Brickbat: You Don't Want To See This

For almost eight years, California law enforcement officials kept a death in police custody secret, labeling the case an "accident" and refusing to disclose basic information to journalists and the family of the victim, according to an investigation by Open Vallejo. Darryl Mefferd had seemed disoriented and dehydrated and was making paranoid remarks, so his niece took him to a local hospital, where he was treated with vitamins and a sedative. Doctors wanted him to remain in the hospital, but they did not feel he met the conditions for an involuntary commitment and did not call police. Mefferd left the hospital but outside encountered Vallejo Police Department Officer Jeremy Callinan, who was at the hospital on another call. Callinan ignored the niece's pleas to take her uncle home, insisting on taking Mefferd into protective custody. Thirty minutes later, Mefferd was dead. The coroner ruled the death an accident, due to a lethal dose of methamphetamine. But Mefferd had spent the previous eight hours in a hospital, where a doctor said his drug diagnosis was "uncomplicated." A source who had reviewed body camera footage—which has still not been made public—claims that Mefferd either fell or was thrown to the ground before Callinan handcuffed and sat on him for 10 minutes.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
But what colors were they?
No one called the police but they still inserted themselves.
We have been told, "Don't stick it in Crazy!"
Now we must add, "Don't let Crazy stick it in you!"
Mefferd left the hospital but outside encountered Vallejo Police Department Officer Jeremy Callinan, who was at the hospital on another call. Callinan ignored the niece's pleas to take her uncle home, insisting on taking Mefferd into protective custody.
JFC, learn to journalism wouldja? "Encountered"? Taker her uncle home with her?
This reads as poorly and passive/inactive voice as a police report. Almost like they were discharged and the niece begged the nearest LEO to take him home. Which would kinda make her the asshole here.
Mefferd either fell or was thrown to the ground before Callinan handcuffed and sat on him for 10 minutes.
Well, as long as the video shows him clearly either falling or being thrown then... duh.
Finally... could be worse, he could've been sentenced to death by a sentencing jury in a 9-3 split decision.
Oh yeah? Well what about Ashley Babbitt? Why aren't you writing about Ashley Babbitt you left-handed leftist?
Poor sarc. So broken.
She doesn't fit Reason's agenda.
Who polices the policemen?
The police does!
This Callinan copper must be a really big fan of offissa Chauvin. They say imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, so mebbe being promoted to Derek's cellmate would be a suitable reward. Did they get the same medical examiner--the one who swore Floyd was walking dead before being knelt on--to sign the death certificate saying Mefford was a walking meth lab?
He took him into protective custody. For his protection. We are truly living through the age of clown world.
The coroner ruled the death an accident, due to a lethal dose of methamphetamine. But Mefferd had spent the previous eight hours in a hospital, where a doctor said his drug diagnosis was “uncomplicated.”
So you’re suggesting that not only the cops did something shady, but the coroner did too.
And instead of seeking out the coroner and his notes, you’re going with, “Anonymous sources claim…”
Who’s the source, Charlie? How can you verify he reviewed the video? How can you verify that the video says what he says it does?
Who’s the source, Charlie? Why didn’t you talk to the coroner, Charlie? Clearly you have his notes, in order to report the COD.
Also, why not take a look at Mefferd? WAS he a known methhead, disoriented and paranoid and otherwise doing very characteristically methhead things?
We should also note that this is California. Where drug abuse is not only enabled, but actively encouraged. Why DIDN’T the hospital put him on involuntary commitment? They wanted him to stay – but apparently not very much. That tracks.
This is why Brickbat is so stupid more often than it is – wait for it – REASONable. You’ve got an ACAB axe to grind, and you do sloppy investigation and reporting. It’s like a one-paragraph, “Here’s why you should hate cops today” feature intended to preach to the choir by playing to their prejudices and bigotry, which makes zero effort to confirm or corroborate or put together a whole picture of what actually happened and why.
Obviously the poor sap died from fentanyl. People can survive indefinitely with a couple hundred pounds sitting on their torso. Pain forte et dure was just a myth.
This why most line-duty cops should not be involved in mental health management cases unless the threat of violence is recognizable and immediate. They aren’t trained well enough for this. Nor do they have a natural aptitude, I suggest: they have hammers on their tool belts and tend to see everything as nails. It’s also why too many mass shooting suspects are shot and killed and cannot be questioned about their motives. In this country, apparently, street and SWAT cops have never heard of curare analogs and don’t know how to use dart guns. Game wardens do and would probably be happy to help out.
Of course, when we DO know their motives, the FBI helps cover it up.
Unless they're white, straight, Christian males, obviously.
Dart guns are not instant-acting, and have to be used from fairly close - too close if the crazy guy actually is dangerous.