Latest Inflation Numbers Show That Rent Is Too Damn High
The cost of shelter was up 0.7 percent in August and 6.2 percent for the year, according to the latest Consumer Price Index report.

Inflation continues to ravage America's paychecks, and it's increasingly showing up in rising rents.
The latest Consumer Price Index (CPI) by the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) shows that prices ticked up by 0.1 percent for urban consumers in August, for an annualized increase of 8.3 percent for the year. The marginal increase in inflation comes in spite of fuel costs falling 10.3 percent last month.
"Increases in the shelter, food, and medical care indexes were the largest of many contributors to the broad-based monthly all items increase," said the BLS in its news release today. The latest CPI numbers show a 0.7 percent increase in shelter costs in August and 6.2 percent over the past year.
The BLS measures both cash rents paid by tenants and something called Owners' Equivalent Rent—a measurement of how much an owner-occupied home could be rented for. The bureau doesn't include home prices in the CPI.
Spot rents reported by listing companies are growing at an even faster rate. Apartment List reports a 7.2 percent increase in rental prices so far this year. That's moderate compared to the 17.6 percent increase in rents the company reported in 2021. It's still well above pre-pandemic increases from 3.4 percent and 2.3 percent in 2018 and 2019 respectively.
Rents plunged during 2020, driven by an urban exodus from high-cost coastal metros like New York City, San Francisco, Los Angeles, and Seattle. Many of those same cities are where rents are growing the fastest—alongside many of the Sun Belt metros where people fled to during the pandemic.
That suggests at least a partial reset of migration patterns during the pandemic. People are returning to the city (although not necessarily to the office).
The upshot is that the country's housing affordability struggles aren't going anywhere. Some analysts warn that they're likely to get worse.
"Rent prices look to accelerate in the near term as rental demand remains exceptionally high from ongoing job additions and higher mortgage rates forcing people out of the homebuying market," Lawrence Yun, the National Association of Realtors chief economist, said in a statement to Barron's.
Inflation is a monetary phenomenon driven by a lot of new money entering the system thanks to the federal government's spending binge during and after the pandemic.
All else equal, new housing construction would help put downward pressure on housing costs. The odds of that happening are mixed. Multifamily housing construction is booming. Axios reports that 420,000 new apartments are supposed to be completed this year—a 50-year high.
But that explosion of new apartments is still coming after a decade of severe underbuilding. The latest federal data also show that single-family home construction is collapsing too.
In other words, rent is too damn high, and we can expect it to stay that way.
Rent Free is a weekly newsletter from Christian Britschgi on urbanism and the fight for less regulation, more housing, more property rights, and more freedom in America's cities.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
That meme is a dozen years old.
And they couldn't even bother to link it. Whoever wrote this headline deserves and OK Boomer.
I am creating eighty North American nation greenbacks per-hr. to finish some web services from home. I actually have not ever thought adore it would even realisable but (ami-0s2) my friend mate got $27k solely in four weeks simply doing this best assignment and conjointly she convinced Maine to avail. Look further details going this web-page.
.
---------->>> https://smartpay21.pages.dev
thankls https://oto.4u-review.com/courserious-2-0-oto-login/
Today Mr. Buttplug has stepped up his #DefendBidenAtAllCosts game to previously unimaginable levels of skill and precision. He'll be here shortly to explain why inflation is a wingnut.com lie.
#BestEconomyEver
Wait, I thought we were past the "there's no inflation" on to the "well, there, is and it's a good thing" phase.
https://www.cnn.com/2021/12/01/economy/inflation-good-bad-winners-losers/index.html
Soon , almost everyone will be a millionaire!
Inflation is a monetary phenomenon driven by a lot of new money entering the system thanks to the federal government's spending binge during and after the pandemic.
The Inflation Reduction Act cured it. Didn’t you hear Biden or his robotic mouthpiece?
Biden's handlers trotted out his fucking fellow fossil, James Taylor, for the Bidenflation Bill victory lap today. Who the hell designs these events, one of his idiot fuckup kids?
Taylor sang a song about suicide which is where WEF wants people to go towards.
Good thing 2 million illegal immigrants don't effect demand curves.
2?
You mean 22 million, all requiring housing. They’re taking up all the “affordable housing” that had been built with public subsidies for needy Americans. They’re also using up privately developed homes, sometimes living like roaches, ten to a bedroom, with illegally subdivisions.
And because most of it is in sanctuary cities, no one kicks them out.
Begin a mass deportation and watch all costs decrease.
