Another Legal Resident Faces Deportation for Vague Allegations That They Support Terrorists
The Trump administration keeps arresting legal immigrants with views they don't like.

Yet another legal U.S. resident is facing deportation for nebulous claims that they have expressed support for terrorism.
A Georgetown University postdoctoral student was arrested by immigration officials and sent to a detention facility in Louisiana—all because of his wife's "identity as a Palestinian and her constitutionally protected speech," according to a legal document obtained by the Associated Press.
Badar Khan Suri is an Indian citizen studying as a postdoctoral fellow at the Alwaleed Bin Talal Center for Muslim-Christian Understanding. He was arrested by Homeland Security agents outside his home in Virginia on Monday night, according to the A.P.
"Suri was a foreign exchange student at Georgetown University actively spreading Hamas propaganda and promoting antisemitism on social media," Homeland Security Assistant Secretary Tricia McLaughlin said in a Wednesday post on X. "Suri has close connections to a known or suspected terrorist, who is a senior advisor to Hamas. The Secretary of State issued a determination on March 15, 2025 that Suri's activities and presence in the United States rendered him deportable."
On Thursday, a judge ruled that Suri could not be deported without due process, ordering that he "shall not be removed from the United States unless and until the Court issues a contrary order."
As of Friday morning, it's unclear what speech the Trump administration is using to justify deportation proceedings against Suri, nor is it clear the nature of his alleged connection to a senior Hamas adviser. But The Washington Post reported that the "advisor to Hamas" is likely a reference to Suri's wife, "a U.S. citizen who once worked with the Gaza foreign ministry and whose father, Ahmed Yousef, is a former political advisor to the now-deceased Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh."
In a statement to CBS News, a Georgetown spokesperson said that the school "[has] not received a reason for his detention," adding that, "We support our community members' rights to free and open inquiry, deliberation and debate, even if the underlying ideas may be difficult, controversial or objectionable. We expect the legal system to adjudicate this case fairly."
This is far from the first time a legal U.S. resident has faced deportation for shaky allegations that they supported terrorists. Earlier this month, Columbia University student activist Mahmoud Khalil was arrested by Immigration and Customs Enforcement, with Trump administration officials justifying his detention on the grounds that activists at pro-Palestine protests he organized passed out pro-Hamas flyers. Last week, a Brown University physician was deported to Lebanon after border officials alleged that she had attended the funeral of assassinated Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah.
"The Trump Administration has openly expressed its intention to weaponize immigration law to punish noncitizens whose views are deemed critical of U.S. policy as it relates to Israel," Suri's lawyer wrote in a legal document obtained by the A.P., adding that the deportation is "plainly intended as retaliation and punishment for Mr. Suri's protected speech."
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Oh. How terrible.
Now, something important. What shall I have for breakfast?
Last week, a Brown University physician was deported to Lebanon after border officials alleged that she had attended the funeral of assassinated Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah.
Emma, I understand that you may well be too stupid to comprehend the difference between "deported to Lebanon" and "refused re-entry from Lebanon", or the difference between "border officials alleged" and "she admitted". But most people aren't.
"Last week, a Brown University physician was refused re-entry from Lebanon after she admitted that she had attended the funeral of assassinated Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah."
It's funny how severely the sentence changes when it's restated accurately, isn't it?
all because of his wife's "identity as a Palestinian and her constitutionally protected speech,"
Hunh, I wonder if it's really as straightforward as her simply being Palestinian and engaging in constitutionally protected speech.
"a U.S. citizen who once worked with the Gaza foreign ministry and whose father, Ahmed Yousef, is a former political advisor to the now-deceased Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh."
Oh! She worked for the terrorist government, and she's related to someone who was a political advisor to terrorists! Well, gosh. That sounds like a pretty decent reason to 86 everyone she's close with, who is in the club on a guest pass.
And if they deport her husband, maybe she'll go with him.
I am not sure if Emma Camp fully understands what "vague" means.
I am sure Emma Camp doesn't understand much, if anything.
Bacon.
That was my conclusion as well.
Yes, I noticed you had excellent carnivore taste. I made my comment in homage.
Bacon, a thicker cut.
English Breakfast sausages
Steak
Fried eggs
Baked Beans
Fried tomatoes
Fried mushrooms
Buttered toast or fried bread
Oatmeal
Pancakes
Waffles
Yogurt
Coffee and milk tea
Zionists need to be listed on the terrorist list too including Trump and Biden as well as many more of our own homegrown nut cases.
