Five Phony Public Health Scares
In "Five Phony Public Health Scares" (November), Ronald Bailey mentions the campaign against fluoridation of water. Fluoridation, arguably one of the great successes of public health policy, shines a light on the progressive mindset.
Here we have a policy opposed by persons concerned about effects of a chemical accumulating in human bodies over decades, persons who would apply the precautionary principle to fluoridation in exactly the way progressives have used it to forestall every other technological advance in memory. Yet our news media have taken those progressives seriously, while scoffing the fluoridation skeptics off the stage of public opinion as a bunch of ignorant rednecks.
I can't see that the progressives are any more enlightened than the fluoridation skeptics.
Joel A. Eaton
Ronald Bailey responds: I agree with Mr. Eaton. Under the precautionary principle, proponents of change must prove that new technologies will never cause harm. The ironic upshot is that modern progressives have in effect adopted William Buckley's famous conservative position of standing "athwart history, yelling Stop." One way to summarize the precautionary principle is, "Never do anything for the first time."
Not changing is often riskier than changing. For example, refusing vaccination involves risks to personal health, rejecting nuclear power increases the risk of climate change, and banning biotech crops increases the risk of soil erosion and famine.
Correction: As a result of an editing error, Veronique de Rugy's column "The Kids Aren't All Right" (November) incorrectly stated that young people who must pay Obamacare's penalty will "be $2,000 poorer." The 2014 penalty for individuals is actually $95 or 1 percent of income, whichever is greater.
Letters are welcome and should be addressed to
reason 1747 Connecticut Avenue, NW Washington, DC 20009 fax: 202-315-3623 firstname.lastname@example.org
"Dark Side of the Moon is an excellent choice, but if you want to expand your getting-stoned-and-listening-to-Floyd repertoire, I strongly suggest the Live at Pompeii DVD."
–reason.com commenter "Libertarius" in response to "Cops Give Seattle Stoners Special Doritos" (November)
"Just about everybody is guilty of one felony or another, and most active adults are guilty of one or more felonies every day. This means that prosecutors face an impossible workload, and prisons cannot be built fast enough to house all the lawbreakers."
–reason.com commenter "CatoTheElder" in response to "Eric Holder's Prison Break" (November)
"When I was young my working mother's doctor prescribed her methamphetamine, apparently because working mothers raising five children need a little extra pep sometimes. Back then, the early '60s, methamphetamine was considered by few outside the hardcore prohibitionist circles to be a drug of concern. Doctors prescribed it for everything from those experiencing fatigue or having trouble staying alert to students preparing for exams. When considering the information about the drug being circulated today, it's suspicious that there wasn't a period of mass psychotic violence back when a large swath of the country was prescribed the drug."
–reason.com commenter "John Galt" in response to "The Scientific Case for Decriminalization" (November)