Apartment List reports a 7.2 percent increase in rental prices so far this year. That's moderate compared to the 17.6 percent increase in rents the company reported in 2021.
This jump is completely all on Sleepy Joe.
First look when it started - in 2021 when he stole the presidency from the Donald.
Second, according to wingnut.com, Biden told Big Apartment that he was banning all new construction and only treehouses would be green enough to build.
Fail.
Wow wow wow wow can you believe how amazing this Biden economy is?
Asia's richest man Gautam Adani made $1.58 billion today bringing his 2022 increase to $70.3 billion for a total net worth of $147 billion!
That settles it. From now on we should use the GANWI (Gautam Adani Net Worth Index) instead of the WBNWI (Warren Buffett Net Worth Index) you relied on from 2009 to 2016 to prove Obama's economy was the best ever.
#LibertariansForBiden
Paul Krugman on economics: (source: NY Times opinion)
The reality: (source: Oilprice.com)
Own foot sighted, target acquired. Send it.
Krugman:
Cue video of German delegation laughing at Trump.
More Krugnuts wisdom nuggets:
But right now protecting families and preserving a sense of fairness have to take priority over textbook market efficiency.
What Krugnuts is talking about is the EU subsidizing a scarce resource by making it cheaper. I need to look at my economics Agrippa to bone up... but I'm not sure if what Krugnuts proposes is going to work out for Europe.
Interesting thread
I think it may work in the short term. What is troubling is his open addition of 'fairness,' which is not a tenet of the Austrian or Behavioral schools. The governments don't need more running dogs writing excuses for them to better establish unopposed control.
Oh yeah, any day now, we will turn the ruble into rubble.
Yep, any day now.
Ruble against the USD is at its highest point since *squints at graph* 2018.
Remember, you can easily ask higher prices on an automated system -- and may get them.
Can try to negotiate for a better deal. That were one highlight of liberty.
The natgas prices are going to hit this country good and hard. Unfortunately it will happen after the midterms. Last January my heating bill was 62% higher than the previous January. This year with world pressure on prices who knows what the hell it'll be. Cook county is delaying property tax bills. The second installment generally posts in late summer I expect it also to be issued around the first week in November substantially higher.
He had information that will lead to Hillary Clinton's arrest.
RIP Kenneth Starr
https://www.yahoo.com/entertainment/ken-starr-prosecutor-led-clinton-235412361.html?fr=yhssrp_catchall
Fetterman may still agree to a debate but only Joe or Kamala.
https://tinyurl.com/yc6xjatz
A rate of increase that is below inflation is too high?
You guys gotta be better.
The story is *why* housing is tight.
Lots of people are blaming Blackrock. They are citing a conspiracy to make us a rental society. Is that true???
There are complaints of foreign investors. What role does that have?
You cite "underbuilt".... but why? How? Where?
We could really use some deep dive reporting instead of fitting a populist story to a tag line.
Latest Inflation Numbers Show That
Rent Is Too Damn High
Energy Is Too Damn High
Groceries are Too Damn High
Healthcare Is Too Damn High
Why? Insane money printing and spending. Biden's and the Democrats policies.
If anyone thinks about rent control...
Economists are virtually unanimous in concluding that rent controls are destructive. In a 1990 poll of 464 economists published in the May 1992 issue of the American Economic Review, 93 percent of U.S. respondents agreed, either completely or with provisos, that “a ceiling on rents reduces the quantity and quality of housing available.”1 Similarly, another study reported that more than 95 percent of the Canadian economists polled agreed with the statement.2
The agreement cuts across the usual political spectrum, ranging all the way from Nobel Prize winners milton friedman and friedrich hayek on the “right” to their fellow Nobel laureate gunnar myrdal, an important architect of the Swedish Labor Party’s welfare state, on the “left.” Myrdal stated, “Rent control has in certain Western countries constituted, maybe, the worst example of poor planning by governments lacking courage and vision.”3
His fellow Swedish economist (and socialist) Assar Lindbeck asserted, “In many cases rent control appears to be the most efficient technique presently known to destroy a city—except for bombing.”
[econlib.org]
There is also mass migration.
A couple of million people left New York and California. That was unexpected.
Detroit is basically depopulated.
We have seen historic levels of illegal immigration.
That means massive shifts in housing needs that could not have been forseen. (Unless you were planning to call forth millions of illegal immigrants)
So the housing story should not be uniform nationally as this story implies. Texas and Florida should be seeing high demand. Florida has definitely seen an explosion, with a confluence of a couple million migrants and huge numbers of properties bought up by inbestment groups to become VRBO or Airbnb rentals.
