Is Organized Labor Turning on Obama?
Over at the pro-union site In These Times, lefty journalist Steve Early complains that the Obama administration sold out organized labor in favor of health care "reform" (his scare quotes):
To keep labor in line, the administration has, for the last seven months, repeatedly dangled the carrot of labor law reform whenever leading unionists joined other critics of the president's health care plan who lamented its emerging lack of a public option, expanded access to Medicare, or any other single-payer strengthening features. Earlier this month, unions were even prodded to accept, in postponed form, a controversial tax on more expensive medical private plans; if enacted, this 40 per cent excise tax will encourage further cost shifting by management, leave workers without bargaining rights more exposed to an already devastating trend, and, ultimately, saddle union members with higher co-payments and deductibles as well. In marathon talks with the White House that produced this self-defeating deal, labor reps were reminded once again, that any derailing of such "reform" would be a victory for the GOP and, thus, the death-knell of employee free choice.
Now trade unionists are seeing the latest opportunity to strengthen workplace rights, as promised by the Democrats, simply vanish. As one dismayed union official in Washington, D.C. told me: "It's the end of labor law reform for another generation."
Last July, Shikha Dalmia explained why the Employee Free Choice Act deserved to die.
[Via Point of Law]
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
Boo
fucking
hoo.
"It's the end of labor law reform for another generation."
Damn man, news just keeps getting better and better. Of course then the Republicans will be in control and we can go back to bad news all over again, just a different sort of bad news.
I demand alt text.
You people and your demands. I want to see a good long hunger strike before I take you people seriously.
Not bad. I can totally see Obama saying that to the base's various special interests, but I just don't know how it ties in with him toasting.
Caption Contest:
Damn, I want a forty.
"you tell 'em Billy Dee..."
Rule #2: Never run out of Colt 45.
"to less oil for more blood!"
"For a magazine called 'reason'..."
A few weeks ago the construction guys at my Metro North station were talking about how they hated Obama's health care plan, because they didn't want to have to pay to support deadbeats.
Anecdotal, I know.
Define deadbeat.
Someone who depends on the generosity of others for a living. This also includes those who make a living off of taxpayer money.
brotherben
There is no credible threat of unions abandoning the democrats en masse to vote republican. As such, democrats can walk all over them. If they only applied these political instincts more universally, they would be able to accomplish a lot more.
Just like we do with black folk.
The following is generally only true of the old-line industrial and craft unions of the AFL-CIO. In other words, the dying unions.
It is not generally true of the public sector unions like AFSCME or those reprenting lower wage workers like SEIU and UFW. In other words, the growing unions.
There has been a serious disconnect between union leadership and their members for decades now.
Union members want high wages and benefits and wil tend to vote for candidates who will legislate the necessary protectionism and immigration restrictions (and in times past racial discrimination) they perceive are necessary to get and keep them.
On the other hand, union leaders tend to be increasingly removed from the "shop floor" as their ranks become filled with college grads who have never done a lick of blue collar work in their lives.
Significant numbers of union members have been voting Republican since the Nixon years (remember the "hard hat" attacks on Vietnam war protesters and other hippie layabouts).
In spite of this alienation from their membership the primary purpose of unions today is to raise money for the Democratic Party. That is because the people who keep winning union leadership elections are still generally attached to the mythology of the Party.
"remember the "hard hat" attacks on Vietnam war protesters and other hippie layabouts"
All that proves is that like everyone else, union workers hate goddam dirty hippies.
There has been a serious disconnect between union leadership and their members for decades now.
I'd put it a bit farther back than that. The unions became mob subsidiaries pretty much from day one of prohibition.
-jcr
ultimately, saddle union members with higher co-payments and deductibles
Free unlimited health care is a RIGHT. You can't ask these people to take money out their own pocket; that's not fair.
and racist.
the unionistscollectivist thugs have a point; for years, they have (collectively) opted to forgo wage increases in exchange for better health plans. To turn around and selectively tax these plans means they get screwed, and have to start their negotiations over from the beginning.
I've seen some studies which explain the stagnation of wages in the US since the 70's in this light; it's not that we're being compensated less, it's that healthcare keeps taking a bigger piece of the pie.
Caption Contest!
"Here's to me, because...well, what else is there to toast?"
"Ladies and gentlemen, only my national healthcare proposal will save us from the scourge of bitter beer face."
"Lips that touch alcohol will never touch mine."
Remember, when the hand that feeds you arrives empty it's time to bite.
That's an about-to-say-"fuck" face.
"Fuckin' 'Irish pint' my fuckin' ass."
"I like drinking from tiny glasses. It makes me feel like a giant. Excuse, but now I must go ravage Tokyo."
I'd like to see Godzilla & Giant Obama battle over Tokyo.
"I'd like to see Godzilla & Giant Obama battle over Tokyo in a locked box.
Obama = Megaguirus?
Obama vs. MECHA-OBAMA!
"I shall steal your money with my cold steel hands! Try and stop me! Ha ha ha!"
"Never, Mecha-Obama! Flesh-Obama totally has first dibs!"
"Then fight we must!"
My idea is better.
Racism detected and duly noted.
Racism detected and duly noted.
No, no... racism is when I point out that Obama is controlled by the songs of two tiny Asian ladies in a bird cage.
Who isn't?
I ate mine. Tasted like star anise.
You guys are just full of great book ideas today.
Geez, and here I thought I dreamed that movie with the tiny Japanese ladies in the cage.
They did make some weird stuff back then. Not unlike the weird stuff they still make now.
Racism detected and duly noted.
I didn't really sink in the first time.
