Star Iraqi Prisoner Exposed

|

The January 2005 issue of Esquire has a gripping and maddening tale of Iraq war propaganda exposed, by Sara Solovitch. Some might remember the tales of woe told by Jumana Hanna, most memorably in this Washington Post story from July 2003, with such reporter's-goldmine material as:

Hanna was hung from a rod and beaten with a special stick when she called out for Jesus or the Virgin Mary. This is where she and other female prisoners were dragged outside and tied to a dead tree trunk, nicknamed "Walid" by the guards, and raped in the shadow of palm trees. This is the place where electric shock was applied to Hanna's vagina. And this is where in February 2001 someone put a bullet in her husband's head and handed his corpse through the steel gate like a piece of butcher's meat.

This nightmare was all because she dared attempt to marry an Indian man in a tribal, tyrannical Iraq. She was, in one of her best novelistic details, beseeching Uday Hussein himself for official sanction for her forbidden love when she was snatched away for the beginnings of her rape, torture, and imprisonment.

Conservative columnist Ross McKenzie said her tale was "justification alone for Bush's Operation Iraqi Freedom." The Wall St. Journal's Opinion Journal said that in the face of Hanna's horror, any carping about misleading statements Bush may have made about Saddam seeking nukes in Niger were mere "kerfuffle."

Sara Solovitch too was beguiled by Hanna's tale, and began working with her on a book-length memoir. Hanna and her family were kept under U.S. military protection in the Green Zone of Baghdad for months, then she was airlifted to a new life in California, where she has been dining out–quite literally–on her tales of Iraqi women's prison horror ever since.

Turns out that the original Post piece was a mine of fool's gold, and the very long Esquire story–read the whole thing–details how Hanna's story frayed, ripped, and blew to the wind once Solovitch tried to verify it. Hanna remains throughout a fascinating, vivid, and real character: I think Solovitch should still be able to glean a book from this story.

My favorite detail for dark comedy:

I received information about her husband, Haytham Jamil Anwar–whose corpse had been handed through the prison gate like a "piece of butcher's meat," as the Post put it. Family members in Iraq insist that he is alive and well–though destitute–in Baghdad. Indeed, his two children, Sabr and Ayyub, on several occasions told their teachers in California that they had seen their father right before they moved into the Green Zone. The teachers had assumed that the kids were in denial and arranged a service on a sunny day in which balloons were released into the sky so that Sabr and Ayyub could say goodbye to their father up in heaven.

Solovitch's article is not meant to mock or belittle whatever tyrannies and agonies did occur in Iraqi prisons. But it is a cautionary tale of how horror stories that support a dominant narrative of enemy perfidy and inhumanity should not be uncritically embraced just for that reason. (Especially when you read that men were actually arrested–then later, fortunately, released–based on Hanna's made-up testimony.)

NEXT: Pentagon: Mosul an Inside Job

Editor's Note: We invite comments and request that they be civil and on-topic. We do not moderate or assume any responsibility for comments, which are owned by the readers who post them. Comments do not represent the views of Reason.com or Reason Foundation. We reserve the right to delete any comment for any reason at any time. Report abuses.

  1. Why use a fake horror story when there were so many real ones?

  2. Good question.

  3. “Why use a fake horror story when there were so many real ones?”

    I don’t think the US government intentionally chose a fake horror story. It seems that they actually believed her.

  4. Sorta reminiscent of early witch hunts.

    “She turned into a cat in front of my eyes…she must be a witch”

    The willing will believe what they want…no matter how much truth is in it.

  5. Perhaps Hanna should be awarded a Nobel Peace Prize, like Rigoberta Menchu.

  6. “The Wall St. Journal’s Opinion Journal said that in the face of Hanna’s horror, any carping about misleading statements Bush may have made about Saddam seeking nukes in Niger were mere “kerfuffle.”

    After the Niger “kerfuffle”, why would anyone believe anything the Bush Administration said about Iran without independent verification? God help us if there really is a state sponsor of terrorism that presents a clear and present danger to the people of the United States.

    “Solovitch’s article is not meant to mock or belittle whatever tyrannies and agonies did occur in Iraqi prisons. But it is a cautionary tale of how horror stories that support a dominant narrative of enemy perfidy and inhumanity should not be uncritically embraced just for that reason.”

    Those who tried to support the occupation of Iraq by propagating this lie are the enemy of people everywhere else in the world who might have been hoping for liberation by way of a U.S. led invasion. I was against the invasion, but even amongst those that supported it, I doubt there were many who would have supported the occupation on a strictly humanitarian basis.

    So anyone who lives under the yoke of a regime, even one that really does present a threat to the people of the United States, will probably just have to hang on for another four years–I just don’t think the Bush Administration has the credibility to convince enough Americans that we should occupy another country.

    …and even evidence like photographs of mobile WMD labs probably isn’t going to be enough.

  7. Dude, there’s a War going on. How dare you unpatriotic SoBs question our Holy leader, strike that, our Messiah?!?

    In any case, if the WoD is any indication, this is par for the course.

  8. The Huns are bayonetting babies in Belgium!

    Oh, sorry–thought it was 1914 again.

    Amazing how the bullshit to justify one massively idiotic war begins to resemble another, isn’t it?

  9. Tawana Brawley, please call Secretary Rumsfeld about a job opportunity working for Public Information in Iraq.

  10. Henry,

    “When the Germans are crucifying kittens on church doors in Belgium?!?”

  11. If something’s too good to be true, it probably
    isn’t. If it’s too awful to contemplate, and makes you feel like killing the perpetrators, it so often isn’t true either.
    Sometimes it does happen, but very, very rarely.

Please to post comments

Comments are closed.