How Big Government Makes Life Worse

Another day, another story of government waste, fraud, or abuse.

Occupy Wall Street protesters are reminiscent of writer R. Emmett Tyrrell’s criticism of radical feminists: They don’t know what they want, but they want it very badly. On May Day, the protesters tied up the streets of Oakland, San Francisco, and elsewhere. They are mad as hell and they are not going to take it any more, although it remains unclear what, specifically, they are angry about.

I am not particularly annoyed by the overall protests. It’s an American tradition to take to the streets. These folks need an economic lesson at the very least, and none of us should tolerate violence or destruction. But many of the Occupiers appear more open to ideas than our state legislators, who continually express similar ill-defined anti-corporate sentiments. To those who run California’s grotesquely large and bumbling state government, the problem always is the same: the private sector, a good bit of which is fleeing to other states. 

A new ad on a major Bay Area radio station is recruiting high-tech employees for positions in Detroit. Talk about insults. San Francisco is one of the most beautiful cities in the world, and wretched, cold Detroit is going to seed, literally. Michiganders talk about rural sprawl rather than urban sprawl—so many neighborhoods have been abandoned and bulldozed that farms are sprouting within the city limits. But despite the fantasies of Gov. Jerry Brown and his fellow Democrats, people will indeed leave this magnificent place for less-desirable locales to pursue better economic opportunities.

Not everyone lives on a trust fund or works for, or is retired from, the government, which, these days, is more lucrative than having such a fund. A recent San Francisco Chronicle column explained, “When it comes to city worker payouts, forget the old $100,000 club or even the $250,000 club—the new elite among San Francisco's civic workforce are those who got more than $500,000 in pay last year.” Apparently, it’s impossible to exaggerate how wasteful California governments have become.

I heard that radio ad after returning from Austin, Texas, where the locals talk about the sea of Californians moving to their pro-growth (but attractive, friendly, and hip) locale. California officials remain in denial. They promote bills that shift more money from the private economy to the state, which promptly squanders it as quickly as possible. They mock Texas, which lures our most energetic workers and laughs all the way to the state treasury.

As an example of misplaced priorities, California’s Democratic legislators say they have no time to deal with the pension crisis, busy as they are creating new rules, regulations, and programs. Their big idea was to create a new mini-Social Security system. In their view, the problem isn’t an unaffordable and unsustainable public system that lavishes huge payouts on union members, but a too-stingy private one. That’s almost too goofy to mock, given that the private system isn’t destroying public budgets. That proposal epitomizes the thinking in Sacramento.

There is nothing perfect in this world, so the private sector will always be afflicted with imperfections borne of the human condition. In the private world, we have to pay our own way—there is no mechanism to live off of the fruits of others, which upsets those who are frustrated that they cannot have everything they want as quickly as they want it

All great advancements in affluence have come from the private realm, although some government is necessary to provide the backdrop to all of this through the administration of a legal system and construction of infrastructure. We know the wretchedness found in government-dominated societies. Most of what American governments do these days strays far outside those boundaries, but I’ve sensed no area of our economic life that our state's leaders would not subject to government control.

Entrepreneurs take risks. They often fail, but they sometimes make great strides forward. Government employees go to jobs where they cannot be fired except in the most extreme circumstances. They regulate us and provide “services” few of us want. They retire at young ages with pensions that make them the envy of their neighbors. They consume an ever-larger share of the money earned by those who take risks and create growth. Then their unions lobby for more government. And our fellow citizens willingly vote for the politicians who perpetuate this system.

These lessons should be obvious in the world following the collapse of the Soviet Union. But they seem forgotten and not just in California. The unions protesting Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker’s reforms have been shockingly bold in their hard-left rhetoric and clenched-fist symbolism. Whereas the Occupy protesters are a straggly group of powerless young people and vagrants, the radicalization of the union movement is something that should cause worry.

Every day, we read the stories of malfunctioning government agencies, of government waste, fraud, and abuse. Journalist H.L. Mencken quipped that all government is evil and efforts to improve it therefore are a waste of time. Maybe he exaggerated, but there is little hope in reforming government—the only solution is cutting it back. Yet legislators believe in this magical thing called government. They provide new funds and create new agencies to solve problems.

Then out of nowhere a newspaper will expose how that agency really works, and everyone pretends to be shocked. For instance, the Sacramento Bee recently reported how the federal Department of Agriculture’s Wildlife Services really operates, which “has accidentally killed more than 50,000 animals since 2000 that were not problems, including federally protected golden and bald eagles; more than 1,100 dogs, including family pets."

The problem is not with one agency, but with the vast expansion of federal and state government, which takes our money and freedoms and leaves a path of destruction wherever it goes. Sure the Occupy protesters are annoying. But the real surprise is why the rest of us aren’t at least as angry as they are.

Steven Greenhut is vice president of journalism at the Franklin Center for Government and Public Integrity.

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  • sarcasmic||

    These lessons should be obvious in the world following the collapse of the Soviet Union.

