Yesterday we learned that Rachel Dolezal, president of the Spokane NAACP, was born of Czech/German stock before she started presenting herself to the world as black. Such "reverse racial passing," as it's called, has been around for a long time, and not just across the line supposedly separating black from white. The Dolezal story reminds me of another American who became a famous face of an ethnic group he hadn't been born into.
You may recall this public service announcement of the 1970s:
That man with the tear was known as Iron Eyes Cody. Here's what Snopes has to say about him:
Iron Eyes Cody was born Espera DeCorti on 3 April 1904 in the small town of Kaplan, Louisiana. He was the son of Francesca Salpietra and Antonio DeCorti, she an immigrant from Sicily who had arrived in the USA in 1902, and he another immigrant who had arrived in America not long before her. Theirs was an arranged marriage, and the couple had four children, with Espera (or Oscar, as he was called) their second eldest. In 1909, when Espera was five years old, Antonio DeCorti abandoned his wife and children and headed for Texas. Francesca married again, this time to a man named Alton Abshire, with whom she bore five more children.
Keep America Beautiful
As teenagers the three DeCorti boys joined their father in Texas. He had since altered his name from Antonio DeCorti to Tony Corti, and the boys apparently followed suit as far as their surname was concerned. In 1924, following their father's death, the boys moved to Hollywood, changed "Corti" to "Cody," and began working in the motion picture industry. It was about this time Iron Eyes began presenting himself to the world as an Indian. Iron Eyes' two brothers, Joseph William and Frank Henry, found work as extras but soon drifted into other lines of work. Iron Eyes went on to achieve a full career as an actor, appearing in well over a hundred movies and dozens of television shows across the span of several decades.
Although Iron Eyes was not born an Indian, he lived his adult years as one. He pledged his life to Native American causes, married an Indian woman (Bertha Parker), adopted two Indian boys (Robert and Arthur), and seldom left home without his beaded moccasins, buckskin jacket and braided wig.
Warner Bros.
For more, read Ron Russell's great 1999 story about DeCorti for the Los Angeles New Times.
Iron Eyes isn't the only well-known American who's gone to Croatan this way. (An especially peculiar case is that of Asa "Forrest" Carter, whose alleged memoir The Education of Little Tree moved many readers with its account of a Cherokee boyhood. In fact, his early life had been not just white but white supremacist—Carter's other contributions to American letters include George Wallace's "segregation now, segregation tomorrow, segregation forever" speech.) But Iron Eyes' path is particularly twisty, because it wasn't all that long ago that Italians themselves weren't considered white. As tightly policed as America's racial identities have traditionally been, they've also always been rather fluid, even when you don't introduce actual fraud into the mix. Indeed, that fluidity is one reason for the policing in the first place.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com
posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary
period.
Subscribe
here to preserve your ability to comment. Your
Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the
digital
edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do
not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments
do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and
ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Start working at home with Google! It's by-far the best job I've had. Last Wednesday I got a brand new BMW since getting a check for $6474 this - 4 weeks past. I began this 8-months ago and immediately was bringing home at least $77 per hour. I work through this link, go? to tech tab for work detail,,,,,,,
She's been doing this for years, and when a reporter asks her on camera if she's an African American, her only response is a completely awestruck deer-in-the-headlights stare and "I don't understand your question?" Come on, man, that's not even trying.
I can't wait to see the official talking point the lowlife scum on the left come up with in order to say "Everyone can identify themselves however they want to, with this exception."
Because you know they're all furiously working their tiny little brains on it right now even as we speak.
I think this is great: it makes a mockery of the whole racial identity issue. What better way to stick a finger in the eyes of race baiters than for a "white" NAACP official to claim that they are African American "because we all come from Africa"?
Hah, "you guys" is used in a gender-neutral fashion around here to address groups of people, even exclusively women.
Awaiting the hyperventilating article about how languages with gendered nouns need to be reformed, because it's tantamount to rape and harassment, or something.
Ehn. Wrong. Where would I respond to you guys if not from my workplace can. And I have excellent credit, btw. Everyone knows those credit score agencies are a fucking joke.
Wait, wait... Is this where libertarians assign the most ridiculous and outlandish interpretations of a complicated and multi-faceted philosophy(psst, most early libertarians called themselves socialists) and assign it to someone who doesn't agree with them? And people call libertarians a cult. Pshaw, they just don't know you.
