Dispatch From Ukraine: Living as a Russian in Ukraine
A Russian-Ukrainian woman describes how Russians are being fed misinformation.

Though she was born in Ukraine, Nataliya Myslo is of half-Russian and half-Ukrainian descent. By attending Russian schools and speaking exclusively in Russian with her friends and family, her world in Ukraine is largely Russian. But since Russian President Vladimir Putin invaded Ukraine, Myslo has been ashamed of her Russian background.
Myslo spoke, through a translator, with Reason's Nancy Rommelmann sitting in a station wagon in the parking lot of a supermarket in Lviv, Ukraine.

"It's very horrible seeing what's going on, and no other way to describe it. My mother is Russian and she is here and she's in deep shock. I have many relatives in Russia, and I want to explain to them the situation. They don't believe it, they don't want to listen to us. It's like a wall that you cannot shoot through. They get their information from the main governmental television channels in Russia. Their propaganda works. They are like zombies with that information, and then they don't hear anyone else.
"We try to explain to them that we don't have any Nazis or fascism here. Nobody harms us; nobody touches us. My mother was born in Russia and she has lived here [in Ukraine] since the 1960s. We have Russian-speaking friends.
"Our relatives in Russia haven't even called since the war started. They haven't asked, 'Are you okay?' or 'Should we help you or save you because you are Russians and maybe somebody's going to kill you there?' They are not worried. They are not aggressive toward Ukrainians but they have an aggressive attitude toward our authorities. They claim our authorities are Nazis. It's very funny. Zelenskyy is from central Ukraine, and he's Jewish and he's Russian speaking. So how can you call him Nazi if he speaks Russian and he is Jewish? They want to make him an enemy. They need to have this enemy.
"[Russians] live very poor lives. If they have sanctions, nothing is going to change in their lives because they already have nothing. They have natural gas they are selling to many countries, but many of them don't have gas at home. Our living conditions are much better here in Ukraine, and maybe that's the reason why they want to destroy everything here, because Ukraine makes Russia look bad; they don't want us to develop.
"I have many Russian friends living abroad and they say, it's a shame that they have Russian blood, and I also can say now, it is a shame for me. I never could imagine saying that.
"I am more than shocked with what Putin is doing. We were all hoping he was pretending, threatening, bargaining to get better conditions in negotiations and so on, and we didn't believe he could do this. Everyone was shocked. We have a community of people that speak Russian, and we decided to change. We now speak to each other in Ukrainian because we want to protest that we don't agree with Russia. We decided to change our native language because of the crazy one.
"We found a contact for the mothers of Russian soldiers. They have a community, a union of mothers of Russian soldiers, and we send them information, explaining the situation, that their sons are coming here and they are not going to only kill military but also civilian people, children. We explain to them that it is craziness. The mothers are very stressed with that information and they do whatever they can do to not let their sons go.
"There were also some other ways to fight information in this field. We spread information through Google Maps. First of all, we look at the documents of soldiers; we have many documents for soldiers and we have their home addresses. We look on Google Maps for some restaurant or other place in the area and we write a review. In this review we say, 'People from your city come and kill our civilians. Have a look at these documents; he is imprisoned,' or 'He has already died here on our land.' It's real. It's not fake information. This is how we are spreading the information to Russians because you cannot delete this review in Google maps. But now Russia has blocked Google. We were doing the same thing on Instagram too, we were sharing stories with pictures and documents and putting their location with a hashtag, with the name of the city where this soldier is from so somebody would recognize him. But recently Instagram divided Russian and Ukrainian users; Russians cannot see our information and we cannot see Russia's information. They have blocked Facebook and Google. They have switched off VPN [virtual private networks], but we find a way to get this information out to people.
"We have videos of people from Russia where they were interviewed about whether they support Putin or not. And they really do support him; 'Good job, well done,' and that's it. And we send this video to our relatives and say, 'What is your country doing?'"
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
I did the suggested thing of posting some reviews to Russian restaurants, etc. telling them what’s going on. I doubt it makes much difference but doing some small thing to help made me feel better.
Thanks for the report Nancy. Stay safe.
Amen.
+
They get their information from the main governmental television channels in Russia. Their propaganda works. They are like zombies with that information, and then they don't hear anyone else.
The CDC has determined that face masks protect against thermobaric weapons.
The cloth masks help reduce the effects of bombing*
* results not statistically significant
pfizer is on the vaccine.
