Stossel: Lessons From Africa
Entrepreneur Magatte Wade explains how regulations are keeping Africa poor.
HD DownloadMore than half of the world's poorest people live in sub-Saharan Africa.
Why is that region so poor? There are lots of theories. Some blame a colonial history. Others blame the weather, or discrimination.
Magatte Wade, an African entrepreneur, tells John Stossel that she knows the biggest reason from her own first-hand experience: It's crushing government regulation.
"Once you hire someone, good luck getting rid of them for any reason," she says. Her home country, Senegal, requires government permission to fire an employee. That makes it hard to run a business. It also makes entrepreneurs reluctant to hire.
Then there's the complicated tax code.
"Some people say it's worth at least two or three truckloads of paper," she says. Hiring an accountant to wade through that is expensive for new businesses.
Magatte started a business anyway—she makes lip balm. She has to import several ingredients that are not made in Senegal.
"Some of them have a 70 percent import tariff on them!" Wade complains.
High taxes and complex rules often lead to corruption, because people pay bribes to get around the rules. Wade says corruption "a natural consequence of stupid senseless idiot laws….The only way to fix corruption is to simplify."
Wade's business survives without corruption, she says. One reason is that she was fortunate to find a bureaucrat who helped her find a way around the ruinous tariffs.
"We found a clause in one of the binders saying actually if you're exporting at least 80 percent of your products and if you've been in business for two years then you can ask for an exemption," she said.
Well-meaning Westerners often try to help Africa with aid. Tom's Shoes gives a pair of shoes to someone in the developing world for every pair customers buy. But Wade points out that such donations destroy local African shoemakers.
Instead of aid, she says, demand that rules be cut. That would create jobs.
"If I have a job then, guess what?" Wade asks. "My malnutrition problem goes poof! My uneven access to clean water goes poof. It's just poof, poof, poof!
"Create greater economic freedom…in all countries," Wade concludes. "So that all people everywhere get a chance to experience free enterprise."
The views expressed in this video are solely those of John Stossel; his independent production company, Stossel Productions; and the people he interviews. The claims and opinions set forth in the video and accompanying text are not necessarily those of Reason.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
I heard China is investing into Africa
I was in central Africa a couple years ago. Most of the time I was in relatively rural areas but I spent a few days in a large city and got to eat brunch at a high-end hotel where visiting dignitaries and business people stay at. There weren't very many "white folks" in the restaurant but there were a LOT of Asians. They're way ahead of North America on investing in Africa.
"investing" or colonialism?
China FDI is a real issue, sho nuff. Companies from the PRC build up in Africa and staff themselves with their own nationals, rather than the indigenous. This was a good video, but there's nothing new here. Check out Dambisa Moyo's Dead Aid. Makes all the same points about the handshake between foreign aid and corruption; and how companies like Tom's fuck the locals' economy.
Refreshing to see that it isn’t global warming bringing them down.
You just aren't believing hard enough!
"Create greater economic freedom…in all countries," Wade concludes. "So that all people everywhere get a chance to experience free enterprise."
So...sweatshops and money laundering?
It's like you didn't even watch the video but went straight to your Marxist straw man arguments.
Do I really need to?
It is generally considered recommendable to at least have a basic understanding of a subject before pontificating. Thus way you don't end up looking like a jejune partisan.
A job in a sweatshop is better than no job at all.
If Africa is poor, the Koch / Reason solution is to encourage everybody on that continent to immigrate to the United States. In fact, this plan makes so much sense only an alt-right white nationalist would oppose it.
#OpenBorders
In fact, this _______ makes so much sense only an alt-right white nationalist would oppose it.
And that is pretty much the talking point for ANY progressive agenda.
Look, other than Europe, North America, Southeast Asia, Australia, South Africa, and Israel, where has this crazy idea worked?
Nah, best stick with living off of foreign aid and propping up corrupt governments.
its not just the corrupt governments themselves that like these burdensome rules of control but it is also the U.N.. I saw a documentary where locals wanted to connect a bicycle to a pump to pump water form a well but it was the U.N. that was denying them that right. it was quite enlighting watching this fat white bitch at the U.N arms crossed in derission telling them they should be proud of the life they live as it is their heritage and we ant to keep it that way. I was proud of the African when he comment if teh U.S. can send people to the moon we sure as heck can put in a water pump. note this is not unusual. I had a relative went to Camaroon and I saw video of them bent over using a rope to pull water form a well and i asked why they didn't put a crank on it they said they weren't allowed to. Buracracy is used to control, when people spend their time trying to survive they can't rebel
the Tom's example is an idea I've been thinking about homeless people are not because of capitalisms failures but because capitalism is so successfull that people can give money and items away allowing people to not work and live homeless. In a society where everyone lives marginally no one helps the poor and even they realize get off your ass or else, but in America you have a choice due to our success
Stossel is definitely doing well to make up for being a Lefty early in his life.
He's a brave man too. No one is hated more than an apostate.
It takes someone ignorant of Africa's culture and history to believe its troubles are caused by government regulations. And it takes a libertarian to announce that belief out loud in public.
They didn't claim it was the ultimate cause, just the proximate cause.
A minor cause among a huge number of big ones. I guess you can call what Mugabe did to Zimbabwe "government regulation", but that's a whole different thing than what Stossel is talking about. Same goes for Emperor Bhokassa, Idi Amin or many others who could be named. Tribal rivalries like Hutus vs. Tutsis simply blot out anything positive or negative governments might do.
Tribal rivalries like Hutus vs. Tutsis simply blot out anything positive or negative governments might do.
As long as we're focusing on minor causes among major ones, why is the Hutu vs. Tutsi "tribal rivalry" so much more virulent than any "tribal rivalries" in Nigeria or Ghana?
They're not, just a lot bloodier and hence better publicized and likely better known, so a logical choice for an example.
They’re not
I'm not sure I agree. The majority Hutu were enslaved by the Belgians and the minority Tutsi were put in charge of them due to the Afro-Asiatic appearance of the Tutsi leading the Belgians to see them as racially superior to the Bantu Hutu, who were regarding by the Belgians (and their Tutsi administrators) as being little better than pack animals.
Doesn't strike me as a particularly good example of typical "tribal rivalries" that don't seem to afflict other countries in Africa in quite the same way.
+
Lord knows, that African lady who owns and runs a business in Africa is woefully ignorant of African culture and history and what impacts government has on the ability of Africans to run a business. I mean, how could she possibly have any insight into the African business climate?
nice bro
LImBo
Good article, but IMO corruption is a cultural phenomenon and not the result of over regulation.
Well, yeah. But couldn't one also say that, in most cases, over-regulation is just an example of legalized corruption?
nice
Africa is one of the richest continents, just not many smart and people there to develop the continent. Also, They just need outsiders to stop telling them how to live their life. Their time will come soon with people like Akon doing bits.
Hey John... This was one of your best pieces! Bravo!
what a shame if the article about mp3 songs are not read
thank you, this very nice
Very nice.
Airtel Balance Check Codes
Economic freedom in all countries of the world remains a dream for the next few decades. I don’t even know if mankind can cope with this lesson. It seems to me that a competent disclosure of this topic should go as a criterion in the iwriter review or other similar reviews of services. Just a review of the international situation with the expression of their own opinions is the highest indicator of quality.
Make good articles and suggestions https://issuu.com/kixaxe4041
it was quite enlighting watching this fat white bitch at the U.N arms crossed in derission telling them they should be proud of the life they live as it is their heritage and we ant to keep it that way.https://catchthemes.com/support-forum/users/sangkicau/
So many socks; it's hard to keep up with them.