The Volokh Conspiracy

Mostly law professors | Sometimes contrarian | Often libertarian | Always independent

Free Speech

Theater Prof Facing Possible Firing for Not Being Sufficiently Outraged


From the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education; I missed it when it was first posted (Oct. 20):

Dr. Steven ​​Earnest [of Coastal Carolina University] … was suspended from teaching after criticizing student protestors who staged a walkout because they saw the names of students of color written on a whiteboard and mistook the list as malicious. In fact, it turned out to have been a list of students who might want to hang out together….

On Sept. 16, a visiting artist was working with two students of color after class, and one student expressed that she felt isolated and would like to get to know other non-white students in the department. The visiting artist asked about whether it might be helpful for non-white students to connect as a group, and she and the students wrote out the names of other non-white students on the classroom whiteboard while brainstorming ideas.

The names were still on the board when the next class arrived, and several of the entering students were offended, believing that whoever had written the list must have been singling out non-white students. They decided to hold a protest in a campus courtyard on Sept. 21 instead of attending class.

After discussion with the students and faculty involved, the Department of Theatre's Diversity, Equity and Inclusion Committee determined that the names on the board had been presented "as a resource for newer students who are looking to be in community with other BIPOC students." Nonetheless, the DEI committee apologized to the offended students, writing in an email to the theater department that the "faculty and students involved as well as the Theatre Department as a whole are deeply sorry to anyone who was affected by this incident." The visiting artist who helped create the list of names also apologized profusely, calling her participation "thoughtless and careless."

Earnest did not agree. He responded to the email, stating (as written): "Sorry but I dont think its a big deal. Im just sad people get their feelings hurt so easily. And they are going into Theatre?" He received several responses criticizing his remark, and responded again to clarify that he was "just defending our guest artist."

Students critical of Earnest's emails accused him of being racially insensitive and dismissive of students of color. Several also called for Earnest to be fired and protested by boycotting theater classes.

"It was upsetting to be accused of racism by students and others with whom I have never interacted," said Earnest. "But it was even more upsetting to have these false accusations ratified by a university that I have called home for over fifteen years."

On Sept. 20, Claudia Bornholdt, the dean of Coastal Carolina's College of Humanities and Fine Arts, told Earnest not to come to his classes and to send her his syllabus, effectively suspending him from his teaching duties.

Earnest contacted FIRE and is now working with the Faculty Legal Defense Fund to defend his rights. FLDF provides free legal assistance to faculty at public universities whose civil liberties are in jeopardy. Launched this year, it has successfully worked (and is still working with) over a dozen faculty members whose rights or livelihoods have been threatened by their public universities….

FIRE wrote to Coastal Carolina on Sept. 29, reminding the university that professors have the right to speak freely on matters of public concern. Additionally, the fact that others found Earnest's emails offensive does not diminish the emails' protection under the First Amendment. As a public institution, Coastal Carolina is bound by the First Amendment and required to protect the free speech of its faculty.

FIRE received no response to its letter, but Earnest's attorney told FIRE that rather than backing down, the university is launching a termination process against Earnest….