And all this right into the teeth of an explosion in materials cost and a shortage of labor.
But what of Michigan or Illinois? Surely Chicago isn't experiencing the same 25 to 150% rental increases Miami is? I would not expect them to be successful at luring large numbers to the city with violent crime in the news as much as it is.
How about Portland? A couple of years of continuous riots had no impact on property values?
No mention AT ALL of the eviction moratorium? Of course you have to expect rents to go up, now that landlords are aware that they face the prospect, without advance warning, of not being permitted to evict delinquent tenants. That risk has to be priced into the rent!
And that's on top of inflation, and the housing market inflation that has to be expected to be reflected in rental prices.
Open borders. 3 billion people, give or take, want to move to the United States. That’s a lot of Japanese coffin pods.
Rent's never too high. Usually it lies unrecovered. The part of housing that's high is the location. The value of a location is generated by the surrounding society and the natural assets. No lone owner is responsible for either. Society needs to recover the value it generates--sort of like Singapore--and share the revenue out as a dividend to residents--sort of like Alaska. Then society can quit whining about rent and start celebrating each and every increase.
Has government been meddling in housing???
Well; That's why.....
Name one thing... One thing at all that government has meddled with that actually produced anything but an astronomically ridiculous price.
Because a large part of the problem is government made in the first place.
Everything from zoning restrictions to endlessly cheap interest rates to devaluation of the currency to draconian regulations on lending (but only to normal homebuyers, not to the banks and moneyed classes who hey quantitative easing!) have completely fucked the market.
A libertarian can find a million things here to talk about. People aren't "willing to pay the price" so much as they have no alternatives, and those alternatives have not appeared because of all the externalities and consequences of other governmental interventions that have stopped the natural market forces from solving the shortage.
It's a problem to be solved, though the correct solution was to stop trying to solve the problem Greenspan was solving two decades ago.
A notion which completely misses out on the entire libertarian reason for discussing the issue.
It isn't about "you don't get what you want" at all. If a market was operating properly, you'd still have to make all of those choices. However, the entire price structure would be lower relative to average incomes as folks would be looking to get a piece of that sweet, sweet housing money by building more of it where people wanted to live.
If you don't see why there are libertarian things worth examining here it's entirely because you're being willful. I know you're smarter than that.
Yeah, that's one of the basic obvious things that "affordable housing" advocates pretend not to understand--and maybe some are not pretending.
Plenty of places have VERY cheap rents. And even in desirable areas, rent varies by geography. But trendy people all want to live in the same trendy areas, and sub-areas. And then, um, supply and demand something something.
Great
The biggest govt housing distortion that affects rent is the various subsidies and distortions that create incentives to INVEST in real estate. That is what really ensures that housing prices ratchet up but not down. And increased house prices increase rent.
Investment is now bad.
Who knew?
My god, how can JFear go day after day declaring that day is night and the sun is the moon without just killing himself in embarrassment?
Let's just unpack the idiocy of this statement. The government ENCOURAGES people to invest in real estate, and THAT is why we have such a low supply in real estate. That will of course be news to actual real estate investors who buy land and improve it with new buildings, or buy run-down houses and fix them up to rent, or buy houses that they then upkeep and make available to Renters who cannot otherwise, you know, afford to plunk down the money to buy and upkeep a house. All these people are actually increasing the supply of rentals. Through INVESTMENT.
But yeah, because the government has created incentives that increase demand on real estate consumption, it's the investment that is the problem.
But just set aside how JFear wouldn't know INVESTMENT if it bit him in the ass. He has made a bold statement that government inducements of demand (specific to Real Estate, not just general inflation) are the primary cause of prices rising, not government restrictions on supply.
One wonders who could get us out of this government mess. We have the government convincing all of the INVESTORS to consume real estate. If only there were some class of people who saw the increased demand and could put their money to work building MORE real estate. They would VEST their money IN this new supply and thereby capture immeasurable return on that...monetary use...I wonder why they don't do that?
That investment is distorted - massively- by government. But hey it's not a surprise that sort of govt welfare is considered good
Who do you think creates rental properties?
Ooh look - a Californians opinion about how affordable (meaning rent that is actually affordable relative to lower incomes rather than yet more fucking developer/govt deals) rental housing works.
Idiot filled with envy.
For the last decade plus - No One.
You wanna see where rents go up and a housing crisis begins?
Wherever CA homeowners move to - and cash out their equity into 'inveatment' real estate.