Farmworkers Panic as ICE Raids California Fields
Agents were chasing and apprehending workers in the early hours of the morning.

As protests against immigration enforcement rage on in Los Angeles, despite the efforts of local law enforcement and the military, Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) raids have expanded into California's agricultural centers.
Just 70 miles to the northwest of L.A., eyewitnesses told ABC7 News that ICE agents arrived at an Oxnard, California, farm around 6 a.m. on Tuesday. The agents, who were captured on video, then ran through fields of crops, chasing and apprehending on-duty farmworkers. It's unclear how many people were detained, although FBI Los Angeles confirmed the operation was part of immigration enforcement tactics.
Oxnard's mayor, Luis McArthur, responded to the arrests via a Facebook video, stating, "These actions are completely unjustified and harmful. They create chaos and distress in our community without contributing much to public safety."
Although President Donald Trump has made immigration policy a priority in his administration since retaking office, federal immigration authorities have mostly refrained from enforcement action in farming communities. "Today we are seeing an uptick in the chaotic presence of immigration enforcement, particularly the Border Patrol," Elizabeth Strater, vice president of the United Farm Workers, told the Los Angeles Times. Strater says she has seen an increase in reports of agents patrolling near fields across southern California, causing panic about stops and warrantless arrests.
According to research from the University of California Merced, at least half of the approximately 255,700 farmworkers in California are undocumented, with some estimates reaching as high as 75 percent. "These are people who are going to be afraid to take their kids to school, afraid to go to graduation, afraid to go to the grocery store," said Strater. Beyond farmworkers, agents have also reportedly engaged in racial profiling, stopping nonwhite people as they drive to work.
Reps. Julia Brownley (D–Calif.) and Salud Carbajal (D–Calif.), who represent the area, condemned the raids, stating, "These actions are completely unjustified, deeply harmful, and raise serious concerns about the agency's tactics and its respect for due process."
Questions of due process aside, the ramifications of these raids may reach Americans far beyond the Oxnard Plain. California is the largest food producer in the United States, producing over a third of the country's vegetables, over three-quarters of the country's fruits and nuts, and $59.4 billion in cash receipts for output in 2023. Globally, the state's farm and ranch exports totaled $23.6 billion in 2022. Losing such a significant portion of the farm workforce due to ICE detention, deportation, or fear will likely lead to severe supply-chain disruptions, closed agricultural businesses, and higher prices for American consumers until the industry can adapt.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
>>The agents, who were captured on video, then ran through fields of crops, chasing and apprehending on-duty farmworkers.
if the on-duty farmworkers would line up nicely no running or chasing would be required
I’m not able to rightly wrap my head around the notion of “illegal immigrant on-duty farm worker”. Did they swear an oath to grow vegetables? To whom did they swear this oath and how is anyone to know? On duty to whom?
I guess it's the distinction from "illegal immigrants outstanding in the field".
when things get too stupid to mock there is trouble ahead
If things could get too stupid to mock, how could we mock sarcasmic?
Sarcasmic is eminently mockable.
So? Sounds like they are doing their job.
Reason gets mad about the law being enforced when it isn't someone vaguely in the political opposition.
Way angrier about deporting illegals than sticking 1/6 protesters in solitary for over a year.
Libertarianism as a political movement is dead and it is well deserved.
https://www.uscis.gov/working-in-the-united-states/temporary-workers/h-2a-temporary-agricultural-workers
So.... whats the story?
What's funny about this is in the 2006 immigration bill Bush wanted modest border security measures for an increase in these legal visas. Dems and the GOP actually had an agreement and the bill was moving forward. Obama was om the bipartisan committee. Then Obama, against agreements, added a poison pill, killing the legislation. Good times. Good times.
Even Cato understood this.
https://www.cato.org/commentary/president-obamas-delayed-action-immigration-part-long-pattern
Obama, the gift that keeps on giving.
Trump is doing what presidents both D and R have been doing for well over half a century legally and without chaos. If Bernie Sanders were president it would probably be the same strategy but nobody would notice.