" libertarians assign the most ridiculous and outlandish interpretations of a complicated and multi-faceted philosophy"
Wow i'm impressed, for a second there I thought you were just going "DERP LOOK UR ALL DUDES" instead of trying to share your complicated and multi-faceted philosophy with your big ol' brain
Ever read the Communist Manifesto, Gilmore? It talks about the withering of the state and how government power intervenes on behalf of propertied special interests-- and how that's bad. It's somewhat better than that Introduction to Objectivist Epistemology book that you've read over and over again.
I minored in political philosophy, yes i read Marx & Engels and Adorno and Horkheimer and a half-dozen other branches of that Tree of Woe.
Which is actually partly how i ended up a libertarian. I actually *understood* what they were talking about. People like you just wave it around thinking you'll impress someone. its really kind of sad.
Sorry, waving your political science minor at me while you lump democratic and libertarian socialism in with Stalin is still vastly oversimplifying a complex economic philosophy. Return to my comment on cults.
"you lump democratic and libertarian socialism in with Stalin is still vastly oversimplifying a complex economic philosophy."
The fact that you once dedicated the hour or so it takes to read the Communist Manifesto and found it really vastly complex is not evidence that other people are oversimplifying things.
How does the Marxist government-free libertarian utopia of free exchange come about? How does your advocacy for the Democratic Party program of more government work toward that?
The greatest appeal of socialism to idiots is the very-common belief that "complexity" = "sophistication & intelligence"
anyone with half a brain understands that Marxism's collection of scientificky-sounding neologisms and pretzel-like attempts to make reality align to theory (see: "Labor theory of value") is a sign of its intellectual failures, not evidence of its virtue.
as i said - your attempts to impress yourself here are just sad. you have my pity.
Right. But Rand, Hayek, Rothbard, Mozilla, et. Al. Are super interesting.
Who is arguing about complexity? I favor simple-- as opposed to simplistic-- philosophies. If I had to choose my favorite economic and political philosopher is George Orwell-- a lifelong socialist.
So you are saying you spent years studying a subject to come up with a conclusion that is common sense to the rest of us? (communism is BAD, libertarian capitalism is good) and somehow that makes you feel superior?
Just the "Wrong" "Top Men" running things. Get the "right" ones in power and all will be gud. Also, hoarders and wreckers and shit and agitators, always ruining the beauty of socialism.
Why isn't everyone celebrating her courageous decision to throw off the vestiges of White Privilege? Aren't SJW' constantly preaching the need to acknowledge and reject that white privilege, yet when someone actually DOES it, she's the problem? She's a hero.
And with this story, it doesn't hurt to point out that the NAACP's first president was white. Moorfield Storey was descended from some of the original Puritan settlers, was a Mugwump who jumped from the Republican Party to become a Cleveland Democrat, was anti-imperialist, classical liberal, and president of the NAACP for 20 years. He was one of the more influential libertarians in history, but is not as well known or celebrated as others.
The thing that pisses me off about all this, as someone not impressed by the new pro-transwoman prog fad (don't get me wrong, I don't care what people do or wear or identify as, I just don't like the social pressure to pretend they aren't mentally ill -- the Emperor has no vag, etc.), is that I was waiting for a good time to illustrate the idiocy by making a joke about white people in blackface being transracial. Now reality has taken that from me, and I find it disheartening.
I may get flack for saying this, but I think part of Rachel Dolezal's motivation may have been that she's slightly better looking as a black woman than she is as a white woman.
If I can accept that Caitlyn Jenner is a woman, then I have no problem accepting that Rachel Dolezal is black. At least she's not using her blackness to perpetuate awful stereotypes with the group she supposedly identifies with.
My best friend's step-mother makes $85 hourly on the computer . She has been fired from work for nine months but last month her pay check was $17089 just working on the computer for a few hours. see it here
LINK HERE?????? http://www.BuzzReport20.com
I self identify as a terracotta roof tile. If this courageous act is not treated with the utmost respect and dignity, you're being insensitive and probably violating many of my rights.
Google pay 97$ per hour my last pay check was $8500 working 1o hours a week online. My younger brother friend has been averaging 12k for months now and he works about 22 hours a week. I cant believe how easy it was once I tried it out.
This is wha- I do...... ?????? http://www.netcash5.com
Google pay 97$ per hour my last pay check was $8500 working 1o hours a week online. My younger brother friend has been averaging 12k for months now and he works about 22 hours a week. I cant believe how easy it was once I tried it out.
