The Volokh Conspiracy
Mostly law professors | Sometimes contrarian | Often libertarian | Always independent
Guilty Plea in Pro-Abortion-Rights Firebombing Case
From a Dec. 1 Justice Department press release:
According to court documents, Hridindu Sankar Roychowdhury, 29, of Madison, pleaded guilty to attempting to cause damage by means of fire or an explosive. On Sunday, May 8, 2022, at approximately 6:06 a.m., law enforcement responded to an active fire at an office building located in Madison. Once inside the building, police observed a mason jar under a broken window; the jar was broken, and the lid and screw top were burned black. The police also saw a purple disposable lighter near the mason jar. On the opposite wall from the window, the police saw another mason jar with the lid on and a blue cloth tucked into the top; the cloth was singed. The jar was about half full of a clear fluid that smelled like an accelerant.
Outside of the building, someone spray painted on one wall, "If abortions aren't safe then you aren't either" and, on another wall, a large "A" with a circle around it and the number "1312." During the investigation, law enforcement collected DNA from the scene of the attack.
In March 2023, law enforcement identified Roychowdhury as a possible suspect. Local police officers observed Roychowdhury dispose of food in a public trash can; the officers recovered the leftover food and related items, and law enforcement collected DNA from the food. On March 17, law enforcement advised that a forensic biologist examined the DNA evidence recovered from the attack scene and compared it to the DNA collected from the food contents. The forensic biologist found the two samples matched and likely were the same individual.
In March, Roychowdhury travelled from Madison to Portland, Maine, and he purchased a one-way ticket from Boston to Guatemala City, departing March 28. Law enforcement arrested Roychowdhury at Boston Logan International Airport that day….
Assistant U.S. Attorney Elizabeth Altman for the Western District of Wisconsin and Trial Attorney Justin Sher of the National Security Division's Counterterrorism Section are prosecuting the case. Assistant U.S. Attorney Amanda Beck for the District of Massachusetts handled the defendant's appearance in Boston following his arrest.
According to the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel (Jessie Opoien), the target was "anti-abortion group Wisconsin Family Action's office." The attack took place six days after the publication of the leaked draft opinion in Dobbs. Thanks to InstaPundit for the pointer.
Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
What makes this case more interesting and noteworthy to Profs. Volokh and Reynolds than the Rudy Giuliani case, the John Eastman case, the Donald Trump case, the other John Eastman case, the other Rudy Giuliani case, the other Donald Trump cases, the low-grade insurrectionist cases, the George Santos case, the Mark Meadows case, etc.?
Carry on, clingers.
LOL, Meat.
Your Betters are watching, impatiently.
Carry on, Meat.
Open wider, clinger. You will get the same treatment as all of the other clingers at the hands of your betters. Culture wars have consequences, especially for the bitter, disaffected, conservative losers.
They are trying to maximize profits from your posts. Unknown to you until now, I have access to secret information about Volokh accounts showing that your comments add $0.02 value to ad revenue, per comment.
So keep on keeping on supporting the Volokh blog.
It is worth it, from the culture war winners' perspective, to publicize the cowardice, hypocrisy, bigotry, and partisanship of ostensible leaders of the failed conservative movement.
LOL. Figures Kirkland's too dull to realize he was the product and not the customer.
LOL
Can we return him for gross product defects?
Kirkland, attempting to firebomb a building is a wee bit more serious than challenging the accuracy of an election.
If you can't understand that -- GET HELP!!!!
Attempting to overthrow the government, you mean, and so of course you're wrong.
Hyperbole alert!
Yes yes, some people attempted to overthrow the government by occupying the most useless building in the country. If they occupied it, the military would have turned over the nuclear codes, the bureaucracy would do whatever they said, and everyone would act under their rule.
Riiiiiiiiiiiight.
Like the Reverend, I’m not seeing the significance of this. Per WIKI perps were identified in all eleven anti-abortion murders and many, if not most, of the hundreds of bombings and arsons at abortion clinics. Is this one case anything more than a feeble attempt at bothsides?
If a supposed toll of 11 people over 50 years means the prolife movement as a whole has been debunked and discredited than the proabortion movement is also discredited. I'm pretty sure theres been a lot more than 11 people (as in born people not unborn) over the past 50 years who have been killed due to proabortion sentiment. Mothers killing their already born babies. Doctors who killed born babies. Partners killing those who didn't want abortions etc etc. If you include unborn who had nervous systems equivalent to born people whom it would be illegal to kill it would probably reach into the millions if not higher.
As for arson theres been a lot of pro abortion arson, definitely more than a few isolated cases, especially in recent years as the proabortion lobby becomes more militant.
Interesting because the Biden Dept of Justice was leading the prosecution?? The most pro-abortion administration in the history of the United States actually charged and convicted a pro-abortion terrorist is news worthy.
Yup, a very man bites dog story.
Because they keep proving your unfounded assumptions completely wrong, yet you always take that as confirming your assumptions?
Trying to figure out why this was posted.
Disaffected, discarded clinger lathering his half-educated, gullible, obsolete, superstitious, bigoted right-wing followers.
And a partridge in a pear tree.
