Michelle Rhee Says Screw You to Democrats, Endorses Vouchers
In her new memoir, Radical, former Washington, D.C., public schools honcho Michelle Rhee describes on her eureka moment about vouchers. She describes the parade of mothers who came to her after working the system as hard as they could to get their kids out of bad neighborhood public schools and failing and her sense of despair at being unable to help them:
Who am I, I thought, to deny this mom and her child an opportunity for a better school, even if that meant help with a seventy-five-hundred-dollar voucher? If they got a voucher, and her child could attend a really good Catholic school, perhaps, why would I stand in the way—especially since I don't have a high-quality DCPS alternative?
I just couldn't look mother after mother in the eye and deny their children the opportunity I wanted for my own children. It would have required me to say, "Gee, I'm sorry, you're just going to have to suck it up. I know your elementary school is a failing school, and your child will probably not learn how to read, but I really need five more years to fix the system. And while I'm fixing the system, I need you and your neighbors to be really patient. Hang in there with me. Things will get better. I promise."
If someone said that to me, I'd have said, "You may need more time to fix the system but my kid doesn't have time. She has only one chance to attend first grade, and if she can't learn to read by the end of first grade, her chances for success in life will be compromised. So with all due respect—heck no!"
Rhee has a reputation as a hardass, so it's telling that on this issue she appeal to emotion. She changes her mind because she feels like a jerk telling these parents to suck it up. And well she should. Democrats gave her hell for this decision at the time. She now runs the advocacy group Students First, which flights for school choice and against unions.
And here's Reason TV on D.C.'s voucher program:
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
There is nothing more racist than advocating that black kids deserve a better educational system.
But I didn't think Asians could be racist.
Asians are just smaller, smarter, less expensive forms of Caucasian.
Dude, that's lacist.
It can't be racist; I'm Asian.
lacist.
I just couldn't look mother after mother in the eye and deny their children the opportunity I wanted for my own children.
What? No fathers?
Dude. Washington D.C.
So, no.
"if she can't learn to read by the end of first grade, her chances for success in life will be compromised."
Huh?
Yeah, that's bullshit. Look at Charlemagne.
But how many kids in DC can slamg Joyuese through a Saxon skull?
What kid enters first grade without knowing how to read? Before I even went to first grade I already had pressured my parents into teaching me how, and my three year old is already recognizing words. Probably helps that I read her a story every night.
My mom read to us when we were little. I did the reading to our kids - a lot of the same stories I grew up with. All three are now avid readers.
I submit this is one of the best things any parent can do to help their kids develop.
I hate reading (especially journal articles) but I'm super glad my parents taught me to read at three.
A kid whose IQ is so low that he can't read in first grade - i.e., someone whose education has nothing to do with his future lack of success.
Hence, "huh?"
That's a bit oversimplified. There are lots of other reasons besides stupidity that kids have a hard time learning to read. A lot of dyslexics don't learn to read well for a long time, yet can turn out to be quite intelligent once they learn to deal with the disability.
But the biggest is probably shitty parents who don't read to their kids.
I wonder what the IQ of parents who don't read to their kids tends to be.
Seriously, this is another instance of the "LATIN IMPROVES SAT SCORES!" fallacy.
I read to my daughter when she was little, I tried reading to my son but he wasn't interested. Do I fall in the lousy parents who don't read group?
You fall into the lousy parents who think Ke$ha has talent group.
😉
Bah, when did I ever say Ke$ha had talent?
Ask Zeb? The guy who was talking about "shitty parents" etc.
Well, the shitty parents comment is one thing I object to a bit. But I was asking just in regards to your comment about IQ of such parents.
Or maybe I misunderstood the point of your comment to Zeb.
"Do I fall in the lousy parents who don't read group?"
Probably not. You tried, you apparently engage with your kids and I will assume you give a fuck if they succeed or not in school and other pursuits.
I said "shitty parents who don't read to their kids". That leaves open the possibility of there being good parents who don't read to their kids for other reasons. Though I have a hard time imagining what kind of monstrous abomination you conceived that doesn't want to be read to.
Though I have a hard time imagining what kind of monstrous abomination you conceived that doesn't want to be read to.
Just an average boy. He didn't like being read to when he was little, he doesn't like reading now. Pretty much the same way I was at his age. Ain't nobody got time for that.
I don't know ANYONE who voted for Nixon
Seriously, this is another instance of the "LATIN IMPROVES SAT SCORES!" fallacy.
The Sociologist's Fallacy
I don't see how Latin would help with the Math section, but Classics majors constantly score the highest on the Verbal sections of the GRE, so I can see that a deep knowledge of Latin and Greek root words, prefixes, and suffixes would have a positive transference with the English academic vocabulary that makes a up a large portion of the Verbal section of the SAT.
Is it that a deep knowledge of Latin (or Greek) and would lead to a good verbal score on the SAT, or are people who would do well on the verbal portion of the SAT just better at learning Latin (or Greek)? Correlation is relatively easy to show, but it's harder to prove that one caused the other.
Like that notorious dumbass Frederick Douglass.
Kid's with shitty parents or learning disabilities, that's who.
Are parents that don't read to their kids because their kids have no interest in being read to still shitty?
Only you, you monster
Oh good, nice to know I'm still unique.
Obviously any good parent would have tied the kid down, forced open his eyes so he can follow along and read to him. CPS is on their way.
