The Volokh Conspiracy
Mostly law professors | Sometimes contrarian | Often libertarian | Always independent
Justice Alito Sends Recorded Video Message To Fifth Circuit Judicial Conference
"Unfortunately personal attendance became impractical, and I apologize for everyone for the change in plans."
Justice Alito, the Circuit Justice of the Fifth Circuit, was slated to speak at the Fifth Circuit's Annual Conference. Alas, that presentation was cancelled. Justice Alito recorded a video of brief remarks, which were played for the ballroom audience.
Justice Alito said that he was very much looking forward to visiting the conference, but he could not. Here was my best effort to transcribe what he said:
Unfortunately personal attendance became impractical, and I apologize for everyone for the change in plans.
I pray that Justice Alito and his colleagues stay safe.
For those curious, the Fifth Circuit is holding its conference in Nashville because, apparently, there are no facilities large enough in Mississippi to host this confab.
Update: I have since been reliably informed that judicial conferences are not held in Mississippi for another reason: all of the hotels large enough in the state are attached to casinos, and some rule prohibits holding judicial functions in places attached to casinos. As a result, several hotels in Mississippi are large enough, but due to the casinos, none are not suitable.
Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Why was Mississippi involved? They are part of the 5th Circuit, but so are Texas and Louisiana and I know both of those states have facilities large enough. BTW how many people attend these things?
Impractical b/c everyone fears there will be an assassination attempt. To protect everyone's safety, Roberts needs to issue the final opinion immediately.
Yeah, a Scott Roeder, Shelley Shannon, Eric Rudolph, etc., could be lurking out there!
Maybe not them, but perhaps a James Thomas Hodgkinson.
Let's not pretend like this is limited to one party/ideology.
Remember how the FBI declared that incident as "Death by Cop" and not political terrorism which is clearly was?
Democrat institutions are downright evil.
The FBI is a 'Democratic institution!' This guy is ridiculous.
Yeah man the FBI is totally non-partisan and equally applies their powers to both sides of the political coin.
lmao get real
I'm actually curious if your 15 years old or a total dupe of recent right wing propaganda?
Law enforcement *in general* has a very conservative bent. Lots of history and studies show this.
Federal law enforcement is where people *really* devoted to law enforcement go (also, lots of former prosecutors, now that's a very liberal group, amirite?).
I mean, you've heard of Hoover, right? Real Marxist cat that one! And in more recent times there's fellows like Mueller-I get he crossed your Orange God but that doesn't change the fact he was a lifelong Republican, sorry.
This idea that the FBI is a 'Democrat' or "left' institution is as laughable as it is recent, it's a talking point manufactured because they dared investigate your Orange Lord some when he surrounded himself with foreign agents (note, they also kept quiet about that while leaking like a sieve about their concurrent Hillary Clinton investigation).
Don't be such a tool.
Are you Gaslightr0's alter?
We see their partisan behavior with our own eyes. The Democrats at the FBI, DOJ, IRS, ATF, DHS etc. are just institutional arms of the DNC and the rest of the Federal Class.
These are just lazy, tool-ish conclusory statements by you. There's a lot of research supporting the idea law enforcement skews conservative (do you really want to argue cops and prosecutors don't skew conservative? where do you think FBI agents come from?), what have you got other than your strange capitalization?
You have research that shows the people at the DOJ, FBI, IRS, ATF and DHS skews conservative?
https://www.fedsmith.com/2021/02/12/political-donations-and-federal-employees/
Look at the table under the section "Is There a 'Deep State'". Does that data support your beliefs, or do you think that data support my beliefs?
Look at these conservative Republicans!
https://imgs.search.brave.com/3jjrVs16sioE3n5mHTkBeHcNY-UA_HGBKfIykFqP4CY/rs:fit:1200:630:1/g:ce/aHR0cHM6Ly9pMC53/cC5jb20vdHJ1ZXB1/bmRpdC5jb20vd3At/Y29udGVudC91cGxv/YWRzLzIwMjAvMDYv/ZmJpLWFnZW50cy10/YWtpbmcta25lZS5q/cGc_cmVzaXplPTEy/MDAlMkM2MzAmc3Ns/PTE
https://imgs.search.brave.com/_knyc0He6QjSzF1lDIGMNwibvnsea9IjUeK-Cizc568/rs:fit:962:627:1/g:ce/aHR0cHM6Ly9pLmRh/aWx5bWFpbC5jby51/ay8xcy8yMDIwLzA2/LzAzLzIxLzI5MTg1/Njc4LTgzODUyNjct/QV9wcm90ZXN0ZXJf/ZGVtb25zdHJhdGlu/Z19hZ2FpbnN0X3Ro/ZV9kZWF0aF9vZl9H/ZW9yZ2VfRmxveWRf/dGFsay1hLTMwXzE1/OTEyMTY5MzU4NDIu/anBn
Are you aware, you bigoted half-wit, that every director of the FBI has been a Republican?
This blog attracts a profoundly stupid audience. That could explain why the culture war has been such a rout -- and why top law school faculties hire relatively few strident conservatives.
That guy wasn't motivated by abortion rights was he? You're really bad at this.
He was motivated by hysterical anti-Republican sentiment, but I do appreciate the hair-splitting.
When you have rabid senators threatening sitting conservative justices (by name) with violence over abortion rulings, blue-checkmarked journalists on Twitter conducting "thought experiments" about assassinating said justices over the same, and violent pro-abortion activists convicted of making credible death threats", it ia not a stretch to assume that similar criminals could be lying in wait for Alito.
Lol, sure dude, in a debate about one of the most famous 'single issue' issues ever it's 'hair splitting' to point out that your single example is not like my many (one was just anti Republican, the others pro-abortion).
