ICE Is Trying To Deport a Harvard Medical School Researcher Over Frog Embryos
An immigration judge found the official document initiating Kseniia Petrova’s deportation to be legally deficient. She remains in detention, unable to further her cancer research.

This week, an immigration judge found the official document initiating the deportation of Kseniia Petrova, a Russian-born Harvard Medical School researcher, failed to meet legal standards. Petrova has been in Immigration and Customs Enforcement's (ICE) custody since February. She is challenging the cancellation of her J-1 scholar visa while seeking asylum due to the threat of persecution she faces in Russia. The judge asked the government to file additional information to support deportation, and a hearing to assess the validity of Petrova's deportation charge has been set for late July.
Petrova was initially taken into ICE custody on February 16 at Boston Logan International Airport while returning from a work trip. She had flown to France to pick up frog embryo samples from a partner research lab for her research on cancer detection. Petrova did not declare the samples and was detained by Customs and Border Protection (CBP). Petrova "was lawfully detained after lying to federal officers about carrying substances into the country," including "petri dishes, containers of unknown substances, and loose vials of embryonic frog cells," according to the Department of Homeland Security (DHS).
In cases like these, CBP typically confiscates undeclared items and issues a fine of $50 to $500, Gregory Romanovsky, Petrova's attorney, told MSNBC. Instead, Petrova was taken into custody and her scholar visa was canceled. Romanovsky believes Petrova's arrest is "part of a broader effort to create an unwelcoming and hostile environment for noncitizens." He is representing Petrova in a lawsuit against DHS alleging that her visa cancellation and subsequent detention are unlawful. Although DHS accuses Petrova of "knowingly breaking the law and took deliberate steps to evade it" when she chose to "smuggle" research samples into the U.S., Romanovsky is pushing for her release. He told NBC News that she's a victim of a new, indiscriminate policy of refusing release, despite Petrova not being a flight risk or a risk to the community. Instead, "she's just taking up bed space."
Petrova has also requested asylum for fear of persecution should she return to Russia. Before coming to the U.S., she was arrested for protesting against the war in Ukraine and now fears further persecution and jail time if she returns to Russia. But even if an immigration judge grants her asylum, the appeals process could keep her in continued detention.
While Petrova sits in custody awaiting answers, researchers at Harvard Medical School's Kirschner Lab cannot continue with their cancer research without Petrova's expertise. The lab is currently developing a microscope, whose computer script was developed by Petrova, that could drastically improve early cancer detection, according to one of her co-workers.
Petrova's case represents a growing trend causing many international students to fear immigration backlash. Under the Trump administration, over 1,800 international students have lost their F-1 or J-1 student statuses, according to a tracking database by Inside Higher Ed, with little explanation as to why.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Hey, dumbass, that’s what happens when you lie to customs agents. They do not look kindly upon undeclared animal and plant products, including these frog embryo among the other items she tried to smuggle in. She’s an idiot who earned her plight the hard way.
CAn't you read knuckldragging cultist? Cases like this result in confiscation and a fine. But THANK YOU for saving us from this dangerous lady! SCREAM about murdrer gang members while you ignore this bullshit. FUCKING CLOWNS ALL OF YOU
You didn’t complain when Biden held the J6 political prisoners in prison you hypocrite. That means you can’t complain about Trump imprisoning immigrants without charges, and because Democrats did it first it’s ok when Trump does it.
And can you believe the nerve of that judge asking for information? That smells like due process. Only leftists support due process. That judge should be impeached.
Hey, Sarc, how about you try to take some undeclared plant products into New Brunswick, I triple dog dare you, and see what happens at customs.
Better yet, try smuggling maple syrup out of Canada and see what happens.
He said the thing! Drink!
He's paid by the character count.
No, that would be Jesse. Tell you what. I'll post exactly zero more characters today because I've got better things to do than argue with Trump defending douchebags who will excuse literally anything the man does. As he said, he could murder someone in broad daylight and you would still defend him.
Lol. Is this like when you said you were rarely here?
If I'm on mute how do you know sarc?
In one thread you claim you're for the rule of law. In this thread an obvious violation by a foreigner you aren't.
Weird.
If you hate being called a raging leftist hypocrite, don't br a fucking raging leftist hypocrite.
Sounds pretty stupid, but also sounds like typical bureaucratic blunder, and she did lie to customs. I hope she wins, and they ought to let her out. She wasn't trying to hide, didn't change her name, wasn't caught driving a van full of illegal immigrants cross country.
But she lied to customs, and you'd think an immigrant on a visa of all people would think twice before doing that, especially a month after Trump was inaugurated and had already begun cracking down on Biden's illegal immigrants.
