Reason.com - Free Minds and Free Markets
Reason logo Reason logo
  • Latest
  • Magazine
    • Current Issue
    • Archives
    • Subscribe
    • Crossword
  • Video
    • Reason TV
    • The Reason Roundtable
    • Just Asking Questions
    • Free Media
    • The Reason Interview
  • Podcasts
    • All Shows
    • The Reason Roundtable
    • The Reason Interview With Nick Gillespie
    • The Soho Forum Debates
    • Just Asking Questions
  • Volokh
  • Newsletters
  • Donate
    • Donate Online
    • Donate Crypto
    • Ways To Give To Reason Foundation
    • Torchbearer Society
    • Planned Giving
  • Subscribe
    • Reason Plus Subscription
    • Gift Subscriptions
    • Print Subscription
    • Subscriber Support

Login Form

Create new account
Forgot password

Israel

A Year Since the Massacre

Plus: Adams administration corruption, Fauci in hindsight, Taiwan's nuclear mistake, and more...

Liz Wolfe | 10.7.2024 9:37 AM

Share on FacebookShare on XShare on RedditShare by emailPrint friendly versionCopy page URL Add Reason to Google
Media Contact & Reprint Requests
Two protesters hold an Israeli flag. | Salvador Ceja | Dreamstime.com
(Salvador Ceja | Dreamstime.com)

One year since that awful day: Exactly one year ago, Hamas rushed into Israel and massacred more than 1,200 people, abducting 250. About 100 hostages in Gaza are not accounted for—either imprisoned or dead, held by terrorists who won't return either the living captives or their bodies to their families.

Following the attack, Israel invaded Gaza; so far, more than 40,000 Palestinians have been killed in the fighting, per (Hamas-controlled) health authority data. Israel claims it has killed 17,000 Hamas militants; how many deaths are civilians and how many are fighters is obviously important but is hard to reliably determine. Israel's campaign has obliterated vast swaths of the Gaza Strip, and the Israeli military says its goal is to fully wipe out Hamas and those responsible for the pogrom. Now Israeli is also attempting to eradicate Hezbollah, an Iran-backed group in Lebanon with whom they've been exchanging fire for much of the last year. In April, Israel and Iran directly exchanged strikes. Last week, Iran fired 181 ballistic missiles at Israel; it is still awaiting Israel's response.

"We're excelling at eliminating our enemies but failing to save our loved ones," Carmit Palty Katzir, whose brother Elad was one of the killed hostages, told The New York Times at a memorial held at Kibbutz Nir Oz. This sentiment is not unique.

It's not just that Israeli public opinion has at times soured on the war effort, with citizens split on whether Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu should just bring the hostages home versus trying to fully wipe out Hamas. It's also that Israel's north—the border it shares with Lebanon—has been evacuated to varying degrees for the better part of a year, essentially making a significant portion of the territory unlivable. Now it's an active front. And in the wake of Israel's recent ground invasion of Lebanon, all signs suggest that things there will heat up further.

More than 60,000 Israelis in that region have been displaced. "An area equivalent to 2.5 percent of this small country has been transformed into a civilian-free zone, and for an entire year Israel's border has effectively been set by Hezbollah," writes Matti Friedman. "The decision to clear out an entire part of the country will be remembered as one of the most significant Israel made in this war, marking both the collapse of a Zionist principle and the realization of the fantasy of Israel's enemies."


Scenes from New York: The three brothers at the heart of the corruption scandal in Mayor Eric Adams' administration.


QUICK HITS

  • Anthony Fauci "will be remembered as a cautionary tale of what can happen when too much power is invested in a single person for far too long," writes Jay Bhattacharya in Reason. 
  • Russian arms dealers are selling to the Houthis.
  • "The great Florida migration is coming undone," reports The Wall Street Journal.
  • Inside Arizona's plan for bolstering election security.
  • "The Nobel Prize in physiology or medicine was awarded Monday to Americans Victor Ambros and Gary Ruvkun for their discovery of microRNA, tiny pieces of genetic material that alter how genes work at the cellular level and could lead to new ways of treating cancer," reports the Associated Press.
  • Disturbing:

Taiwan is copying Germany's extremely dumb mistake:

It's shutting down all of the country's nuclear power plants.

The island already depends on imported fossil fuel for around 90% of its energy. pic.twitter.com/o7kYoKCyyB

— Alec Stapp (@AlecStapp) October 7, 2024

Start your day with Reason. Get a daily brief of the most important stories and trends every weekday morning when you subscribe to Reason Roundup.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

NEXT: The ‘Day of Jihad’ That Never Came

Liz Wolfe is an associate editor at Reason.

IsraelMiddle EastTerrorismPalestineIranWarPoliticsReason Roundup
Share on FacebookShare on XShare on RedditShare by emailPrint friendly versionCopy page URL Add Reason to Google
Media Contact & Reprint Requests

Hide Comments (201)

Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.

  1. Chumby   1 year ago

    A Muffed Dive

    Captain of the Royal NZ Navy, an alleged lesbian, ran aground the HMNZS Manawanui on a reef off the coast of Samoa. This ship later sank and is now adjacent to DEIvy Jones’ locker. Thankfully, all souls on board have been rescued.

