Sidney Lumet, RIP
I don't have a lot to say about Sidney Lumet, who died this weekend at age 86. Just that he directed one movie that's just about perfect -- Dog Day Afternoon -- and a bunch of others that haven't simply colonized my imagination; they've seized it and remade it in their own image. If I'm reading about New York in the '70s, the associations that jump to my mind are probably recycled from one of Lumet's pictures: if not Dog Day, then Serpico or Prince of the City or maybe even The Wiz. (*) And if I'm hearing about a trial, my mental images are apt to come from 12 Angry Men or The Verdict.
He made other worthy films too. The Pawnbroker is a vivid character study. Equus is one of my favorite stage-to-celluloid adaptations. Network is filled with funny scenes, not to mention one of the greatest Ned Beatty supporting roles in the long, rich history of great Ned Beatty supporting roles. Running on Empty won me over to the point that I somehow even enjoyed the sequence where the cast sings along to James Taylor's "Fire and Rain," a song that under any other circumstances I would despise. Lumet's best movies feature complex characters, a strong sense of place, and stories that aren't afraid to take some unexpected turns before depositing the audience at the end. The man put his stamp on the second half of the 20th century, and it's hard for me to imagine it without him.
* Yes, I know Prince of the City came out in 1981. I'm pretty sure it was supposed to be set in the '70s, and at any rate it feels like the same world.
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
[cough]
[cough]
sloopyinca|4.9.11 @ 5:15PM|#|show direct|ignore
For all you movie buffs out there in Libertopia:
Sidney Lumet has died. He directed Serpico, Dog Day Afternoon, Twelve Angry Men and most-notably Network.
[cough]
[COUGH]
[COUGH]
Yeah Jesse Walker already broke that story, dude. Nice repost.
Really? Was that before I posted it on his Egypt story yesterday afternoon? If so, I humbly apologize.
Linky?
The squirrels must have made a mistake, there's no way an amateur like you could scoop a professional like Jesse.
/messing with you
If you want to play that game, I tweeted the news on Saturday. But I don't think either one of us gets to claim the scoop.
What the fuck is twitter?
Well, if you want to play THAT game, I dreamed that he died 3 weeks ago. neener-neener...
Lighten up, Francis.
http://reason.com/blog/2011/03.....nt_2210740
I posted this ealier. I want a hat tip bitches
http://reason.com/blog/2011/03.....nt_2210742
http://rctlfy.wordpress.com/20.....terrorist/
Hey it was Jesse Walker too.
Jesse why do you hate hat tips? 😉
FUCK ME HARDER BITCH!
Agreed, Dog Day was a masterpiece. RIP.
Is it possible to like Network and still be a libertarian?
Is it possible to like Network and still be a libertarian?
Why not? I don't think it's particularly prescient or predictive, as so many people claim, but it's pretty damn funny. Especially the scene where the host of The Mao Tse-Tung Hour renegotiates her contract.
Whose leg do ya gotta hump to get a hat tip around here?
No homo.
I don't think you get a hat tip if the writer never saw your post. You should email next time.
Agreed.
Laureen Hobbs: Don't fuck with my distribution costs! I'm making a lousy two-fifteen per segment and I'm already deficiting twenty-five grand a week with Metro! I'm paying William Morris ten percent off the top, and I'm giving this turkey ten thou per segment, and another five to this fruitcake! And Helen, don't start no shit about a piece again! I'm paying Metro twenty-thousand for all foreign and Canadian distribution, and that's after recoupment! The Communist Party's not gonna see a nickel of this goddamn show until we go into syndication!
Helen Miggs: C'mon Laureen. The party's in for seventy-five hundred a week of the production expenses.
Laureen Hobbs: I'm not giving this pseudoinsurrectionary sedentarian a piece of my show! I'm not giving him script approval, and I sure as shit ain't gotten him into my distribution charges!
Mary Ann Gifford: [screaming] You fucking fascist! Did you see the film we made of the San Marino jail breakout, demonstrating the rising up of the seminal prisoner class infrastructure?
Laureen Hobbs: You can blow the seminal prisoner class infrastructure out your ass! I'm not knockin' down my goddamn distribution charges!
Great Ahmed Kahn: [fires off his gun through the ceiling] Man, give her the FUCKING overhead clause. Let's get back to page twenty-two, number 5, small 'a'. Subsidiary rights.
Lumet directed what should be required viewing for anyone wanting to invest public (or private, for that matter) funds in high-speed rail. Murder on the Orient Express tells of dangers inherent to train travel.
Equus has some serious Jenny Agutter nudity I think. I can't believe I haven't seen it. Directing naked Jenny Agutter is enough to put Lumet in the upper tier of directors.
I "borrowed" that VHS tape from my dad as a teenager. Many times.
Along with Body Heat, back when Kathleen Turner could melt stone with her sexuality.
My sister liked Dog Day too. I'm not sure why she does as I'm never a fan of the dir. We don't even live in the U.S. but in the Philippines but she likes plays and theater act and maybe that's the reason she stumbled upon Dog Day. I remember her telling me about it back when I used to sing for theater act. Hmmm. I'd rather sing than watch a movie. - Ana
I didn't like Dog Day Afternoon...I found it to be, well, a little too hippie-pretentious and "gay" for my taste (NTTAWWT)...
Serpico though I liked. Great anti-establishment message and just the right amount of gay and hippie pretentiousness.
