German Nanny State Wants to Shut Down Food Donation Service
Hygiene violations like "torn packaging" could end Berlin's food-sharing fridges.
Foodsharing, a German volunteer service that

enables people to donate leftover food for the hungry, could be facing its doom if a Berlin regulatory agency implements its proposed enhanced hygiene guidelines.
Deutsche Welle reports that foodsharing fridges have been successful in places like the US and UK, but authorities in Berlin classify the fridges as "food establishments" because they are in public and therefore must comport with European Union regulations. It's literally a case of one bureaucracy after another thwarting innovation, charity and volunteerism in the name of protecting the public.
The BBC notes some of the reported violations for "unhygienic conditions" included "non-packaged bread and torn packaging." Much like former New York City Mayor Mike Bloomberg's ban on food donations to the homeless because "the city can't assess their salt, fat and fiber content," this is a case of the perfect being the enemy of the good, with the government essentially saying it's better to allow the needy to pick through garbage cans than for private citizens to take the creative initiative to help one another.
Foodsharing enthusiasts have launched a petition, and some of the more than 16,000 signatories have taken to the group's Facebook page to mock this instance of "typical German regulation mania." The BBC excerpted some of the more choice comments:
"God, if only the authorities knew how the fridge in our flatshare looks!" another writes, prompting another to reply: "Shhh. Keep quiet - you'll give them ideas and they start inspecting it."
Follow the links for more Reason coverage on Food Freedom and Food Policy.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
OT: The Greatest Political Ad Ever has been released.
"It Feels Good to Be a Clinton"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FECIYlo3KRY
OK, this is the best Friday AV Club evar!
Quite *edgy* for Ted.
The "damn", I mean.
I wonder how apeshit the proggies would go if they used more of the original lyrics.
She apparently even lied about just using a cloth.
Whoever came up with this idea is just a straight-shooter with upper-management written all over him.
Where is that TPS report you owe your 5 managers?
"Unpackaged bread". I haven't spent a lot of time in Germany, but everywhere in Europe I've been, bread seems to be generally unpackaged.
I've tried to eat it the other way, but it just doesn't taste as good and the texture is way off.
It's literally a case of one bureaucracy after another thwarting innovation, charity and volunteerism in the name of protecting the public.
So it's just government doing what government does best. In other news: water is wet.
Only unpackaged water is wet.
Why would the government whom enjoys their monopoly on these rackets allow any sort of competition, huh? Especially when that competition could actually show how ineffective and inefficient these government run programes tend to be otherwise...
My progressive friends always "but some regulation is necessary [to protect grown-ass adults from the consequences of their own decisions], just not this regulation".
There is absolutely not principle involved with these people. Their ideology is just one ad-hoc viewpoint after another.
The principle is "If I don't like it, no one else should be able to do it. Otherwise, back off ye fascist."
That explains why Bill Maher is such a fan.
If I don't like it, no one should be allowed to do it. If I like it, it is a fundamental human right, and access must be ensured.
If I like it, it is a fundamental human right, and access must be ensured.
Forgot about that one. If it's not free, it's not available!
Foolish consistency, hobgoblin, little minds and all that. Although I suspect the bar by which they judge when consistency becomes foolish is low enough that Bloomberg's ban sails over it without question even if this does not.
I've heard them leave out "foolish." Sometimes the mask slips, and sometimes it ends up in the trash.
*facepalm*
Let them eat expired yogurt!
Well, what *must* they do with it? It had jolly well better not be to *burn* it!
They have to send it to homeless shelters and the like who are then allowed to throw it away. I wonder how those charitable organizations feel about having to pay to throw away all this extra garbage that is getting dumped on them.
Wouldn't there be local farmers that came by and took it to feed their pigs? That's what I did to fatten up Little Dunphy and Lindy West before I killed and ate them.
You named pig Dunphy? That's just cruel. I'm calling the SPCA.
Mexicans, Ass-Sex, and Weed*
*this product does not contain Mexicans, ass-sex, or weed
Oops. That was a beer.
OT: the agency I work for is hiring UNPAID interns, everyone! Liberal hypocrisy FTW!
Slave labor!!!1
It's a *humane* internship, which is more than you can say about those corporate internships.
How is that even possible? Are they not even on the GS scale?
Nope, not considered civil service.
AND it's full-time, too! 40 hours a week, for 10 weeks, without pay. Progtopia!
Also, you can't convert your internship into a paid job with the government. After giving them 400 hours of your time, you don't even get a leg up in the hiring process.
Tewtally worth it, gize!
Oh, come on.
We know there are no hungry people in Europe.
this is a case of the perfect being the enemy of the good,
No, this is a case of the stupid being the enemy of the good. There's nothing perfect about letting a city assess the fat content of foods when deciding whether that food should be donated to the needy.
*clicks ballpoint pen*
Alles ist NICHT in Ordnung.
I know that when I think of freedom, liberty, and libertarianism, Germany is always the first country that comes to mind (big eyeball roll to the ceiling).
They have legalized prostitution, that's what matters to me.
Tony the Fish loses potential points by failing to mention French "Charity" scandal from a few years back =
French version of 'Salvation Army' (and thus 'extreme right wing', according to the Guardian, natch) decides to serve homeless people "Pork Soup"
Court eventually decided this was technically 'not racist'. Because religion is stupid and pig tastes good.
i dont care about starving americans yet i clicked on this anyway.
no one cares who you care about
both our moms care
FOILED!! (shakes fist)
lurkers unite! have absolutely no fear of the cool kids here! a third grade burn can turn the tide in your favor!
/struts
please use FOLDED!! in the future im trying to make it a thing.
So I've been gone for a while...what's with all the socks and trolls out-an-about these days? Seems like more than usual.
You gotta pay the troll toll to get into this site's soul.
Chalk it up to election season and an abundance of click-bait...
Big Brother will decide who eats and who starves.
"German hygiene laws".
That sounds totally innocuous.