Paul Ryan

Dropping the BAT Is Key to Passing Tax Reform This Year

Paul Ryan is needlessly holding up tax reform by pushing a harmful Border Adjustment Tax.


Rep. Paul Ryan

House Speaker Paul Ryan just made his pitch to the country about tax reform. He wants it, and he wants it before the end of 2017 because, as he said in his prepared remarks, "we cannot let this once-in-a-generation moment slip by." That's all well and good, except that the main factor holding up tax reform is the speaker's insistence that the United States adopt a distortive and unfair border adjustment tax to pay for the reform.

In the best of circumstances, fundamental tax reform is difficult, but now it seems even harder, thanks to Ryan's refusal to move away from a proposed 20 percent tax on imports while giving a free ride to exporters. The whole point of fundamental reform is to cut taxes and grow the economy. Though the rest of the Republican tax plan is pro-growth, according to scores of the plan, the border adjustment tax wouldn't create any growth. Its only purpose would be to raise revenue, as Republicans are apparently once again refusing to pay for tax reform with spending cuts.

Though the speaker tried not mentioning the border adjustment tax, his speech made clear his commitment to his blueprint as originally proposed, which includes the BAT. Concocted by economists in the comfort of the frictionless world of an academic paper, it would allegedly raise $100 billion per year from importers and consumers while handing out more subsidies to giant companies such as Boeing and General Electric. If you think it reeks of the export mercantilism that plagues Washington, you're right, and that's hard to square with Ryan's talking point about the need to turn away from granting tax favors to special interests.

The plan is also sold as a way to undermine tax competition by putting an end to tax avoidance—the legal way companies structure their operations to send as little money to Uncle Sam as possible. This may not sound too bad when the tax rate is 20 percent or 15 percent. It's a terrible idea, however, when the rate is raised to 30 percent or more by lawmakers who desperately need revenue to mitigate their inevitable failure to reform entitlement spending.

Those pushing for the plan also have the notion that the adjustment of the dollar resulting from the tax's implementation would compensate for the added tax burden. As a currency trader noted recently, building "an intergenerational tax reform based on the assumption of what the (foreign exchange) market will do is a laughable notion." If you think it sounds very risky and distortive, you're right. The result is a measure that has divided the business community, the Republican caucus and the free market policy world. And it has little chance of getting out of the House, let alone passing the Senate.

Yet Ryan and House Ways and Means Committee Chairman Kevin Brady continue to hang on to the divisive measure. In a new twist, they're now hoping they can fool the opposition by phasing in the tax over several years, as if implementing a bad idea slowly makes it any better. As Stan Veuger of the American Enterprise Institute recently observed, we shouldn't count on a phase-in improving it. The phase-in would be more distortive and increase the trade deficit for the first five or six years without increasing whatever little chances exist of reaching whatever currency adjustment would be necessary to offset the tax pain for importers. If anything, the prospect of trade deficit growth makes it even less politically acceptable to the Trump administration, which is already opposed to it.

Finally, border-adjusting our corporate income tax as Ryan wants to do presents massive implementation challenges. In particular, it would be a nightmare for a bunch of industries, including finance and insurance. So now BAT proponents are talking about putting in place targeted rules for a whole swath of industries—making the tax code more complicated, not less.

I agree with Ryan that it would be a shame to miss this once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to implement fundamental tax reform. Yet he's the one who is derailing the effort with his insistence on the BAT's being part of his tax plan. If he dropped it, we could finally unite and start looking for alternatives (including spending cuts) to pay for the good reforms. If he doesn't, Republicans may have to add tax reform to their list of broken promises.


NEXT: Milwaukee Jury Acquits Ex-Cop in Police Shooting Case

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  1. I liked Paul Ryan better when he was dropping phat beats as Triple P Paulie a.k.a. Pimp Block.

  2. “..Ryan’s refusal to move away from a proposed 20 percent tax on imports while giving a free ride to exporters.”
    The only way that I would be for this is if import duties were the primary income of our federal government. So, income tax would be repealed and our federal government would be run on $100 billion or less.

    Since that is never going to happen, import tax is just more costly for Americans and US companies should not be subsidized.

    In fact, I would like to see the tax code changes include: zero subsidies to business and individuals, lowering the tax rate by more than 50%, no deductions, and shrink the need of the IRS because the tax code would be simpler.

  3. Silly Republicans. Tax reform coupled with a massive tax hike is not tax reform.

  4. How did the GOP get to this point? They are supposed to be the ones who care about how economies actually work. Instead they’ve given themselves to racially-tinged protectionism. We know that tariff-heavy trade policies fail at their intended goals while depressing economic production. And I imagine that many Republicans in office know this too. But when ethno-nationalists offered their support, the GOP gobbled it up, and now they’re afraid of them. This is what soul-selling looks like.

    1. WTF are you babbling about…..”racially-tinged protectionism”, GTFOH. It’s purely protecting cronies, despite your race delusions.

  5. Corporate tax reform is dead as fried chicken to steal a phrase from one of my favorite movies. Corporations have been paying good money for preferential tax treatment for decades. Moneyed interests rule, my friends. Ryan knows this nonsense is going nowhere. He’s just going through the motions. Nothing will come of it.

  6. The BAT is the worst idea from a town full of bad ideas.

  7. Great idea!! Let’s create an even bigger welfare plan for accountants and lobbyists!!
    All new taxes should have this sort of mechanism to hide the taxes within the price of consumer goods. Like gasoline taxes, no one will complain about high taxes, just about high prices from those evil corporations!
    Tax reform involves REDUCING the paperwork and government bureaucracy overhead, not multiplying it.

  8. It is true that if there is something that this country is really in need of is tax reforms. Let’s hope that our leaders will take advantage of this opportunity to bring about the necessary reforms in this sector. You may want toclick on Professional SOP Writers for reliable statement of purpose writing assistance.

  9. It is incredible how legislators are quick to to put in place austerity measures whenever the country is facing a hard economic time. We really hope that this legislation is in the best interest of the people. Feel free to click on Social Studies Help

  10. At Eagle Writers we have an experienced and qualified team of writers and in line with what our values are ? professionalism, dedication, responsibility, accurancy and punctuality. We provide quality writing services to clients. For over 10 years we have gained experience with international clients from many nations of the world. We normally get clients struggling to have their content properly written or documented and we put a smile on their faces when we eventually give them what they wanted within the agreed time. At Eagle Writers we are keen on details and follow the instructions of the client to the letter and off course not without suggestions where we see necessary. Visit Us at

  11. At Acemyhomeworkwriters we understand that writing papers is very challenging to students. This is because they come in different sizes and topics. Due to this fact, most students face multiple problems when writing their assignments. Our writing service is here to help you with this. We guarantee expert tutoring to ensure you ace that class. All our writers who are holders of masters and PhD in various disciplines. Our tutors are vetted, tested and trained before they join the writing panel. Additionally, we have years of experience in offering quality homework help to students from all over the world. Masterly of writing styles is our norm . We pride ourselves in having a dedicated customer support panel, professionally trained writers, as well as skilled editors. We are knowledgeable and passionate in providing the academic writing help. Besides that, we are always available 24/7. Support and writers are ready to help you in tackling that assignment. Visit us on

Please to post comments

Comments are closed.