Vermont Cops Terrorize High School Students With 'Mock Shooting'
"I'm shaking and crying because I'm like, 'Oh my god, I'm gonna get shot,'" one student told a Vermont newspaper. "It felt so real."

A group of Burlington, Vermont, high school students were touring a local police department as part of a forensics class this week. In the middle of a presentation from a detective, the unthinkable happened: a masked gunman burst into the room and seemed to open fire.
The students were terrified. One says she dove on the ground, hurting her knee. Another says she reached for her phone to text her mother.
But soon, the students realized that they weren't actually being shot at. Instead, they were the victims of a bizarre "demonstration" from the local police.
According to Seven Days, a Vermont independent newspaper, the students had no idea that the presentation would involve a mock shooting. Students were watching a detective speak at the front of a room when they heard screams. Two women ran in, followed by a man wearing a ski mask, who—it seemed—began firing.
"I'm shaking and crying because I'm like, 'Oh my god, I'm gonna get shot,'" one student told Seven Days. "It felt so real."
The students eventually realized that the shooting was fake after police officers in the room failed to do anything to stop the apparent gunman.
While performing a fake mass shooting with high schoolers was obviously a terrible idea, it's unclear whether high school staff also share some blame for needlessly terrifying the students.
The teachers told Seven Days that, while they knew officers would possibly demonstrate a "gunshot-related crime," they had no idea they wouldn't be warned first. However, in an email obtained by Seven Days, "teachers said officers told them that they'd previously used the lesson with college students and adults, and that they wanted the event to be 'as realistic as possible.'"
In a statement, police claimed that school staff had agreed to the content of the demonstration and that it would include "fake firearms in a mock shooting."
"Do you think that sort of incident would be ok for your group of students?" police asked school employees on May 23. "It is about as real life as you can get, and is certainly exactly the sort of thing we deal with most frequently."
"I think these students will be fine with this simulation," school employees replied, according to a statement from police. "We will give a heads up to parents and students."
No matter how you slice it, there's not much educational utility to having a fake gunman commit a "mock shooting" in a room full of unaware high school students. However, it's far from the first time that police have gone overboard with educational demonstrations like this. In 2019, police in Indiana shot elementary school teachers with airsoft guns during an active shooter training drill. Those teachers filed a lawsuit.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
The students eventually realized that the shooting was fake after police officers in the room failed to do anything to stop the apparent gunman.
Actually, that would make it seem more real.
Exactly my thought.
Cops doing nothing during a mass shooting is the rule, not the exception.
That they didn’t use the students as human shields and piss their pants was the giveaway.
Read about the 1984 McDonald's shootings.
McDonald's shootings were apparently the thing before school shootings were.
San Yosidro. I was there the day before the shooting. I was changing stations in the Navy and was in Tijuana getting souvenirs for when I was home on leave. I rode the trolley down from San Diego.
"...and is certainly exactly the sort of thing we deal with most frequently."
In Vermont. Masked gunman chasing women around inside of buildings. In Vermont. That asshole should be fired for uttering such a stupid thing.
The thing you deal with most frequently is harassing witnesses for having outstanding warrants you worthless union pigs.
"It is about as real life as you can get, and is certainly exactly the sort of thing we deal with most frequently."
Yeah, I'll believe that. Right. You don't most frequently deal with traffic stops and parking tickets in Burlington, VT?
Crime stats for Burlington indicate that out of 2668 total crimes reported, 193 were 'violent'. Or about 7%. 1 in 14.
Exactly. Born and raised in the state and I can say with certainty that masked gunman chasing women around is not a thing and obviously not one of the most frequent things Burlington cops deal with.
there’s not much educational utility
Actually, at least some of kids learned that authority figures like teachers and cops don’t invariably have good judgment. That's worth the field trip.
Eh, instead of participating in these scary simulations maybe we should get rid of the guns. That’s what your fucking precious Dear Leader suggested once so why not just follow along, Peanuts.
Hey Shrike, I’m surprised you and managed to tear yourself away from all your child porn to come here and say something stupid.
Fire every government employee involved then close the high school permanently.
It's the only way to restore justice.
Given that this is the same state that sends Bernie Sanders to Washington as a senator, I’m not completely shocked at this lack of judgement.
No matter how you slice it, there’s not much educational utility to having a fake gunman commit a “mock shooting” in a room full of unaware high school students.
Nonsense. The specific term is a “rapid reaction drill.”
But before we go any further, let’s make one thing very clear – what the cops here did wasn’t a rapid response drill. I’m not going to clutch my pearls and fall to my fainting couch like hack garbage lol jOuRnALiSt Emma and breathlessly sob that the kids were “terrorized” – but this doesn’t read like a drill. It reads like a prank. A frankly kinda mean one.
But to say there’s no educational utility to a rapid reaction drill is asinine. There’s a VERY good reason for them.
Rule #1 in ANY crisis situation or emergency: Keep your head. If you lose that, and you fall into panic and freeze, you’re a thousand times more at risk. If you practice what to do in emergency situations, you’re far more likely to hold onto your wits and take decisive, immediate action.
Really, the schools - working with the cops - should be doing them more often. Same way they used to conduct the fire drills (I don’t know if they still do, but I kinda doubt it in Precious Sensitive Snowflake America). I don’t know how many people who had schools that did them this way, but for the first few months, they’d announce them. You knew they were coming, because the point was to train you what to do. Line up, leaders hold the doors, march out single file, don’t push, go to your assigned spot outside the building. You practiced that until the school felt pretty confident that you knew what to do if that alarm went off. They did this to everyone from kinders to seniors.
Then they started to do them randomly. Didn’t tell you they were coming. And most kids wouldn’t panic. They had the proper reaction trained into them, and then when it wasn’t expected, they reacted the way they were supposed to.
THAT’S an extremely valuable educational tool, and some people (smart people) even practice them with their families. Fire drills, burglar drills, earthquake drills. The more you condition your mind and body to know what to do, the more likely you’ll be to do precisely that in a real emergency.
And the less likely you’ll be to panic.
Now, again, this is not remotely what these cops were doing that day. I’m just illustrating how Emma is, as usual and so predictably utterly stupid in her ultimate conclusion on the subject.
Good post. Read more like a vicious prank meant to scare the shit out of kids than a teaching moment.
This was a crime. 13 V.S.A. § 1702 says in relevant part:
According to Vermont law this would appear to be a misdemeanor; unlike most states, it's not a felony unless the maximum sentence is more than two years.
"Vermont Cop Stabbed And Beaten While Trying To Terrorize Kids With 'Mock Shooting'" would be a great headline.
Too bad we got "Another says she reached for her phone to text her mother."
Cops used to lie to school assemblies and say a classmate had been killed in a car accident. I think the goal was to keep kids from drinking.
It wasn't the cops, but I did hear a Dean mention that a classmate got shot and killed in a coke deal. The Dean was talking to a teacher. I never saw the kid again though