No. Happy now?
I am making rather broad statements, so don't take me too literally.
But I do maintain that parents are the most important factor in educational outcomes.
This seems like some kind of spite aimed at teachers unions.
Is that a complaint or just an observation?
Michelle Rhee describes on her eureka moment about vouchers.
I'm just going to let the typo slide, but eureka moment? Say it with me now, KMW, epiphany. There are VPs here at my work that say things like aha-moment, and it drives me crazy. It's not a difficult word, so why make up one that sounds dumb (e.g. whatever-moment) when there already exists a perfectly good word that better describes what you mean?
sounds like a good, yet original, stripper name too.
Actually, those are BOTH good:
"If you'll direct your attention to the staaaaaaage - straight from Quebec - EurEKA!"
"Aaaaaaand on the catwalk, Miss Nude Newfoundland 2012, making her debut here at The Swanky Poon....EPIPHany."
Fokin' brilliant.
Please note my reference to Canadian girls comes from living in a border state - trips to the "Windsor [Ontario] Ballet" were legend.
It was always "Forty French Models From Quebec!" at every place. My fave was Studio Four - we'd hit it now and again on the way from band practice when I was with the St. Thomas Police Pipe Band.
Good times...
St. Thomas Police Pipe Band
Lead pipe, or iron pipe?
Copper.
Erscheinungsfest.
Nobody cares what the title of your scheisse movie is.
I like that he (intentionally?) confuses an epiphany with the holiday celebrating the Epiphany (i.e. Three Kings' Day).
There's a difference???
Not to the Buddhists
Because "eureka" means "I have found [it]" in Greek, hence it's classy?
And 'epiphany' comes from the Greek word epiphaneia, meaning manifestation or striking appearance. That word works better than 'I have found it' moment, and is equally classy and Greek.
Eureka implies she was actively searching for a solution to a problem rather than one day, out of the blue, she has a realization, which appears to be the situation here.
Context-wise, it also implies that once she found it, Rhee ran through the streets of D.C., butt naked and dripping wet.
That would have improved the class of DC streets by at least a magnitude.
classy and Greek
I have it on good authority that Sandi took a shit in Greece, once.
It's not a difficult word, so why make up one that sounds dumb (e.g. whatever-moment) when there already exists a perfectly good word that better describes what you mean?
Probably because a lot of people are reminded of The Simpsons Movie when they hear or see the word "epiphany" and she's trying to save people from having to relive such a traumatic experience. Kind of like not refering to the alleged 4th Indiana Jones movie spares people from having to relive the rape.
As for the typo/ grammatical error, thank God they got rid of Lucy so we don't have to put up with shoddy editing like this anymore... /sarc
Do you know who else had an epiphany?
Colonel Nicholson at the end of "Bridge on the River Kwai"?
Dr. Emmett Brown?
Paul?
Because they had shitty teachers in school, and/or a learning disability.
Being illiterate hasn't stopped me from achieving success.
Huh. So you just cut and paste sentences from other places on the Internet, or do you just type randomly?
Man, that post is shockingly on topic given those two choices.
Mambo dogface to the banana patch!
Yes you can Almanian. Here's your hall pass.
Actually, my posts are the result of Dragon Naturally Speaking and dictating to a trained literate eunuch. It's a surprisingly potent combination.
You mean you don't use cambodian orphan child labor for your dictations?
And be left with a short-staffed coal mine? I don't think so.
You know who else didn't let a learning disability stop him from achieving success?
Einstein?
Eli Manning?
George W. Bush?
Stalin?
Joe Biden?
Forrest Gump?
Ah, I see by the expression on your face that you're confused by my statement. Perhaps you doubt its veracity but let me assure you, I read/write not a word of English.
Michelle Rhee Says Screw You Me Love You Long Time! to Democrats, Endorses Vouchers
Fixed
/lacist
lol
Wow, Helen Mirren was quite the honey before she got old!
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/fem.....z2Jw2rvyBx
She isn't shabby now.
Imogen Poots is the spittin' image of her (but sadly, with smaller boobs).
YOU voted for Obama, well, this is his plan for your kids: ignorance and lifelong dependence. What part of that has you upset?
The part where a majority of voters chose The President instead of me.
"Almanian for President - 2016 - The Revenge!"
I'll just leave this here:
http://www.washingtonpost.com/.....06240.html
Don't ask Fenty or Rhee whom this world-class school system will serve if low-income black residents are being evicted from his world-class city in droves.
It seems his only complaint about Rhee, other than she was affiliated with that administration, is that the neighborhoods are being gentrified.
That was unusually obnoxious, even for Cortland Milloy.
That's some grade A race baiting.
As for you blacks: Don't you, like, even know what's good for you? So what if Fenty reneged on his promise to strengthen the city from the inside by helping the working poor move into the middle class. Nobody cares that he has opted to import a middle class, mostly young whites who can afford to pay high rent for condos that replaced affordable apartments.
How do you import young whites?
Ask the hipster infected sections of Brooklyn.
The comments over at the daily beast nearly gave me a brain aneurysm.
There should have been a NSFIP (Not Safe For Intelligent People) warning on the link.
In the mess that will exist after the collapse of the dollar and the welfare state, we will be better off because we have a few people like Michelle Rhee around to help rebuild.
Bobby Jindal I bet would hire Ms. Rhee for something.