I hate to see what the booster's going to look like.
The selfies added so much to the story.
-Russia is not targeting civilians
-Russia wouldn't bomb a hostipal
-'Materinity hospital' that seems made up
-The US is building bioweapons in Ukrainian labs
-Zelenskyy is forcing civilians to die fighting Russia
-Ukraine is run by Nazis
-Ukraine is committing genocide against Russians in Dombas
These are just some of the narratives being promoted in the comment section.
-civilian casualty count alone, put out by Ukraine itself, indicates civilians aren't being targeted - further, thanks to Zelensky's orders, there are no longer any official civilians in Ukraine
-youre lying, not a single person has claimed they wouldn't bomb a hospital (notice which side keeps having to resort to lies)
-you admitted yourself in the roundup thread that it was no longer functioning as a maternity hospital
-lol, it's really sad that you've fallen so far that people talking about DoD biolabs in Ukraine upsets you more than DoD running biolabs in Ukraine
-Zelensky is forcing civilians to fight Russia- he literally outlawed males 18-60 from leaving the country
-nobody here claims Ukraine is run by nazis, but neonazis do have considerable power in the military and politically
-nobody here claims Ukraine is committing genocide, but the Kiev government has been waging war on the Donbass for 8 years and 14,000 deaths
Cronut
March.10.2022 at 10:05 am
Flag Comment Mute User
Yeah. It's very possible that the hospital was hit by accident somehow, but a deliberate bombing of a maternity hospital sounds like bullshit to me.
That's a stretch, but you do you.
It's not a stretch; you're an ignorant pile of shit.
Then why have I posted much more information than you, sqrlvo?
You did not read the link. They moved all the patients to the basement. Using it as a bomb shelter. Still a hosptial, still filled with civilians.
Do believe their number of enemy KIA put out by Ukraine? Or do you just believe the ones you like. Either way, none of the numbers are going to be accurate. They have started burying people in mass graves in Mariupol, a sure sign civilians are not being targeted.
https://abcnews.go.com/International/wireStory/besieged-ukraine-city-mariupol-buries-dead-mass-grave-83339614
Ukraine has incentive to inflate both the Russian KIA and Ukrainian civilian counts
And ignorant assholes like you have every incentive to lie.
Russia has an incentive to deflate them.
Misek, you are literally defending him and parroting his talking points.
I wouldn't know, since I have him muted.
I'm just going off information that's been around for 8 years. Some of us have been informed throughout that time, while others of you just found out there was a near decade long war already going on in Ukraine and are just parroting what the TV tells you.
https://thegrayzone.com/2022/03/04/nazis-ukrainian-war-russia/
Someone who preaches against censorship has someone muted? How ever will you be exposed to batcrap crazy alternate points of view?
I'm not preventing anyone else from seeing his idiocy, I'm simply not wasting time on it.
Wtf is wrong with you?
So waging war against invaders is genocide?
Well, the people being notionally genocided there in Eastern Ukraine are Ukraine citizens of Russian descent. Given the sheer numbers of Russians in the world, I'm not sure it would count as genocide even if the Ukrainians killed all the (non-military) "Russians" in Donbass, though it would obviously be horrible and almost certainly meet the bar for "ethnic cleansing".
That said, it doesn't really seem to make any sense for "white supremacists" to dislike the Russians in the area, since they're every bit as white as the Ukrainians.
"The East Slavs are the most populous subgroup of the Slavs. They speak the East Slavic languages, and formed the majority of the population of the medieval state Kievan Rus', which all three independent East Slavic states (Belarus, Russia, and Ukraine) claim as their cultural ancestor."
(See also: This map I posted in another thread.)
So you’re talking about the Russian “volunteers” following Russian military tactics and using Russian weapons to take over the eastern part of Ukraine, right?
This war in Ukraine was planned and executed by the west in 2014 by funding extreme zealots Nazis who are still being funded along with the western puppet Jewish president.
The US was just caught red handed trying to bring Poland into the war, which would have brought NATO into WW3, by transferring Russian fighters to Ukraine.
The bad guys in this conflict are clear and you don’t have to go overseas to find them.
Yeah, Putin and the Russians. That's pretty clear. Regardless of anything, Russian troops are in Ukraine, an independent free nation, that much is known.
It would not have brought on WW3. Putin may be crazy, but he's not stupid.