Word of the day: Chaos.
Surrendering to invasion and conquest can certainly go more peacefully and smoothly than resisting.
Who will pick our cotton now?
Coincidence?
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cg71xrxrn8go
Maybe he finally got a good look at modern California Girls.
I wish they all could be California girls out there surfin USA and riding around in little deuce coupes.
You can side with Laken Riley, or you can side with the killer who was trying to rape her pussy.
Which side did Reason take?
Reason always take the side of criminals.
OH NO!!
Criminals are afraid!
The end of the world is here!
Just for the record, they are criminal border crossers, not "undocumented".
"These are people who are going to be afraid to take their kids to school, afraid to go to graduation, afraid to go to the grocery store,"
Good. Now if they were afraid to take taxpayer funded benefits it would be a good start.
Criminally crossing the border to get some of those high-paying strawberry picking jobs.
Care to explain how raiding central California farm fields is Making America Great Again? How is anyone better off?
Sure. It is re-establishing respect for the county's laws. That leaves everyone safer.
That leaves everyone safer.
How are farm workers unsafe? How is it safer for us regular folks to have the people on the low end of the economic scale picking the strawberries?
Please cite proof, not just MAGA talking points.
So you see foreigners as lesser than you. Got it. Good work.
You know there's a link right above about a legal way to do this. But apparently educating yourself isn't important.
Who says these people didn't do it the legal way? I, for one, do not accept the the gov'ts statement these we all "illegals". Not when their deploying military force to get their way.
BTW, which color boot polish tastes best, brown or black?
So. You actually are retarded.
Legal migrants have no reason to flee dumdum.
It is amazing the lies you tell yourself to think you’re making a valid argument. Like most leftists, lies from ignorance. Fevered imaginations. Instead of spending time yo educate yourself. Odd.
Have you ever actually interacted with someone here on a work visa? My guess is no.
We see how much MAGA respects the country's laws when Trump pardons the Jan. 6 rioters, even the violent ones.
It's not about 'respect for the law'. It's about purging the nation of the cultural undesirables.
It’s about scapegoating. People don’t like how things are going? Blame an “other” like illegals. They’re the cause. Purge society of the “other” and that will cure all of our ills.
I’m sure the 1930s were not the first time this scenario has been played out.
The only difference is that today it's not socially acceptable to go around murdering people.
Give it time.
And here, Sarc finally says it: Trump is Hitler, or worse than Hitler.
Finally? He has said it dozens of times. His imagination butresses all his views.
Hey ICP, you’re on mute because nothing you say matters. But please keep stalking me. It only proves that you’re a loser. Oh shit I just kicked the puppy. Now it will come back for more attention.
You mute no one, dork.
LOL @ “muting”.
Yeah I have ICP on mute too. He's just a troll and an ankle-biter. Nothing he says is of any value.
You lie even more than Sarc does, and that's saying something.
Poor retard
It's not an accident that Naziism really gained hold in Germany after the Great Depression started. The immiserated people wanted someone to blame for their condition, and Hitler gave them a ready answer.
The authoritarian tactics on display in this country are following the same pattern. After a period of economic upheaval, the people want someone to blame for their condition, and Trump gives them an answer.
Economic upheaval? I’m told Biden delivered an excellent economy.
Or you mean now that inflation is lower, that’s bad?
Whoever told you that Biden delivered an "excellent economy" was lying to you.
Haha! Thanks Lying Jeffy.
Thanks Maddow.
Man, you lie rather big. The violent ones (of which there were some, but few) had their sentences commuted at best.
I still remember when Jeff was advocating murder for trespassing. Good times.
Good to see you back Lying Jeffy. I’ve got a few outstanding questions I was trying to get you to answer awhile back.
Try not to bring up incestuous anal sex as a distraction this time, ok?
I’ll start with a really easy one.
Does the president have the authority to remove the security clearance of a lawfirm?
It is amazing how devoid of self-reflection you are.
