Florida Proposes 'Alligator Alcatraz' to House Detained Migrants and Speed Up Deportations
Florida's attorney general proposed using a 30-square-mile part of the Everglades to house, process, and deport detained migrants.

Florida is looking to strengthen its position as a national leader in immigration enforcement.
Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier told Fox Business that he is proposing to build a new 1,000-bed immigration detention center on a 30-square-mile property in the Everglades owned by Miami-Dade County. He has dubbed the facility, which would be the largest of its kind in the state, "Alligator Alcatraz."
"If somebody were to get out, there's nowhere to run, nowhere to hide. Only alligators and pythons are waiting," he said during an interview with Fox News correspondent Danamarie McNicholl on Tuesday.
Uthmeier said in a video posted on X that the site could be ready in as little as 30 to 60 days and serve as a three-in-one immigration enforcement facility, capable of housing detainees, processing legal cases, and serving as a deportation hub. The identified land for the project is an old airport facility with a landing strip already in place to potentially fly people directly out of the facility for deportation.
Uthmeier's proposal, which would require local, state, and federal approval to move forward, is the newest attempt to increase immigration enforcement by not only supplying more beds to house detained migrants but also by expediting the deportation process.
One of President Donald Trump's top priorities since taking office in January has been to "complete the largest deportation operation in American history." The immigration crackdown has led to an influx of nearly 30 percent more detained migrants since January. As of June 1, 51,302 migrants are being housed in detention facilities. This has caused overcrowding in the country's existing local jails and immigration detention facilities and created a bottleneck limiting the number of total possible deportations. To solve this problem, the Trump administration has experimented with unprecedented options like housing detained migrants in El Salvador and Guantanamo Bay, each riddled with controversy over due process and civil liberty violations.
While the three-in-one facility proposed by Uthmeier could decrease the amount of time deportation proceedings take to move a migrant from detainment to deportation, it will not solve the many constitutional and due process questions that still exist. Without answering these crucial questions, optimizing for speed will only serve to erode the rights of migrants while expanding government power.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Without answering these crucial questions, optimizing for speed will only serve to erode the rights of migrants while expanding government power.
Well yeah. That's the plan, isn't it?
No, the plan is to do what people want, expel illegal immigrants.
Let him live in his pretend world.
Did the gray box say something?
He’s as coherent as Biden.
Illegals have zero rights to residency. The non retarded understand this.
1. This idea really should be for those convicted of violent crimes only.
2. Just think of the savings this idea would bring.
Save money on barbed wire, guard towers, and correctional personnel.
3. Just think if Alaska thought of the same idea for their convicted violent criminals.
Place the convicts in the middle of Alaska, and let them fend for themselves.
I'm sure nothing but good would happen.
Save money...
Until you see the fricken' cost of mounting lasers on the Alligators.
Will they at least dig a big moat around it?
Already done - - - - - - - -
Stocked with sharks with friggin laser beams?
Even better, it's stocked with gators. They are basically amphibious sharks. The friggin laser beams are pending.
Over the EPA's dead body... Hopefully
Waiting for dems to cry alligators and pythons don't get minimum wage.
Could be kind of fun, just use air national guard C130s to pallet drop the food and water and let the inmates sort it out.
For shits and giggles, we should import highly poisonous animals from foreign countries to be on the prison grounds. Illegals guarding illegals and all.
Why go through the bother? Just kill them and send their families a bill for the bullets. I'm sure there are plenty of MAGAs who would volunteer to be executioners. Heck, half of the posters in these comments would jump at the opportunity.
Poor sarc. Off the deep end.
Sarc always does. By the way, I’ve “muted” him the same way he’s “muted” me and others.
You hate immigrants so much you want to compare them to babbit?!?
Dems? Josh Hawley, is a Republican.
I don't live in a third world shithole because I dont want to live with those people, in that culture, under their society's rules.
Likewise, I dont want to have so many of them move into my neighborhood that my neighborhood becomes a satellite office of their third world shithole.
This is not hard to understand.
They all have to go back.
I've suggested this kind of thing as a reasonable alternative in the past. Nothing scummy or inhumane like the Alaskan tundra. Something reasonable.
Specifically: Johnston AFB.
It's been decommissioned for 20 years, so it's not in the best condition - but no matter. It's a comfortable climate, it's got a lot of room, it's safe from predators. Throw up a bunch of quonset huts, a few solar generators, and do daily airdrops of food, water, linens, and the new roundup of temporary residents captured by ICE. The... guests... can roam about freely, as they patiently wait for their day in immigration court - which will have a bunker-like thing built for private videoconferencing (if they break it, or the comms station that powers it - then they'll sadly have to wait for repairs to continue immigration hearings, and unfortunately extend their own stay until we get around to it).
No need to sort out the women and children from the TdA and MS13 types, since I've been thoroughly assured (especially by this website) the latter are peaceful Maryland Man sorts just looking for a better life. And, best part - especially for libertarians: it's 100% optional. Upon arrest, they can immediately self-deport and willfully forfeit any due process (as well as conditioned that any subsequent return to illegal status also willingly forfeits due process and they go straight to CECOT).
Or they can wait things out on Johnston. Their choice.
This is the most libertarian option available.
Another option is Sheriff Arpaio style prisons on the border. Military tents to sleep in (good enough for the troops, good enough for illegals), cots to sleep on, basic meals (cold cereal for breakfast,soup and bologna sandwiches for lunch and stew for dinner) bought in bulk and the only entertainment a large field to walk around in ( okay give them a couple of soccer balls they can have inmates act as the goal posts). Put them on the border and they act as a deterrence to illegal border crossers
NGL, I really think they need to not be anywhere on the mainland. That's the biggest problem. They seem to think that so long as they reach it, they've got a foothold.
I say eliminate that foothold. These crybabies around here got their panties in a wad about CECOT - fine. Then we'll send them to a place that's still technically America while they wait out their immigration hearings. One at a time. No reason Americans should have to suffer their unwanted presence in the meantime.
The only real fear is that Johnston isn't large enough to contain them all. But I'm also not against stacking them up in tightly packed shipping crates with 20- (or even 30-40-)story ladders to bunk for the night. We've got lots of shipping crates - and hipsters even consider them a progressive form of housing. So, no inhumanity whining there.
Prison ships maybe? Just convert old cargo ships holds into massive dormitories and base them in the Gulf of America. Or use old decommissioned oil platforms.
If course the reason I like Sheriff Arpaio style prisons is that they are cheap and can be based on the border so illegals caught crossing can quickly be sent there and sent from there back into Mexico. Another advantage is that they become additional border security in the areas that they are located.
Autumn, dear . . . those due process issues have already been resolved.
Remember, you're the one telling us illegal immigration isn't a crime - thus they don't get a full criminal jury trial.