This is wha- I do...... ?????? http://www.netcash5.com
Iron Eyes should have considered representing Massachusetts in the United States Senate.
Start working at home with Google! It's by-far the best job I've had. Last Wednesday I got a brand new BMW since getting a check for $6474 this - 4 weeks past. I began this 8-months ago and immediately was bringing home at least $77 per hour. I work through this link, go? to tech tab for work detail,,,,,,,
????????????? http://www.pay-buzz.com
More than anything else, the recent Rachel Dolezal story reminds me of Steve Martin's title character in The Jerk.
It's not the same, but this woman is just a delusional.
She's been doing this for years, and when a reporter asks her on camera if she's an African American, her only response is a completely awestruck deer-in-the-headlights stare and "I don't understand your question?" Come on, man, that's not even trying.
Well, she does look "more African American" than Charlize Theron ...
Wait, where can I see this?
Charlize Theron was born in South Africa: http://www.lifetimetv.co.uk/bi.....ize-theron
She's got a personality disorder. So her behavior must be accomodated per the ADA.
I can't wait to see the official talking point the lowlife scum on the left come up with in order to say "Everyone can identify themselves however they want to, with this exception."
Because you know they're all furiously working their tiny little brains on it right now even as we speak.
Cultural appropriation!
If a man can be a woman, why can't a white person be black?
"If he is Pedro, why can't I be Tyrone?"
Obvious joke about cis-racial oppression in 5, 4, 3, ...
(a single wood chip rolls down my cheek)
*standing ovation*
Please document said account for future subpoena
Wow, that woman is a one-person hate hoax spree.
Isn't "woman" kinda discriminative itself, and presumptive, and coercive?
I'm whatever I want to be and don't you judge me, hater!
Reality is a political construct.
Reality isn't a political construct, but race is, and this sort of scandal illustrates it.
Reality isn't a political construct
It wasn't in the past, but it absolutely is now.
Maybe they can hire her to be Wyoming Knott in the 'Moon is a Harsh Mistress' adaptation.
"'Wyoming Knott""
that was actually a character's name?
'Why Not'? jesus what a slut
Pussy Galore. I'm mean, come on!
Absolutely was a character's name, and much was made of it in the plot.
I think this is great: it makes a mockery of the whole racial identity issue. What better way to stick a finger in the eyes of race baiters than for a "white" NAACP official to claim that they are African American "because we all come from Africa"?
You can't fool me. There's no way that's real.
From the headline:
"'Black' NAACP leader outed as white woman"
You want a glimpse of a future world of fluid reality and PC? Read xojane.com for a week
"You guys" now sexist
http://www.vox.com/2015/6/11/8.....m-language
But he's a scientist so it must be true
http://www.cnn.com/2015/06/11/.....index.html
OMG! You guys!!!
HAard to believe anyone is faling in love with this guy (other than a swiffer!)
Holy S@%T, You could sweep the floor with just one nostril!
Hah, "you guys" is used in a gender-neutral fashion around here to address groups of people, even exclusively women.
Awaiting the hyperventilating article about how languages with gendered nouns need to be reformed, because it's tantamount to rape and harassment, or something.
In her defense, we don't have many black people here in Spokane, so we all take turns.
Quick question: is everyone here a dude and employed-- vaguely is ok-- in the IT industry?
No.
So you're not employed?
Or vaccinated.
That's a job for other people.
STIMULUS!
I self-identify as a dude employed vaguely in the IT industry
Yes.
no
No.
Rebuttal question: are you employed in the fast food industry?
What a silly question.
Of course he's not employed.
Ehn. Wrong. Where would I respond to you guys if not from my workplace can. And I have excellent credit, btw. Everyone knows those credit score agencies are a fucking joke.
If you have good credit after welching on a mortgage like a fucking piece of shit, they ARE a joke.
Are you employed in the Walmart greeter industry?
His poor credit precluded him from that position.
" it wasn't all that long ago that Italians themselves weren't considered white."
Wait, that's not a thing anymore?
for fucks sake. who I am supposed to look down on now? besides New Jersey....
I think Salon Magazine probably should be retitled something more appropriate to describe its new, "White-Guilt Pornography"-focus.
'By white people, for white people, who hate the other white people* who don't hate themselves (*"because we're the good ones")'
Hi Gilmore,
You're certainly a dude, right?