It didn't... Those typing classes at the adult annex over Christmas were a total waste of time and money.
That's what he said!
Racism detected and duly noted.
Goddamnit Sug. You double-talked Nomad into overload *again.*
Say yeah. Card check was suppose to sail through congress and signed into law before the inauguration music stopped. Here it is a year later, and it's still on the back burner.
A GOP sweep in Nov. could be a repeat of the Clinton years. Could be the best of all possible worlds.
Now THAT would be something to drink to. And I don't mean "DRINK!" like when someone brings up Somalia or roads, but drink, because it's a relief to see an actual do-nothing government for a change.
Fun Fact: All of Somalia's roads are privately owned.
Although... the alt-text should totally be:
"Pass me a leg. Ha ha."
It's "Ha, pass me a leg man"
Racism detected and duly noted.
Blow me?
No thank you. But don't worry, it's Seattle, I'm sure your oral-erotic, hemp-drenched Price Charming will hacky sac his way into your loving, yet strangely muscular arms any day now.
Heterophobism detected and duly noted.
As well as the heterosexism.
No, no no:
It's "Hahaha pass me a leg please."
What the hell is wrong with you people?
I am The First Apostate and will not be spoken to in such a scurrilous manner.
Your reward, SF, will come in the next world.
Infidel!!!
This is EXACTLY what happened to the Bible.
"If it's not King James, it's not The Bible."
"This one's for you, Gepetto. I'm a real boy, now!"
"Caption Contest!"
"Let me be clear. I will not tax tiny glasses of beer. Not one dime"
"Mmmm! Goddamn, Jimmie! This is some serious gourmet shit! Usually, me and Vince would be happy with some freeze-dried Taster's Choice right, but he springs this serious GOURMET shit on us! What flavor is this?"
OK, serious question...
If you cannibalize a person of the same sex, is that gay? What if you purposely avoid eating the sexual organs?
Name one body part on a living dude you would put into your mouth and not think it was gay.
His ear.
Sorry, Mike, it is gay.
Those closet-cases can be violent, it's true.
-jcr
Good point. I guess that, once again, Ed Gein has shown us the way.
His heart.
Unless you're Klingon, that's gay.
Ripping the heart out of your enemy and eating it is not gay. Nor is it strictly a Klingon practice.
However, sex acts with your same-sex enemy's ripped-out-but-still-beating heart are most assuredly gay.
We've all heard stories about the Vulcans, but are there any gay Klingons?
I thought Koloth came across as a little light on his feet.
Was it the unitard, the tunic shirt or the sparkly pants that gave it away? Or was it just that fierce pose he's striking? Rowr! Work it, girl!
Yeah, and who is his gay buddy? Not Kirk, of course. Kirk is 100% all-American, not gay even for Spock.
Or the tribble. Tribbles are too busy with breeding to allow time for, well, anything else. Except eating, maybe.
The image might be blocked for some people. Heir's a new link.
If there was ever going to be a Klingon ice dancing medalist, that dude would be him.
For the record, of course, he also played Trelane.
Why, that's Korax, of course. Played by Michael Pataki, who guest-starred in almost every TV show ever.
Kind of the Harry Dean Stanton of television.
Are you a fan of the old Mission: Impossible series? It was shot right next door to Star Trek, and the overlap in props and actors is mindboggling. George Takei was one of those mission guest dudes, for instance, and, of course, there was Nimoy. But the guest stars were practically all the same for a while.
Actually, they were all Peter Lupus, but just wearing different masks.
They were all Martin Landau. If they were all Peter Lupus, I think masks wouldn't be enough to disguise him, at well over six feet.
I've seen a bunch, but not since I was kid. Sounds like they were the Law and Order franchise of their day.
I really like the show. The movies are an abomination, but what else is new?
Even Steve Smith wouldn't fuck with Kirk.
Even Steve Smith wouldn't fuck with Kirk.
Clicky
They're all gay. Leather boys, big time.
-jcr
"Hoist one for populism, lads."
OK, serious question...
"Ahhhh, you no fool-a me!"
"Woman, what have I to do with thee? Mine hour is not yet come."
Or, "I never. . .tried to wreck a whole country's economy." [Obama drinks.]
Obama playing never did I ever sounds like a very frightening game.
Seems to me, the only thing Obama is truly good at is giving speeches.
RT
http://www.be-invisible.es.tc
That's deep, man.
HOLY SHIT, THAT IS SO TRUE.
Racism detected and duly noted.
"Thanks to my hard work, and that of my economic team over the past six years, I am pleased to announce the beer ration has been increased, and the price of a glass of beer like this is stable, at only $365.- dollars. Have a happy and prosperous 2014, America!"
"To the Obamalypse!"
Obama doing his impersonation of a working man.
I think he needs to work on it a bit.
Doesn't the drama department teach that at Harvard Law?
If everyone would just join a union, we could all make $30 an hour and have a "cadillac health plan".
"It's the end of labor law reform for another generation."
Maybe this Obama guy isn't so bad afterall.
I think Obama is about to puke after half a pussy glass.
In his defense, it might be Budweiser.
Not on the taxpayer's money!
the unionists collectivist thugs have a point; for years, they have (collectively) opted to forgo wage increases in exchange for better health plans.
Boo fucking hoo. They got what they negotiated for.
The world changes, for union members and non-union members alike.
Deal with it.
Who moved my union cheese?
"I take a straw, and I stretch it across the room, and I DRINK your beer, I drink it right up. Bitches." BHO
Winner. Right there.
Hello.organized.labor.you're.quite.GOOD.at.TURNING.me.on.
Who knew that Smithers was wielding the fist of etiquette?