    The ship’s mission was to scan the ocean floor for unexploded WW2 ordinance. You’d think they would have known where the reef was given that the ship looks at the ocean floor. A $100M loss.

    – reported by Lord Bebo et al

    1. Don't look at me!   1 year ago

      Women drivers, amirite?

      1. Quicktown Brix   1 year ago

        It's not that she's a woman, but a lesbian. She has no idea how to work with seamen.

        1. Earth-based Human Skeptic   1 year ago

          Or Navy cox.

        2. MyPublicName   1 year ago

          Nice.

        3. Chumby   1 year ago

          Loose lips sink ships

    2. Randy Sax   1 year ago

      An alleged lesbian?

      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SVRODdXVI3Q

      1. Mother's Lament   1 year ago

        Those two were as good as Monty Python.

      2. Gaear Grimsrud   1 year ago

        Never saw that before. Hilarious!

      3. SRG2   1 year ago

        Excellent!

    3. Idaho-Bob   1 year ago

      DEIvy Jones’ locker

      Awesome! 🙂

    4. Earth-based Human Skeptic   1 year ago

      There goes the NZ Navy boat insurance.

      1. Chumby   1 year ago

        Boaty McLesboat Face hardest hit.

        1. Rev Arthur L kuckland (5-30-24 banana republic day)   1 year ago

          Queue theme
          "the lez boooaaat, soonwel be running aground
          The lez boat, something for only queers

    5. Ska   1 year ago

      Fishing from the reef. Is that like putting from the rough?

    6. Gaear Grimsrud   1 year ago

      Has JD Vance addressed this issue?

      1. Sevo, 5-30-24, embarrassment   1 year ago

        It would be wrong if he did.

    7. Minadin   1 year ago

      I mean, is she an alleged lesbian if she's a woman in the Navy? Seems confirmed. (Also, her wife's name is Sharon)

      https://www.nzdf.mil.nz/media-centre/news/yorkshire-woman-takes-command-of-royal-new-zealand-navy-ship/

      1. Chumby   1 year ago

        If she had served with ground forces, it could have been with a militia Etheridge.

      2. Mother's Lament   1 year ago

        Oh wow, the New Zealand Rear Admiral's name is David Proctor. Just a logist away from having the most apt name ever.

        1. Chumby   1 year ago

          He’s got the right stuff.

  2. Fist of Etiquette   1 year ago

    Anthony Fauci "will be remembered as a cautionary tale of what can happen when too much power is invested in a single person for far too long..."

    As long as that power is lucrative.

    1. Earth-based Human Skeptic   1 year ago

      You know who else made money from being in power too long?

      1. Anomalous   1 year ago

        Nancy Pelosi?

      2. Ajsloss   1 year ago

        Andrew Wiggin?

      3. Chumby   1 year ago

        David Stern?

      4. MyPublicName   1 year ago

        Terrance Howard?

        1. Dillinger   1 year ago

          is that the guy who couldn't understand two on Rogan?

          1. Jefferson Paul   1 year ago

            What did Terrance Howard say? I'm not familiar with that episode of Rogan.

            1. Dillinger   1 year ago

              like in June or July some guy - I'm relatively certain it was TH - argued with a math guy about how he couldn't understand 1+1=2 but 1x1=1 ... it was too stupid to listen to for more than like 3 minutes

              1. Jefferson Paul   1 year ago

                God damn.

                I think it was TH. I remember there was some controversy over that episode, but I never watched it or clips of it.

                1. Dillinger   1 year ago

                  my genius math degree better half threatened to break my ipad if I didn't turn it off lol

        2. EISTAU Gree-Vance   1 year ago

          Howard stern?

      5. InsaneTrollLogic (Factio Democratica delenda est 5/30/24)   1 year ago

        Former Speaker of the Illinois House Michael J. Madigan?

      6. Gaear Grimsrud   1 year ago

        J. Edgar Hoover?

      7. Commenter_XY   1 year ago

        Dan Rostenkowski?

  3. Chumby   1 year ago

    Harris Venn diagram

    * Strategic oil reserves
    * FEMA funds for hurricane relief
    * Willie Brown’s balls

    The intersection of all three: drained

    1. Don't look at me!   1 year ago

      What JD Vance got wrong about Kamala.

    2. InsaneTrollLogic (Factio Democratica delenda est 5/30/24)   1 year ago

      Basically, Kamala sucks.

      1. Ajsloss   1 year ago

        And blows.

  4. Fist of Etiquette   1 year ago

    A Year Since the Massacre

    I think you mean since the literal open air prison finally fought back in a totally acceptable way.

    1. Mother's Lament   1 year ago

      Today marks one year since thousands of Hamas terrorists poured over the border from Gaza into Israel and went on a horrendous spree killing, raping, beheading, maiming, and burning more than 1,200 men, women and children, including infants.

      And yet right here, at least three of clowns celebrate it.

      1. InsaneTrollLogic (Factio Democratica delenda est 5/30/24)   1 year ago

        Misconstrueman
        J(ew)free
        Herr Misek

        I’m sure I’m missing someone, but surprised Strawcasmic hasn’t white knighted them yet.

