Don't Send Cubans and Venezuelans Back To Suffer Under Communism
Despite Trump promising to stand "with the good people of Cuba and Venezuela," his administration has fast-tracked deportations for victims of communism.
"Under my administration, we have taken decisive action to stand with the good people of Cuba and Venezuela," President Donald Trump said at the White House in 2017. "The same failed communist ideology that has brought oppression to Cuba has brought nothing but suffering and misery everywhere and every place it has been anywhere in the world. Communism is the past. Freedom is the future."
Communism should indeed be a thing of the past—but a recent immigration policy from Trump's second administration threatens to trap its victims there.
Consider the case of a man identified in court filings as M.A.R., a political dissident from Cuba who came to the United States legally in 2024. A ruling from the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia outlined that he faced "threats, harassment, and retaliation from Cuban authorities" for his views. He was granted humanitarian parole, obtained work authorization, and married a U.S. citizen. He has no criminal record.
But when M.A.R. attended an immigration hearing in May 2025, he was detained by Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers afterward, though he had met the legal obligations of his parole and his asylum case had not been dismissed. He soon found out, according to his attorney, that the government would subject him to expedited removal—a fast-track proceeding with a much less robust process, including no hearing in front of a judge.
That quicker process has typically been limited to people arrested crossing the U.S.-Mexico border. But the Trump administration expanded it in January to apply to humanitarian parolees. In doing so, the government exceeded its statutory authority, ruled Judge Jia Cobb of D.C.'s federal district court in August, temporarily barring the Department of Homeland Security from executing fast-track deportations for migrants admitted to the U.S. on humanitarian grounds.
In that same speech from 2017, Trump singled out another country: We "stand with the people of Venezuela, who are suffering under the ruthless socialism of the Maduro regime," he said. "We reject socialist oppression."
Those remarks—which reflect his longstanding rhetorical antipathy to socialism—are puzzling in the context of another individual mentioned in the decision, R.J.L.B., a Venezuelan military officer who came to the U.S. legally. The Venezuelan government, he says, is surveilling him and his family. He too was arrested this year after an immigration proceeding and set for a fast-track return to Venezuela, notwithstanding that he believes he will be killed for desertion if forced to return. It's a strange way for the Trump administration to "reject socialist oppression."
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please to post comments
Better idea: overthrow Cuba, overthrow Venezuela, liberate them both, and then tell MAR and RJLB not to waste the gift we've given them.
This notion that they should all just come to America - particularly when Billy offers no evidence whatsoever of a desire for them to be American (rather merely not-Cuban and not-Venezuelan) - is both unrealistic and unsustainable.
"Admitted to the U.S. on humanitarian grounds" is the rape baby. Like the baby killers trying to rationalize ALL elective abortions on its back, Billy is trying to rationalize every border jumping scumbag on the back of those genuinely fleeing persecution. Well, sorry, but don't piss down my back and tell me it's raining. Especially when their new lives in America is just going right back to the communist ideology they claim to have fled. You can't pretend that fleeing Maduro only to wind up under Newsom is a step in a positive direction, Billy.
If the problem is that they're suffering under communism, then your position should be to go kill the communists. Liberate Cuba and Venezuela.
After we've liberated California and New York, that is.
Priorities.
they had freedom and they gave it up, its not our job to fix them.
It's not our job to take them in, either.
But if the choice is between "take in failed state refugees until our state also fails" and "eliminate the failed state," we should go with the latter.
Unless we're willing to close our borders and isolate - which I guarantee isn't a case that globalist Billy or anyone even slightly shade of blue here is going to make.
I'm personally of a position that any State even hinting at communist overtones is a declaration of war against the United States. One that we shouldn't even pussyfoot around - just start hitting them with non-nuclear MIRVs on all their critical targets.
Yes, that includes missile strikes on California.
McCarthy was right.
Ladies and Gentelemen for your viewing pleasure a warmongering psychopath who thinks america has a right nay a dutyto go around slaughtering the entire world whenever they feel like it.
I didn't say "the entire world."
Unless you think the entire world is a bunch of commies. In which case then, yes, I'm saying "the entire world."
Stop defending communism you pinko.
...slaughtering the entire world whenever they feel like it.
When did communists become the entire world?
We don't want them here, Billy. It is time for them to go home.
Who's the "we", you and the mouse in your pocket?
If they want to be here, are willing to work, and don't engage in real crimes (to exclude victimless crimes), then I, for one, want them here! (This is called "freedom", BTW.)
Maybe the haters and xenophobes could self-deport, ass an example to the rest of us, back to Africa, where humans came from?
The idea of 'victimless crime' is dumb. We have a process to create laws, if you don't like the law or the process work to change it.
AND as a Libertarian you should realize the cost in taxation that creates victims of those of us who work.
Wow, we haven't sent a Cubano back since Elian Gonzalez.
That’s because of the sandwiches.
The what now? - sarc
[checks records] That we *know of*.
Don't Send Cubans and Venezuelans Back To Suffer Under Communism
If only there were a way kill two birds with one stone... you know, a couple ounces of prevention to forswear several pounds of cure.
Ive seen Venezuelans on TikTok demanding free welfare benefits. They didnt leave it behind.
Cubans who left 20 years ago worked hard. Many became citizens and vote against socialism policies. I dont see thst from recent ones.
We just saw foreigners vote in a socialist in NYC. Which is why blind importation of immigrants doesn't work.
This is more retarded of a take than more testing needed.
And Jesse knows that the Venezuelans that he sees on TikTok (cherry picked by his right-wing algorithm of course), represent all Venezuelans everywhere. But don't call him a bigot, that is just mean.
Which is why blind importation of immigrants doesn't work.
The best society is an ideologically conformist society! We should only allow people in who act and think exactly as Jesse wants them to think! Then we will have finally achieved the American utopia!
Yes. A society with some uniting principles is the best society. Absolutely.
Diversity is the opposite of community.
Cubans, I have no problem with except Narco Rubio(family was a Cuban mafia)
Venezuelans on the other hand will contribute about as much as your average ghetto queen.
There isn't a day or week goes by where ICE or the cops arrest some Venezuelan for rape, violent crime of child molestation. I don't know what it is in the water in that country but apparently, it affects their brains.
When countries empty their prisons and sends them to our borders, it should be considered an act of war.
It's the Jews, right, Herr Schicklgruber?
Yes send them back.
They can try again in a country closer that shares their culture and language.
This is what should be the response regarding immigrants and refugees. Why import a bunch of Spanish speaking immigrants to an English speaking country when most of South and Central America share their language and some degree of culture? Why import a bunch of Muslims from the opposite side of the globe when there are advancing Muslim nations in their region who share their religion and possibly even their language and cultural norms? Mass importation of non-Americans makes the US less American.
Why send illegal alien rapefugees back to their communist homes when you can expand communism domestically and fund them staying here?
I thought this was going to be an article about southern border states shipping illegal immigrants to NYC.
Bolivia is again free. Send them all to Bolivia.
There are some people with a legitimate asylum claim. A lot not, but some do. For example:
https://www.legion.org/information-center/news/security/2021/april/us-veterans-scramble-to-help-interpreters-left-behind
Hey Billy, if we take in all the suffering peoples of bad countries, who the fuck is going to be left there to try and fix those countries?
WHO do you think supported the communist/socialist nation building if it wasn't the residents?
As-if NYC (huge immigration population) electing a Socialist mayor didn't end the BS narrative that they're ?escaping? communism/socialism.
Statistically. Current Immigration filtering plays out to...
20% want a USA.
80% want to conquer and consume the USA with MORE communism/socialism.