Industrial Policy Failed With Vaccines Too

Global supply chains beat government-directed manufacturing once again.


More than 100 million Americans have already received at least one dose of a COVID-19 vaccine—but if the country was waiting for the federal government's handpicked vaccine manufacturer to deliver those shots, the pandemic's end would be nowhere in sight.

Emergent BioSolutions, a Maryland-based biotech firm, has received a series of government contracts since 2012 as part of a federal effort that anticipated the need for domestic vaccine production in response to a global pandemic of a flu-like disease, The New York Times reports. Last June, the company received a $628 million contract to produce COVID-19 vaccines being designed by Johnson & Johnson and AstraZeneca—but so far the facility has yet to produce a single usable dose of either vaccine.

Last week's announcement that more than 15 million doses of the Johnson & Johnson vaccine produced at Emergent's Baltimore factory would have to be destroyed after being contaminated is the most high-profile mistake, but it's part of a long track record of problems. The explosive Times story says at least 10 million doses of the AstraZeneca vaccine have been discarded due to contamination, while millions of other doses have yet to be approved for use by the general public.

Emergent has "spent much of the last two decades cornering a lucrative market in federal spending on biodefense," the Times reports. But while getting fat on government contracts, audits found "a persistent problem with mold in areas required to be kept clean, poor disinfection of some plant equipment leading to growth of bacteria, the repeated approval of raw materials that had not been fully tested, and inadequate training of some employees"—issues that likely culminated in the contamination problems that have plagued Emergent's COVID-19 vaccine production.

The whole story is a perfect illustration of why the urge to give the government greater control over crucial supply chains—something that some on both the right and the left are urging in the wake of the pandemic—could be inviting disaster. The vaccines that millions of Americans receive every day are the result of a global system of research, development, manufacturing, and trade. Forcing those networks to be concentrated within the United States wouldn't make those supply chains more robust, but would leave Americans vulnerable to the accountability problems that seem endemic to federal government contracting.

These problems are probably inevitable because of the incentives created by industrial policy. Emergent has a massive lobbying operation that has successfully steered hundreds of millions of dollars of government funding to the company. What it hasn't done is produce usable COVID-19 vaccines.

It's true, of course, that the federal government paid billions of dollars to Pfizer and other vaccine manufacturers in the form of advance-purchase agreements last year. But that's a different situation—one that effectively promised prize money but still put the onus on private companies to deliver vaccines that worked. While certainly not an ideal arrangement from a libertarian point of view, it's far better than an industrial policy that directs public funds to companies that hire the best lobbyists.

Unfortunately, there are plenty of people calling for exactly that. From the Biden administration's "Buy American" mandate, to Sen. Josh Hawley's (R–Mo.) demands that the federal government invest in manufacturing to counter China, industrial policy takes many forms. The COVID-19 pandemic has spurred calls for greater government involvement in supply chains for vaccines, pharmaceutical drugs, medical equipment, and more.

Advocates for industrial policy say they are concerned about the resiliency of global supply chains or worried that outsourcing manufacturing will leave Americans cut-off from vital goods. Those concerns are largely overblown—either the result of misleading political narratives or temporary disruptions caused by a once-in-a-generation global catastrophe. In fact, the private supply chains that carry everything from Xbox consoles to t-shirts around the globe have proven to be invaluable in the widespread distribution of vaccines, most of which are produced in Europe.

Industrial policy, meanwhile, results in head-scratching decisions like the Trump administration throwing $765 million at Eastman Kodak, a bankrupt film company, in the name of securing America's supply of crucial drugs—but only after the company had lobbied hard for the cash. This sort of thing doesn't protect America from the next pandemic. It merely empowers lobbyists and encourages cronyism.

The mess at Emergent Biosolutions seems to be the result of a similar set of incentives. A year after the 2009 H1N1 epidemic in the United States, a federal audit recommended that the government invest in "domestic manufacturing sites" for vaccines to head off the next disease outbreak, the Times reports. Two years later, Emergent started getting government funding for exactly that purpose.

We're still waiting for it to pay off.