        1. Mother's Lament   1 year ago

          Don't be surprised because Strawcasmic has indeed white knighted for them and has done a little PR for Hamas himself.

          1. JesseAz (5-30 Banana Republic Day)   1 year ago

            He loves his google searches (never reading the articles, just the link names) and corporate media narratives for sure.

            Or whatever jeffshrike tells him.

      2. EISTAU Gree-Vance   1 year ago

        mtruman says the “gratuitous” killings and rapings were not done by hamas, (who were bravely confronting the IDF) but by other Palestinians looking to get in on the fun.

        I don’t think he was actually trying to justify glassing the entire strip, but there ya have it….

    2. Commenter_XY   1 year ago

      https://www.israelnationalnews.com/news/397205

      Some interesting stats on Swords of Iron.

    3. SRG2   1 year ago

      the literal open air prison finally fought back in a totally acceptable way.

      Your description would be accurate only if Palestinians had risen up to overthrow Hamas. They didn't.

  5. Fist of Etiquette   1 year ago

    Russian arms dealers are selling to the Houthis.

    We should lock those Russian arms dealers up and throw away the key unless we need a celeb back.

    1. Don't look at me!   1 year ago

      Competition in the arms market is a good thing.

    2. Chumby   1 year ago

      This is part of the blowback (boomerang) Putin mentioned when the US is providing weapons to Kiev that they have used against Russian civilians.

    3. Earth-based Human Skeptic   1 year ago

      Celeb? What does that mean these days?

      1. MyPublicName   1 year ago

        Anyone in the WNBA,
        I feel like an LGBT influencer should count too

        1. Mike Parsons   1 year ago

          Ironically, they wouldn't have made the deal for Caitlyn Clark the way they bent over for Greiner.

          1. Chumby   1 year ago

            You are saying that had Clark been held in custody, the strong efforts to secure her release would not have been a slam dunk?

            1. Ajsloss   1 year ago

              Maybe not a slam dunk, but the fundamentals would've been on full display.

              1. Chumby   1 year ago

                Greiner was heavily penalized for traveling.

                1. Commenter_XY   1 year ago

                  Can we trade her back?

          2. EISTAU Gree-Vance   1 year ago

            Clark probably wouldn’t have been stupid and entitled enough to carry THC products with her in Russia.

            Not saying she deserved to be locked up for it, but still, use your fucking brain, bitch.

      2. Ajsloss   1 year ago

        If the ability to get a double-double in the WNBA makes one a celeb, then any man over 6'2" should suffice.

    4. JesseAz (5-30 Banana Republic Day)   1 year ago

      Merchant of Death is back selling to Houthis. But at least the WNBA had a record viewership this year with Griner.

      https://www.wsj.com/world/russia/putins-merchant-of-death-is-back-in-the-arms-business-this-time-selling-to-the-houthis-10b7f521

      1. mad.casual   1 year ago

        Merchant of Death is back selling to Houthis. But at least the WNBA had a record viewership this year with Griner.

        Women hardest hit.

  6. Fist of Etiquette   1 year ago

    The great Florida migration is coming undone...

    Blue State escapees meet Florida Man?

    1. Sevo, 5-30-24, embarrassment   1 year ago

      And hurricanes are something new there? I expect more from Wally.

      1. Don't look at me!   1 year ago

        It’s because global warming climate change! Soccer moms in SUV’s are to blame!

        1. Earth-based Human Skeptic   1 year ago

          Is that why they hate themselves (at least the white ones)?

        2. Gaear Grimsrud   1 year ago

          Childless cat ladies who drive Teslas are the real heroes in this story.

    2. Minadin   1 year ago

      The example case study they used for that argument was some jackass from suburban DC, who moved to a gated community, and now can't sell his overpriced house.

      1. Chumby   1 year ago

        Gatored community

        1. Ajsloss   1 year ago

          It was easy when they caiman, now it’s difficult for them to leave.

          1. Eeyore   1 year ago
    3. Eeyore   1 year ago

      So people are bitching that they moved to a state that doesn't have a housing shortage?

  7. Fist of Etiquette   1 year ago

    Taiwan is copying Germany's extremely dumb mistake...

    You know who else copied Germany's dumb mistake?

    1. Jerry B.   1 year ago

      J. D. Vance? But I could be wrong about that.

      1. Mother's Lament   1 year ago

        JD Vance is wrong

    2. Chumby   1 year ago

      That David Hasselhoff poster I purchased was a gift for a friend…in Canada. I swear.

      1. Jefferson Paul   1 year ago

        You bought the Hasselhoff poster for ML?

        1. Chumby   1 year ago

          ML drives around western Canada in a KIT replica while wearing a Member’s Only jacket with a popped collar. I thought he’d like the poster for his birthday. That’s my story and I’m sticking to it.

    3. Earth-based Human Skeptic   1 year ago

      Il Duce?

    4. Gaear Grimsrud   1 year ago

      Well Trump reportedly keeps a copy of Mein Kampf on his nightstand. JD Vance claims he sees it as a cautionary tale. JD Vance is wrong.