Stop hitting on people its gross and sexist and you're making people uncomfortable with your sexual advances
Gay is ok, ok?
You shouldn't be imposing your self-hating masculinity trauma on others. Go back to your room and play with your Stalin-dolls.
There are multiple Stalin dolls? Like "train managing Stalin" and "mass starvation Stalin". Neat.
My fave is "Parade Marshal Stalin", cause you get all the cool tanks and missile transporters with it!
don't forget "Young, Sexy Stalin"...and, "If you denounce your parents you can get an extra food-ration-Stalin"
I prefer, "dying a horrible death" Stalin, myself.
Is that the one made entirely of wood with "Insert doll feet first" typed in large, friendly letters on the front of the package?
Does anyone really need 18 different Stalin dolls? Children are starving.
They're Matryoshka dolls. They come as a set.
Wait, wait... Is this where libertarians assign the most ridiculous and outlandish interpretations of a complicated and multi-faceted philosophy(psst, most early libertarians called themselves socialists) and assign it to someone who doesn't agree with them? And people call libertarians a cult. Pshaw, they just don't know you.
" libertarians assign the most ridiculous and outlandish interpretations of a complicated and multi-faceted philosophy"
Wow i'm impressed, for a second there I thought you were just going "DERP LOOK UR ALL DUDES" instead of trying to share your complicated and multi-faceted philosophy with your big ol' brain
Hi Gilmore,
Ever read the Communist Manifesto, Gilmore? It talks about the withering of the state and how government power intervenes on behalf of propertied special interests-- and how that's bad. It's somewhat better than that Introduction to Objectivist Epistemology book that you've read over and over again.
I minored in political philosophy, yes i read Marx & Engels and Adorno and Horkheimer and a half-dozen other branches of that Tree of Woe.
Which is actually partly how i ended up a libertarian. I actually *understood* what they were talking about. People like you just wave it around thinking you'll impress someone. its really kind of sad.
Sorry, waving your political science minor at me while you lump democratic and libertarian socialism in with Stalin is still vastly oversimplifying a complex economic philosophy. Return to my comment on cults.
"you lump democratic and libertarian socialism in with Stalin is still vastly oversimplifying a complex economic philosophy."
The fact that you once dedicated the hour or so it takes to read the Communist Manifesto and found it really vastly complex is not evidence that other people are oversimplifying things.
How does the Marxist government-free libertarian utopia of free exchange come about? How does your advocacy for the Democratic Party program of more government work toward that?
"a complex economic philosophy."
The greatest appeal of socialism to idiots is the very-common belief that "complexity" = "sophistication & intelligence"
anyone with half a brain understands that Marxism's collection of scientificky-sounding neologisms and pretzel-like attempts to make reality align to theory (see: "Labor theory of value") is a sign of its intellectual failures, not evidence of its virtue.
as i said - your attempts to impress yourself here are just sad. you have my pity.
Right. But Rand, Hayek, Rothbard, Mozilla, et. Al. Are super interesting.
Who is arguing about complexity? I favor simple-- as opposed to simplistic-- philosophies. If I had to choose my favorite economic and political philosopher is George Orwell-- a lifelong socialist.
So you are saying you spent years studying a subject to come up with a conclusion that is common sense to the rest of us? (communism is BAD, libertarian capitalism is good) and somehow that makes you feel superior?
Look at socialism in the real world and let me know all the "success" it is enjoying.
Derp da derp derp.
Just the "Wrong" "Top Men" running things. Get the "right" ones in power and all will be gud. Also, hoarders and wreckers and shit and agitators, always ruining the beauty of socialism.
Out with it. What are you getting at?
http://weknowmemes.com/generat.....113735.jpg
I think he's going for libertarians are all nerds and there are no libertarian women.
I'm just wondering why chicks don't dig Hayek and the position papers he inspires. Maybe they're just dumb.
This going to shock: Nikki, riven, brownyn, carol, Kristen, IVH, etc.
You forgot Lady B. She broke up with me, though, so I suspect she's a man.
Sorry. There are literally too many to remember, which is the same as none, right?
Did you use the Crazy/Hot Matrix to determine that or did you get ass-raped?
In response to Playa.
That woman who made the "I'm In Love with Friedrich Hayek" video.
...Lady Bertrum, SusanM, KMW, Cathy Young, Kerry Howley, Virginia Postrel...
Most fans of American Idol and Dance Moms are female. If you don't like either show, you are sexist.