OK Adolf
See Harisiades v. Shaughnessy
The US has an inconceivably restricted notion of what a 'free press' should be allowed to talk about when it comes to the Middle East. The Israeli press provides magnitudes more information to its citizens - and it is completely (and I suppose understandably) driven by a propaganda agenda. The US can only produce useful idiots - people like the commentariat here who are happy to be stupid about anything related to this particular subject. There is no reason for a 1st amendment here in the US - so no reason why there's much objection to it when there are threats to it.
Reason is just part of that dumbing down. The only concern about the deportations - and the increasingly clear threat to US citizens - is 'what about open borders'? ok.
JewFree wants to discuss how evil jews are. Shocking.
I strongly encourage JFree to go to Israel and participate directly in the Intifada.
I’ll help chip in for the one-way plane fare.
I'll go halvesies.
If I had a poodle, it would go Arf Arf rrrrr arfarfarf.
And with more intelligence than you.
You can't even spell Arafat correctly.
Lol. Now he is using the same insults as jeff and sarc. It is amazing how all you antisemitic leftists adopt each other's language.
And Hamas should unconditionally surrender to end the "genocide". Reason and any other Western media outlet can't control Hamas's refusal to unconditionally surender.
Residency is not a right for foreigners. It is really that fucking simple.
The USSC has held up bans due to viewpoints for centuries such as for communists and cat Steven's.
Reason really does believe the US needs to import their enemies.
Last election shows that. Several million at least.
Reason wants more like minds
LOL you are using the commie red scare to support your position?!? You fucking idiots are hilarious at least!
quoting the defendant's attorney and not posting the relevant weaponized immigration laws seems something something.
When I willingly visit other people's homes, I try not to say or do things that would make them want to throw me out.
See, there's the answer. Refugees did not willingly visit, they were virtually kidnapped, so they can say anything they want.
The secretary of state made a determination which is the only due process required. Don't like it change the law in Congress. District court judges have no power to change laws.
That's news to them!
But do you really care? No. If they were citizens, you still wouldn't care.
That's the whole point of going after these unpleasant and unsympathetic types - to soften up the citizenry for further incursions on liberty and to remove constitutional checks and balances.
I am sure that if Krasnov purported to remove US citizenship from naturalised Americans with left-wing views on nebulous and untested claims of national interest, you and the other cultists would have no problem with that,
Look at how shrike has to deny reality and facts to try to make an appeal to morality. A losers argument lol.
What did he say that was incorrect shrike?
"No. If they were citizens, you still wouldn't care"
Trump's wife, Vance's in-laws, Patel's parents, Musk's Musk, etcetera, etcetera are all legal immigrants, but shills like this fuck need you to believe it's all about xenophobia because they have no actual fucking argument.
If they were not married or otherwise connected to the right people, you and he wouldn't care. And AFAICT the people you mention are not inherently unpleasant and unsympathetic (at least, not as much as some of these activists - and tat was whom I was talking about, you cretin.
Had the secretary of state used 8 USC 1227 (a)(4)(C)(i) "An alien whose presence or activities in the United States the Secretary of State has reasonable ground to believe would have potentially serious adverse foreign policy consequences for the United States is deportable" back in 2001 on several foreign students attending flight schools in the US om visas and a district court judge ruled they cannot use that law, and ultimately lead to those students taking over airplanes and killing over 3000 people in one day and beginning a decades long war that lead to more death and destruction, would you criticize the district court judge?
That is exactly what judges do. They rule on the constitutionality of law. They rule on if laws are followed as written as well.
The Alwaleed Bin Talal Center for Muslim-Christian Understanding soon to be known as the Alwaleed Bin Talal Center for Christian Sprawled Under our Muslim Feet.
Another vague and nebulous.
Emma please define.
Because you used vague, when the immigrant in question attended the funeral of the main Hamas leader. And now its nebulous that a man who supports Hamas and is married to the daughter of a Hamas Leader is nebulous.
You have a person who watched the towers fall and who hated Bush (rightfully) for Iraq and Patriot Act questioning his long held beliefs every time you write in favor of Hamas. And I'm an Irish/German Catholic, who doesn't have a horse in the Israeli Palestinian race.