Furthermore, in this case, the law itself is dumb. Respect for dumb laws does not make everyone safer. Instead it creates complacency and a population of sheep willing to go along with even dumb laws.
Remember how you all complained about people obeying COVID lockdown laws? Resistance to THOSE laws was apparently noble and just. What changed?
It is not about "respect for the law". That was always a red herring. You just want to kick out "those people". They are impure cultural contaminants.
Remember how you all complained about people obeying COVID lockdown laws? Resistance to THOSE laws was apparently noble and just. What changed?
That’s easy. DEMOCRATS! If Republicans and Trump had supported lockdowns, these same people would have defended them.
If Democrats sent masked federal goons in military gear out to arrest people without warrants, Trump defenders would rightly be outraged.
But partisans judge right and wrong based upon who, not what.
You couldn't be fuller of bullshit if you tried.
That’s easy. DEMOCRATS!
I used to think that, but that's not accurate. Because as we all know, every single governor, even Republican ones, issued some form of authoritarian lockdown order about COVID. But MAGA of course lets the Republicans off the hook.
It's not about Democrats vs. Republicans. It's about Traitors vs. Patriots.
They really do think Democrats (and everyone not like them) are Traitors. So they are evil. Republicans like themselves (not GOPe of course!), they are Patriots and so they get the benefit of the doubt. Because they were well-intentioned even if they make mistakes.
MAGA = Patriots, Everyone Else = Traitors. It's pretty much that simple.
People rejected lockdowns because it was a stupid idea.
Deporting border jumpers is something that happens in all civilized societies.
Thank you for proving my point.
When YOU break the law, it’s because the law itself is wrong.
When THEY break the law, and are punished for it, it’s because “that’s just what civilized societies do”.
And, before the ankle-biters chime in, we are talking about instances where “breaking the law” does not result in any violation of the NAP.
Damn, I really thought you were dead or in jail. Fuck off fatass, lying, shit-eating, Leftist pedo Jeffsarc.
You really cannot understand how criminalization of the free movement of people is wrong when it applies to YOU and COVID lockdowns, but is not wrong when it applies to THEM and immigration restrictions, can you?
This is why your flavor of "libertarianism" is not libertarian in the slightest. It is just straight-up narcissism. That YOU get to do what YOU want, but THEY get the boot of government power.
Are you aware Canada refuses entry to Americans who have criminal records?
Are you aware Canada has socialized health care? Should the US copy that too?
It is done by the provincial governments.
Are you aware Canada calls ham bacon, Lying Jeffy?
The irony dripping from you two as you both defended lock downs, masking, and vaccines against citizens. Defending citizenship against citizens. Defended firing people refusing the vaccines.
You two truly believe illegals are above the law.
“Remember how you all complained about people obeying COVID lockdown laws?”
I do not. I remember complaining about covid lockdown orders from my governor.
Are you pretending you don’t know the difference between laws and orders? Nobody believes that Lying Jeffy. So dishonest.
What covid lockdown orders were laws, exactly? Most of the ones I recall were illegally issued, unilaterally, by some executive, acting outside their authority.
It's a an attempt at a stretch but equating health directors to the president is a dumb if then this type of argument.
Just doubling down on retarded talking points today. Good work.
Is this tactic supposed to be something new instituted by the Trump admin? TV dramas for decades have featured farm hand illegals running when "la migra" shows up. And didn't the Left complain for years that ICE should go after greedy businesses and farmers that hire illegal immigrants?
Prosecuting employers would require that the law make clear what constitutes adequate diligence in determining whether an applicant is legally employable. Right now employers could defend themselves just by saying, "how was I supposed to know he was an illegal?"
So if criminals run away I guess that’s that.
They have a fundamental human right to decline arrest.
Defying the law and running or fighting back apparently means law enforcement is supposed to stop enforcing the law. This exemplifies shitlib thinking and leads to the sort of chaos you keep seeing as dems keep enabling psychopaths.
Defying the law is moral and just if you're an "insurrectionist" on Jan. 6.