It was entirely irresponsible and provocative of the US to try to make this a NATO WW3.
Not letting half your civilians leave during a war isn't exactly the most pro-freedom stance a leader can take.
But letting 100% of your people be ruled by a hostile foreign power is? There are no good options here.
Keep that neocon narrative going!
Keep kissing Putin’s ass.
Sure. So what? You should see the kind of fascist and racist crap progressives promote not just here but on CNN. What’s your point?
If you’re confused about the actual libertarian position, it’s simple: libertarians don’t fucking care; what happens between Russia and Ukraine, both of which are corrupt authoritarian states, is none of our business and has no bearing on libertarianism.
Ukraine got rid of their authoritarian puppet government years ago. It's one of the many things that Ukraine has done to turn away from Russia and towards Europe. Away from authoritarianism and towrds democracy. And Putin hates that.
^Right. From a libertarian perspective, Ukraine is a lot less authoritarian than Russia, therefore deserves to win.
This is clearly one of Pootin's motives.
I didn't know that Putin stooges were the same thing as libertarians until I found this board.
T.V. Eye is my favorite
They aren’t libertarians. There aren’t a lot of libertarians frequenting the Reason commentariat anymore.
Barbie Jack, I've missed your scintillating scientific analysis these days, but it's good to see you still sulking about making snide comments.
It reassures me that Dems are still in for a historic drubbing come midterms for being vile totalitarians.
Be sure to stay current on your boosters!
Joe, here is the libertarian position: Ukraine and Russia are none of America’s government’s fucking business.
Your brain is so scrambled that you mistake neutrality for being a Putin stooge.
There is a difference between opposing foreign military adventurism and being isolationists. Retreating from the world is not libertarian.
Supporting those who share our values against those that don't is what we should be doing.
"I want to explain to them the situation. They don't believe it, they don't want to listen to us. It's like a wall that you cannot shoot through. They get their information from the main governmental television channels in Russia. Their propaganda works. They are like zombies with that information, and then they don't hear anyone else."
Funny how that goes...
We just did fucking covid, people, and some of you are running around screaming "sovereignty" like "public good" was screamed then.
Sorry, they cannot be spared either. Just a casualty of their govt's actions, just like we are by out govt., and the German and Japanese civilians of WW II. This is why you can't be complacent in the first place. I live in occupied California and am at eternal war with the libs. Yet the rest of the country hates me because I am from Cali and they thinks we are all the same. It sucks but that's the hand I was dealt so I have to play it. Same goes for the sputniks.
“Their propaganda works. They are like zombies with that information, and then they don't hear anyone else.”
Hence the big “Z” painted on all their military vehicles.
Next they'll be banning Zorro.
"Our living conditions are much better here in Ukraine [than in Russia]"
I would certainly hope so, as Ukraine has three times as much public debt per unit of GDP and higher dept per capita. Hopefully borrowing from their kids got them some nice things.
Am I reading this right? The US paid Ukraine $15m for samples of all their bioweapons and oversight on continued development under the guise of nonproliferation?
Dissemination = reduction. Obedience is freedom.
https://www.state.gov/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/05-829-Ukraine-Weapons.pdf
https://twitter.com/cliftonaduncan/status/1501969339116838912?t=YHOIBPrQdMOzgkwoUQp7tw&s=19
Sam Kinison has returned, and he has something to say
[Pic]
https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/exclusive-facebook-instagram-temporarily-allow-calls-violence-against-russians-2022-03-10/
Good. The anti-libertarian invaders deserve to die.
https://twitter.com/realjuliasong/status/1501973081530769411?t=82y5bfwRgoehEAgbQ4GNxw&s=19
The truth is we became energy independent during Trump and for some reason y’all thought it would be a good idea to put an end to that.
[Propaganda video]
https://twitter.com/lwoodhouse/status/1501946980192317448?t=M0LEliMm0IVg9RvLJEnwEA&s=19
How dare the pharmaceutical industry continue providing medicine to Russian children with leukemia
One of the most sociopathic quotes I’ve seen all year.
"If we continue to make life palatable for them, then we are continuing to support the regime"
[Link]
Let 'em make their own leukemia drugs for their children if they hate freedom so much. Or, they can revolt against their anti-libertarian government and stop invading free nations.
https://twitter.com/SallyMayweather/status/1502034817101279235?t=Nv5KoneyZQZHmSglGnilbw&s=19
[Meme]
OH, OH, another twitter feed!