Obama was called a deporter in chief for sending back foreign nationals caught near the border. Apparently, all of them were guaranteed a trial by jury and Obama violated their rights. These judges are making up their own rules.
The conservative media, although hostile to anti America Muslims, actually practice journalism when reporting on these supposed victims. Did Reason actually HEAR what Khalil and what his group said? There are literally videos.
Replace Hamas with the KKK. Replace Suri with some European white guy named Bill Jones whose wife was an advisor to the head of the Memphis chapter of the KKK. Now make the argument that we should grant him citizenship is deference to his 1A protected speech.
Do you guys realize that these people are a threat to the Jewish community, and by extension, every other non Jews in the country? Because Hamas is a TERRORIST organization, and spreading their propaganda is not the same thing as simply ranting "Israel is guilty of genocide"?
It all comes back to the Jew question here, huh? Yeah, I remember Shelden Richman.
There were several foreign students on visas in the US back in 2000 and 2001. They attended flight schools. Had the secretary of state utilized 8 USC 1227 (a)(4)(C)(i) back then maybe they wouldn't have been able to take over planes and fly them into buildings and a field in PA, ultimately killing over 3000 people in one day and beginning a decades long war that led to even more death and destruction. Or would you wanted a judge to determine the secretary of state doesnt have the authority to make those determinations as outlined by 8 USC 1227 (a)(4)(C)(i) "An alien whose presence or activities in the United States the Secretary of State has reasonable ground to believe would have potentially serious adverse foreign policy consequences for the United States is deportable."
We should be helping the Israeli people clear out the genocidal zionist ratfucks that have taken over their country. Unfortunately those same ratficks have taken over ours too.
Buh-bye bish
A Georgetown University postdoctoral student was arrested by immigration officials and sent to a detention facility in Louisiana—all because of his wife's "identity as a Palestinian" ... Suri has close connections to a known or suspected terrorist, who is a senior advisor to Hamas.
I mean, what do you want me to say here?
Lay down with dogs, wake up with fleas. For pete's sake.
He's out.
Put a bullet in the wife. Head or kneecap, I doubt anyone really cares which.
How do you clown world retards at Reason NOT understand that this is the overwhelmingly supported mandate of the American People? Do you NOT get that Americans are in full-on FAFO mode right now? And if you think they're going to start sympathizing with ACTUAL TERRORISTS or their kin like you do, after the mayhem of the Biden Shadow Administration, you are hopelessly stuck in your bubble and not paying attention to the rest of the world at all.
I'm not a MAGA, and I'm sure as heck not a Leftist. But I'm not so hopelessly insulated and ensconced in my echo chambers that I can't take the pulse of this nation and feel the way the winds are blowing.
You done messed up big with the Biden Shadow Administration and its Legacy Media enablers/liars. Now the right is coming for blood. And they are done with everyone like you and Reason, Emma. (And the real kick in the face is, over and over it's turning out that they're a whole lot smarter than you are.)
NOBODY cares about the fact that he's a "legal U.S. resident" or that they're "nebulous claims." They're DONE with the nonsense. They know the wolves are inside the fence line, and they mean to do something about it.
Their loudest and most unified directive is simple: get these kinds of people OUT of this country. Until you come out of your echo chamber and wrap your brain around this, your articles will continue to make ZERO sense at all, further degrade Reason's reputation, and cause every single person who reads it to distrust ANYTHING you have to say on anything.
WAKE. UP.
IF IF IF this is true , you are defending a MONSTER
In one now-deleted post, he reportedly denied reports of the Hamas attack on southern Israel on October 7, 2023.
'Three lies by Israeli occupation, no proof whatsoever of babies beheaded, rapes or mass killing at carnival,' the postdoctoral student, who also teaches a class on majority and minority rights in South Asia, wrote at the time, according to Campus Watch.
In another post from years ago, Suri reportedly expressed support for Hamas founder Sheikh Ahmed Yasin.
He is said to have posted a video saying, 'This is what Hamas argues. Sheikh Yaseen giving the reasons why his group is fighting for their land which was stolen.'
=====> Suri even reportedly posted a video showing Hamas terrorists holding Israeli child hostages, writing: 'This is how Hamas men deal with kids on Oct. 7.' <===== would justify immediate deportation
But : IF IF IF
“Legal Resident” is not the same as “Citizen”. You only have the privilege of residing here until someone with authority decides you don’t.