Is this the worst you can dredge up of an example of Trump's disastrous effect on legal good immigrants? Kinda undermines the case for rampant abuse.
>>Petrova did not declare the samples and was detained by Customs and Border Protection (CBP).
don't. date. robots.
Petrova did not declare the samples
What could possibly be wrong with that?....
anyone remember the ending of 12 Monkeys?
The movie or the TV series?
great twilight zone lesson considering it was the 90s
Why not just use an express delivery service?
She was so close. Now frogs will still have to worry about the scourge of cancer.
J-1 scholar visa ... seeking asylum due to the threat of persecution
OK, see, now this is precisely the kind of garbage that America is done with. We're sick to death of people crying wolf and demanding "asylum" from it. It's a BALD-FACED LIE COMING OUT OF THESE PEOPLE'S MOUTHS. And in this case, it's provable!
Because RETURN INTENT IS A CORE REQUIREMENT FOR OBTAINING A J-1!!!
I'll bet you didn't know that, did you Reason. I'll bet you never even thought to ask the question. How exactly can she be claiming "fear of persecution" of a place she SWORE - as a condition of obtaining her visa - she intends to return to?
Autumn? Anybody? Bueller?
And this is why nobody cares. This is why the extreme majority is no longer splitting hairs when it comes to non-citizens in this country. This is why Trump especially doesn't care if you're a border jumping wife-beating gang-member, a student visa holder advocating terrorism on a State-funded campus, or a J-1 scholar actually doing research. It's not an issue where most folks are "good people" and there's just a few bad apples that are the exception to the rule. America has opened its eyes and wised up: it's the other way around. And, frankly, we're past the point of caring whether the dragnet scoops up a few "good people" exceptions while it's mass-deporting the majority of bad apples.
Also, let's not forget the fact that we're talking about someone who intentionally lied to CBP about smuggling in biological samples in a post-COVID world. I mean, come on. This broad is ASKING for deportation.
Toss her in CECOT before any pissant bureaucrats can get their act together. We'll figure it out later. Or we won't. Who cares.
America has opened its eyes and wised up: it's the other way around.
I keep bringing up Raspail but the guy nailed it to a T more than 50 yrs. ago. Even a good portion of near-literally suicidal natives, of multiple races, will enable and even celebrate rape and murder by immigrants to avoid the potential stigma of *being perceived* as potentially thinking less of specific groups of people.
The expectation is completely immoral and there's no living up to it even if there weren't and, again, that's 50 yrs. and running. The idea that the whole affair hinges on one El Salvadoran wife beater would be laughable if it weren't so horribly tragic.
TF are you talking about idiot? This is not about murder or rape. You fucking cult tards are embarrasiing.
He didn't say it was about murder or rape. He said it was about how much abuse and injustice foolish people will accept in the name of "tolerance and diversity" out of fear of being stigmatized as intolerant or xenophobic. (AWFL's fall prey to this more than anyone else.)
You may have seen me discuss this before. I use the term Toxic Virtue. Others use Weaponized Empathy. It's essentially the propensity for bad actors with malicious intent to use good people's virtues against them, or trying to guilt them into compliance and submission by bastardizing said virtues.
In simple terms, "Jesus says turn the other cheek. Do it so I can slap you in it." Well that's not what Jesus meant, and the person threatening the slap knows it. But he's trying to use a person's belief in Jesus as a weapon against them.
It's the most cowardly and shameful form of manipulation. And that's what MC was pointing out. With the illustrated example of a border-jumping wife-beating gangbanger criminal being the scumbag folks like you would have us all "empathize" with. Like, that's the best person you can come up with to advocate your toxic virtue and weaponized empathy.
Go screw yourself. Americans are wise to your con now. Nobody cares anymore. Get the illegals out, and put your liberal tears about it in the jar.
BREAKING NEWSWisconsin judge Hannah Dugan arrested by FBI for helping illegal migrant 'evade arrest'
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14648203/Wisconsin-judge-arrested-FBI-helping-illegal-migrant-evade-arrest.html
A Wisconsin Democratic judge was arrested on the job for allegedly helping an undocumented migrant evade arrest.
Milwaukee County circuit judge Hannah Dugan is accused of obstructing the arrest of Eduardo Flores Ruiz, 30. She was taken into custody Friday at the Milwaukee County Courthouse.
Bitch better not get any due process. She needs to go to prison indefinitely without charges. That's what Biden did to the J6 patriots. Time for Trump to return the favor.
Yet another law sarc doesn't want prosecuted despite claiming he is for the law against conservatives.
Leftist fucking hypocrite.
Voters give Trump shock new approval rating as he nears first 100 days in power: Live updates
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14647677/donald-trump-approval-rating-100-days-tariffs-time-magazine.html
According to a new Reuters/Ipsos poll, his backing is at 42 percent with only 37 percent approving of his handling of the economy.