Defying the law is an abomination if you are an "insurrectionist" in LA.
False equivalency.
Committing misdemeanor trespassing at worst and being held and charged (or held without charges) as if you were an "insurrectionist" is illegal political persecution.
Violently interfering with federal law enforcement officers engaged in legitimate duties on behalf of foreign invaders IS insurrection.
Committing misdemeanor trespassing at worst and being held and charged (or held without charges) as if you were an “insurrectionist” is illegal political persecution.
Unironically, you are describing most of the illegal immigrants being swept up in these raids. But you don't even realize it.
Illegal immigrants are ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS, idiot.
on behalf of foreign invaders
Your "invader" narrative is bullshit. Penniless Guatemalans coming here for a better life are no more "invaders" than penniless Italians coming here in the beginning of the 20th century.
Or penniless English and Dutchman coming here in the 17th century?
penniless Italians coming here in the beginning of the 20th century.
And thank God the Immigration Act of 1924 slowed down that onslaught long enough for the immigrants to begin assimilating.
Tell that to the land oathers.
Tell the people flying foreign flags amongst the ruin of major cities. Or Mexican political leaders supporting this action.
Once this is resolved, it is time to REALLY piss off Mexico. They bitched about a 3.5% tax on remittances. Make it 100%.
We can do better than that. It's time to start dropping cruise missiles on the cartel bosses.
So the law is being applied against people who willingly broke it and what? I thought nobody was above the law. I thought the law was to have meaning if it was to be anything. Take your leftist gaslighting elsewhere Autumn, preferably a country that respects it's laws like you want ours respected.
Pot, meet kettle.
I bet your very own government takes many actions which are "completely unjustified and harmful" and "create chaos and distress in our community", and I know they don't contribute diddly squat to "public safety".
Clean up your own house before complaining that some other government, whose stolen taxes you are quite happy to accept, is enforcing other laws. I'd have more faith in your concern being honest if you weren't just another dishonest politician.
Seems like just this morning Reeeason was telling me Trump was doing a piss poor job of deporting illegals. Worse than Biden. Ah, memories.
Nothing says Freedom like masked government agents in military gear arresting people without warrants.
Break a few eggs. Add some leftover salmon. Some fresh dill. Melt in a slice of smoked gouda. Yum.
You sure as hell cheered this for anyone connected to the J6 protesters, hypocrite.
Of course it's freedom! It's Freedom for the Right People. They are the ones who deserve it. Everyone else deserves only the back of the hand.
Correct. Freedom for citizens of our country and those foreign guests we allow to remain here. Other guests are here conditionally, and must leave when we ask them to. Those who are here illegally must leave immediately, or be forced out. This is how it works everywhere in the world. It's called "being a nation".
So, which is more important:
Having a bunch of people who have substantial cultural similarities with each other, or
Having a government which respects the rights and liberties of ALL people, even those who are non-citizens?
No foreigner has any right to enter or remain in our country. That is a privilege we extend, and can withdraw.
The first, assuming all are legally here.
That is even a question?
NO LIVING WAGES FOR FARM WORKERS! KEEP PRICES DOWN!
Please tell me you're being sarcastic. If not I'll add it to the ever growing list of things Trump defenders have in common with the leftist they hate.
You, ironically, wouldn't know what the hell sarcasm was if it slapped you in the face.
KICK OUT THE INVADERS! I DON'T GIVE A SHIT ABOUT ECONOMICS, I WANT MY CULTURAL PURITY!
WHO WILL PICK THE COTTON!?!
THAT'S WHY DARKIES WERE BORN!
And thank God for that.
No country should have economics dictate policy solely.
Look people.
America has to be made safe for the people who matter, you know, the “normal people”, like God-fearing straight white Christian male citizens. It is the duty of the government to sweep away the riff-raff so that the normies can go about their daily lives without having to worry about illegals running rampant. Why can’t you all understand this?
