Should We Allow Performance Enhancing Drugs in Sports?

One argument in favor.

On January 15, Reason Senior Editor Radley Balko participated in a debate in New York City on the topic of performance-enhancing drugs in sports, sponsored by Intelligence Squared. Video text of his initial argument follow. Check this YouTube page for video of the other presentations, rebuttals, and Q&A.

On the train ride from D.C. this morning, we passed through Baltimore. It reminded me of one of my favorite authors, Baltimore native H.L. Mencken, who I think would’ve had a good laugh at the hypocrisy, the posturing, and the moral prudery associated with the steroid controversy. Eighty years ago, Mencken aptly summarized this debate when he wrote, quote:

“The urge to save humanity is almost always a false-face for the urge to rule it.”


Let me start by saying that I believe private sports organizations should be able to set their own rules, and that they should be free to discipline in any manner they see fit the players who break those rules. I don’t think Congress should forcibly allow performance enhancing substances in sports any more than I think Congress should prohibit them.

That said, we’re here today to debate what those rules ought to be.

So why exactly do people to ban some substances from professional sports?

If it’s about fairness and competition, I’m dubious. Take Rep. Tom Davis, one of the more camera-hungry politicians to demagogue this issue. After the 2000 census, Rep. Davis maneuvered to have his congressional district gerrymandered to include as many Republicans as possible, ensuring his continual reelection, and limiting the number of real options for his constituents. He ran the next year unopposed. Davis also snuck a provision into an unrelated piece of federal legislation preventing an apartment complex from going up in his district because, he said, he feared it would bring too many Democrats into his district.

This guy is cheating at democracy, and he’s lecturing baseball players about fairness.

It’s hard to believe the steroid panic is really about the safety of our athletes, either. My copanelist Dr. Fost I think has ably shown that the alleged side affects of anabolic steroids are overstated, and the negative side effects of HGH are negligible at best.

If we want to talk about health risks and professional sports, we might discuss the ballooning, unrelated-to-steroids weight of NFL linemen over the last 20 years, and the corresponding drop in life expectancy that’s come with it.

Or we might talk about the particularly hellish world of thoroughbred horseracing jockeys, who subject themselves to sweatboxes, diuretics and suppositories, and intentional eating disorders.

In fact, any world-class athlete subjects his body to stresses it wasn’t really designed to endure.

As we’ve seen with government bans on consensual activity—from alcohol to gambling to cocaine to prostitution—prohibitions not only don’t work, they make the activity in question more dangerous by pushing it underground.

So what about the children? As with just about every paternalistic policy dating back to alcohol prohibition, many a politician has iterated over the last few years that we need to ban performance enhancing drugs “for the children.”

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  • Barrack||

    Cool. ill check it out skeet skeet my G

  • My Nigga||

    Is DAT Da PRESIDENT!

  • bill cosby||

    hey hey hey its fat albert

  • me||

    yo yo yo my president is black

  • MR Prez, O Bomb IN debt||

    I am drunked and i dont give about u normals

  • MR Prez, O Bomb IN debt||

    I am drunked and i dont give about u normals

  • izzy jacobo||

    i would just like to say that i was only here on this website for an english assignment.

  • ckruger||

    yup. i was only on here for a 21st century tech assignment.... it wasnt fun. but good job....i guess

  • hmmm||

    Ha these guys are funny

  • trent||

    i like men

  • ||

    i wuz just on dis website on sumn fa skewl...

  • ||

    some1 message me bak dog

  • Rusty||

    this site sux!!!!!

  • Rusty||

    Thats Mama Luigi to you Mario!

  • jake barr||

    is this a reliable source and does this guy have experiance with this matter?

  • ipwnatcod||

    I luv cod

  • dany||

    gay

  • dany||

    gay ass bitch nigga

  • ||

    #Dany calling one on or somehting gay is not that nice even when your on the enternet.

  • Billy||

    Weaksauce english teacher is sexy though

  • Alexander||

    My english teacher is sexy

  • Gardener Shock Site||

    Wonderful article! I've gotten some great new insight about the subject :)

  • Gardener Shock Site||

    Wonderful article! I've gotten some great new insight about the subject :)

  • Nike Dunk Low||

    is good

  • ||

    nigga

  • ||

    i ;like mennn

  • ||

    justin davies

  • ||

    i liikkkeee meennnnn yummmmmyyyyyyy

  • happy is wierd||

    WOW happy get a ****

  • ||

    hey big boyzzz

  • ||

    i aint weird!!!!!!!!!!!! WTF U TALKING ABOUT BOY?????????

  • ||

    me i like my men big and hard

  • ||

    hey 69er wanna meet up man?

  • ||

    mmmmm i want 69er

  • ||

    69er is yummy like the sushi rolll

  • ||

    mmmmmm i can taste it right now!! big ass sushi roll in my mouth :):):):):):):):)

  • Asian||

    I LOVe sushi roll

  • ||

    smd asian!!!!

  • happy||

    I am using the bathroom

  • ||

    mee to

  • is gay||

    u are a wierdo

  • 69er+happy=gay marriage||

    my name is true:

  • ||

    meet me at the the mall big boyyy
    in china

  • ||

    ikr??/ we meant for eachother baby :)

  • liool||

    Gabi V.

  • ||

    spam

  • ||

    spam

  • ||

    spam

  • ||

    spam

  • ||

    spam

  • ||

    spam

  • happy||

    McSpam

  • ||

    MCSPAM MUFFIN

  • Comment faggots||

    who said this

  • Justin davies||

    Hey 69er

  • IM Awesome||

    your weird lol

  • IM Awesome||

    you really weird lol

  • IM Awesome||

    who watches this im only reading and watching becasue im in school this is boring lol jk

  • ugg sheepskin cuff||

    good

  • hi||

    hi ya

  • mbt shoes clearance||

    nice

  • thomas ||

    then what you happen if people at the age of 7 or 8 srat taking drugs for there favorite sport tell me what would happen come on man

  • lil dick||

    Muthaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa FUCKER!

  • lil dick||

    NIGGER !

  • carl||

    i eat booty

  • sac hermes 2012||

    we’re here today to debate what those rules ought to be.

  • Alrazaak.com||

    great keep it up i like your work

GET REASON MAGAZINE

Get Reason's print or digital edition before it’s posted online

  • Video Game Nation: How gaming is making America freer – and more fun.
  • Matt Welch: How the left turned against free speech.
  • Nothing Left to Cut? Congress can’t live within their means.
  • And much more.

SUBSCRIBE

advertisement