That differs from DailyMail.com's exclusive poll out last week that found Trump is at 54 percent approval, tied with his highest-ever rating in February.
The polls are obviously fraudulent attempts to change peoples' minds about Trump. The pollsters need to be put in prison for fraud. Just lock them up. They forfeited their due process when they lied about Trump.
The polling after mass propaganda to effect retards like you? Lol. Show us the economic data and not the MSNBC fear mongering.
Jesse do you think Trump is doing a good job with the economy?
He's doing just fine with it. His attempt to fix decades of negative global trade theory has led to ever increasing welfare, due to offshoring of jobs, lowest share of gdp by the bottom 50% since the 70s, created the supply chain havic we saw during and post covid, etc.
Here's what some of you don't understand and what I find really amusing.
A 30 year decade long trade deficit can only be achieved through inflationary policies. Full stop. Yet the primary cries are inflation! The Feds literally peg a 2.5% inflationary goal. This is to make debt cheaper foe the government but also to mask the trade deficits.
If we were on a gold standard we would be fucked. If we didn't have the ability to hide our manipulations through being the reserve currency, we would be fucked.
Here is the other part that most people who don't work manufacturing or work solely service related jobs don't realize, risks are booked as costs. So when you increase supply chain risk by offshoring everything, the costs on the books increases. We realized these costs during covid.
Then there is the political cost due to becoming reliant on other countries. China has been public that this is their goal. They buy and close down manufacturing in other countries, see steel in Britain. Dependency is always a cost. What's truly funny about this is the very people who cheered this Dependency recognize the risk because they continue to claim the US can scale back up with the tariffs.
Finally there have been announcements for over 1.5T in investments from these acts. Something almost completely ignored by reason and media.
Meanwhile all the predictions haven't come to pass. They are so lacking in negative economic data they are citing businesses that closed before tariffs took effect.
The ATL fed, not a Maga outfit, projected the estimated inflation from the full tariffs at under 1%
Long term the us will stabilize and become more self sufficient reducing unseen costs.
And if you're truly curious, a lot of what's going on now was hypothesized and proven decades ago, optimal tariff theory.
Of course I really come at this from thr NAP and game theory. And decades of economic algorithmic trade games. Not responding to bad actors is always a bad outcome in these theories and games. The optimal outcome in the games is always tit for tat or a variation of it. This has been on the forward edge of economics since the 80s.
HAHAHA you did not say ANY OF THIS before he did you goosestepping fucking cult clown!!
In English and with logic please.
Been saying this for a decade dumbass. There are articles during Obamas term i say the same shit retard.
EXCLUSIVE Harvard doctor: I was on the cusp of a cure for cancer, then Trump cut my funding... now thousands could die needlessly
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-14640535/Harvard-doctor-Trump-cut-funding-cure.html
Cancer research is leftist. Fuck this guy.
Dr John Quackenbush...
The jokes write themselves.
The 63-year-old scientist who has been a professor at the prestigious university for the last 20 years explained that the about $2.4 million research project was meant to find personalized and improved treatments for both sexes.
Doesn't sound like anything near a cure. It does sound like an excuse for Harvard to steal more taxes.
Wow. You're retarded enough to believe that claim lol.
Just like you were for masks and covid deaths.
If he is as close as he claims you don't think anyone would pay him to finish it?
You're a fucking retard.
I don’t think she should be in detention.
However it is very very common for academics to transport lab samples between countries in their personal luggage without declaring it. They should not do this.
She’s not going to cure cancer. Every academic is convinced that their new project is the key. It never is.
She is challenging the cancellation of her J-1 scholar visa while seeking asylum due to the threat of persecution she faces in Russia.
The magic phrase. "Threat of persecution".
This one looks more like "threat of prosecution in Russia".
She tried smuggling biological materials through customs...
What the fuck is wrong with you reason.
Wonder how cooperative or apologetic she was with the ICE officials at Logan. If started going apeshit when they questioned her about the samples, then it makes sense they took action. I don’t agree with deporting her, but this could have ended differently I think.
She was carrying the samples from France "at the request of her boss at Harvard".
Harvard was afraid to advocate for her at the time of the incident because they were still trying to negotiate with the administration regarding all of Trump's demands for changes at Harvard.
https://archive.is/WEywk
She still failed to declare them at customs and fill out the paperwork.
That's correct. She was apparently unfamiliar with the process.
As the plane sat on the tarmac, she texted back and forth with Dr. Peshkin, trying to confirm how she should handle the package in customs. But by then, the passengers were already filing off the plane, he said, and Ms. Petrova cut short the conversation.
