Korsakov läks eile Lätti - My buddy some Korsakov went to Latvia

    As far as I've heard (as nobody is able to tell the lyrics anyway) it's about some truck driver who went to Latvia and had all his bones broken, and how life is generally unfair and so on.

  • Ted S.||

    One of my Finnish friends says that Estonian (about the most closely related language to him) sounds like people trying to speak Finnish who are extremely constipated. :-)

  • Ted S.||

    Er, closest to Finnish.

    Unfortunately, I don't have access to Eurovision live, but from the chat threads I'm reading, the highlights seem to be the Romanian entry above; Bonnie Tyler looking drunk; and the Belgian entry's eyebrows.

  • Drave Robber||

    Estonian and Finnish aren't related closely enough to be mutually intelligible but are similar enough to embarrass someone who thinks they can speak the other language. One Estonian guy told me a story of a man showing off his new house to his Finnish friends - ruumis means room in Estonian but corpse in Finnish - "...and we've also got three stiffs upstairs!".

  • Sevo||

    Ted,
    I've heard Northern Germans claim those in the south don't have a language, they have a throat disease. And I'd rate that about the same as northern US presumptions of southerners; NWS.

  • Eduard van Haalen||

    If the Romanian doesn't want to provoke vampire jokes, he shouldn't dress in that Count Dracula get-up.

  • LTC(ret) John||

    At Talill, Iraq, the Romanians had the security force in 2008 - they had the good humor to name their encampment "Camp Dracula".

  • ||

    People from that region that I've met, mostly Albanians, Bosniaks and Romanians, have consistently had the best and darkest sense of humor.

  • mad libertarian guy||

    If Romania is to enter something, the least they can do is to enter something awesome.

  • IceTrey||

    How come hardly anyone is talking about Sarah Ingram. She was the one who was actually in charge of the tax exempt unit when this was going on. Guess what she does now, she's the head of the Obamacare office!

    http://abcnews.go.com/blogs/po.....re-office/

  • LTC(ret) John||

    So, a merit promotion then?

  • PapayaSF||

    I suspect she's talking to a lawyer and not getting a lot of sleep these days....

  • Finrod||

    I hope she's not getting a lot of sleep these days. Unfortunately with Eric Holder as Attorney General, I doubt she has anything to worry about.

  • CE||

    Sort of like how the low level underlings at Abu Grab decided to abuse the Iraqi prisoners, with no knowledge of or commands from their superiors?

  • Peej||

    Look, a squirrel!

  • Paul.||

    Seattle Times claims the IRS scandal is all just a big misunderstanding.

    IRS office was perplexed, inundated with tax-exempt applications.

  • PapayaSF||

    "We were so overwhelmed with applications that we decided to generate lots of extra paperwork for ourselves and everyone: asking for all 'indirect communications' with politicians, contents of prayers, promises to never protest Planned Parenthood, that sort of thing. We had to make sure they wouldn't do something like endorse candidates. It would have been much simpler if these Tea Party groups had started as campaign organizations, like Obama for America. It was quite easy to turn them into a 501(c)(4)...."

  • paranoid android||

    The article boils down to, "There's talk of a scandal at the IRS, but we asked some guys at the IRS and they said it's totally cool and there's nothing to see here."

    Journalism!

  • Peej||

    You know, if I were as incompetent at my job as some of these lefty commentators are claiming the "low level" employees were, I would be out of work.

    There need to be "low level" employees fired, or "high level" employees in jail, or preferably both.

  • Bruce Majors||

    Now we know why Obama was tap dancing all week.

    Obama is the secret love child of Sammy Davis Jr and Richard Nixon.

    That's why the birth certificate is hidden.

  • PapayaSF||

    +1

  • AD-RtR/OS!||

    "...TIGTA has made nine recommendations to fix its problems..."

    I don't suppose that any of those recommendation included the hanging from a lamppost of any of the offending IRS employees?

  • John||

    Ken Shultz is right on the other thread. My experience of over 15 years working in government is that the beaucracy is remarkably non political. People just don't give their political views on a regular basis. Maybe the IRS is different. But I doubt it. I find it extremely unlikely that a bunch of low level employees would have on their own commited a crime and risked their jobs and careers to do this. Moreover, even if they did, they wouldn't just have started doing it in 2010. They would have been doing it all along. And it wouldn't have just been Tea Party groups but all conservative groups.

    It is the targeted nature and the timing of this that makes it so suspicous. Anything is possible. But the idea that some low level employees at teh IRS would, after years of otherwise non political service, decide on their own accord, to target the Tea Party seems extremely unlikely.

  • para_dimz||

    I see what I think is the root cause. Taxation of proceeds to non-profits used for political advocacy. Why are we tolerating a new Stamp Act? That is what this tax policy does. It uses taxation as a govenor to throttle speech. Had we object to and prevented this type of taxation to begin with this whole episode wouldn't be happening. Therefore, the way to prevent a future event of the nature lays plainly before us.

GET REASON MAGAZINE

Get Reason's print or digital edition before it’s posted online

  • Video Game Nation: How gaming is making America freer – and more fun.
  • Matt Welch: How the left turned against free speech.
  • Nothing Left to Cut? Congress can’t live within their means.
  • And much more.

SUBSCRIBE

advertisement