    The only lesson from that was that they didn't have the right people in charge.

  • ||

    "It trys moar hardre!"

    /progressive zombie

  • Top Men||

    If only the Soviets had a few more of us...

  • purple_persuader||

    And spent too much on the military.

  • Social Security||

    Sarcasm?

  • ¿Ex Nihilo?||

    reported how the federal Department of Agriculture's Wildlife Services really operates, which "has accidentally killed more than 50,000 animals since 2000 that were not problems, including federally protected golden and bald eagles; more than 1,100 dogs, including family pets."

    Interesting, they had to kill them to protect them. And what is it with law enforcement and family pets?

  • Concerned Citizen||

    This article is bullshit. The MSM told me so. Before the Income Tax, life was nasty, brutish, and short. Also, no roads.

  • Social Security||

    Most lacked indoor plumbing too.

  • TingoZing||

    OK wow, now there is a dude that jsut totally knows whats going on man.

    www.Privacy-Dudes.tk

  • ||

    I was hoping to print this and put it on the desk of my colleague who handed me the Dept of Labor article (see morning links), but it's a bit short on hard data and a bit long on emotional appeals and anecdotes.

    Ah well.

  • Jordan||

    There's always unemployment statistics

  • Loki||

    more than 1,100 dogs, including family pets

    Well they can't just let the local pigs have all the fun.

  • CE||

    Here's how:

    They take half your income off the top in taxes (federal, state, local, excise, etc.)

    Everything you buy costs twice as much because everyone else if paying half their income in taxes too.

    Regulations make it twice as expensive as it should be to make anything.

    So basically we have one-eighth the prosperity we would have without government.

  • plu1959||

    And don't forget:

    The Feds have a monopoly on currency.

    The Feds maintain a positive rate of inflation, causing us to put our savings in ever riskier investments in the hope of keeping up with said inflation.

    In bad years, the Feds use our tax money to prop up the financial institutions that in good years make a mint of the risky investments we make to survive the Feds' inflation.

  • plu1959||

    "of" = "off"

  • Old Mexican||

    How Big Government Makes Life Worse


    But... but... Julia!

  • Mr. FIFY||

    Gotta admit, Barry's handlers pulled off a masterstroke with that insipid "Life of Julia" thing... though it does tip Team Blue's hand as to how they want to raise and control people cradle-to-grave.

  • jacob the barbarian||

    Shouldn't Stossel have written this article? It has that Libertarianism for Idiots feel.

  • plu1959||

    Hey, idiots need enlightenment, too!

  • joy||

    But despite the fantasies of Gov. Jerry Brown and his fellow Democrats, http://hqh1314.eklablog.com people will indeed leave this magnificent place for less-desirable locales to pursue better economic opportunities.

  • xenawp||

    I left California (the Monterey Peninsula) to move to Detroit many years ago and have never regretted it. So please stop with the Detroit diss. Yes, there are parts of Detroit that are as bad as Mogadishu,and it isn't pretty like California, but I prefer it here where life is hard, yes, but there is spirit and community and hard-scrabble people who actually know what hardship is like. I have a great quality of life in Detroit, and for the younger generation it is a great place for music, art and entrepreneurial spirit. New York is so over for such young people, and so is the Bay Area for that matter. Detroit is where it's at!

  • stout77||

    If we really wanted to test America's appetite for a welfare state, the best thing to do would be to raise taxes next year to the level that would be required to pay all our bills. For 2013 that amounts to a 32% increase according to CBO projections. It would be like a mirror of truth to the taxpaying saps who are not engaged in this fight.

    The next thing I would is take Joe Biden to South Atlanta and let him explain to the local residents that, if we had divided the stimulus by the bottom 25% of the populations and just written checks to them instead, they would each have received about $11,000. The last thing I would do is get some lemonade, sit back, and watch all the welfare statists get run out of D.C. on a rail.

    Call it truth in advertising - it would be like a nutrition label for the federal government.

  • Ace||

    My thoughts exactly, stout. Lets raise taxes to the point where all government costs are covered and then see how people feel about their precious government. It's easy to preach about the benefits of government when the costs aren't manifesting.

  • James Ryan||

    Stout77 - So, I take it you voted libertarian for the last 40 years.

    Joy - they are going leave just like all those people who don't live in NYC anymore (oh, wait, NYC is gaining population; so is SF - people are so stupid).

  • Ace||

    You should realize that the population growth has been slowing in NYC and in California. Nobody said anything in the article or in the comments about populations declining.

  • stout77||

    Are they attracting businesses or more welfare beneficiaries? Big difference.

  • vivian||

    nice post,thanks for your sharing, i am really very happy t view your post.chaussures lacoste homme i will pay attention for your post again.thanks

GET REASON MAGAZINE

Get Reason's print or digital edition before it’s posted online

  • Video Game Nation: How gaming is making America freer – and more fun.
  • Matt Welch: How the left turned against free speech.
  • Nothing Left to Cut? Congress can’t live within their means.
  • And much more.

SUBSCRIBE

advertisement