Ignorance of the process can be an excuse for failing to follow it properly, but it is not an excuse to avoid any punishment for the violation.
Have you ever traveled internationally?
Almost every customs has massive signs regarding biological items.
Does anybody remember the Wuhan kerfuffle? Biological samples really? Would she declare a suitcase nuke?
Every country deports you for this even with a visa.
IME, the failure is academia and it's been obvious for [checks link metata] 13 yrs. if not longer.
Here's Sabine Hossenfelder more recently, touching on the same fundamental issue (which she does several times in other videos), that these people are being paid, not to generate breakthroughs, but merely to be ignorant of the real world and insulated from real life and the consequences of their own actions.
“Well, he’s just sending them back home. If their home decides to put them in jail that’s on them.”
Most are from Venezuela. El Salvador isn’t home.
“Well, who cares? If El Salvador decides to put them in prison that’s on them.”
Trump hired El Salvador expressly to put them in prison. They’re in prison because he made that happen and he’s using your money to imprison them.
“Maybe they shouldn’t have broken the law?”
There’s no evidence they did. The USA didn’t charge them with anything or formally accuse them of anything. They simply rounded up immigrants because they looked suspicious to ICE officers and put them in prison.
“Well, they weren’t here legally. So it’s good.”
Says who? They were never given the ability to prove they were here legally. And attorneys for many of the victims have indicated they were here legally. Their assertions haven’t been refuted and the state won’t hear their case in court.
Besides, if the worst they’ve done is be here illegally, why do you think putting them in prison for life is a just punishment for that?
It’s not even a crime.
“But they’re in gangs. Why do you want gang members here?”
There’s no evidence they were in gangs. Maybe some were, maybe some weren’t. Do you think it’s good for a cop to simply say you’re in a gang and then toss you in prison for life?
“That’s different. I’m a citizen. I get different rights!”
If you’re going to appeal to rights guaranteed by the state, you’re wrong. The constitution is clear that due process is owed to all people, not just citizens. And the courts have routinely upheld that.
“I’m tired of them using my tax money to be here in the first place.”
It’s debatable on whether they were.
What’s not debatable is your tax money IS being used to imprison them.
“It’s a good deterrent, though. That way other migrants don’t come.”
Do you think having a government imprison innocent people as a deterrent is how you get a free society?
Do you just want a dictator that can punish whoever he wants whenever he wants, even for breaking no laws? Do you think that will end well for you later on when other people wield the same power but have different goals than you?
Found one.
https://x.com/IfindRetards
Maduro refused repatriation. Blame him.
Hey, dipshit, let's compromise and send them halfway back.
Petrova was initially taken into ICE custody on February 16 at Boston Logan International Airport while returning from a work trip.
Plate O' Shrimp (or frog legs as the case may be):
Way back in the olden days I used to work for a biotech company that worked with metal nanoparticles. International packages would routinely get delayed because the solutions just don't "look normal" to the human eye (imagine you bend down to look through the bottles in the link and discover, without touching them, that the bottle on the right is actually more clear than the one on the left) and, if you put them through an X-ray machine, scatter the fuck out of X-rays... like they were made of metal. Just weird. I think FedEx as the only carrier that didn't *generally* hold our packages.
I say "back in the olden days" because one of our lead researchers was from India, here on a work visa, and he was (somewhat understandably) delayed/detained in Logan on 9/11/01.
So, I can only assume that even before Trump... even before 9/11... flying in or out of an airport, on a visa, while carrying weird shit that you don't declare was not a "Nah, it'll be fine!" proposition. Also, academics, Ph.D.s, post-docs, and 8th yr. grad students are some of the people I would put at the top of my list of 'most likely to literally say "Nah, it'll be fine!", walk into such a situation, and be befuddled by the outcome'.
'Petrova was initially taken into ICE custody on February 16 at Boston Logan International Airport while returning from a work trip. She had flown to France to pick up frog embryo samples from a partner research lab for her research on cancer detection. Petrova did not declare the samples and was detained by Customs and Border Protection (CBP).'
LAWFARE!
Best you can say for this lady is that she's not particularly bright. First she goes to Russia and advocates for Ukraine. Then she tries to smuggle biological samples into the US. Now she claims she can't go back to Russia because she supports their enemy. Looks like she has painted herself into a corner and wants a court to get her out. If she wants to be an American she could have started the citizenship process. But she didn't. Now she's a woman without a country but she can't stay here forever. Maybe France will take her.
Harvard Medical School Researchers ARE ABOVE immigration law!!! /s
Then this, that, those, gangsters and everyone else will be ABOVE immigration law!!! /s
Then the USA will be destroyed by invading [Na]tional So[zi]alist minds. As if that isn't already happening.