Wednesday Mini-Book Review: In The Studio


Continuing the grand two-week tradition, a short review of a book I found worth noting.

In the Studio: Visits with Contemporary Cartoonists , by Todd Hignite (Yale University Press, 2006). To get the complaints out of the way first: a book this lovely with so much stark white on both the cover and interior layouts is a sure way to invite anxiety about ruining the beautiful object, especially among the fans of comics and cartooning it's aimed at, who are well known for their fetishizing of the object (and with possible tendencies to, um, enjoy snacking while reading, though that's exactly the sort of association with traditional stereotypes about "comics fans" that books like this from serious university presses are trying to get beyond, I suppose). And Todd Hignite (editor of the fine journal of serious writings about great comic art and artists, Comic Art), in his short written introductions to each artist's interview chapter, can get a little clotted with the critspeak.

Beyond that, this book of quotations from fresh interviews Hignite conducted with nine major "alternative" (i.e., non superhero) cartoonists linked with beautiful large reproductions of their own art and the art and objects that influenced them, delight them, or about which they have interesting or strange things to say, is an unalloyed triumph. Without making a big honking deal out of it, the choice of design and approach has a lot to say about how the artifacts of junk culture–from R. Crumb's encounters with L.B. Cole's bizarre 1940s comics noir to Art Spiegelman's fascination with Chester Gould's Dick Tracy to Jaime Hernandez having his imagination sparked by cheap wrestling mags and old Little Archie comics–feed and inspire works of art of greater ambition and deeper complexity.

Hell, nearly half of the drawers of comics contained herein–Crumb, Spiegelman, Gary Panter and Chris Ware–are gen-u-ine museum artistes now, stars of the recent–and crazily excellent–show Masters of American Comics, which has appeared at Los Angeles's MOCA and Hammer, and currently in the New York area at the Jewish Museum and the Newark Museum . I value lots of books because they feed my own curious interests; I think I can fairly say that this book is so gorgeous as an art object, and the cartoonists so inherently interesting as minds judging and discussing their own work habits and inspirations, that my enjoyment of and admiration for this book goes beyond my own fetishistic interest in its subject matter.

NEXT: Follow-Up on the SWAT Office and Little Boy Photo

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  1. I hadn’t heard of this. Are the interviews short/introductions for the causal reader or long in-depth things like the comics journal has? I’d be tempted to check it out just for Panter’s contribution, but knowing this would help me decide on a blind buy if I can’t find it locally.

  2. This post can’t possibly be complete without a link to the UN’s Conference on, I kid you not, Cartooning for Peace.

    From the Secretary General:
    “Cartoons make us laugh. Without them, our lives would be much sadder. But they are no laughing matter: they have the power to inform, and also to offend. Short of physical pain, few things can hurt you more directly than a caricature of yourself, of a group you belong to, or — perhaps worst — of a person you deeply respect.

    Someone might draw a mean caricature of you? The horror!

  3. Dave-a–This from the post–“this book of quotations from fresh interviews Hignite conducted with nine major “alternative” (i.e., non superhero) cartoonists linked with beautiful large reproductions of their own art and the art and objects that influenced them”–is pretty precise. They aren’t presented as full flowing conversations–it’s just random disconnected quotes connected with particular images, either of their own work or some object or art on which they have some comment, generally one that Hignite found in their possession. The one or two page intros by Hignite explain to the reader who the artist is/what they’ve done…the rest is just the thoughts and observations of the artists, not attempting to be particularly thorough about “all you need to know about the artist”.

  4. okay, thanks. re: quotes I wasn’t sure if that was as you say, just reformated quotes or abbridged interviews.

  5. The plural of press is presses.

    Example: serious university presses

  6. Mirriam–Right you are–with your obvious family pedigree, no surprise. Fixed.

  7. Sorry, Merriam, for name misspelling. Me typing too fast, thinking too slow to-day.

  8. Just finished this book, and while there is plenty of interest, it should be retitled “White Male Cartoonists Speak Of Their White (and in a few cases Japanese) Male Cartoonist Influences.” How is it that in 2006 not a single female creator can be referenced in over 300 pages? (Okay, Brunetti mentions one, so I guess I should shut my mouth.) Way to go, bros. I’m glad I didn’t plunk over any cash for this well-trod road.

Please to post comments

Comments are closed.