Comparing Obama and Bush on Executive Power
At the Volokh Conspiracy, University of Chicago law professor Eric Posner compares the records of George W. Bush and Barack Obama when it comes to the expansion of executive power:
Thanks to Bush, Obama enjoys the legal authorities he needs to conduct the conflict with Al Qaida—and so, until our next crisis, we don't know how Obama would have acted under similar circumstances. The Obama lawyers are certainly less inclined to bloviate than the Bush lawyers were but again where it counts—have Obama's lawyers ever stopped him from going beyond the edge of legality?—we have little information and some reason for skepticism. Obama has vigorously expanded the drone program, taken the war into Pakistan, robustly defended his right to kill American citizens abroad, and opposed litigation that could expose secrets about the treatment of detainees…. And that was before the Libya intervention.
For more on the distressing similarities between Bush and Obama, don't miss Eli Lake's June 2010 Reason feature "The 9/14 Presidency: Barack Obama, like George W. Bush, is operating with war powers granted three days after the 9/11 attacks."
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
"Four legs good, two legs BETTER!"
I don't think Eli Lake found those similarities distressing at all.
Well, sure, if you look at their records they're similar, but Obama is a Democrat. And black.
It's okay when our guy does it!
the legal authorities he needs to conduct the conflict with Al Qaida
needs, wants, whatever
Lies, Obama is very different from Bush, Obama is much better at reading from a teleprompter then Bush
Does this mean that President Obama is also a chicken-hawk?
The most relevant sentence was cut off from the beginning of the quote:
Bush got the authorities he needed by demanding them from Congress, and Congress accommodated him with the Patriot Act, the Protect America Act, the Detainee Treatment Act, the Military Commissions Act, and two AUMFs.
Pretty much in linear progression, presidents have been expanding their power for some time now. Even Carter did his bit. It's not a partisan issue; it's a power issue. And, of course, "We the People" are the victim.
What's odd is that as much as the parties use each other as awful bogeymen to drum up votes, the fact is that they knowingly expand the government's power when in office all while knowing that their old opponents will take office with those shiny new powers.
You're giving them credit for too much forethought and awareness.
Replace "knowing" with "vaguely aware."
I don't know about that. They know their TEAM will be back in power in a cycle or two, pretty much without fail. Plus, when one of these egomaniacs gets into the White House, it's all them all the time for the next few years. Thinking of the future? That's for their "legacy", baby.
They all know each other. The thing that most surprised me about Washington is how damned friendly the politicals are to each other.
That's the bit that should be shown to the partisan morons who fuel their power. I'm sure that a TEAM BLUE dipshit would be appalled by Obama speaking to Bush civilly, as opposed to their fantasy of him rending Bush in twain with a claymore. Or TEAM RED idiots seeing Cheney and Barney Frank having a sitdown and discussing promoting mortgages.
I would like to think Barney would take an opportunity like that to lick Cheney's cold, robotic heart. SEXILICIOUS!
Lick it? He'd fingerbang it, baby!
Cheney's robot heart has put a real cramp on his piss play activities.
At the risk of sounding like anonymity bot: LOL
OMG! Where you been, man?
The Art!
Hey! You're alive!
And now everything Bush did is "bi partisan".
OT: Venture Bros. renewed for two more seasons.
Finally, some good news.
F yeah. Possibly my favorite TV show period.
What do you mean "with Al-Qaeda"? The purpose for all that accumulated power is clear...
http://www.toonpool.com/user/9.....255085.jpg
Ach! Those broken links...
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_82jY.....385835.jpg
taken the war into Pakistan
Wait, what? We have always been at war with Pakistan.
See, you have to understand the difference between "Candidate" Obama and "President" Obama. I know I said when I was "Candidate" Obama that the president did not have the constitutional power to unilaterally send the U.S. military into another country without an authorization from Congress, but I "President" Obama now. So technically, I, President Obama, did not actually ever say those things.
You can't fool me - the REAL Obama says "Let me be clear" before every sentence.
lol, is there any comparison? I dont think so.
http://www.real-privacy.it.tc
You...you're one of us!