Stuff it up your ass, shitbag.
Twitter is shit.
As articles like this show, we are subjected to constant propaganda as well.
We're all propaganda.
But, is it not true?
The obsession our media elite have for Russia and the former Soviet "republics" is really interesting. I'm old enough to recall how the media was pushing "Peaceful co-existence" and one positive article after another of life in the USSR. Now they have an almost visceral hatred of Russia and Russians. You honestly have to ask yourself why. I know many of our media elite tend to have ancestry from Eastern Europe or Russia (seriously at the NYT or WaPo there are very few Irish or Italian or German or English and on and on) journalists. I think much of this besides the obvious that a sovereign nation should not be attacked (Iraq anyone? Libya? Syria? Yemen?) has to do with historical issues. I have a journalist friend at Gannett and he is very clear that Putin is the new czar and the old czar was a bad guy to his ancestors. Communism doesn't bother him (he thinks it is needed here to wipe away white privilege) but Putin is the devil. Very insightful.
Uh, have you heard about the meeting between Nixon and Hitler in Uruguay in '56?
Care to offer any cite at all for that pile of bullshit?
Every few years a well connected media celebrity claims who controls the media and are immediately cancelled for it.
They aren’t saying Russia or Hitler.
"A Russian-Ukrainian woman describes how Russians are being fed misinformation."
well I'm relieved to hear that, for the first time in recorded history, only the people on one side of a war are lying
the lurid histrionics leading up the invasion are now shown to be totally false -- Russia's pathetic excuse for armed forces have not rolled unopposed into Kiev or beyond, and are clearly no threat to any modern Western military, let alone to re-assemble the Soviet Union, while Putin has already signaled he is willing to pull back to the Donbas republics
absolutely no reason for the West to obsess over yet another pointless Russian border war, let alone become involved
No, but some people here tend to believe the Russian narrative over the Ukrainian one.
There are three sides here, Russia, Ukraine, and reality.
Not one brick off the wall but the courtyard was decimated.
Had the building been targeted the walls would have been destroyed.
Cowardly Nazi Ukrainians firing from hospital grounds.
Russian casualties stem from their care taken to precisely hit military targets. If they were cowardly Nazis like the west, they’d bomb from altitude like we did with SHOCK AND AWE levelling everything and killing indiscriminately.
Given Russia has lied constantly throughout the buildup and the invasion, it's not hard to figure out who is lying.
How about the word pedantic?
Lol, you love being a dick. You'd never moderate a chance to let the hate flow.
[JOIN NOW] I really make A LOT OF MONEY ($200-$300/hour) online from my laptop. Last month I received almost $50,000. this line work is simple and straightforward. You don’t need to go to the office, it’s online work from home. rbg You become independent after joining this position. I really appreciate my friend.
...
Who pointed it out to me SITE….., http://moneystar33.blogspot.com/
Wow, googling “proud Russian” yields zero results.
Our media must be right.
Joe Friday still doesn't know anything, but at least he's found this board.
Nuance has no place in emoting wars.
So both sides? Russia is definitely morally and legally wrong, but don't pay attention to that. Ignore Russia's track record, the fact that Putin is a violent, brutal autocrat, and the fact that there is no reason for them to be invading Ukraine.
Imagine my surprise that you are playing the Russian apologist
Unequivocally yes, pistachio is a superior flavor, unless it's contaminated with mint nonsense.
No, he's saying, "Russian “volunteers” following Russian military tactics and using Russian weapons to take over the eastern part of Ukraine..."
Yet, "libertarians" have become completely comfortable being on these people's side now
That's not very humane.
On that we agree.
If Ukraine closer I can tell you more.
Refusing to consider counter arguments defines bigotry.
Using a mute button proves bigotry.
Truth doesn’t reach bigots.
It doesn’t take rocket science to recognize the false claims of a bigot.
Any intelligent person can expose their bigotry and refute what they say.
I do it all the time. You know when you’re a hopeless bigot when you give up trying to silence counter arguments and push the mute button. You live in blissful ignorance.
People have actually admitted their bigotry to me thinking it’s similar to having an irrefutable argument.
NOYB2
February.11.2022 at 1:15 pm
Flag Comment Mute User
We're both bigots
Yes, Misek, I have an unshakable view that you are a despicable human being. In that sense, and only in that sense, I am a bigot.