    5. Uncle Jay   1 year ago

      Biden.
      Harris.
      Hitlery.
      Nazi Pelosi.
      Chuck "The Schmuck" Schumer.
      Pritzker.
      Whitmer.
      Gruesome Newsom.

    6. EISTAU Gree-Vance   1 year ago

      Germany?

    7. mad.casual   1 year ago

      Houghton Mifflin?

  8. Chumby   1 year ago

    FEMA Disaster Preparedness Meeting:

    "We should focus our efforts on LGBTQIA people… they struggled before the storm"

    FEMA relief is no longer about getting the greatest good for the greatest amount of people…. It's about disaster equity.

    - reported by End Wokeness

    1. Randy Sax   1 year ago

      "Hey, I just blew this guy, can I get some aid?"

      1. Don't look at me!   1 year ago

        You might be in line for some AIDS.

        1. Jefferson Paul   1 year ago

          AIDS is so 80s. He's in line for Monkey Pox now.

    2. MyPublicName   1 year ago

      At least their priorities are straight.......

      1. Mother's Lament   1 year ago

        Ba dum tss.

    3. JesseAz (5-30 Banana Republic Day)   1 year ago

      Stop criticizing FEMA.

      Tom Elliott
      @tomselliott
      Despite obstructing relief efforts,
      @FEMA
      ’s Criswell says criticizing her agency is “dangerous”:

      “It has a tremendous impact on the comfort level of our own employees … When you have this dangerous rhetoric like you’re hearing, it creates fear in our own employees”
      Video

      https://x.com/tomselliott/status/1842966349372338301

      Also apparently FEMA and Red Cross are taking over citizen driven supplies to these areas then shutting down actually giving out items as they "inventory" what they took.

      https://x.com/MikeVonsteuben/status/1842745328530772054

      But don't worry. FEMA will help you citizen as long as they don't run into a road closed sign they could drive around.

      https://nypost.com/2024/10/06/us-news/fema-abandons-residents-of-devastated-nc-town-because-of-road-closed-sign/

      1. Red Rocks White Privilege   1 year ago

        “It has a tremendous impact on the comfort level of our own employees

        I'd be supportive of a civil war if it meant the death of limp-wristed therapy-speak like this.

        Also apparently FEMA and Red Cross are taking over citizen driven supplies to these areas then shutting down actually giving out items as they “inventory” what they took.

        LOL, not unlike African warlords who appropriate UN aid drops.

      2. Earth-based Human Skeptic   1 year ago

        “It has a tremendous impact on the comfort level of our own employees"

        Every minute that one of our FEMA staff has to spending recovering in our portable Safe Space Trailers is a minute they can't be helping some needy LGBTQ victim!

      3. Eeyore   1 year ago

        They never promised to "manage" emergencies in a way that helped victims.

    4. mad.casual   1 year ago

      We've got to turn this natural disaster back into the disease-riddled, attention-seeking, clusterfuck it was before the hurricane hit!

  9. Mother's Lament   1 year ago

    There's zero accountability – It's just one lie after another.

    KJP 2022 - "We're going to be spending FEMA money on illegals"

    KJP 2024 - "No Biden did not take FEMA relief money to use on illegals"

    1. InsaneTrollLogic (Factio Democratica delenda est 5/30/24)   1 year ago

      KJP lies about as well as a cut and wrinkled rug.

      1. Jerry B.   1 year ago

        But is she wrong, like J.D. Vance?

        1. JesseAz (5-30 Banana Republic Day)   1 year ago

          Truth changed. The gov changed word definitions so jeffsarc can lie about the actions of Democrats.

          1. Mother's Lament   1 year ago

            “They aren’t illegals, they’re migrants. There’s a big difference, liars” – Sarcasmic yesterday

      2. Earth-based Human Skeptic   1 year ago

        Well, she does spent her off hours focused on rugs.

    2. Don't look at me!   1 year ago

      Close down fema. Red Cross does it better.

      1. Mother's Lament   1 year ago

        Local Red Cross do. The International Red Cross is about as crooked and useless an organization as you could imagine.

        1. Don't look at me!   1 year ago

          Still an improvement over fema.

      2. Chumby   1 year ago

        Reference Katrina where funds donated to the Red Cross during that disaster may have ended up in other programs. They had enough backlash where they offered refunds.

      3. JesseAz (5-30 Banana Republic Day)   1 year ago

        From reporting, red cross is being as big of an incompetent jack ass as FEMA is.

        1. Don't look at me!   1 year ago

          But at least I’m not paying for it.

          1. JesseAz (5-30 Banana Republic Day)   1 year ago

            You sure?

            https://www.federalgrants.com/American-Red-Cross-22765.html

        2. Stuck in California   1 year ago

          From first hand, personal experience Red Cross is absolutely horrible.

          They basically swoop in and do fundraising off of emergencies, but then don't use those funds for the affected area. At all. Just into Red Cross coffers.

          They also do horrible shit like when they tried to get everyone to donate blood for this freezing blood bank idea they had, that was specifically against the law. The end goal there was to say "Oh, we have so much surplus it will go to waste, you HAVE to let us do this" rather than actually meet regulations or get them changed through normal public processes.

          They're ghouls, ambulance chasers, and the worst part of the culture of "if you say it confidently, people will believe it." A horrible organization only about enriching its executives.

