Brickbat: Thumbs Down

Charles Oliver | 3.21.2016 4:00 AM

(Facebook)

A German court has ruled that having a Facebook "Like" button on a commercial website violates German privacy laws if the site does not warns users that clicking the button logs their IP address.

Start your day with Reason. Get a daily brief of the most important stories and trends every weekday morning when you subscribe to Reason Roundup.

NEXT: No Opiates for the Masses?

Hide Comments (67)

Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.

MSimon 9 years ago

I wouldn’t worry about it. No matter what NSA will be logging the IP address.
1. Tom Bombadil 9 years ago
  
  Also, ‘liking’ one business is the equivalent of ‘not liking’ all the similar business which is equivalent to hate speech, which is really problematic.
Migrant Log Chipper 9 years ago

I laughed…
Fist of Etiquette 9 years ago

You know who else wanted to track people who liked commerce?
1. Adans smith 9 years ago
  
  The Ming Dynasty?
2. The Hyperbole (?'s r 2D) 9 years ago
  
  Pirates?
3. UnCivilServant 9 years ago
  
  The Soviets?
4. MSimon 9 years ago
  
  The DEA?
  1. Adans smith 9 years ago
    
    + 1 We have a winner!
5. Jerryskids 9 years ago
  
  Jerry Brown and the California High-Speed Rail Coalition?
6. Suthenboy 9 years ago
  
  The IRS?
  
  Oh, wait. Someone already said pirates…
7. Rufus The Monocled Derp Slayer 9 years ago
  
  Bernie Grandpa Gulag Sanders?
8. Slammer 9 years ago
  
  Google?
9. Spencer 9 years ago
  
  Amazon?
10. Citizen X 9 years ago
  
  Somalians?
Jerryskids 9 years ago

A link within the article: Zuckerberg ‘hopes USA follows German example’. This is not the example he’s talking about. But I hope the brickbat here is that Germany has stronger privacy laws than the US.
1. Adans smith 9 years ago
  
  The E.U. has that right to be forgotten too. If you go on Face Book and other sites expect to be known.They are a business trying to make a profit.
  1. DJF 9 years ago
    
    In the EU you have the right to be forgotten but that does not include being forgotten by the EU
straffinrun 9 years ago

I have a reason for being up at this ungodly hour. What the hell are you guys up to?
1. Adans smith 9 years ago
  
  I’m up at 4 every morning.Have coffee,read the news and the get moving for the day.Always been a early riser.Must be the duck hunter in me.
  1. straffinrun 9 years ago
    
    And people say it’s no fun to hang out with a drunk if you’re sober. Holiday here and I’m about a half a bottle through of this stuff.
    Tasty.
    1. Adans smith 9 years ago
      
      Damn,good luck with that.I had a client being me back a bottle of what he called mie jo from China once.Came in a bottle shaped like a grenade.Nasty stuff,strong.Took too Sam Adams to get the tase out of my mouth.I’ll stick to scotch.Enjoy your holiday.
      1. straffinrun 9 years ago
        
        China is the deathbed of alcohol. Been there and choked down the slop they call “quality”. Japanese sake is awesome. NEVER compare it to that swill in China. *Cheers* and enjoy you’re week. 😉
        
        Adans smith 9 years ago
        
        I found that out the hard way..I’ve never had sake.I don’t drink much liquor.A little scotch,a gin martini ( the only real martini ) Mostly stout,porter, Sam Adam’s lager..I do like dark red wine or a port.Drink some for me.
    2. Suthenboy 9 years ago
      
      It is not unheard of for me to have a cup of coffee and then refill my cup with vodka. Sadly, not this morning. Going to meet with a logger to examine some timber provided the road is passable. The timber is in the Brushy bayou (pronounced Bursley – go figure) basin and I don’t know if the water has gone down there yet. I will bring a snorkel.
  2. Radioactive 9 years ago
    
    you have a duck hunter in you??? what are you practicing for, the turducken competition?
    1. Adans smith 9 years ago
      
      I am a proud member of People Eating Tasty Animals.
      1. Radioactive 9 years ago
        
        with a nice chianti?
        
        True Scottsman 9 years ago
        
        And some fava beans!
2. Suthenboy 9 years ago
  
  Same as Adans. 3:30 – 4:00 a.m. I pop awake every morning. I haven’t set an alarm in decades.
  
  More coffee please…
  1. straffinrun 9 years ago
    
    Live on coffee. Question, Walking Dead is coming on here in about an hour. I love it. Never here anyone talking about it. Fan? It’s the only American show I watch.
    1. Rufus The Monocled Derp Slayer 9 years ago
      
      Why are you in Japan?
      1. straffinrun 9 years ago
        
        Rufus with the million dollar question. Short answer? I have no loyalty to my tribe. Especially when my tribe went nuts.
    2. Adans smith 9 years ago
      
      Not a zombie fan.I do like Arrow.
    3. Inigo Montoya, Micro-Aggressor 9 years ago
      
      I’m a fan. It’s a good show. I catch it on Netflix (cut the cable cord a few years back), so I’m always about one season behind.
    4. Suthenboy 9 years ago
      
      I watch it but I wouldn’t call myself a fan. I am not really fan material.
  2. Adans smith 9 years ago
    
    If I’m playing golf it’s Bailey’s Irish cream and coffee.
3. Rufus The Monocled Derp Slayer 9 years ago
  
  I take my kid to school.
  