You should stick to listening songs (great ones btw) about Legs.
It was the same on several dimensions (political identity of the criminal, politics of the victims etc..) and different in one other (the specific issue leading to the attempted murder.
That you know crazy leftists have been known to attempt murder of their ideological opponents on general issues, but think that's no reason to think they'll do it for a specific ideological issue is a problem with the way you reason.
My "single example' , btw was followed up by another example, this time on this specific issue. When you're in a hole, stop digging.
You don't have a pro-choice example, you're the one digging.
Reading not one of your strong suits, eh? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theodore_Shulman - that's the follow up example I gave you.
You're out of your depth, stop digging.
Pro-abortion group today [not last century like Rudoplh and Shannon] is posting maps and pictures with addresses of justices.
Bob is a dishonest person. Look, he's said he's a partisan before any neutral principle before. And here look how he elides the *first* of the *three* names I presented. Why did he do that? Was it because it was more current (of course, none were 'a century ago')?
He's just engaging in volunteer propaganda. Pathetic.
Nice deflection. Today a left group is targeting justices.
[PS, "last century" does not mean 'a century ago'. Learn to read at least.]
"Today a left group is targeting justices."
Are they? Pro-life people have a record of shooting and bombing pro-choice people. You've got...what exactly?
""last century" does not mean 'a century ago'."
Lol, in 2022! This is how he operates, folks.
I don't think it's an unreasonable concern.
All it takes is one lunatic.
No need to invoke assassination. A crowd of screaming feminists waving coat hangers and throwing diapers would ruin the party too.
"He should have quoted Zelensky's video address from February: "This might be the last time you see me alive.""
Zelensky was being overdramatic and Alito should be too to make light of the overreaction to the leak.
Justice Roberts and, I believe, Justice Thomas made it to another judicial conference.
Face it. Justice Alito is probably just a pussy.
(as in kitten-like, pusillanimous)
And playing the persecution card, like plenty of disaffected clingers.
It must have gotten really difficult to transcribe after that first sentence.
He should have quoted Zelensky's video address from February: "This might be the last time you see me alive."
No facilities in Mississippi big enough? It looks no bigger than a faculty meeting at my university.
Alternate reality: No facility in Mississippi wanted a bunch of federal lawyers hanging around driving down property values.
Actual reality: Mississippi has the second cheapest home prices in the nation (only above the loser - surprise surprise - West Virginia).
A bunch of federal lawyers hanging the state can only have a positive affect.
Right because we know the Federal Class earns twice as much as the rest of us, on average.
But sadly that ratio declines as you get more educated and provide more value, so laywer-dom is safe from decline!
"the Federal Class "
A nonsense term for a nonsense person.
"social class, also called class, a group of people within a society who possess the same socioeconomic status. Besides being important in social theory, the concept of class as a collection of individuals sharing similar economic circumstances has been widely used in censuses and in studies of social mobility."
Read a f'n book, dude.
You're an idiot tool. So the postman and the infantry Marine and the park ranger and the GS-15 are all in the same 'class' because they are all 'federal' (no, excuse me, you use the retarded Trumpian capitalization rules 'Federal Class')? They don't fit your definition at all, moron.
Here's the thing: some stupid right wing media outlet has turned you on to this (or you're part of one, or even more pathetic a self-styled volunteer one). They are the ones who have made you look stupid here, not me. Maybe turn a critical eye on them once in a blue moon?
All the overpaid, unaccountable, and unelected morons that make up the Administrative State that lord over us lawmaking and lawbreaking are the Federal Class.
I like that you doubled down on the Wacky Capitalization, hate English rules as a conspiracy now, do you?
"All the overpaid, unaccountable, and unelected morons that make up the Administrative State that lord over us lawmaking and lawbreaking are the Federal Class."
What a lazy, stupid, grievance based 'definition.'
Like I said, it's a nonsense term for a nonsense person. What happened in your life to make you so pathetic?
You never heard of "proper nouns"?
Good lord, you must be a Federale. Twice as paid, twice as dumb.
Note he dodged every question I posed.
Troll.
>What happened in your life to make you so pathetic?
You're crying because I "dodged" that question?
Are you for real?
" So the postman and the infantry Marine and the park ranger and the GS-15 are all in the same 'class' because they are all 'federal' (no, excuse me, you use the retarded Trumpian capitalization rules 'Federal Class')?"
" hate English rules as a conspiracy now, do you? "
" No facility in Mississippi wanted a bunch of federal lawyers hanging around driving down property values. "
Mississippi property values?
How much is a half-wide on cinder blocks with a meth smile next to the Superfund site going for these days?
Yeah, the explanation is not plausible.
Probably what he really meant was no facility with the level of luxury and entertainment option required by the participants, within 10-minute limo range of an airport with direct flights to and from DC.
American actually has a nonstop from DCA to Jackson MS.
Why?
Maybe Kagan ought to be the circuit judge for the 5th Circuit, and Alito for the 1st Circuit.
It would be irresponsible not to speculate!
This comes to mind.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KGL4c-23Mxo
Careful David, talk like this could get a person permanently banned from match.com
Imbecilic incel's imagination!
The person that got me banned was a Yale Law School grad. I did say, she was really cute, and I that wanted a heart to heart to discuss jurisprudence. She was partner at a top downtown law firm. She had a lot of money, but did not think I was funny. I thought I was when I called her profession the most failed occupation in the country, 1000 times more toxic than organized crime. We did not even reach the depth of relationship where I tell her whom I voted for.
Queenie. How is your social life? I have so much to say about my stunning experiences on the dating scene. I can help you avoid my mistakes.