    3. Idaho-Bob   1 year ago

      Yep, those two recorded press releases were making the rounds yesterday.

      Funny how the MSM doesn't even mention it.

      1. Mother's Lament   1 year ago

        Because they are the Democratic Party. There's just nine corporations who hold 95% of the media in the US and every single CEO of the nine have publicly stated they are 100% in on 2030.

    4. Mother's Lament   1 year ago

      And it wasn’t a one off. Look at these receipts!

      How can she lie so freely, so brazenly?

      1. Earth-based Human Skeptic   1 year ago

        Does she even know she lies? Level 10 believers have very little relationship with objective truth.

      2. InsaneTrollLogic (Factio Democratica delenda est 5/30/24)   1 year ago

        Because the media is compliant and complicit.

    5. Red Rocks White Privilege   1 year ago

      Raggedy Dykey always was a cut-rate Squealer.

    6. Sevo, 5-30-24, embarrassment   1 year ago

      Pretty sure it was a CNN headline scroll: 'Trump weaponizing lack of FEMA funds'.

  10. Earth-based Human Skeptic   1 year ago

    'how many deaths are civilians and how many are fighters is obviously important but is hard to reliably determine.'

    Equally hard to determine is how many live people are combatants and how many are "innocent". How would you categorize a Gazan who directly facilitates military action but does not actually fire a weapon or launch a rocket?

    1. Idaho-Bob   1 year ago

      While I fully understand the point you are trying to make, the same could be said for Americans.

      How would you categorize an American who directly facilitates military action but does not actually fire a weapon or launch a rocket

      1. Earth-based Human Skeptic   1 year ago

        If you mean the 90%-plus in any armed forces group who support those who directly confront the enemy, then I agree. In conventional forces, they all wear uniforms and are legitimate targets. In unconventional forces, there are no uniforms, but that does not mean that grandma and some 10 year old kid are not combatants.

        1. Idaho-Bob   1 year ago

          but that does not mean that grandma and some 10 year old kid are not combatants.

          And I agree with this.

        2. Sevo, 5-30-24, embarrassment   1 year ago

          FDR claimed the Boy Scout on a scrap metal drive was the equivalent of the Marine on Guadalcanal.
          One of the few times he wasn't outright lying; ever since war became mechanized (say mid 19th century), finding an "innocent" has become more and more difficult.
          WWII Japan took it to the extreme, arming kids with bamboo spears, but if the US had been facing invasion, you can bet all the home front folks would have been digging out dad's squirrel gun.

      2. MyPublicName   1 year ago

        That's the risk you take when supporting any military force, you put a mark on your head. You are correct for saying it's the same for Americans as it is the same everywhere.

      3. TrickyVic (old school)   1 year ago

        ""who directly facilitates military action""

        Like how? Letting the troops setup HQ and weapons below your hospital, neighborhood or home?

        1. Randy Sax   1 year ago

          Complicated by;

          "Let us into your hospital or we will rape your family to death in front of you, then cut your head off."

    2. Minadin   1 year ago

      I would categorize them as fair game.

    3. Mike Parsons   1 year ago

      I mean, they are totally innocent. Sometimes when you are a good upstanding innocent civilian and journalist for the 'respectable' MSM of the area, you keep a hostage or 2 locked in your basement to prove how innocent and not terrorist you are.

      1. EISTAU Gree-Vance   1 year ago

        mtruman has some interesting thoughts on this.

    4. Rev Arthur L kuckland (5-30-24 banana republic day)   1 year ago

      The 30 year old with an AK identifies as a civilian child

      1. Chumby   1 year ago

        That dovetails with provisions in Obamacare.

  11. Earth-based Human Skeptic   1 year ago

    "The great Florida migration is coming undone," reports The Wall Street Journal.

    FLORIDA IS TERRIBLE! says a New York publication.

    1. Dillinger   1 year ago

      Del Boca Vista hardest hit.

      1. Ajsloss   1 year ago

        Only because there is nothing available in Tuscany, so don't even look.

        1. Dillinger   1 year ago

          in all of Tuscany?

    2. mad.casual   1 year ago

      Woke killed Disney. Big surprise.

  12. Sarah Palin's Buttplug - Jan 6 = 9/11 (same motive)   1 year ago

    Commies at the Wall St Journal:

    Trump’s Plan Boosts Budget Deficits by $7.5 Trillion, Double Harris’s Proposal

    https://www.wsj.com/politics/policy/trump-plan-boosts-budget-deficits-by-7-5-trillion-double-harris-proposal-526effd2?mod=hp_lead_pos5

    DREAMY LIBERTARIAN!

    1. Chumby   1 year ago

      Where is your other account?

    2. Mother's Lament   1 year ago

      So future deficits as imagined by Richard Rubin’s pals, versus the Democrats real ones right now? Say Pluggo, what was Trump’s spending looking like pre-Covid lockdown?

      Trump’s combination of tax cuts, tariff increases, military expansion and mass deportations would widen budget deficits by an estimated $7.5 trillion

      TAX CUTS!!! How anti-libertarian. And how the fuck is no longer blowing billions on illegals going to raise the deficit?
      What a clown.

