Marijuana

This Marijuana Reform T-Shirt Cost Iowa Taxpayers Half a Million Bucks

The state will pay damages and legal fees for violating the First Amendment rights of ISU activists.

|

lawsuit exhibit

The cost of violating the First Amendment by censoring T-shirts promoting a marijuana reform group at Iowa State University is likely to exceed $500,000 under a settlement announced this week. That's not counting the resources the Iowa Attorney General's Office has devoted to its defense of the university's refusal to let the ISU chapter of the National Organization for the Reform of Marijuana Laws (NORML) use an image of the school's mascot, Cy the Cardinal, on its shirts.

Student groups are routinely allowed to use Cy, and in 2012 ISU's Trademark Office initially approved a design in which the bird was leaning on the initials ISU with his head taking the place of the O in NORML. The back of the shirt said "Freedom is NORML at ISU" with a cannabis leaf above NORML.

That decision became politically problematic a month later after The Des Moines Register ran a story about marijuana legalization that included a photo of NORML ISU members wearing the T-shirts. Responding to complaints from state legislators and Iowa Gov. Terry Branstad's chief drug policy adviser, ISU officials effectively rescinded approval of the T-shirt by refusing to let the student group order more, changed the rules for using ISU trademarks, and subjected NORML ISU T-shirt designs to special scrutiny, rejecting any that featured Cy or cannabis leaves.

In 2014, with the help of the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education, NORML ISU members Paul Gerlich and Erin Furleigh sued ISU President Steven Leath and three other administrators, arguing that the state university's politically motivated T-shirt censorship violated their right to freedom of speech. A federal judge agreed. "Plaintiffs' political message, and a political reaction, was a driving factor behind Defendants' actions," U.S. District Judge Gritzner wrote in a 2016 ruling. "Defendants took action specifically directed at NORML ISU based on their views and the political reaction to those views so that Defendants could maintain favor with Iowa political figures. As such, the Court must conclude Defendants' conduct amounts to discrimination on the basis of Plaintiffs' viewpoint."

ISU appealed Gritzner's decision, and last year the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 8th Circuit rebuked the school again. "Defendants' actions and statements show that the unique scrutiny they imposed on NORML ISU's trademark applications was motivated by viewpoint discrimination," said a three-judge panel of the court. "Defendants violated plaintiffs' First Amendment rights because defendants engaged in viewpoint discrimination and did not argue that their administration of the trademark licensing program was narrowly tailored to satisfy a compelling governmental interest."

Under a settlement agreement approved on Tuesday by the State Appeal Board, the state will pay $150,000 in damages to Gerlich and Furleigh, $193,000 for the appeals work done by their lawyers, and an additional sum, to be determined by a judge, for their trial work. Robert Corn-Revere, the lead attorney for the plaintiffs, told the Associated Press that last bill will be "substantially more" than $193,000.

"It is an unambiguous win for our clients and for the First Amendment," Corn-Revere said. "Violating people's rights isn't free. One reason we urge universities to settle early is to avoid these kinds of expenses."

NEXT: Court Unblocks Ranked-Choice Voting in Santa Fe; Maine Still Obstructed

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  1. Holy grade school Batman! This new website format is terrible. Some of us still have actual computers and don’t comment from our phones.

    1. For some reason, Reason opened at a 170 percent zoom. Other websites were fine. It’s okay now after going back to 110 percent. (Just like Pete Rose, I always give 110 percent.)

      1. /outrage

        1. It’s /outrage all the way down

    2. I prefer the mobile setting for my desktop computer.

  2. The worst part is, it’s one hell of an ugly-ass shirt.

    1. That’s the cyclones for ya – iowa is the Hawkeye State! (thanks Pittsburg Steelers for letting the Hawks steal your design)

    2. that’s what makes this case so hilarious. I am guessing the students in the shirt project came up with some pretty nice designs, all rejected by the school. Had the school’s hoooh hahs not gone all stinko on the first one, maybe they’d have improved it.

      But, I think the design is decent.. it conveys the desired message, is just enough “in yer face, Bucko” to make the uptight/upright lot even more so, yet not so terrible I’d have been glad had the T shirt guys lost.

  3. I’m kind of disappointed that the school didn’t appeal to SCOTUS. They seem to dig having judges tell them that they violated peoples’ rights.

  4. That’s not counting the resources the Iowa Attorney General’s Office has devoted to its defense…

    Meh. They weren’t otherwise doing anything important anyway.

  5. What does a totalitarian state care? They got to trample rights.Tax payers pay for it, further trampling rights. Win win for wannabe dictators.

  6. OK, I’m surprised that anyone in Herbert Hoover’s Landover Baptist Iowa can get away with mixing cartoons and hemp, nevermind that it’s been 50 years since 1968. But I’m not surprised that Beauregard Sessions is being unleashed upon Gomorrah. God’s Own Prohibitionists, in their Combatting Drug Abuse platform declared: “The progress made over the last three decades against drug abuse is eroding, whether for cultural reasons or for lack of national leadership. In many jurisdictions, marijuana is virtually legalized despite its illegality under federal law.”
    That as many as a million morons willing to vote for those creeps–or their energy hating co-kleptocrats–is a sad sign of the breakdown of ethical values and political freedom. Seeing such creeps sworn in is ipso facto proof of massive vote fraud.

  7. Top grade marijuana,Edibles,Wax oils and Pain relief pills

    Top legit and genuine suppliers of Best medical marijuana

    like,Cannabis,
    sour diesel etc at affordable prices available. Very good for

    patients of
    cancer of all kinds.We await good customers.

    E-mail Address; (bodybuildingpharma59@gmail.com)
    Text or Call; (325) 261-0302

    *Grand Daddy Purple Grade: A
    *Sensi Star x ak47 Grade: AAA
    *Northern Lights #5 :Grade: A+
    *Lemon KUSH:Grade: A+
    *Purple Kush:Grade:A+ Top Shelf
    *OG Kush :Grade:A++ Top
    *purple-urkle:Grade:A+
    *White Widow:A+
    *Blue Dream:A++
    *kurupts moonrock: A+
    *Kratom:A
    *Edibles
    *Wax oils

    And more….

    we are also suppliers of pain anxiety pain relief meds. Discount

    are also
    applicable for bulk buyers.The shipping is meticulously planned;

    packaging
    is done. Such as

    ,Adderall,Ativan,Oxycontin,Xanax,percocets,Morphin and
    more…
    E-mail Address; (bodybuildingpharma59@gmail.com)
    Text or Call; (325) 261-0302

Please to post comments

Comments are closed.