Will the Ohio Healthcare Freedom Amendment End Obamacare? Tea Party Leader Chris Littleton on Mandates, Markets, and Occupy Wall Street
"If you're going to take away liberty and property, there has to be some sort of due process involved," says Chris Littleton, the head of Ohioans for Healthcare Freedom and a Tea Party leader in the Buckeye state. "In this case, as citizens, we feel that those things are fundamentally inhibited and we want the Supreme Court to hear our case on this."
Littleton's group is pushing an upcoming ballot initiative that would amend the state constitution to prevent citizens' involuntary participation in any health-insurance system. The U.S. Supreme Court is widely expected to issue a ruling on the constituationality of what's known as the "individual mandate" in Obamacare and Littelton thinks passage of the Ohio Healthcare Freedom Amendment will give his state unique legal standing: "This is citizen-initiated, which is very unique. If it passes, Ohio will be the only state that's done something like that." While most challenges to the individual mandate revolve around the limits of Congress' commerce clause powers, Littleton believes the amendment will activate due process and 10th Amendment considerations.
Littleton sat down with Reason.tv's Nick Gillespie to discuss the Healthcare Freedom Amendment and the similarities between the Occupy Movement and the Tea Party. "I sympathize with the Occupy people…They're sensing that the system is broken," explains Littleton. "But it seems their answer to things is the confiscation of wealth…where [the Tea Party] advocates for legitimate and true free market systems rather than what we have right now."
For more on the constitutionality of the individual mandate, watch Reason.tv's "Wheat, Weed, and Obamacare," which U.S. District Judge Roger Vinson cited earlier this year in his ruling striking down the Affordable Care Act.
For more on Chris Littleton and his work with the Ohio Tea Party, watch Reason.tv's "The Tea Party vs. John Boehner."
Approximately 5 minutes.
Produced by Jim Epstein; additional camera, Joshua Swain.
Go to Reason.tv for downloadable versions, and subscribe to Reason.tv's YouTube Channel to receive automatic updates when new material goes live.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
the never ending saga of Obamacare is worse than election season.
Jon Huntsman's Slutty Daughters mock Herman Cain's Smoking Ad
http://tinyurl.com/3josffn
Hot daughters and a prog rock fan? He's looking better by the day. If only he had policies I could support.
If only he had daughters who weren't childish and stupid.
You listened to them talk? That's just asking for trouble.
Heh. That, and watched them act.
polling shows this issue will be defeated ~2-1 along with kasich's collective bargining debacle.
the tenth amendment is just a RW [MEME] to foam the wingnutz
these issues are citizens referendums subject to majority voting.
>what's ur point about the 10th again?
Behold... the stOOOOpid.
o4: it's like o2, but twice as bad.
we are up to 'quadruple asshole'. Where is 'old mexican'?
We keep trying to find similarities between the Tea Party and Occupy Wall Street.
"...they're sensing - we know it too, I think every American knows it - the system is broken."
That's probably the most diplomatic thing you can say about those hippies. "That thing every sentient being on the planet knows? They sort of know it, too."
"... but they've only connected half the dots. It's really sad."
POOP?
[PILE] not [SCOOP]!
HERCULE TRIATHLON SAVINIEN
+ number two
I love that every iteration of Ohio Orrin (o1-o4) is blocked by reasonable. It really is bliss not having to read you, oo.
another RW radio [MEME] to foam the wingnutz
Now if only it would work with rectal's 50,000 names...
like i care.
That's fine, oo. o5-7 go in the filter too.
herp!
What about Hi On Urine?
hey now, u can count to 7. pretty good for a wingnut
Methinks it would be rather simple to match the incif to /^o\d+$/.
Would this mean Ohio companies would stop collecting Medicare tax for those who choose not to be a part of Medicare?
I don't think it will turn out how they want.
It exempts older laws.
"If it passes, Ohio will be the only state that's done something like that."
Not so fast, NH beat you to it a few weeks back:
"the New Hampshire Legislature passed two bills, one that rejected federal funds to implement provisions of the health care law and another saying no state resident could be compelled to purchase health insurance. Both became law without the signature of Gov. John Lynch, a Democrat." (http://www.unionleader.com/article/20110813/NEWS12/708139989)
I'm more interested in Issue 2, since it has the potential to actually achieve something useful.
Im an Ohioan and will be shocked if Issue 2 goes the way the polling says. It reminds me of Bush v. Kerry here. The Kerry houses had 10 signs each, but the houses without signs voted Bush. Ohio Ds are so unreasonable, Rs dont voice opposition, but they are resolute. The silent majority will support SB5 and this retraint on Washington.
That is the perfect analogy Mr. Soul. I was talking with someone about this the other day and reminded him not to mistake the passion of the "NO" side with an actual majority. I'll be surprised if "YES" on 2 doesn't win by at least 7-8 points.
Well, you can count on me and my old man to vote yes on Issue 2 and yes for this healthcare thing. We're the only 2 sane people left in Cleveland.
Strike that. Were the only 2 people left in Cleveland. FIFM
I feel you Rob. I'm from CBUS, its more politically palatable for me than Cleveland. Hopefully Issue 2 passes and places like Cleveland will have a fighting chance to grow again.
Although places w massive public funding like the Jake, the Q, Browns Stadium, and the RR Hall of fame totally bring the city's economy down on taxpayers.
Love Cleveland sports...but unwavering tax dollars for huge inefficient projects like those kill a city already hurting since 1950 something.
I had to uproot two pro-issue-2 signs fro my business's front yard.
Road sign concentration is not a good measure of a ballot issue passing.
Most people are not involved in the propaganda movement - union meetings/spread the wealth(as long as it's not mine) philosophy.
People have seen what unions, and their democrat counterparts do - they make things worse - many see this, and they will show their disdain when time to vote - then we will again see majority support for common sense/Yes on issue 2, and issue 3.
America is a capitalistic, not a socialistic republic - wish many people in government, media, and Wall Street protesters would admit this.
If I lived in Ohio, I'd vote for it.
A gimmick like this, I suppose, is better than nothing, albeit far worse than an ultimatum threatening secession (with the willingness to reinforce that ultimatum by force). Ah, my stupid little fantasies, where significant portions of the population and political class give a shit about liberty!
Take what you can get. Face it, the sheeple is phat dumb and still happy.
Comfortably Numb?!?
Pay close attention to life, believe that everything can be resolved soon
What about SB4646? Isn't anyone paying attention?
I will also vote for it.
If I was there, I will also vote on one of my ticket.
http://www.rs4mil.com
Mr. Marc Jacobs is a legend
Thank you Chris Littleton and the good people of the Buckeye state of Ohio for attempting to preserve all of our Constitutional rights across America. What Obama and the Democrats have done by passing ObamaCare is to make us all slaves to the insurance companies with no supply and demand pressures on rates. This is a defining moment in our history which will tell us if our fore-founders wasted their time in creating our Constitution. Those who took an oath to support and defend the Constitution and voted for ObamaCare should be voted out of office.
Read more: Portsmouth Daily Times - Thanks Ohio for vote against ObamaCare