    3. Earth-based Human Skeptic   1 year ago

      Which party pushes for more spending and higher taxes?

      1. sarcasmic   1 year ago

        Both parties raise spending. That’s a fact.
        So when it comes to deficits, if you care about that sort of thing (both Trump defenders and rank GOP do not), are they made worse by increased spending coupled with decreased revenue, or increased spending coupled with increased revenue?
        The math ain’t that hard.

        1. Earth-based Human Skeptic   1 year ago

          Apparently the math of higher taxes is (for you).

    4. Don't look at me!   1 year ago

      Harris has no proposals.

      1. Rev Arthur L kuckland (5-30-24 banana republic day)   1 year ago

        That's a lie. She has proposed building a wall, and not taxing tips

        1. MyPublicName   1 year ago

          While that's such an original idea, she wouldn't do it anyways.

    5. Red Rocks White Privilege   1 year ago

      What proposals does Harris have other than what she's ripped off from Trump, or the continuation of the last 3.5 years of your side's failed economic policies? What's that current FY deficit looking like again, you hicklib pederast?

      1. JesseAz (5-30 Banana Republic Day)   1 year ago

        She has proposed a lot of taxes. Revealed little of her spending. Making this analysis effective for retards like sarcshrike.

    6. JesseAz (5-30 Banana Republic Day)   1 year ago

      Libertarians for wealth tax and increased corporate taxes? I do like an analysis who treats tariffs worse than a much higher corporate tax though. Makes their analysis seem legit.

      1. sarcasmic   1 year ago
        1. InsaneTrollLogic (Factio Democratica delenda est 5/30/24)   1 year ago

          Smartest thing you’ve probably ever said.

        2. JesseAz (5-30 Banana Republic Day)   1 year ago

          Were you about to say something retarded like corporate taxes and regulations don't increase costs?

          1. sarcasmic   1 year ago

            I don’t need to say anything at all. Just let you make stuff up and argue against it. It’s the only thing you're good at.

            1. Mother's Lament   1 year ago

              Literally you yesterday, Mr. MigrantsAren'tIllegals.

            2. InsaneTrollLogic (Factio Democratica delenda est 5/30/24)   1 year ago

              Make shit up…

              That’s been your MO for quite some time, Sarc. Tell us again how migrants aren’t illegal aliens?

    7. Sevo, 5-30-24, embarrassment   1 year ago

      turd, the ass-clown of the commentariat, lies; it’s all he ever does. turd is a kiddie diddler, and a pathological liar, entirely too stupid to remember which lies he posted even minutes ago, and also too stupid to understand we all know he’s a liar.
      If anything he posts isn’t a lie, it’s totally accidental.
      turd lies; it’s what he does. turd is a lying pile of lefty shit

    8. EISTAU Gree-Vance   1 year ago

      Yeah, I totally buy that.

  13. lwt1960   1 year ago

    This essay is depressingly amoral in its tone. This is a somber day, which should be remembered for what it was- a cowardly, unprovoked massacre of helpless non-combatants in a time of (apparent) peace. You can sympathize with the innocents on both sides devastated by the aftermath, but save that for another day.

    1. Mother's Lament   1 year ago

      ^this

      1. Z Crazy   1 year ago

        It’s like Operation Barbarosa.

        the blowback from the Red Army wasn’t pretty.

        the blowback from the IDF isn’t pretty.

        1. Chumby   1 year ago

          Bagratian was a few years later. There was the “not one step back” at Stalingrad and holding onto Leningrad beforehand.

    2. But SkyNet is a Private Company   1 year ago

      Just like every Dec 7th, we remember the victims of the firebombing of Tokyo

    3. Commenter_XY   1 year ago

      +1

    4. Longtobefree   1 year ago

      Cease fire violation, General; don't forget it was a cease fire violation.

  14. Ajsloss   1 year ago

    Anthony Fauci "will be remembered as a cautionary tale of what can happen when too much power is invested in a single person for far too long," writes Jay Bhattacharya in Reason.

    Sorry, Jay. It's already been forgotten. #amnesty

    1. Chumby   1 year ago

      Wonder if Fauci has a rat line to Argentina planned out.

      1. Earth-based Human Skeptic   1 year ago

        More of a bat line. Or pangolin line.

    2. Ska   1 year ago

      I guess that's why he has an op-ed in the NYT published today. Completely forgotten.

    3. Ron   1 year ago

      Fauci wasn't in power that long before he screwed over those suffering from aids. he denied them medications that the rest of the world was using until a very rich athlete went to Europe to get his medication then it was too obvious that Fauci was holding back care and finally relented and allowed those medicines to be used. Reminds me of him denying the use of Ivermetine. does Fauci love the power of control so much that he takes pleasure from people dying

  15. TrickyVic (old school)   1 year ago

    Democrats like to make fun of people who do disaster preparedness.

    1. Randy Sax   1 year ago

      They aren't worried. They don't need to be preppers. FEMA will help them because they are gay.

      1. InsaneTrollLogic (Factio Democratica delenda est 5/30/24)   1 year ago

        Will FEMA gayly drop off some faggots further to burn for warmth? Or will they just take a drag on their fags?

