New York Legislature Repeals Notorious Police Secrecy Law

New York was a national outlier in hiding police misconduct records. The state legislature finally repealed the law responsible for it.


New York lawmakers passed a bill today rolling back a notorious police secrecy law that has hidden misconduct records from the public for decades. 

The New York Senate and Assembly both passed legislation repealing Section 50-a of New York's civil rights statute, which makes law enforcement personnel records exempt from the state's Freedom of Information Law (FOIL). New York Democratic Gov. Andrew Cuomo said last week that he would sign such a bill.

Civil rights activists and progressive state legislators have been trying to repeal the law for years, saying it shields officers with long histories of misconduct from accountability. Calls for repeal grew after the 2014 killing of Eric Garner by an NYPD officer whose secret misconduct records were later leaked to the media.

However, politically powerful police unions squashed those reform efforts every year, securing the support of Republicans and moderate Democrats, including Cuomo and New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio. But in the wake of massive, multi-day protests over the killing of George Floyd by a Minneapolis police officer, the state's Democrats moved swiftly.

The legislation is part of a larger package of police reform bills Democrats are pushing. It will open up disciplinary records to FOIL requests, except for discipline for technical infractions that don't involve interactions with the public.

New York Civil Liberties Union executive director Donna Lieberman said in a statement that the repeal is "a historic win for New York and a long overdue change to the most restrictive police secrecy law in the country."

"The repeal of 50-a is a critical step toward justice for New Yorkers, especially Black and Brown New Yorkers who have historically been the main targets of police abuse," said Lieberman.

New York lawmakers originally passed Section 50-a in 1976 to prevent attorneys from using unfounded complaints to impugn police officers' testimony during trial. But it has been steadily expanded by courts over the last 40 years—often as a result of litigation between police departments and news outlets or civil liberties groups—to hide a wide array of police records, including police shooting reports, transcripts of administrative trials, and even anonymized data on police use of force. A 2018 report by the New York City Bar concluded that 50-a "has been interpreted so broadly that police misconduct in New York State is more secretive than any other state in the nation."

Reason reported last year on how Section 50-a has stonewalled the families of police shooting victims looking for answers, like Constance Malcolm. In 2012, NYPD officer Richard Haste and several other narcotics officers tailed Malcolm's son, 18-year-old Ramarley Graham, from a bodega into Graham's apartment, believing he had a gun, and fatally shot the unarmed young man. Malcolm has been fighting for years to pry information from the NYPD about the shooting and the officers involved, with little success. 

"Even now, eight years later, Ramarley's family has still only been allowed to know some of the officers' names who were involved," New York state Sen. Julia Salazar said in a floor speech on the bill today. "Repealing Section 50-a is about giving these families answers when we know that we collectively have not given them justice."

Police unions opposed the legislation—as they have all efforts to reform 50-a—on the grounds that it would unfairly reveal unsubstantiated complaints and open up officers to targeted harassment and threats. A group of nine New York police unions wrote in a letter on Friday that such disclosures "would expose the accused officer to serious safety concerns as well as unavoidable and irreparable harm to reputation and livelihood."

But for the first time since the law was passed, the police unions couldn't sway enough Democrats. The New York Senate passed the legislation by a 40-22 vote, and the House passed it by 101-43. In the House, the vote was followed by a moment of silence for George Floyd.

"New York affirmed today that our state stands for transparency in policing, a vital step toward restoring confidence in law enforcement which is so undermined when a black or brown person, like George Floyd or Eric Garner, dies as a result of an encounter with an officer with a history of misconduct," Norman Reimer, the executive director of the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, said in a press release. "With the full repeal 50-a, police accountability takes a step closer to becoming a reality by allowing misconduct engaged in by a police officer to be accessible by the public."

NEXT: 'Defund the Police' Should Include Federal Cops Too

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  1. “A group of nine New York police unions ”

    Really? NINE different unions? That explains a lot.

    1. Do they have overlapping memberships or something? Someone really should be writing an article to explain how the fuck THAT works. Paint that picture for us, please.

      1. Make 5000 bucks every month… I have been working from home for 4 years now and I love it. I don’t have a boss standing over my shoulder and I make my own hours. The tips below are very informative and anyone currently working from home or planning to in the future could use these. Start doing online computer-based work through our website… Reading Articles

  2. But for the first time since the law was passed, the police unions couldn’t sway enough Democrats.

    When all this blows over, they will pay. Oh, yes. They will pay.

    1. Corona is big threat of the century which effect physically, mentally and financially/MLp To over come these difficulties and make full use of this hostage period and make online earning.

      For more detail visit the given link…….► Home Profit System

  3. Is it retroactive? Does it open up records from prior to today? Or is it only for records created from now on?

    Expect litigation to take years; long enough for the legislature to reinstate it.

    1. Is it retroactive?

      Are there exempted records that remain sealed?

  4. New York’s Republicans voted for continued secrecy.

    Carry on, clingers. But only so far as better Americans permit.

    1. Keep on clingin’ gecko.

      1. The clingers were overrun by their betters in this one.

        Get used to it.

  5. Well, they passed a law, let’s see if they can enforce it.

  6. “However, politically powerful police unions squashed those reform efforts every year, securing the support of Republicans and moderate Democrats, including Cuomo and New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio.”

    You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.

  7. “The New York Senate passed the legislation by a 40-22 vote, and the House passed it by 101-43.”

    The lower house of the New York State legislature is called the “Assembly.”

    1. And the Republicans in the New York State legislator are called the “losers.”

      And that’s before the November election kicks clingers to the curb.

  8. O/T and FFS – David Petraeus suggests changing the name of former confederate bases, including Bragg and Benning.

    1. Sad thing is that Petraeus didn’t just recently get woke, he’s been pretty squishy for years. He’s a member of several groups that promote, among other things, gun control, “peace studies”, addressing the global threat of climate change, and other such internationalist crap.

  9. I Make Money At H0me.Let’s start work offered by Google!!Yes,this is definitely the most financially rewarding Job I’ve had . YEr Last Monday I bought a great Lotus Elan after I been earning $9534 this-last/5 weeks and-a little over, $10k last month . . I started this four months/ago and immediately started to bring home minimum $97 per/hr

    Heres what I do…… SeeMore here

  10. Leave it to New York to have the “secret police”.

    These police unions need to be torn down. Their influence is unacceptable. They occupy no public office & operate without liability to the considerable detriment of all. They don’t belong in the public realm

  11. Anyone who can leave the liberal cesspool also known as NY should. You will not enjoy living there much longer. I left well before this shit way back in 1978 and miss absolutely nothing…especially the taxes which will go up even higher to find all the blacks demands.

  12. Another good example of how the riots were successful. Like them or hate them, so far, they have definitely led to some significant change.

    Such a “reform” should have been easy. The reasons it wasn’t accomplished long ago are the reasons why it was needed in the first place and the reasons why change was only going to be initiated by a jolt to the public–regarding policing, most Americans didn’t feel responsible, most Americans didn’t know, most Americans didn’t care.

Please to post comments

Comments are closed.