I find it funny people are outraged Volokh doesn't cover the exact same news the MSM does. If you want 24/7 anticonservative stories you are free to visit the portion of the internet news, which represent the lionshare of corporate media, that specialize in that type of content.
Not "people." Just one person with a serious inferiority complex.
(1) People trying being violent against speakers (here, Wisconsin Family Action). (2) The federal government prosecuting those people, and deterring such violence against speakers. (3) The federal government doing that even when the speakers are on the other side from the Administration politically.
All in all, an illustration of one way that free speech is protected -- as interesting in its own way as the more normal posts about a court protecting speech by striking down government action that restricts speech.
Doesn’t seem a departure from ordinary practice to me.
You are not the Volokh Conspiracy's target audience.
Arson is a heinous crime no matter who is the target. It is entirely appropriate for the DOJ to vigorously prosecute this offense.
As a tactical matter, those of us who support abortion rights should leave the firebombing to Eric Rudolph's side of the culture war.
I'm pro-life and I don't approve of firebombs either.
There's no excuse for it....
Now if they could only find the person who planted the "bombs" on Jan. 5/6.
"In March, Roychowdhury travelled from Madison to Portland, Maine, and he purchased a one-way ticket from Boston to Guatemala City,..."
WTF????
Even if you take I-90 to I-495 to I-95, you have to go through the outer Boston suburbs. There long has been talk of an east/west highway through VT/NH/ME, possibly following US Route 2, but there isn't one.
What a very bizarre comment. Even if US2 was a freeway, it goes from Burlington VT to Bangor and not especially near Portland. It isn't clear such an interstate (if it existed) would be any faster than I90-I290-I495-I95, unless he could not avoid eastern MA right at rush hour. In fact, it would probably be slower most of the time.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JTVDOx35FNg
(And no, SNL did not invent that with The Californians.)
Take 201 in Skowhegan to I-95.
I'm going to guess you are just not very good with plotting driving routes.
Why would someone go 100+ miles out of the way to stay on a (mythical) freeway when there is US302 that is probably less than half the distance and is 45+MPH most of the way. I suppose maybe if you just love very long drives on freeways.
And unless he went through Canada (note: it is generally a bad choice going through multiple border crossings if the government is looking for you) you would have to get up to Rt2 somehow. Yes, I know how to do it from I90, but it would be again a long unnecessary detour vs. just going directly through MA.
He could have gone through Canada (Detroit - Toronto - Montreal). My best assumption is that he had a friend in Portland and it was a convenient place to park his car. Take the Downeaster to North Station, walk or T to South Station, Silver Line into the airport.
Easier to take Concord Trailways Bus -- it is nonstop from Portland to South Station and memory is that it then continues on to Logan. Or get off Downeaster in Woburn (MA) and take Logan Express Bus to Logan -- just make sure the train is taking the Lowell line and not Haverhill line into Boston.
To use the subway, you have to transfer from the Orange line to the Red line to go between North & South Station. Coming north from DC, I get off at Back Bay (last stop before South Station) which is a direct Orange Line run to North Station.
Um, the lede gets buried here. So our perp commits the act in May 2022. DNA analysis provides a match on March 17 2023. After sitting around for ~10 months the perp gets the itch to amscray 10 days later? I think someone in law enforcement tipped this piece of human debris off.
I agree -- and still wonder why go the extra 110 miles to Portland to fly out of Boston which isn't really near Wisconsin.
He might have noticed he was being tailed although you are probably right as he doesn't sound overly bright.
It says "In March 2023, law enforcement identified Roychowdhury as a possible suspect." That was before the DNA. Presumably that came from talking to someone, which Roychowdhury might have found out about.
When you find yourself defending, explaining away, and minimizing firebombers, it's time to reevaluate your life choices.
I was under the impression that firebombing violated state law.
Special federal protection for these facilities is based on a Roe-era act of Congress which ought to be reconsidered. They were focused on protecting abortuaries but added pregnancy counseling centers to look impartial.
No, it's more:
If you look at the DoJ press release https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/wisconsin-man-charged-firebombing-building
It appears this is what they charged him with:
18 USC 844(f)(1)
(1) Whoever maliciously damages or destroys, or attempts to damage or destroy, by means of fire or an explosive, any building, vehicle, or other personal or real property in whole or in part owned or possessed by, or leased to, the United States, or any department or agency thereof, or any institution or organization receiving Federal financial assistance, shall be imprisoned for not less than 5 years and not more than 20 years, fined under this title, or both.
Wow, that would cover a lot of territory. Would a private home with a VA mortgage fit that bill?
I mean, technically, it could cover any mortgage if the lending institution borrowed money from the Fed and then issued a mortgage using those funds.
Doubtful. The mortgagee owns the property (and holds the deed). The property is collateral for the loan. The VA doesn't own the property, only the loan, unless the mortgagee defaults. Even then, the VA has to go through the courts to seize the property. Ownership is retained by the mortgagee until that occurs.
This would be interesting if the punishment were enhanced over the motive. As it stands this isn't really about speech because it plays no real part in the prosecution
Presumably that would be permitted under Wisconsin v. Mitchell. Although I still think it's bad policy. The fire bombing is very bad, regardless if the person was trying to make a political point, or just had it in for the owner for some other reason.