    2. Chumby   1 year ago

      Other than the lurking glowies, haven’t seen anyone in the prepping community admit being a member of the Democratic Party. Mostly libertarians, libertines, conservative Republicans, a few neocons (they take a royal beating), and the occasional anarchist. In international groups, there are some socialists as well.

      1. KARtikeya   1 year ago

        Any Latter-day Saints? They are super into prepping.

        1. Chumby   1 year ago

          They are though I’m not in any groups that have “I’m a Mormon” Mormon. Occasionally see references to what they do and a few decent vendors for that stuff in Utah.
          The Amish are too but not in those forums either.

  16. Red Rocks White Privilege   1 year ago

    The Wicked Witch of the Midwest once again agitates for TOTAL FIRST AMENDMENT DEATH:

    Hillary Clinton called for a government crack down on social media, sparking users on X to accuse her of saying 'the quiet part out loud.'
    The former Secretary of State told CNN host Michael Smerconish Saturday that leaders could 'lose control' if they don't take serious action to censor digital content - sparking outcry on the web...
    'We need national action and sadly our Congress has been dysfunctional when it comes to addressing these threats to our children,' Clinton said.
    Clinton brought up the issue in the context of controlling more of what children were experiencing on social media and getting addicted to content on major platforms.
    She called for the repeal of Section 230 of the Communications Act, the keeps online platforms from being held liable for content posted by users on their platforms.
    That legal carve out, she argued, was an 'overly simple view' that did not take into account the dangers of social media...
    She conceded that many of her proposed changes would require Democrats to be empowered in the federal government, so they could turn their focus to issues that she cared about.
    'Hopefully the election will turn out the right way, the fever will be broken and we can go back to try and put our families and communities on the right track,' she said...

    Since she first lost her life-long dream of becoming the first female president of the United States to former President Donald Trump in the 2016 election, Clinton has blamed the rise of 'misinformation' and 'fake news' for convincing voters not to trust her.
    In September, Clinton called for more controls on online activity, specifically against Americans who were paid by foreign countries to spread online propaganda.
    'We are only at the beginning of understanding the whole iceberg here,' she said, warning of the Russians to deploy 'more sophisticated' operations to influence the United States.
    Clinton proposed during an interview on MSNBC that the United States government to prosecute Americans for sharing information and propaganda on behalf of foreign governments.
    'I also think that there are Americans engaged in this kind of propaganda and whether they should be civilly or in some cases criminally charged is something that would be a better deterrence,' she said.

    The "protecting children" argument was the same one that France used to arrest Pavel Durov, even though everyone knew it was really because he wouldn't let the EU globohomos have access to the platform to spy on people and use it for COIN ops like the US does with Facebook, Twitter, etc. But ultimately, it boils down to the fact that Regime vermin like Hillary and John Kerry want top-down control of the flow of information to project only that which supports the Regime.

    These people are flat-out evil, and simply being outvoted isn't going to stop them. That's why the witch deems any resistance to her and her side as a "fever" that needs to be broken, rather than a logical response to their globalist totalitarianism.

    Break up the west today.

    1. TrickyVic (old school)   1 year ago

      ""that leaders could ‘lose control’ if they don’t take serious action to censor digital content""

      Nothing says freedom like government in control.

      1. Red Rocks White Privilege   1 year ago

        It's a lot easier to shut down the digital gateway than to do the work to arrest these people that are supposedly doing such egregious shit in the first place. It's why their agenda is so fucking transparent.

        1. Earth-based Human Skeptic   1 year ago

          How much for a mid-size nuke in Davos next year?

          1. InsaneTrollLogic (Factio Democratica delenda est 5/30/24)   1 year ago

            No idea, but maybe someone can set up a GiveSendGo fund?

          2. Dillinger   1 year ago

            think we traded the guy with the answer to your question back to Russia for the chick hoopster.

            1. Sevo, 5-30-24, embarrassment   1 year ago

              Someone should NOT have been involved in player transactions.

            2. Chumby   1 year ago

              Will this trade go down as more lopsided than Herschel Walker to the Vikings?

              1. Dillinger   1 year ago

                I bet Johnny Ukraine feels like the Buffalo Bills right about now.

        2. Commenter_XY   1 year ago

          It is incredible to me that we are even discussing this in America.

          Did the Soviets get the last laugh?

    2. InsaneTrollLogic (Factio Democratica delenda est 5/30/24)   1 year ago

      Hillary really is the most evil person of our time.

      1. Jefferson Paul   1 year ago

        For her to go on and on about the harms of disinformation, after having funded and propagated the Steele dossier is such a blatant slap in the face to Americans, I don't understand how she isn't pilloried by the left as well.

        Okay, I get it. The left wants control and all their talk about mis-, dis-, and malformation is simply to erode our liberties to make it easier for them to take over fully. But how brainwashed must regular lefties be to accept it, unless they, too, don't GAF about our rights and just want people they agree with to take full control. It's cool now for them to oppose the 1st Amendment, but when the people they help take over start cracking down on their speech and other rights, they'll probably sing a different tune. By then it will be too late.