NEXT: Florida Cops Use a Victims’ Rights Law To Conceal Their Names

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  1. LIFE CHANGING OPPORTUNITY BE an Internet HOME-BASED real Earner.I am just working on facebook only 3 to 4 hours a Day and earning £47786 a month easily, that is handsome earning BHGY to meet my extra expenses and that is really life changing opportunity. Let me give you a little insight into what I do….. Visit Here

    1. Making money online more than 15$ just by doing simple work from home. I have received $18376 last month. Its an easy and simple job to do and its earnings C are much better than regular office job and even a little child can do this and earns money. Everybody must try this job by just use the info
      on this page…..VISIT HERE

    2. I am creating an honest wage from home 3000 Dollars/week , that is wonderful, below a year agone i used to be unemployed during a atrocious economy. I convey God on a daily basis i used to be endowed these directions and currently it’s my duty to pay it forward and share it with everybody, Here is I started Copy This Link For Full Detail…USA Dollars

  2. Well, sure, government industrial policy looks bad if you focus on the failures, but what about when it works, like when Trump invoked the defense production act to get GM to produce tens of thousands of ventilators? I haven’t heard anybody complaining about a shortage of ventilators lately so it must have worked, right?

    1. No, there is a surplus, of ventilators now because in the end providers found out hey were not that effective in treating Covid patients. If the market had been allowed to work this waste would not have occurred. Government can’t calculate and is the last institution to determine the allocation of scarce resources. The ventilator situation only underlies this.

      1. Check sarc meter calibration.

    2. How much did the DPA even help in that case? GM was already working to manufacture ventilators. Invoking DPA seemed to be more of a negotiation tactic than something that had more than a trivial impact on the end result.

      Note, for example, hand sanitizer. The government did nothing other than get out of the way, and tons of distilleries switched production and put it in whatever bottles they could find.

  3. Start making cash online work easily from home.everybody can join this job and make extra dollars in part time…………….USA PART TIME JOB.

    1. sex personals uk is great web platform for sexy chat contacts in UK, check out and enjoy

  4. Everybody can earn 500 dollars can earn more than you think by working online from home. I have been doing this job for like a few weeks and my last week payment was exactly 2537 dollars…………….EARNS DOLLARS.

  5. More than 100 million Americans have already received at least one dose of a COVID-19 vaccine—but if the country was waiting for the federal government’s handpicked vaccine manufacturer to deliver those shots, the pandemic’s end would be nowhere in sight…………….MORE INFORMACTION.

  6. No wonder the democrat governors didn’t want the trump vaccine. They knew.

  7. The whole story is a perfect illustration of why the urge to give the government greater control over crucial supply chains—something that some on both the right and the left are urging in the wake of the pandemic—could be inviting disaster. something that has nothing to do with anything but which I wanted to write an article about

    Are you saying that government is the customer who is paying for the vaccine? That they are merely an incompetent purchasing agent? Or are you saying that someone else should be the customer for the vaccine and govt – as a proven incompetent purchasing agent should merely purchase the taxpayer-paid vaccine from someone else?

    Or are you saying govt should have entirely ignored everything about the vaccine and hey presto the vaccine would have magically appeared absent ‘Operation Warp Speed’ and been distributed in a far more effective way handwave handwave handwave

    1. Straw man set up – and knocked down. You’re a pro at this.


        1. We are.

          1. FFS. You people are useless

            1. JFree called on bullshit, whines again.
              Stuff your PANIC flag up your ass.

  8. “Two years later, Emergent started getting government funding for exactly that purpose.”

    Oh, they only started in 2011, then that sounds about right. Have you seen a US highway, bridge, or train project that took less than a decade, was billions over budget, and didn’t need billions in repairs immediately on completion if not before?

    Let’s be clear, Biden’s infrastructure plan isn’t short term regardless of what it says. The whole point is to force throwing good money after bad and stretching this shit out over multiple generations.

  9. The COVID-19 pandemic has spurred calls for greater government involvement

    Well there’s your problem right there.

  10. Well, Newsom has a panel, notably incvluding Tom Steyer, to ‘plan’ the CA economy reopening in a more equitable manner; that should be comedy gold for a long time!

  11. The J&J vaccine materials mixup at Emergent is not a failure of industrial policy or a vindication of global supply chains. It is a screw-up. Happens. Shouldn’t happen but it did. One can lay the blame on going too fast or poor leadership/training. It does show that our domestic capacity was over-stretched. Depth in a supply chain is good insurance, but not if the supplier is weak. One can criticize J&J for not having enough internal capacity. Going forward they have reason to tell their cheese-paring bean counters to accept a greater degree of redundancy. (The B school crowd will faint.) How much did J&J lose in share price and prestige? Would build and staff a lot of plants.

  12. Other than wasting money, no one cares about the Holy Rona Water.

Please to post comments

Comments are closed.