You are a bigot too, Misek, because you cling to your absurd and irrational ideas about the Holocaust.
You are simply a bigot. You do you. I argue in good faith.
The fact that you can’t refute the truth demonstrated by logic and science isn’t bigotry. Your subsequent denial of it is.
If you can demonstrate that you have provided irrefutable evidence that I have either ignored or denied, then you have an argument for my bigotry.
You haven’t. You have only admitted your own bigotry.
Your previous admission of bigotry was related to the facts of an argument, nothing to do with me. Fuck you liar.
I would say that you can't possibly be this dumb, but you are a Holocaust denier so it's a definite possibility.
GG and Nardz have made a career of that; the world really doesn't need more ignoramuses, but we got two of them.
Not a "possibility" simply reality. Here's an example of Misek's 'intelligence':
Rob Misek
March.5.2022 at 8:47 am
"The fuel price has nothing to do with supply and demand.
More people are working from home than ever before. Demand is down. Russia isn’t affecting North American supply."
According to Misek, first supply and demand has nothing to do with petroleum pricing, but then it does and, amazingly, to every other observer, a reduction in demand means an increase it price!
There is good reason to treat Misek as you might turd, Nardz, GG and other ignorant pieces of shit; with insults and nothing else.
If you aren’t capable of refuting what I say, by what stupidity are you denying it, bigotry?
Rather, stupid shots like you have done so.
Thou protesteth too much.
To a bigot, any protest is too much.
Hahaha. You’re so stupid.
If price increases with a decrease in demand and no decrease in supply, then it has nothing to do with supply and demand.
Is antisemitism on the rise? Probably.
One thing is certain. Every one of the people quoted here has more credibility than you.
Just add the “h” to each link.
ttps://slate.com/news-and-politics/2010/10/rick-sanchez-says-jews-control-the-media-is-that-true.html
ttps://www.haaretz.com/jewish/1.5152427
ttps://www.beliefnet.com/columnists/feilerfaster/2007/10/jews-do-control-the-media-and.html
ttps://mondoweiss.net/2008/02/do-jews-dominat/
ttps://www.businessinsider.com/these-6-corporations-control-90-of-the-media-in-america-2012-6
ttps://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/boris-johnson-book-jews-control-media-general-election-a9239346.html
ttps://www.jta.org/archive/shah-of-iran-says-u-s-jews-control-banks-media-finances
ttps://www.richardsilverstein.com/2008/06/10/carla-cohen-walt-mearsheimer-say-jews-control-media/
ttps://www.jweekly.com/2011/03/11/npr-exec-sorry-for-saying-jews-control-print-media-to-men-posing-as-donors/
ttps://www.newsweek.com/americans-jews-are-starting-wars-jewish-former-cia-spy-valerie-plame-wilson-669118
ttps://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/dec/18/donald-trump-antisemitic-tropes-anti-defamation-league
ttp://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/4643720.stm
ttps://www.vox.com/identities/2018/3/19/17139516/dc-lawmaker-anti-semitism-conspiracy-theory-trayon-white
ttps://www.thejc.com/news/world/jews-control-the-media-says-former-guardian-editor-1.37617
ttps://edition.cnn.com/2020/07/17/entertainment/nick-cannon-backlash-tweet/index.html
ttps://www.mediaite.com/online/trump-says-israel-literally-owned-congress-until-a-few-years-ago-wonders-why-more-american-jews-didnt-vote-for-him/
ttps://www.transcend.org/tms/2012/07/jews-do-control-the-media/
ttps://shoah.org.uk/jews-do-control-the-media-2/
ttps://www.nytimes.com/2002/03/03/us/billy-graham-apologizes-to-jews-for-his-remarks-on-nixon-tapes.html
ttps://www.washingtonexaminer.com/washington-secrets/72-percent-say-media-dividing-americans-spreading-hate
ttps://archive.ph/ToUJs
ttps://www.bibliotecapleyades.net/sociopolitica/sociopol_mediacontrol45.htm
ttps://ahvalnews.com/turkey-united-states/erdogans-media-say-jews-control-america-brought-biden-office
ttps://www.thetower.org/4984-abbas-appointee-jews-control-the-media-the-money-the-press-the-resources-the-plans/
ttps://whtt.org/noted-zionist-apologist-alan-dershowitz-brags-of-jewish-power/