        1. Mickey Rat   1 year ago

          The Clinton's and their cronies are literally the people who made "spin control" part of our political lexicon. The hypocrisy over "misinformation"and "disinformation"runs very deep.

        2. EISTAU Gree-Vance   1 year ago

          Is it “misinformation” to label a massive spending bill using money borrowed from the future the “inflation reduction act”?

          Talk about a slap in the face.

        3. Red Rocks White Privilege   1 year ago

          Anything that resists their agenda is counter-revolutionary, therefore it must be shut down.

      2. SRG2   1 year ago

        You mean, she's literally Hertler.

  17. Dillinger   1 year ago

    American Hostage Crisis - Day 366

    1. Commenter_XY   1 year ago

      Bring them home!

  18. Dillinger   1 year ago

    >>Israel claims it has killed 17,000 Hamas militants; how many deaths are civilians and how many are fighters is obviously important but is hard to reliably determine.

    sorry but is it obviously important?

  19. Dillinger   1 year ago

    >>Anthony Fauci "will be remembered as a cautionary tale of what can happen when too much power is invested in a single person for far too long,"

    one man's cautionary tale is another's 40 year reign of terror. lamppost required.

  20. Dillinger   1 year ago

    >>"The Nobel Prize in physiology or medicine was awarded Monday to Americans Victor Ambros and Gary Ruvkun for their discovery of microRNA, tiny pieces of genetic material that alter how genes work at the cellular level and could lead to new ways of treating cancer,"

    ... reported Dr. No.

  21. Dillinger   1 year ago

    >>Inside Arizona's plan for bolstering election security.

    200,000 illegals on the rolls is absolute security.

  22. Dillinger   1 year ago

    after reading the entire piece above I will say it was nice of you to remember October 7, 2023 first before spending four paragraphs about troubles in Israel eye roll.

  23. Rick James   1 year ago

    Russian arms dealers are selling to the Houthis.

    Probably the "pro-western" oligarchs that had their assets seized during Sanctions 1.0/1.1/1.2/1.2b/1.21b.

  24. Rick James   1 year ago

    "The great Florida migration is coming undone," reports The Wall Street Journal.

    El oh El.

  25. Sevo, 5-30-24, embarrassment   1 year ago

    "...Scenes from New York: The three brothers at the heart of the corruption scandal in Mayor Eric Adams' administration..."

    DO NOT provide a link to a pay-walled site. Ever!

    1. Jefferson Paul   1 year ago

      I get your frustration, but you can also just add an archive.is/ before the www. to access it for free.

  26. AT   1 year ago

    how many deaths are civilians and how many are fighters is obviously important but is hard to reliably determine.

    Also, nobody really cares. From the perspective of the right, they're accomplices and enablers. From the position of the left, they're invading colonialists trying to assert a right to Israeli land.

    Truth is, we were all stupid and short-sighted to ever go along with this fantasy that "Palestine" is a thing. It's not, it never has been, and it never will be. Those occupying arab oppressors should have been dealt with long before 2024.

    1. Michael Ejercito   1 year ago

      Remember what these people did in Jordan and Lebanon?

  27. MWAocdoc   1 year ago

    “Israeli public opinion has at times soured on the war effort”

    Public sentiment could not matter less to the terrorists. Hamas and Hezbollah have made it crystal clear over two decades that they have no intention of allowing peaceful coexistence between Israel and Islam. The choice is between trying to eliminate as much of the threat as possible now, or not trying to eliminate more of the threat now. The more of the threat Israel is able to eliminate now, the longer the next interval of peace will be. A permanent peace is not possible, that much is clear. Agreement after agreement after agreement – multiple agreements over decades have failed.

Please log in to post comments

Mute this user?

  • Mute User
  • Cancel

Ban this user?

  • Ban User
  • Cancel

Un-ban this user?

  • Un-ban User
  • Cancel

Nuke this user?

  • Nuke User
  • Cancel

Un-nuke this user?

  • Un-nuke User
  • Cancel

Flag this comment?

  • Flag Comment
  • Cancel

Un-flag this comment?

  • Un-flag Comment
  • Cancel

Latest

This Black Friday, Thank Globalization for Affordable Gifts

Jack Nicastro | 11.28.2025 7:00 AM

Review: Quasi-Government Megacompanies Collide in Alien: Earth

Peter Suderman | From the December 2025 issue

Brickbat: Small Town, Big Screwup

Charles Oliver | 11.28.2025 4:00 AM

Trump Pardoned Gobble and Waddle. He Should Pardon More Deserving People, Too.

Billy Binion | 11.27.2025 8:00 AM

Uncle Sam Makes Thanksgiving Worse

Christian Britschgi | 11.27.2025 7:30 AM

Recommended

  • About
  • Browse Topics
  • Events
  • Staff
  • Jobs
  • Donate
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
  • Contact
  • Media
  • Shop
  • Amazon
Reason Facebook@reason on XReason InstagramReason TikTokReason YoutubeApple PodcastsReason on FlipboardReason RSS Add Reason to Google

© 2025 Reason Foundation | Accessibility | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Take Reason's short survey for a chance to win $300
Take Reason's short survey for a chance to win $300
Take Reason's short survey for a chance to win $300