Sub Agent or sumpin like dat.
Is AmSoc looking for a dominate girlfriend ?
I think we have a enough for a calendar
Ummm... is Hamster of Doom chopped liver?
Etc includes all our wonderful female commenters.
The trolls were better when Postrel was in charge
To american socialist:
Why are you forcing labels on people?
Sorry. Who is forcing labels on anyone?
Yes, occasionally that canard still pops up. Some of my best friends are Eye-talian!
Also = Elizabeth Warren - *finally vindicated*??
Because now she's not the biggest race-baiting fraud in America? (or at least she's got company?)
Remember that shit-stain fraud Ward Churchill?
Wasn't ward Churchill in omega man?
From her pictures she seemed to always identify as black. Shouldn't we accept her at her word and not judge her?
Exactly. Gender identity is a one question test, "Which gender do you personally identify as?". Why should race be any different?
Not according to her biological parents. And doing it for years does not equal always.
Once you go black you never go ...
...to the bathroom?
....to....college? (racist)
...to community pools?
rarely actually lol, but damn...
to Portland?
It is a very racist city.
The white liberal Portlandians don't want the blacks to get their $15 hr minimum wage jerbs.
Why isn't everyone celebrating her courageous decision to throw off the vestiges of White Privilege? Aren't SJW' constantly preaching the need to acknowledge and reject that white privilege, yet when someone actually DOES it, she's the problem? She's a hero.
"She's a hero."
Not to most commenters here. They take the divide between black and white very seriously and are offering no words of support to this person.
If you completely redefine what "hero" means, then sure, she can be a hero too.
Thanks for the Johnny Otis bit, Jesse. Can't believe I hadn't heard that before.
And with this story, it doesn't hurt to point out that the NAACP's first president was white. Moorfield Storey was descended from some of the original Puritan settlers, was a Mugwump who jumped from the Republican Party to become a Cleveland Democrat, was anti-imperialist, classical liberal, and president of the NAACP for 20 years. He was one of the more influential libertarians in history, but is not as well known or celebrated as others.
And BET was started by a Jew.
Gotta love the uniforms
Interesting.
The thing that pisses me off about all this, as someone not impressed by the new pro-transwoman prog fad (don't get me wrong, I don't care what people do or wear or identify as, I just don't like the social pressure to pretend they aren't mentally ill -- the Emperor has no vag, etc.), is that I was waiting for a good time to illustrate the idiocy by making a joke about white people in blackface being transracial. Now reality has taken that from me, and I find it disheartening.
If I'm a man who identifies as a woman who identifies as a man, am I allowed to use the women's shower at the gym?
Eazy-E's manger was also a Jew.
Apropos of nothing really, but heard this yesterday for first time in a while.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Igxl7YtS1vQ
Hell yes! I want to be black so I can get some of that 'affirmative action' stuff. It worked for Obama and he's half white.
I may get flack for saying this, but I think part of Rachel Dolezal's motivation may have been that she's slightly better looking as a black woman than she is as a white woman.
All white kids these days should claim to be Asian so they get accepted into college.
You've got that backwards. It's Asians that have to hide their race, because they are "over-represented" and discriminated against.
If I can accept that Caitlyn Jenner is a woman, then I have no problem accepting that Rachel Dolezal is black. At least she's not using her blackness to perpetuate awful stereotypes with the group she supposedly identifies with.
My best friend's step-mother makes $85 hourly on the computer . She has been fired from work for nine months but last month her pay check was $17089 just working on the computer for a few hours. see it here
LINK HERE?????? http://www.BuzzReport20.com
What do you want to bet she's Jewish? Rachel? Eastern European ancestors?
#WrongSkin
It doesn't count if you're acting.
You're part Injun, son. get off my property/
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lUYi0c84gyk
I self identify as a terracotta roof tile. If this courageous act is not treated with the utmost respect and dignity, you're being insensitive and probably violating many of my rights.
Google pay 97$ per hour my last pay check was $8500 working 1o hours a week online. My younger brother friend has been averaging 12k for months now and he works about 22 hours a week. I cant believe how easy it was once I tried it out.
This is wha- I do...... ?????? http://www.netcash5.com
Google pay 97$ per hour my last pay check was $8500 working 1o hours a week online. My younger brother friend has been averaging 12k for months now and he works about 22 hours a week. I cant believe how easy it was once I tried it out.
This is wha- I do...... ?????? http://www.netcash5.com