Gibbs: White House Email Request Not Fishy at All
White House Press Secretary Robert Gibbs responded yesterday to accusations that the request for people to email the White House reporting "fishy" behavior was itself "fishy." From The Wall Street Journal:
"Nobody is collecting names," Gibbs told reporters today. In a Wednesday letter to President Barack Obama, [Texas Republican Sen. John] Cornyn suggesting using the e-mail address could "raise the specter of a data collection program."
"We have used on many occasions the Web site to debunk things that are simply not true," Gibbs said, "We ask people if they have questions about health care reform and about what they're hearing about its effects on them to let us know and we provide them information to show that that wasn't true."
Gibbs went on to say that the practice is just, you know, like when journalists get something wrong:
"When you make a mistake in your report, sometimes I e-mail you; occasionally I call; sometimes I just throw something against the wall. Occasionally it's all three," he quipped. "And all we're asking people to do is if they're confused about what health care reform is going to mean to them, we're happy to help clear that up for you. Nobody is keeping anybody's names."
That's a relief! But couldn't it still end up as some sort of Nixon-style enemies list? For more on the White House's "fishy" email request, watch Reason.tv's Sending Our Fishy E-Mails to the White House!"
Editor's Note: As of February 29, 2024, commenting privileges on reason.com posts are limited to Reason Plus subscribers. Past commenters are grandfathered in for a temporary period. Subscribe here to preserve your ability to comment. Your Reason Plus subscription also gives you an ad-free version of reason.com, along with full access to the digital edition and archives of Reason magazine. We request that comments be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment and ban commenters for any reason at any time. Comments may only be edited within 5 minutes of posting. Report abuses.
Please
to post comments
That picture of Gibbs is priceless. He looks like a fat, pink baby who thinks he's been naughty.
Isn't that a recycled line from an old (GWB administration) "NSA caught illegally eavesdropping on phone calls" memo?
"Nobody is collecting names,"
Except that under law and regulations, the White House has to archive every email... so, I guess they are collecting names. They should just go with "We don't read that stuff anyway."
Ok, SugarFree, i have a writing assignment for you: Robert Gibbs' diaper fetish GO.
strike through16 years agoI never got a response after I sent in my fishy email. Come to think of it, I haven't gotten my mail lately either. And there's a strange van parked outside with the windows blacked out...
But couldn't it still end up as some sort of Nixon-style enemies list?
More likely, a people-willing-to-help-make-an-enemies-list list.
That's worse.
Robert Gibbs' diaper fetish
No, or at least not until after lunch.
"That picture of Gibbs is priceless. He looks like a fat, pink baby who thinks he's been naughty"
To me, he looks like the pedophile uncle telling his four-year-old nephew that this is our little secret so you mustn't tell anybody.
No, or at least not until after lunch.
True brilliance is worth the wait.
Hope and Stasi!
I emailed them the entire text of HB 3200 the other day.
"I emailed them the entire text of HB 3200 the other day."
Me too.
All you fauxtarians who voted for this asshole's boss: How's that working out for you?
Caption Contest!
"Want to know where this finger has been? I'm inhaling, it smells so good."
So, they're just trying to compile a Fishily-Asked Questions list.
Will pornographic spam sent to flag@whitehouse.gov become part of the permanent government database?
Not that I would do such a thing.
strike through16 years agoSo that's why her office smells like tuna!
I emailed them the entire text of HB 3200 the other day.
I like that. It would be great if all the protestors that are showing up at town hall meetings were to simply politely read selected passages from the bill and their Congressperson to explain what they mean.
Gibbs noisily shit his pants and is pretending to shush Helen Thomas in order to blame it on her.
It wasn't me!
"Shhhhh, you guys stop with all the friendly banter. We have to try to at least appear to not be working together."
Caption: My IQ is diss many.
The US Privacy Law (5 US Code ?552a(e)(7)) prohibits the snitch list absent specific statutory authorization, the consent of whoever is snitched out, or in pursuit of law enforcement.
It prohibits any Federal agency from maintaining any records
describing how any individual exercises rights guaranteed by the First Amendment unless expressly authorized by statute or by the individual about whom the record is maintained or unless pertinent to and within the scope of an authorized law enforcement activity;
The administration is clearly in violation of this law. I'm not sure what the sanctions are, but I would hope that at a minimum someone would get a court order to destroy what they have collected, and prohibiting them from doing anything like it in the future.
Don't worry, they'll pass a law retro-actively making it all legal. When the federal government does it, it's not a crime.
I would pay money to watch Helen Thomas kick Gibbs in the nuts.
Good news. I tried to find Obama's original call to snitch but couldn't. It's been burried by opposition responses. I love this country.
Thanks to our internet shock jocks, now we can all send those snitching totalitarian faggots at flag@whitehouse.gov links and images for Goatse, Meat Spin, Lemon Party, Finger Painting, and 2 Girls 1 Cup. Here's hoping they don't actually enjoy them, though.
Are Stalin like purges next (only half -kidding)
There's something fishy alright and it's that cunt in the Whitehouse.
How do you spell 'hope'? C-U-N-T
The level of hypocrisy of the mainstream media over this kind of stuff is off the charts.
This is just one thing in a growing list of things (like Obama calling the CBO director up to the White House for a strong-arm session) that the media would be screaming bloody murder from the rooftops about if it had been done by Bush during his tenure.
Marxist regimes rarely last that long unless they repress the very people they get to vote for them. This is America, founded upon the Constitution which states we have the right to speak our minds individually. I think his openess is now going to backfire. Especially when he is putting the world ahead of his own country with cap and trade and healtcare. Shame on him. He will create the first society that will lead to another revolution if he does not watch out. I think the Veterans are on our side so get to know a vet because they have lots of ammunition.
Especially when he is putting the world ahead of his own country with cap and trade and healtcare.
What's the connection between putting the world ahead of his one's country and the Obama healthcare plan? I didn't follow this part of what you were saying.
"I'm sure you're hashing some nefarious plot, but I, for the life of me, can't understand it," he said.
"It's *hatching*, Robert," responded the President, "and it's actually quite simple."
If the White House wants fishy e-mails, send them fishy e-mails.
LOVE THE VIDEO
Yes, there is something fishy going on in the WH! The chief resident of the WH made many campaign promises, only to break them cynically.
Seriously, Robert Gibbs may well be the dumbest, most inarticulate motherfucker to ever by employed by the United States government.
"And all we're asking people to do is if they're confused about what health care reform..."
Don't you mean "health insurance reform" Robert?
Hey wait a minute... didn't I just have to give my e-mail to make this post? What color helicopters do I need to look out for now? Will a tinfoil hat protect me? Didn't Bush's war on terrorism already give the government the power to do what the right wing's paranoia is claiming? What do I need to do to get off the idiotic chain e-mail list claims that Obama wasn't born in America or that he's a muslim that is in league with Al Queda or right wing emails that claim that the government is going to have some kind of soilent green program, or our health care is going to be monopolized by the government? What is to be done if the "liberal media" doesn't mention the most retarded e-mails to circulate the internet?
Thanks