Wow. I found there to be a lot more "gay" in Serpico than Dog Day Afternoon.
Seriously, though. 12 Angry Men was possibly his best work. One room. 12 men. Shot (supposedly) in real time. Superb acting.
Too bad it was up against Bridge on the River Kwai that year. It's certainly more worthy of a Best Picture Award that a few winners I can think of.
12 Horny Men was probably his gayest work.
No, heller, that would be Doggy Gay Afternoon. It's just 3 hours of Sid nailing dudes doggy style.
I'm gonna win this yet
"Fail Safe" was necessary, and Lumet rose to the moment.
excellent film, a perfect companion to Dr. Strangelove
The ending to Dog Day Afternoon is very nearly as "Oh SHIIIIIIT!!!" as Departed. What a great movie (among many others).
RIP Mr. Lumet...
Not really, pretty predictable ending actually.
Depends on the times. In 2011, it's a predicable ending: trigger-happy cops. In the 1970's, the era of beating-happy cops, it was a little more suprising.
Never saw "Running on Empty" so I do not know what about that version of "Fire and Rain" was appealing to you.
On his album "Afro Classic", Hubert Laws version of F and R may be far enough removed from JT for you to enjoy.
Running on Empty was a film about a 60's counter-culture couple, ala William Ayers/Bernadine Dorhn (played by Judd Hirsch and Christine Lahti), who fire-bombed a university lab involved with DoD contracts, killing a security guard in the process.
They felt bad, though of course not bad enough to turn themselves in.
Jump ahead 14 years. They have been on the run from the FBI, moving and changing identities constantly, taking low-key jobs. They have convinced themselves that they will turn themselves in "when the kids are grown".
Naturally, their 14 yo son (River Phoenix) is a brilliant musical prodigy who gets an invite to Julliard. They must confront the tension between keeping the family together, and letting Little River join the Band (see what I did there?) and realize his dreams.
Pretty basic liberal crap, actually. But, it was well acted.
Why should they turn themselves over to statists?
The better question is: why should they commit a violent act, and escape the consequences?
But, of course, the theme of the movie is that they exist in a prison of their own making; being forced to live like common plebes despite being brilliant, nurturing Gaia-fuckers.
My guess is that either Christine Lahti or a very young Martha Plimpton captured the imagination of Jesse's adolescent junk, so to speak. Which was it, Jesse?
I gave you more than adequate time to respond. I will assume it was both.
I just found out yesterday that Sidney Poitier directed Stir Crazy.
I mean, WTF? It was one of those "Did you know Steven Spielberg directed 1941?" moments.
a little sad
Is it possible to like Network and still be a libertarian?
The last time I saw Network in the listings, a local PBS station was running it during a pledge drive. Evidently, the kind of people who run state TV think Network is the kind of thing that works to fire up and/or bilk the tools who make up their most devoted audience. Are they wrong? Is it ironic if they're not? Does it matter?
Network is an actual thing, out there in the world, serving somebody. You can like whatever you like liking, and call yourself whatever you like calling yourself, obviously, but unless you have the cultural power to reinterpret and "take back" an already fully taken and interpreted thing, liking it and saying so means signing on with whoever already culturally owns it.
Why do you want to say you like Network? Who do you want to tell? Does it seem irreplaceable to you, as a thing to (say you) like? Why?
Shut up already.
In the immortal words of Robert Anton Wilson, like what you like, enjoy what you enjoy, and don't take crap from anybody.
Far from being dated, his movies from each era remain as current and as relevant as ever.
The 70s in many ways was a golden age and 'Dog Day ..' was one of the best. Own this on DVD, and want to get a copy of '12 Angry..' someday.
For film, yes. And for some music.
I really liked his last movie Before the Devil Knows You're Dead too. Great movie on it's own, but worth seeing just for Marisa Tomei.
Network's my favorite, but not because of Lumet. It's perhaps the most brilliant screenplay ever written.
And I think it was pretty prescient. Though you would perhaps have to remember what TV was like in the mid-70s to comprehend how prescient.
Network is worth the price of admission just for the Howard Beale (Peter Finch) character. Finch received a posthumous Oscar for the role.
Funny how one never hears an Orrin Hatch or a Lindsey Graham or a GWB or a Norman Schawrzcough or a Mark "I got mty ass kicked by Tom Woods" Levin or a Bob Grant or a Rush Limbaugh or a Bill O'Reilly or the ugly cankled Nancy Reagan ever champion 12 Angry Men.
How about the scene in The Verdict where Paul Newman's character punches Charlotte Rampling's character after discovering that she had been paid by James Mason's law firm to sleep with Newman's character?
Lumet had the intestinal fortitude to insist upon that scene making the final edit. Most guys would have genuflected to political correctness-you know, the guys who scream racism if another calls Van Jones a black bolshevik.
One of many great scenes in The Verdict. Without it, it's a different movie.
How about the scene where he gets the news that Rampling is a mole ? POV is looking down on a street scene as Jack Warden delivers the news to Newman. You can't hear them of course, but Newman's body language says it all. That's acting, conveying the characters devastation from three stories up, with no words, and totally justifying his reaction when he meets Rampling in the hotel bar.
woow
*woow*
**woow**
>woow<<br /> #woow#
!woow!
$woow$
%woow%
^woow^
&woow;&
*woow*
(woow)
"woow"
:woow:
&woow;&