Today in Supreme Court History: February 14, 1845

2/14/1845: Justice Samuel Nelson takes judicial oath.

Justice Samuel Nelson

Comments

[Dan Schiavetta]

Reynolds v. Atlantic Coast Line R.R. Co., 336 U.S. 207 (decided February 14, 1949): failure to clear sugar cane plants from railbed (this was Alabama) which required brakeman to cross from caboose to seventh instead of to usual sixth car to give signal was not proximate cause of his falling to his death while crossing from sixth to seventh car

Dobson v. Comm’r of Internal Revenue, 321 U.S. 231 (decided February 14, 1944): “Not every gain growing out of a transaction concerning capital assets is allowed the benefits of the capital gains tax provision”. The Court is (or was) aware that people who live off of buying and selling stocks pay a lower tax rate than those of us who work for a living, and tends to construe capital gains narrowly. Here, income was from settlement of dispute over stock sale, not from sale of stock itself.

Maty v. Grasselli Chemical Co., 303 U.S. 197 (decided February 14, 1938): applying state law (New Jersey) as to statute of limitations in a diversity action, holds that plaintiff can add allegations of another job under same employer wherein was exposed to chemicals even after statute has run

Hollingsworth v. Virginia, 3 U.S. 378 (decided February 14, 1798): passage of Eleventh Amendment was valid despite not having been formally presented to the President (obvious to us now, but this was the first time the amendment process was used) and was retroactive (plaintiff, seeking repayment from Virginia, had handed off to an out-of-state plaintiff because Chisholm v. Georgia had made it clear that a state could be sued in federal court by an out-of-state individual but not necessarily by an in-state) (Chisholm had then been abrogated by the Eleventh Amendment)

South Carolina State Highway Dept. v. Barnwell Bros., 303 U.S. 177 (decided February 14, 1938): state restriction on weight of trucks (20,000 lbs.) and width (90 inches) does not unfairly burden interstate commerce, and Congress has not preempted the field

[SMP0328]

If Hollingsworth had come out differently, it would have also taken out the Bill of Rights as it was not presented to President Washington for his signature.

[JoeFromtheBronx]

Justice Nelson was President Tyler’s choice, a highly respected chief justice on the New York Supreme Court.

As associate justice, Nelson administered the oath to Chief Justice Salmon P. Chase took for presiding over the impeachment trial of Andrew Johnson

He served 27 years. He wrote a narrow conflict of laws opinion in Dred Scott v. Scott, but the Court as a whole wanted to fight bigger game. He dissented in the Prize Cases, involving the president’s power during the Civil War.

He died in Cooperstown. Not sure how much he liked baseball.

[A Japanese Student]

Stimulants Control Act Case (Second Petty Bench, decided February 14, 2003): First time the Supreme Court suppressed evidence; urine samples taken after arrest must be excluded when the officer did not present physical warrant during arrest, falsely wrote on the warrant that it was presented during arrest, created investigative reports again falsely declaring such, and lied under oath when called to the stand

Nabari City Assembly Censure Case (First Petty Bench, decided February 14, 2019): Defamation claim against city assembly for censure is justiciable; dismisses suit on the merits because courts must respect the assembly’s power to discipline its members

Theft, Attempted Theft Case (Third Petty Bench, decided February 14, 2022): Defendant tried to steal debit cards by visiting the victim’s home (while impersonating financial regulator), asking the victim to present the card for “verification”, and swapping the actual card with a fake one – but was caught before entering that home. Court upholds attempted theft conviction, rejecting argument that theft hasn’t been commenced yet