Errol Morris on Donald Rumsfeld's "Gobbledygook" and the Twisted Logic that Led to Operation Iraqi Freedom
"The idea that people concluded President Bush made a terrible mistake by [invading Iraq], I think, is something that, over time, will be better understood," former Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld told American Public Media's Marketplace in May.
Rumsfeld can abandon hope that someday he'll be vindicated for his role in Operation Iraqi Freedom, but he is right in one sense: Eleven years after the U.S. invasion, we still don't fully understand the repercussions of Bush's "terrible mistake." Today, the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS) is advancing through the country's northern provinces, slaughtering soldiers en masse, threatening to topple the Maliki government, turn the country into a safe haven for jihadism, and destabilize the region. Americans increasingly acknowledge a horrifying truth: 4,400 U.S. soldiers and as many as 191,000 Iraqis died so Iraq could become a more violent nation and a greater threat to the world.
Last April, Nick Gillespie sat down with documentary filmmaker Errol Morris for an extended chat about his fascinating new film The Unknown Known, which is a profile of Rumsfeld and an examination of the twisted logic that led the nation into a tragic war.
The original write up is below:
Donald Rumsfeld's "war crime," says Oscar-winning filmmaker Errol Morris, is "the gobbledygook, the blizzard of words, the misdirections, the evasions…and ultimately at the heart of it all…the disregard and devaluation of evidence."
The former secretary of defense's complicated relationship with the truth is the subject of Morris' new documentary, The Unknown Known, which opens in theaters nationwide on Friday, April 4. The Unknown Known is an extended conversation with Rumsfeld, tracing his long career through the Nixon, Ford, Reagan, and Bush administrations, and focusing on his role in leading U.S. military forces into Iraq to fight a
bloody and senseless war.
In the film, Morris engages in a verbal sparring session with Rumsfeld in an effort to break through the linguistic "evasions" and "gobbledygook" for which he's known.
The title of the film comes from Rumsfeld's response to a question by NBC reporter Jim Miklaszewski at a Pentagon news conference on February 12, 2002. When Miklaszewski asked Rumsfeld if there was any evidence that Iraq was supplying terrorists with weapons, Rumsfeld replied:
Reports that say that something hasn't happened are always interesting to me, because as we know, there are known knowns; there are things we know we know. We also know there are known unknowns; that is to say we know there are some things we do not know. But there are also unknown unknowns — the ones we don't know we don't know.
In a four-part series in The New York Times titled "The Certainty of Donald Rumsfeld," Morris wrote: "Many people believe Rumsfeld's reply was brilliant. I think otherwise."
The Unknown Known is Errol Morris' 10th documentary feature. He's also the author of two best-selling books and the director of over 1,000 TV commercials. Much of Morris' work explores, as he puts it, "how people prefer untruth to truth" and how they're "blinded by their own spurious convictions."
Reason TV's Nick Gillespie sat down for an extended chat with Morris about The Unknown Known. They discussed, among other things, the difference between Rumsfeld and Secretary of Defense Robert McNamara, whose complicated relationship with his own mistakes is the subject of Morris' Oscar-winning film, The Fog of War; Morris' take on the Jeffrey MacDonald murder case, which was the subject of his book, A Wilderness of Error; how Obama compares to Bush; his friendships with Roger Ebert and Werner Herzog; and why "we're all morons."
Gillespie conducted the interview using an "interrotron," a device Morris invented, which projects an interviewer's face over the camera lens. It creates the impression that the subject is looking directly into the eyes of the viewer.
About 41 minutes.
Shot and edited by Jim Epstein.
Scroll down for downloadable versions and subscribe to Reason TV's YouTube channel to receive automatic updates when new material goes live.