The whole purpose of government is to make sure that the taxpayers get what they want. And by "taxpayers", what I really mean is, "the people in the heartland who really don't pay that much in taxes but who think that they do". They are the only ones who REALLY have any semblance of rights. So if they say that the riff-raff get deported to a third-world torture camp, then that's what should happen.
Just because you’re a non-white, non-christian, non-male doesn’t mean you’re above the law.
Contrary to the BS leftard indoctrination teaches.
No, it's the opposite. Straight white Christian men are above the law. They get to do whatever they want, and if they do happen to break the law, then it's only because the law itself is wrong, it's a political persecution, left-wing corrupt DAs and judges are corrupt, etc. But if some illegal INVADER picks strawberries in the field in California, then it's totally right to round him up and send him to a third-world gulag even if he isn't violating anyone's rights. Because INVADER.
Your hyperbole is escaping the gravitational force of a black hole.
I thought I was good but, man..
You could launch something into geosynchronous into with that velocity.
I am not so sure it is hyperbole.
I mean, they give Trump the infinite benefit of the doubt. And I do mean infinite. There is literally nothing that Trump could do that they would not defend on some level. I mean, he's going to have a goddamn Soviet-style military parade on Saturday and they are 100% in favor.
I do think that THEY think that they are entitled to be in charge. Not really that they think that they are entitled to break any law, but more that they think that they are entitled to set the rules, as well as entitled to decide on exceptions to the rules if they so choose. So for TEAM MAGA, sure they set rules, but if they break the rules, then they decide that they were justified because of "corrupt judges" or "political persecution" or "saving the Republic" or whatever other rationalization that they can think of. But for THE OTHERS, then there are no exceptions. THE LAW IS THE LAW, don't you see? They will demand all of the Constitutional protections for themselves, but they are completely fine with the most absurd of farcical 'due process' for everyone else, like Garcia.
It is not about "rule of law". It is about "rule of the elect". And they are the "elect".
Do you support the pardons of ALL of the Jan. 6 rioters, even the ones who were violent?
Because if your answer is "yes", then you have zero moral standing to talk about "rule of law" or "respect for the law".
Fatass lying pedo jeffsarc.
What violence? Slapping helmets?
The one broken window ended up with a blank-point shooting.
And Yes. I think even J6'ers who vandalized, stole (was there any?) or assaulted police should be charged for such. Not prosecuting people who weren't even there or 20-year prison sentences for tossing a fire extinguisher off a stage.
Try telling this to Laken Riley.
We know....you Dems never got over your hard-ons for having slaves.
"Law and Order is Chaos!", Reason Magazine.
They should have self-deported.
Agents were chasing and apprehending workers in the early hours of the morning.
I really feel like we deserve a better video of that. Like with really good audio capture. I came here hoping for a half-dozen border jumpers running screaming through the fields shouting in a cacophony of gibberish that's not English as agents just run them down without mercy. Like, Agent America tackles him bodily and Border Jumper Jose is yanked up in flexcuffs spitting out a mouth full of dirt and bleeding from several superficial injuries.
That would be awesome. I would binge watch that all day long.
"They're just taking innocent people who are trying to build their own American Dream," said Daniel Larios with the UFW Foundation. "This is not law enforcement. It's a campaign of fear against people whose only 'crime' is living and working in the U.S."
Illegally.
"These are people who are going to be afraid to take their kids to school, afraid to go to graduation, afraid to go to the grocery store," said Strater.
Not too late to self-deport. All the fear disappears when you do the right thing.
Losing such a significant portion of the farm workforce due to ICE detention, deportation, or fear will likely lead to severe supply-chain disruptions, closed agricultural businesses, and higher prices for American consumers until the industry can adapt.
We'll weather it. Your COVID shenanigans taught us that not only can we, that it's really not all that hard.
https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/markets/california-farmers-say-state-s-strict-rules-on-technology-mean-already-high-food-prices-will-only-get-worse/ar-AA1GcP9u?ocid=msedgntp&pc=DCTS&cvid=c83bd119794e445d8331c07b74031467&ei=92
CA deserves all of the misery.