  She’s ruining my life.
  1. straffinrun 9 years ago
    
    Yeah, yeah, yeah. I’ve got a daughter. Best thing ever to happen to me and I’d wager you, too.
    1. Rufus The Monocled Derp Slayer 9 years ago
      
      Pascal’s Wager?
      1. straffinrun 9 years ago
        
        You saying you’d love her even if she didn’t exist?
        
        Rufus The Monocled Derp Slayer 9 years ago
        
        Hm. Never thought about it that way. Now that she’s here, sure why not?
        
        And. Never bet against God.
        
        Tom Bombadil 9 years ago
        
        In that case, never bet against a black God.
        
        Old Man With Candy 9 years ago
        
        Rufus, did I ever mention that you’re a cunt?
        
        Rufus The Monocled Derp Slayer 9 years ago
        
        So we’re clear. It’s pronounced ‘coont’, right?
        
        Old Man With Candy 9 years ago
        
        I had a math professor from Turkey whose name was Kunt. He eventually got sick of saying, “It’s pronounced KOOONT!” and legally changed it to Koont. Still, we all giggled.
        
        Rufus The Monocled Derp Slayer 9 years ago
        
        Ah, the old Igor vs. I-gor.
        
        Old Man With Candy 9 years ago
        
        The classic version.
  2. Adans smith 9 years ago
    
    With a son you only need to worry about his dick,with a daughter,most of them.Good luck.
4. Slammer 9 years ago
  
  Up early no work on Mondays for me…watching yesterdays baseball games on MLB TV. Split the cost with my brother in law, BEST PURCHASE EVAR!!!
MSimon 9 years ago

I’m up early because I “free run” about 10 to 12 hours awake. About 4 hours sleep.
american socialist 9 years ago

99% of the email in my Inbox is spam. Raising that percentage to 99.9% means that I’ll have to sift through 999 emails offering me porn, hotel deals, Hilton vacations, neighborhood alerts, Bernie Sanders events in Utah, and viagra before I can find my airline reservation. But I’m not worried. You know why? Because I know from Libertarianism 1.0 that my life can’t be affected negatively by anything other than something done by the dreaded government.

+1 spam on Reason.com
1. Old Man With Candy 9 years ago
  
  99% of the email in my Inbox is spam.
  
  It’s because you have no friends.
2. Hyperbolical 9 years ago
  
  And the spam filter that you could by using, if you were using an open source product, would likely clean up most of that spam for you. That spam filter that you’re obviously not using is not only non-governmental, it is non-commercial–as is most of the great Internet-age solutions. Your love of government and iconic computer companies (I assume that you’re using Apple) is your problem–not your saviour.
  1. Trigger Hippie 9 years ago
    
    Well shit. I guess refreshing the page is still a thing, huh?
3. MSimon 9 years ago
  
  Your only friends are spammers.
4. Trigger Hippie 9 years ago
  
  You could just, you know, adjust your spam filter settings like everbody else on the planet with email. No government intervention necessary.
5. Citizen X 9 years ago
  
  Yeah, having to delete some emails is exactly the same as getting hauled off to a rape cage by men with guns for, say, owning certain plant material.
  
  Idiot.
  1. Nunya 9 years ago
    
    Well, it’s entirely too complex to create a second or third free email account to use for all of those websites that just have to have an email account. We should just get the gubmint to go to war with all of those Nigerian princes offering money. They can save some money by taking all of our guns. How hard was that?
Hyperbolical 9 years ago

Government could solve this problem by requiring ISPs to reassign IP addresses regularly and randomly, but I don’t think their users would be happy when their cookies regularly and randomly fail. Maybe they’d regain some interest in familiarity.
1. jarflax 9 years ago
  
  Government could solve it by banning commerce. No commerce, no spam. And probably no computer.
Stormy Dragon 9 years ago

It should be noted you don’t even have to click the button, just loading the graphic is enough for Facebook to log your IP, the page the button appeared on, and (if you haven’t deleted all your cookies since the last time you logged in) your Facebook account.

*peers at the Facebook like button at the top of the H&R page*
1. Diane Reynolds (Paul.) 9 years ago
  
  Yeah, I don’t get this. Every web page on the planet can record your ip address.
  1. Dallas H. 9 years ago
    
    And does. Pretty standard default logging for every web server software in existence.
  2. Radioactive 9 years ago
    
    shhh, shhh, don’t upset the old folks
  3. Pay up, Palin's Buttplug! 9 years ago
    
    And screen resolution.
    
    And user agent.
    
    And?
jackrose 9 years ago

nice post thanks admin

Please log in to post comments

Brickbat: Thumbs Down

Latest

How Tariffs Are Breaking the Manufacturing Industries Trump Says He Wants To Protect

The Latest Escalation Between Russia and Ukraine Isn't Changing the Course of the War

Marsha Blackburn Wants Secret Police

This Small Business Is in Limbo As Owner Sues To Stop Trump's Tariffs

A Runner Was Prosecuted for Unapproved Trail Use After the Referring Agency Called It 'Overcriminalization'

Recommended

Login Form